Matt Ward - Hero or Villain?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
@ yorga, before wardie it was alessio cavatore, then probably Andy chambers, it always happens, for at least the decade+ I have been mega into the hobby I can remember the vast ammounts of nerd rage.

@ zanos, +1, that was very eloquently put mate.
 
Personally, I just think Mat Ward needs to improve the points values he gives to different units. I have no problem with powerful rules, but only as long as the cost of fielding them is accordingly high. Mat Ward codexes seem to have a few powerful tools at really low costs, as well as some otherwise useful items that are made worthless because of how pricey they are.

Take the Necron codex for instance. Mindshackle Scarabs are not overpowered (after all, they're practically useless if you're fighting a close combat that doesn't include independent characters or MCs), but they're so cheap that there's really no reason not to spam them. Then there's Heavy Destroyers, who are powerful yet so cost inefficient compared to everything else.

I could say the same of the Grey Knights' codex. Terminator squads, for instance, are troop choices (and thus scoring units), psykers, and all carry force weapons. They also come pre-loaded with a full compliment of Frag and Krak grenades, which I've never seen in any other codex. Now that alone doesn't make me skeptical of Ward's codex writing skills, but they cost exactly the same as Space Marine elite Termies, and they're even 15 points cheaper than Deathwing squads. Who thought that was a good idea? They're better than their counterparts, yet exactly the same price. I suppose you could argue that they can't take chainfists, but they can have force-weapon Thunder Hammers instead.
 
hornywingythingy said:
@ yorga, before wardie it was alessio cavatore, then probably Andy chambers, it always happens, for at least the decade+ I have been mega into the hobby I can remember the vast ammounts of nerd rage.

@ zanos, +1, that was very eloquently put mate.

I've been playing fantasy since 3rd edition. I remember Cavotore and his op rules. They pale in comparison to Matt's. Matt truly (single handedly) busted 7th edition with respect to tournament play when he came out with the un-play tested Daemon army book. Probably friendly play as well. I knew a play tester actually. It was play tested. Matt just ignored ALL the feedback. Arrogance in the extreme! :swear:
 
Of course Bravo, every codex will have that problem. But compare GKTermis to normal termis. Yes they have force weapons and grenades, but they also don't come standard with power fists, nor do they have combat tactics. Also, think of perils of the warp, and psychic defense, those both reduce a grey knight terminator's effectiveness. Plus Grey Knight Terminators will never be as durable as assault terminators without a lot of support. Deathwing terminators are fearless, and have the deathwing assault rule, plus they can mix and match their weapons just like Grey Knights can. Are mindshackle scarabs spammable? Yes, of course, on expensive one wound models that are rather lackluster in close combat. Do Vanilla Space Marine shooty terminators need a buff? Probably, yeah. Every codex has its flaws, but also remember that you can't look at anything in a vacuum.
 
not really hating on matt ward here, u cant really hate someone u dont know XD im sure hes a nice guy and all, but some of the stuff in the necron book is just horrible, im not sure what to think of the fluff, i think that the book has more of a charecter to it now, i mean theres nothing stoppin anyone writing their own fluff, say if u want ur necs to be silent deadly, souless machines then u can put in ur fluff that their programs are corrupted and therefore dont speak, or something like that, let ur imagination go wild, i have fluff for all my armies and it really is fun to write it once u do it (or that can be just me XD) one of the horroble things is a chronometron or somthing like that, not sure how to spell it sorry, but its very cheap in terms of points and gives u a re roll every phase....on anything as far as im aware...not to me thats pretty gd and a bit overpowerd to other stuff that ive seen in other books XD i guess im more jelous than annoyed that my tau dont get something like that (speaking truthfully here XD). also im not sure whther its matt wards fault or not, but the lack of wargear in new books? what is up with that? whos idea was it to remove and limit everyones wargear? yh ok its supose to make the game more balanced but whatever happened to creating unique charecters? when running a general of any sort, its meant to represt u, when i do my charecters i try and make them unique, i want them to be different to everybody elses, im not being funny but limiting the wargear in new books really annoyed me and a couple of people that i know, its a shame really because i am pretty much forced to use the wargear out of the rulebook where its generally cheaper, hope this all makes sense :) rant over XD
 
Chronometron is in no way overpowered. 40 points for a SINGLE re-roll of a SINGLE D6 roll per phase? (That means no Ld checks, pinning etc.) is not cheap, and is not OP. I struggle to find anything unbearably broken with the Necrons book, and I've tried to find it.
 
Aeviaan said:
Chronometron is in no way overpowered. 40 points for a SINGLE re-roll of a SINGLE D6 roll per phase? (That means no Ld checks, pinning etc.) is not cheap, and is not OP. I struggle to find anything unbearably broken with the Necrons book, and I've tried to find it.

so u cant use it for ld or pinning tests? if so please explain it to me, because my mate has necrons and he uses it for everything including reanimation protocols
 
Yeah, you could reroll one of them, but then you couldn't reroll anything else in that phase, like a reanimation protocol roll, or anything before it.
 
Zanos said:
Yeah, you could reroll one of them, but then you couldn't reroll anything else in that phase, like a reanimation protocol roll, or anything before it.

yh but better to re roll a LD test then have ur necs flee and loose the models that are down already, which would be 25% of the squad or more :) hate that piece of wargear...it saved my mate so many times, if he didnt take that he would have less chances in using his tachion arrow, his lord ressurecting, him being pinned....the list goes on....once per phase, one die, but it makes hell of a difference
 
Also, it's worth noting that the one Mat Ward book I actually quite like is the Blood Angels codex. Everything in it seems to actually have a definitive use, aside from maybe a regular Dreadnought (I have no idea why you'd use one when you could take a Death Company Dread or a Furioso). My one complaint is that Mephiston's stats seem a little ridiculous (S/T 6? Really?), but at least he has the huge achilles heel of no invulnerable save. Sure, he can't be insta-killed by strength, but Grey Knight players would just be licking their chops at a chance to get into close combat with that guy.
 
No invuln save is an incredibly huge achilles heel really, even the swarmlord has at least a melee only invuln save and he is pretty much unuseable in competitive play.

Really, I would actually be happiest if Matt Ward was declared in charge of all codexes, with Phil Kelly working under him, and Cruddance..... as Zanos once said, Cruddance should be demoted to making Ward and Kelly's coffee while they write.

It would be much better than the current situation- I don't really think its a problem of Matt Ward's codices being too powerful. I think its a problem of having 3 different writers seemingly working in a vacuum from each other with no one directing them, only one of which is actually consistent in the power levels of his codices.
Phil Kelly- Wrote Eldar, Orks, Dark Eldar and Space Wolves. I can easily pick out which of those books will disembowel the other three and beat them to death with their own intestines before hanging them from the ceillings.
Cruddance- Wrote Imperial Guard and Tyranids. They both are consistent in only one way- that both codices suck terribly on a competitive level, the inconsistency being that Imperial guard have a single army build that makes no sense yet is incredibly overpowered and undercosted.
Matt Ward- Wrote Blood Angels, Grey Knights, Space Marines and Necrons. All of them are powerful books, but they are consistent with each other in all being powerful. All of them have very few bad options, so you can build an army to whatever theme you like.
 
It's funny how everybody is screaming that GK are overpowered which IMO they are not. They are an elite army and pay outrageous costs for what they have. Yes some armies are incredibly f-ed against them but there are enough that stomp right over them as well with the right build.

I miss Alessio Cavatore, some golden work from him IMO and also the days you had fun stuff in the WD like rat-ogre pit fighting, path to glory, warbands, 40K in 40 minutes etc. etc. Wish they did more stuff like that, the small-scale battles to draw new players in instead of putting them off with Apocalypse that, whilst fun, costs a ton of cash and you will probably only play a few times. All new additions to the core games are cash-cows and ridiculously OP games that are only fun for a few times.

Agree with Sanai about only having one or two writers who work together. Cruddance ow man I hate IG now, used to love to play against them but now I know exactly what sort of army I will be facing every damn time and getting my tuchus firmly kicked.
Phil Kelly needs more streamlining, love my DE but every new codex of his does the powercreep and goes up a "level".

Leave the fluff to a special team, set it in stone for once! Consistency people. It's funny how some are okay with the Necron fluff change but yell and bawl about Vashanesh/Vlad background(pretty much in the bin and thank you for buying expensive books in the past that no longer make any sense) or the new Mannfred fluff. You might not like the current fluff(man I dislike Necrons now) but let's keep it like it is now and KEEP IT!
Kick out all the fanfiction-like writers as they are just horrible, but for army books and codici and BL books. I'm not a good writer at all but at least I admit it and some at GW should look long and hard if they are actually writers or not. Looking at you Gav Thorpe, nice guy really but for the love of, just stop writing 'kay?

As for the BA, never had any problems with Mephiston actually. Don't know what the fuss is about. More freaked out about those troops with the sanguinary priest inside :O
 
Zephyr said:
fun stuff in the WD like rat-ogre pit fighting, path to glory, warbands, 40K in 40 minutes etc. etc. Wish they did more stuff like that, the small-scale battles to draw new players

I miss the cool, little things GW used to do on the website, like zombie week for VC (or something that, it was a long time ago) or cool terrain tutorials and conversion stuff. Now it's just "here's a picture of a new painted miniature, oh, and while you're looking at it, here's a link to buy it." I rarely see anything fun on GW anymore. I would just like to see a little more than just promotions for new products.
 
I dunno, I really like the galleries they post up. Its great to see other peoples amazing work from the flickr thingy, and the 360 view thingys are great to better see what a model looks like.
 
I gave up on the site and WD.
GW changed drasticly over the years, for the worse.
Used to be WD was interesting, occaisonally had a free model, or some paper/card terrain, instructions for building terrain, paint guides, extracts from books, the site was full of entertaining things.
It is now near enough 100% advertising and "buy me!"

Used to be I enjoyed browsing the site and mag, enjoyed going into the stores, now I don't bother.
Why? It doesn't even pretend to be anything other than a buisness and about all the staff have to say is buy buy buy!
I didn't mind the costs back in the day, you felt like there was more to the stores than that, WD was something to look forward to, with the occaisional gift, Sales used to be nice too, now they would rather bin things, used to spend hours on the site looking for conversion parts when they still sold seperate pieces.

Now.. I look at the site for models (it is well layed out) then I order the Throne from amazon for £20.. instead of £36.
If all GW want to be is a shop, fine.. then I will shop around for the best bargain.
They give people no reason to enter the actual stores anymore.

It is sad, because many of the staff really are enthusiasts with lots to say, but no time to say it and too many targets to meet.
 
I loved path to glory, I even convinced my Gf to play it, and she really enjoyed it. Kill team and 40k in 40mins also reinvigorated the hobby, though border patrol was crap, some things don't scale down well.

I have started getting the wd again, I really liked the expansions like civil war and death worlds they have been releasing in it, its a small ammount of the total magazine, but its a definite improvement. Plus I like standard bearer, but that's probably because I'm an old fart too.
 
I really like Mat Ward's rules; he writes very well indeed, and, as I have said elsewhere, gets a lot more flak than he should. Some of the flak is sickening, the thought that some greasy man sitting in his filth-encrusted hovel with all his possessions sold for high-speed internet and a good laptop (this is how I imagine evil internet-users, I quite like the image xD ) can start an internet crusade against a human being because they didn't like something he wrote... horrible. There are worse people in the world that go unnoticed whilst we slather Mat Ward with unnecessary hatred, I feel.

Anyway, I really like his rules, but I feel his fluff might need more development. I'm firmly against his decision to poo on C'tan, but for all I know he could have been forced into that decision by GW wanting Chaos to be the big scary guys, and even then many people like the change a lot. Occasionally he can write something slightly silly (BA + Necron team-up, Draigo just flying around killing things) but overall even his fluff isn't bad, just might need more practice; but even then his codex writing will only improve with this practice. Sure, I might not like the C'tan Shards, but I don't need to hate the poor guy for it!

Just my tuppence. :thumbsup:
 
I gave up on the site and WD.
GW changed drasticly over the years, for the worse.
Used to be WD was interesting, occaisonally had a free model, or some paper/card terrain, instructions for building terrain, paint guides, extracts from books, the site was full of entertaining things.
It is now near enough 100% advertising and "buy me!"

Got WD 388 today (the may issue with the necrons)

Lets see...
Pages of cool fluffy stuff/articles/stories/players armies- 26
pages of cool Necron photos of models/armies/etc on the tabletop (which you want anyway, the game is about the models)- 10
Misc Pages (editorial, contents, etc)- 5
Pages of Advertising (pics of the new kits with a description and pricetag)- 17
Pages of Advertising for other parts of games workshop (black library, forgeworld, Roleplays, events, etc includes a two page spread showing warhound titans)- 11
Pages of club directories/events diary- 8
Pages of painting/hobby guides- 20
Pages of new rules/free expansions-18
Batrep pages- 10


So, as you can see alot more space is devoted to hobby/rules/actual articles/batreps than actual advertising.
I think white dwarf is better than ever. It never used to have much in the way of painting guides back in the day, and used to be only about a third of the size, with a quarter of its content devoted to black and white pictures of all of the metal models.
 
In my experience of the current competitive 40k meta, the 3 Tier 1 armies (GK, SW, IG) force a dilemma on players. Armies/builds that can deal with GK struggle to deal with the other 2, and armies/builds that can deal with the other 2 struggle to deal with GK.


Sanai said:
It would be much better than the current situation- I don't really think its a problem of Matt Ward's codices being too powerful. I think its a problem of having 3 different writers seemingly working in a vacuum from each other with no one directing them, only one of which is actually consistent in the power levels of his codices.

That's actually the greater problem IMO, out of which I consider Matt Ward to be a facet of the whole(whole problem that is). The part in italics is the part where I disagree.


Sanai said:
Phil Kelly- Wrote Eldar, Orks, Dark Eldar and Space Wolves. I can easily pick out which of those books will disembowel the other three and beat them to death with their own intestines before hanging them from the ceillings.

Here's where I think you're flat out wrong. As a Dark Eldar player, I shouldn't and I don't fear Space Wolves in the manner you suggest. It's not that Space Wolves are not a threat or underpowered or something. I know they can give me a run for my money, but this huge divide in terms of power that you suggest simply doesn't exist. As for Orks, I've seen them come into contention for Top 3 placing too many times before to simply write them off.

Out of the 4 armies you mentioned, the only clear underdog is actually CWE. In the current meta they struggle(IG in particular being a bad matchup)because the codex lacks reliable sources of anti-tank at 36''+.


Sanai said:
Cruddance- Wrote Imperial Guard and Tyranids. They both are consistent in only one way- that both codices suck terribly on a competitive level, the inconsistency being that Imperial guard have a single army build that makes no sense yet is incredibly overpowered and undercosted.

Actually, it's not so much the build being OP, as it is some units(vehicles in particular) being severely undercosted. The power build you mentioned simply exploits that fact.


Sanai said:
Matt Ward- Wrote Blood Angels, Grey Knights, Space Marines and Necrons. All of them are powerful books, but they are consistent with each other in all being powerful. All of them have very few bad options, so you can build an army to whatever theme you like.

Blood Angels aren't on the same level as Grey Knights. Necrons and Space Marines don't have the sheer power of that book either. Space Marines can still cope, but Necrons are a different story.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu