Matt Ward - Hero or Villain?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Now most people say the exact opposite of that sweeny, that BA are the trouble army, with the vast ammounts of fnp, outflanking fast tanks, and air cav dreadnoughts, I don't know 40k well enough to comment tbh, I'm only recently getting back into it, but one thing I will say is the cruddace nid book is awful, its an assault army with no assault grenade equivalents (except the horribly overcosted fex.) even guard get Frag grenades, and it just means your assault units get slaughtered attacking units in cover.
 
I think the saddest thing about the Tyranid book is that Carnifexes are only actually worth taking in competitive play if its 3 of them with nothing but devourers. I so hate to see my favourite walking tank turned into a quad organic pistol wielder.
 
And even then they get plasma'd to death, three basic fexes is 480, which will get you two trygon primes with regen..... Its a little too obvious that they made the newer units (hive guard,trygon, tervigon, venomthropes) no brainer choices.

And the mawlock is so disappointing, I mean you even get cover saves against it taking a massive bite out of the terrain!

Got loads of fexes, but they don't see much action, same as my ht, just too damn expensive.
 
Well, at least it fits the fluff of tyranids evolving newer, better bioforms, but that isn't really an excuse to obsolete the old ones that we all love.
 
What people have to remember is this: Mr. Ward writes the games mechanic rules, and it's other people that write the fluff in the books, it comes under hobby material, it's a posh name for fluff.

Now do people have a problem with the rules? fine that's HIS domain.

If you have a problem with background. fluff, look to others.

I would rather have Matt than Gav Thorpe, or Toumas Piernen, Alessio "Mr. Broken" Cavatori, and Jake "I broke Orcs and Goblins" Thornton.

A few years from now, they'll be someone else to complain about, and Matt Ward, like Rick Priestly will be a memory at G.W.
 
Personally never minded Priestly. On the whole I don't think Ward does too badly, but as others have said it would seem noone actually talks to each other or playtests books anymore and just wait for the public to give them the feedback on whether they F'd up. Alessio gave us a pretty fine book back in the day. (Last to have Bloodlines in the proper sense.)
 
Lord Elpus said:
I would rather have Matt than Gav Thorpe, or Toumas Piernen, Alessio "Mr. Broken" Cavatori, and Jake "I broke Orcs and Goblins" Thornton.

A few years from now, they'll be someone else to complain about, and Matt Ward, like Rick Priestly will be a memory at G.W.

Toumas was one of the best writers they ever had. Shame how the foreigners can get it right whereas those born and raised with the language muck it up so much. These guys probably don't even have college degrees do they?
 
Yorga said:
Lord Elpus said:
I would rather have Matt than Gav Thorpe, or Toumas Piernen, Alessio "Mr. Broken" Cavatori, and Jake "I broke Orcs and Goblins" Thornton.

A few years from now, they'll be someone else to complain about, and Matt Ward, like Rick Priestly will be a memory at G.W.

Toumas was one of the best writers they ever had. Shame how the foreigners can get it right whereas those born and raised with the language muck it up so much. These guys probably don't even have college degrees do they?

Toumas was a good designer, I loved Mordheim, absolutely great game! but I do think that Toumas was Alessio's mini me, he was an out and out power gamer with very little in the way of balance, trust me I've played against him. As for a college degree, yes most of the G.W staff are highly educated. As for the Forerigners getting it right, what about an old mate of mine Nigel Stillman, he wrote great rule sets along with Rick Priestly. both of whom are from Englandshire.
 
Lord Elpus said:
Toumas was a good designer, I loved Mordheim, absolutely great game! but I do think that Toumas was Alessio's mini me, he was an out and out power gamer with very little in the way of balance, trust me I've played against him. As for a college degree, yes most of the G.W staff are highly educated. As for the Forerigners getting it right, what about an old mate of mine Nigel Stillman, he wrote great rule sets along with Rick Priestly. both of whom are from Englandshire.

I've been playing regularly since about 1992. I toyed with 3rd edition a couple times as a player in multi-player games. But I really didn't play regularly until 4th edition and one on one games. I remember Stillman. If you like his work and thinks Toumas' was OP then you and I must agree to disagree my friend. :)
 
well this is interesting...
i was well and truly a Ward-hater before this thread and i have to say it has made me see differnetly.
now i see ward as a grey instead of black. he has made some decent armies but the only ones i can complain first hand about are space marines and greyknights. but looking back the rules have been reasonable but it was the land-raider-in-500pt-friendlies people tyhat annoyed me. i am still annoyed by some of the questionable rules ( 10man tactical squads with ML and flamer) but now that i look at it i've either had some bad dice rolls or i've made some mistakes.
Mat Ward i apologise for all the bad things i've said/thought about you
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu