Member Suggestions Thread

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I do not know if it has been said before but if it has it will not hurt saying it again. I would very much like a another forum in extension to the general warhammer discussion, namely an army list forum for other armies other than vampire counts. Personally I cannot see any downside to this.
 
So a specific forum to post army lists for other armies? The main issue I see, is that there is very little point in creating a forum that will very rarely be used. People post up an army list from other armies once on a blue moon, so is it really needed?
 
I think there might be more posted lists if there'd be a section which specifically allows it. I tinker around with other armies every now and then and having a place here on CN to post the lists in would be a good thing, in my opinion. :)
 
Disciple of Nagash said:
So a specific forum to post army lists for other armies? The main issue I see, is that there is very little point in creating a forum that will very rarely be used. People post up an army list from other armies once on a blue moon, so is it really needed?

Alot of us play a wide variety of armies so I do think it will all that infrequent.
For example over at D.net there are quite alot of activity in their general forum. Myself I play dwarfs and TK as well, as well as daemons every now and then, plus the odd army project.
 
Well we have a forum to have general discussion on other armies, so perhaps we can try it out.

I will create a forum for people to post up tactics / army lists for other armies in the "To War!" area, and see how much it is used in the next few months.
 
I was wondering if giving out a zombie for posting a thread is such a good idea. It's great in theory, but I think it may be encouraging people to post threads that, while having a question or issue, are rather basic and pointless. The old kind of
"What do you think about _________? Discuss."
Threads that pop up worrying frequently on some forums. Maybe a zombie for posting a thread of a greater that X length?
 
Oracle said:
I was wondering if giving out a zombie for posting a thread is such a good idea. It's great in theory, but I think it may be encouraging people to post threads that, while having a question or issue, are rather basic and pointless. The old kind of
"What do you think about _________? Discuss."
Threads that pop up worrying frequently on some forums. Maybe a zombie for posting a thread of a greater that X length?

Can you give some examples on here?

I think that this community is mature enough to not start 'spamming' in that way.
 
Here's a suggestion:

Instead of punishing "threadomancy" AND multiple threads on the same topic - pick one and stick with it.

This policy is really annoying, it stifles debate and new ideas and it discourages new users like me from getting involved (which is part of the reason I pretty much just lurk).

Seriously, it's ridiculous how many threads get locked here and it's stupid to pretend that every subject has been exhausted just because it has been raised before - especially when new users have questions about the stuff that has been written previously.
 
You might have a point there Lofnazareth, I just checked through the forum rules and couldn't actually find any clear guidelines on how to go about posting in older topics, when to leave them alone and instead start a new discussion. This'll have to be looked into. :)
 
Thanks for your quick reply - I looked in the rules as well and could find nothing on either threadomancy nor on starting multiple threads.

Just so you know, this issue was raised by another member, Shadowfax, here.
 
The rules have now been updated in regard to this issue. Please click on Forum > Rules to see the update.

I notice we have not had many suggestions in a while. This section is always checked so if anyone does have any suggestions please post them!
 
They look good to me DoN. I hope you don't mind that I took the liberty of making a quick little edit to the new rules-piece: you had written that Threadomancy is normally encouraged, so I changed it to discouraged. ;)
 
Hi again. Well done on the swiftness of your rules update. I'm still not sure that it is a very good/clear policy though.

In particular:

"However please bearing in mind the age of the thread may mean there is no point answering a question from over a year ago."

This seems a bit self contradictory. The point is to answer the question. I think this is valid however long ago it was originally asked, since there may still be people interested in the answer, even if the original poster is no longer around. Should these people start a new thread with the same question? It isn't clear.

"if you are adding to the discussion (no spamming), and it is still valid with current rules / situation then you are ok to post"

Isn't answering a question still adding to a discussion, no matter how old the question is?

Also, there is still no mention of starting multiple threads in the rules. Obviously this is an important and related area.

Lastly, the "Hellsteed" thread provides a good example of the problems I am talking about. this thread is linked as the only hellsteed thread in the tactics library. The hellsteed and its use/desirability is obviously still relevant. The rules update states that "Discussions threads with a topic that is still currently valid (such as tactical discussion on the use of a Varghulf) can be resurrected." but the tactical discussion of the use of a hellsteed gets locked down for "threadomancy". Why?

What is someone supposed to do if they want to debate the merits of the Hellsteed now? Bloat the forum with another Hellsteed topic? Will they then be told not to start a new thread on the same issue and get redirected to the old, closed one?
 
I agree with everything you've said Lofnazareth. Because a thread is old doesn't mean its not relevant. If something isn't answered, or not answered satisfactorily, or additional weight can be lent to an argument even if the original poster doesn't care, it should still be fine to post. I'd also like to add that 6 months is irrelevant to someone that just joined the forum, and we want to encourage people to post without cluttering up the forum too much. A number of threads that have been locked down I did not see a good reason why. Bloat is definitely something we want to avoid.
 
Hi again. Well done on the swiftness of your rules update. I'm still not sure that it is a very good/clear policy though.

In particular:

"However please bearing in mind the age of the thread may mean there is no point answering a question from over a year ago."

This seems a bit self contradictory. The point is to answer the question. I think this is valid however long ago it was originally asked, since there may still be people interested in the answer, even if the original poster is no longer around. Should these people start a new thread with the same question? It isn't clear.


I can understand this point. My intention was if someone posted in the thread a question,(e.g "How may skellies should I use in my list?) there would be little point posting in the thread again a year and a half later in relation to answer that (e.g. "Hi Anon, I would recommend putting xx in your list).



"if you are adding to the discussion (no spamming), and it is still valid with current rules / situation then you are ok to post"

Isn't answering a question still adding to a discussion, no matter how old the question is?

You have made the same point twice, so the answer I gave above shows what I mean by the question statement. In regards to the statement about adding to the discussion, I feel it is quite self-explanatory. I don't want spamming like posts just stating lol etc, and if you are going to resurrect a thread only do so if you are adding to the discussion and the discussion is still relevant.

Also, there is still no mention of starting multiple threads in the rules. Obviously this is an important and related area.

With the implementation of these rules, people can now resurrect old valid threads. So it should cut down on multiple threads. If someone does post a duplicate thread, we will now point them in the direction of existing threads.


Lastly, the "Hellsteed" thread provides a good example of the problems I am talking about. this thread is linked as the only hellsteed thread in the tactics library. The hellsteed and its use/desirability is obviously still relevant. The rules update states that "Discussions threads with a topic that is still currently valid (such as tactical discussion on the use of a Varghulf) can be resurrected." but the tactical discussion of the use of a hellsteed gets locked down for "threadomancy". Why?

What is someone supposed to do if they want to debate the merits of the Hellsteed now? Bloat the forum with another Hellsteed topic? Will they then be told not to start a new thread on the same issue and get redirected to the old, closed one?

That topic was locked down previous to these discussions and using the old rules, so is not relevant under the new rules.
 
And just to add one thing: Every once in a while a forum member (most often new members) goes through the entire back catalogue of painting logs, just posting that they like an old model or replying to qustions that have already been resolved. Now it wouldn't have been such a huge problem if only a thread or two were resurrected, but we can clearly see that they go methodically through the entire forum just in order to raise their post count, and cases such as these makes us introduce more restricting rules.
 
Hi Nagash,

Just a few clarifications and added suggestions.

When you say I make the same point about questions twice, you are kind of correct, but I did so in order to draw attention to an apparent contradiction in the rules. That is, that old questions are not worth answering because there is no point, but that it is still ok to add to the discussion if the topic is not outdated. The phrase "please bearing in mind the age of the thread may mean there is no point answering a question from over a year ago" makes it sound like there is no point answering old questions just because they are old, but as I have said, other newer members might still be interested in the answer.

I understand what you are getting at here but it is not very clear in the rules. Perhaps you should try and make it clearer when old questions are still relevant/ok to answer and when they are not? Actually, why not remove the bit about old questions completely? Is it really so bad if someone answers the question in your example? I know that you think that the rules are self-explanatory, but they do not appear that way to me. I think that they could be quite intimidating/confusing for a newbie.

I still think that there should be some mention of multiple threads in the rules if your policy is to discourage them.

On the whole, I think the new direction is a big improvement, I take it that the Hellsteed thread and similar will no longer be locked for threadomancy so this should hopefully avoid confusing no win situations.

If it were up to me, I would just allow "threadomancy" across the board - I mean, what's a few harmless bumps? If people aren't interested in discussing what is being said then the thread will soon fade into obscurity again anyway. I very much doubt that new members are trying to mess up the board just so that they can raise their post counts.

Cheers
 
Lofnazareth said:
I very much doubt that new members are trying to mess up the board just so that they can raise their post counts.

Unfortunately it happens every once in a while. I've seen it happen three times during my time as a member, but after we became stricter against threadomancy I haven't seen it happen at all.
 
If true, that's pretty pathetic.

Still, if it has only happened 3 times in the last 14 months then perhaps it would be better dealt with on an individual basis.

Cheers

P.S. I've noticed that the members suggestions posts don't get counted - I would have doubled mine by now. Luckily, I don't care.
 
Here's something I've noticed, the Stickys in the 'Dying to Help' forum are getting in the way, I think they could comfortably be condensed into "useful painting & modelling links," "Tips for Posting in this Forum" & the current GBPC results.

I'm on a 1280 by 1024 screen & the normal threads are lost off the bottom, I shouldn't have to scroll down to see what's actually going on in the current threads.
 
In regards to the question issue, I will clarifying the wording so hopefully it should be clear to all.

TDS, is right in his post though, so that is why there is rules and guidelines in regards to Threadomancy. The rules may not be to everyones liking, but there as to be a point where a decision is set. At the moment it stands that Threadomancy is allowed, but only under the guidelines.

Ophidicus - I think TDS was looking into that anyway. I will see how the condensing of those threads is coming along.
 
Great work on the editor box in new reply/new topic and the bars in a forum. Better than I could have done.

When replying to a PM, though, you get one of the old standard MyBB buttons though ''reply to all''.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu