Musicians and Bannermen

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

VonRaetia

Zombie
Aug 15, 2015
39
Birmingham
Zombies
28
Re AoS what are people's thoughts as to whether musicians and Bannermen can attack.

I have seen the common weapon approach and that's fine but I seem to remember a rule stating that the weapon must be represented on the model and therefore it a drummer is not carrying an axe he shouldn't be able to fight with one.

To me it makes sense that a musician should not be able to fight as without a points value it adds a consideration to preparing the list esp as you get payoffs.

Any thoughts.
 
As far as AoS is concerned, the game doesn't force us to play "what you see is what you get" in miniatures (maybe 40k, wouldn't know). It is just a happy "coincidence" that all models were deprived of personalization by encompasing the model's equipment into the AoS rules for said weapons, however nowhere does it say that you must build a spear-type skeleton in order to play it with Spear weapon rules, for instance.

It is easier, I'd like to note, to keep track of what model is still on the board when you distinguish between the Musician and the Champion, etc, and if you remove them, you lose the bonus they provide, true.

As far as Standard bearers and Musicians go, the Unit's description is clear about the Equipment that the entire Unit uses, regardless of additional rules (having champs, musicians and standard bearers)

That's how I see it
 
@Demian hits the nail, as always. However, I think the main point is that AoS is a simple game and thus any additional weird rules should be avoided. It is easier to say that all models in the unit has the same attack. But then again - the rules are pretty open so if you like the WYSIWYG part you can just play it that way :)
 
We always play that if a unit can have a champion, banner, and/or musician, it automatically does, even if there is no model to represent them, they have the same equipment as the rest of the unit (unless specifically stated otherwise), and they are always the last three models removed. Generally, the controlling player decides which models are removed anyways, so we applied that to the command team as well. If less than three models of a unit are remaining, the player just states which ones they are and it's worked out well, mainly because it doesn't happen often.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu