Musicians and the Undead

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Lord Roke

Grave Guard
Feb 25, 2008
288
Torontonia
Zombies
160
Aside from obvious fluff complications with musicians in an undead army (a skeleton cannot blow a horn!), from a gaming perspective, what is the tactical advantage to paying the points for them?

Do undead flee?
If so, do they flee enough to warrant a musician?
I know the undead have dismal Ld, will that +1 make the difference in rallying?

Yes, musicians break ties in combat, but that only means 1 model crumbles, IoN would cover that, would it not?

So the question stands, for the few points is takes, is it viable to get a musician in any undead unit?

~Roke
 
No, Undead do not flee, they are Unbreakable and Immune to Psychology. Therefore no, Musicians are useless in Undead units. I should probably have someone who can play the army a little better verify this but as far as I can see, the answer is no.
But I think an Undead Drummer model would be kinda' cool....or a gong!
 
Well they can't be broken but they aren't Unbreakable. They take wounds from losing which is much different than an unbreakable unit.

The tactical advantage with undead that if, on the off chance, you are tied in CR and win with a musician by a single point then, if you outnumber the enemy they will autobreak through fear. Even stubborn LD10 Dwarf hammerers. A single point lost and they're running.

So no, undead don't run and they don't rally. They don't need their leadership for much except when your general dies usually (and now the banshee scream will kill a lot of them). They're ItP and never take a break test. A loss of a single point of CR isn't a big deal on most units (but against something like Knights of the Blood Keep it is a big deal). And saving a unit from crumble is a IoN you don't have to cast. Don't assume you have unlimited magic. You should be using that magic to attack the enemy, not just trying to heal the hurt he does.

It definitely is viable to get a musician. These new armies can be fielded with a lot of inherent static CR and a musician may be that one little bit to push it over the top and send the enemy running.

-Grish
 
grishnakh99 said:
The tactical advantage with undead that if, on the off chance, you are tied in CR and win with a musician by a single point then, if you outnumber the enemy they will autobreak through fear. Even stubborn LD10 Dwarf hammerers. A single point lost and they're running.

[...]

It definitely is viable to get a musician. These new armies can be fielded with a lot of inherent static CR and a musician may be that one little bit to push it over the top and send the enemy running.

Agreed. This musician can win you a battle, don't forget.

However, we all expect to win in a more "shiny" fashion, don't we?:lol::P
 
the musician will rarely win you anything. most enemy units will sport musicians, at least combat units will - because they do flee and the +1 to rally will help.

so a musician will save you a model, not win you (many) combats.

you might get from this that I dont rate them highly...
 
Grish got it right. Muscians are cheap and are good to have, just in case. If you hit a unit in the flank it could potentially mean that they cant turn around to face you, just because they had a musican and you didnt.. :P
 
Musicians are almost always worth it, they're cheap and have helped me out countless times. The game is not played in a vacuum, and relies on dice rolls which don't always go as planned. Say you do loose by one because of a draw without musician and have multiple undead units in combat, there goes a few wounds which will require multiple invocations.

I think the only time you shouldn't have a musician is if you have a BSB and even then all my units that can, will have musicians as there's no major point saving by not taking them. Not taking a musician where I play is known as a 'school boy error'.
 
It really depends on the units involved.

I mean you can sacrifice a skeleton and get a musician in two skeleton units. That is worth it to me. No, they normally don't do anything. But that one time it does do something, it is definitely worth it. Its good against things that don't have musicians, such as monsters or chariots and such.

Some units I don't consider its worth it, such as on units I don't expect to outnumber the enemy (like black knights) or occaisionally on units I don't expect to do anything at all.

They are so cheap though that normally most if not all of my units will have one.
 
Consider it this way. Some have stated that musicians are useless because you can raise the minor losses. The very small point cost of the musicians across your units is only a few skeletons...raise them. IoN can not raise any upgrades that weren't paid for. This is why skilled undead players will raise their best units when they have the chance. Always take musicians.
 
Musicians allow you to win a combat by one if your opponent doesn't have one.
Winning a combat and outnumbering an opponent as good as breaks them (usually).
In what way is this not a good thing?
 
An undead musician is not for "not to loose", it is for winning. "Outnumbered by feared enemy" occurs even if you win by 1. And the situation that CR is determined by a musician occurs more often than once per game.
 
I always take musicians, I like the look of a full command group for a start and i really would kick my self if in a drawn combat I didn't have that one winning factor. For a few points you could break a whole unit.

I think everyone in this thread agrees: Take a musician!! :grin:
 
Not only the musician, but the whole command...
There are only some minor exceptions: no command in dire wolves (you don't want a mage challenge to survive..) and sometimes (in last edition) I didn't put command in Black Knights (particularly champion, because too costy) and Ghouls (It was 10 points... Another ghoul was better in my opinion).

In the new book, are their still some "no-good" command groups ?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu