My philosophy: point to list comparison 8th edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Forge said:
well the way I see it everyone list is forced to be the same then to be competitive, all ghouls, grave guard, black coach or two varghulfs, yay way fun.

The winners of the 2 most important italian tournament use Vampire counts.

The winner of the first tournament use skeletons
The winner of the 2 tournament use a deathstar blood knight unit.
 
As someone else who has played several games in 8th (never counted, but somewhere up there) there are some things I agree (most of which were in your 2nd post) and some things I disagree with. I won't get into everything as too much has been said to do so :)
Two of the big things I agree with are what you said about ghouls...Why are they so ugly? (also the gameplay stuff you said about them) and us not scaling well with high point games. I would say (and it seems you would agree) the biggest reasons are that the benefit from a 3k+ army (having multiples of a unit, extra core) don't apply to us thanks to a relatively weak core and nothing really worth taking many copies. The other reason being that we are a "magic based" army and magic doesn't scale. With all the fluff about magic congregating around big battles you would think 3k+ armies would roll for more WoM but ah well.

Anyways, the main thing I would say you're exaggerating a lil bit is that the coach, skellies and GG are the only viable choices. I would not contend that these are perhaps our MOST viable choices, but cairn wraiths can be very effective against many armies. Fel bats, while generally regarded as worthless, I've found to be invaluable against war machines, especially with the new rules that only 6 models get to attack a war machine and they have 2 attacks/model (giving the most number of attacks in CC possible for our army) combined with their difficulty to stop (fast speed, free reform and -1 to hit from ranged attacks) makes them perfectly tooled to deal with the war machines I find myself against. Granted, I dream of them having their point cost reduced (and I wouldn't mind losing the undead rule for them to do it!) but certainly viable in many situations.
 
I wonder if we are hemming ourselves in with nay-saying. OP. I agree with you, i use ghouls and GG... but maybe im being foolish... ive never TRIED a blood knight deathstar, as it sounds ridic to me..... but maybe it does work!?

Ive realised im being a coward. Playing a conservative game with the same tools every time. NO LONGER!

On another note, i see your point on magic not scaling with pts, due to same power dice..... but i think also some LORES scale worse than others....

Fire for example, would do more in lower pts games. While light, with it's "Balloon spells, all within 12 inches" would likely still have an effect even in games of 5,000 pts...

But enough, tomorrow im going to make a game wit bloodknights in, and zombies ffs!!!!! Im gonna try it. And spirit hosts! And im going to bloody love it. I will post what happens somewhere.
 
Thats the spirit. There is certainly nothing wrong with a conservative list if you are playing for a prize in a tournament, but in friendly games if you experiment with units that maybe you are unsure of, you may find them to be better than you expected. Then next time a tourney comes along they may seem a more competitive choice.
 
vodacce said:
Forge said:
well the way I see it everyone list is forced to be the same then to be competitive, all ghouls, grave guard, black coach or two varghulfs, yay way fun.

The winners of the 2 most important italian tournament use Vampire counts.

The winner of the first tournament use skeletons
The winner of the 2 tournament use a deathstar blood knight unit.

Ohh no dont get me wrong!

I use zero ghouls all skeletons and my win loss ratio is in the 85% region and ive played over 50 games.

I won my local ard boys with a blood knight death star, but you CANT run that in anything less then sub 2800 points imo the points just dont pan out, unless your running 5 blood knights then your going to get creamed, you need 9 or 10 with banner of blood keep, Vampire lord with blood drinker, redfury, infinite hatred ect. and that comes back around to what I was saying, people called me cheesy for running that death star, and its just that a giant block of cheese, but you dont have much option when running that unit, you have to sink so many points into it to make it so they get across the table, you have to throw the lord in there to ensure they survive the rest of the game and can break ranks.

wraiths have their place, but not in a game where you dont know who your fighting what magic they take ect.

war machines are toughness 7 fell bats arnt doing anything but tieing them up, every time ive used them in 6 sized units they die first round of shooting. plus they are expensive as hell.

Spirit hosts are great! but they are 65 points a base and you need 3! no thanks!

zombies, well, pooo

Black knights are good on the charge sure, if you use them in support maybe they can do the job, but a block of skeletons with ranks can do a better job and probably rack up more combat resolution the black knights could.
 
Warmachines are not T7 in CC, only against ranged attacks. you use the crew's toughness in CC. (How would you ever beat a warmachine otherwise O.O )

Also remember fel bats are flyers and thus skirmish so everything is at -1 to hit them in addition to range, cover etc. If you remembered that, then I'm surprised you lost them to firing as I always bring them against dwarfs and they always survive to eat the war machines (unless they are constantly anviled to the ground :( ). Considering they are two wound and two attacks a piece (basically two models), I'll say they are on the pricey side, but not too awful.

You have a point with wraiths, but I still sometimes take a small group of them even with an unknown opponent. I figure at best they'll be unstoppable and at worst, they'll divert some firing which is something. Granted, at worst they aren't worth their cost but the benefits outweigh the risk to me. Plus it keeps opponents on their toes about what I may bring :D
 
I dont see any problem with Fel Bats for assaulting warmachines. Its hard for crew of warmachines to really ammount any offense. I think the Orcs N Gobbos have a slight advantage if they get to put an orc in there to protect their investment, but even then, the Fel Bats do pretty well at tieing it up for several rounds which is what you need. It sometimes isnt about obliterating the unit you hit, its about not letting your opponent utilize his shooting to whittle away our units. War machines can really do some damage to us if we dont have fast moving units to divert their attention and as was mentioned, Fel Bats get the Skirmisher advantage to help with that.

as for the Black Knights... you could try to get some rank n file skeletons into the flank of an opponent, but i guarantee that when those skellies get there, they wont be hitting on STR 6 with Killing Blow and a 2+ armour save, and they wont get there nearly as soon as the Black Knights will with their mounted speed and Ethereal Movement.
 
Large units of wraiths are absolutely murderous...you should often make contact with the enemy second turn.6-8 of them buffed w/ HoC or VH's etc...will make mincemeat out of most units.One hero swinging 3 times at them w/ a magic sword will in no way compensate,and it will likely get him killed to boot.
 
Gladius Rex said:
I dont see any problem with Fel Bats for assaulting warmachines. Its hard for crew of warmachines to really ammount any offense. I think the Orcs N Gobbos have a slight advantage if they get to put an orc in there to protect their investment, but even then, the Fel Bats do pretty well at tieing it up for several rounds which is what you need. It sometimes isnt about obliterating the unit you hit, its about not letting your opponent utilize his shooting to whittle away our units. War machines can really do some damage to us if we dont have fast moving units to divert their attention and as was mentioned, Fel Bats get the Skirmisher advantage to help with that.

as for the Black Knights... you could try to get some rank n file skeletons into the flank of an opponent, but i guarantee that when those skellies get there, they wont be hitting on STR 6 with Killing Blow and a 2+ armour save, and they wont get there nearly as soon as the Black Knights will with their mounted speed and Ethereal Movement.

sure but how many attacks will those knights be doing? how many hits? how many wounds? they dont break ranks, so your opponent will just get his rank bonus and stead fast.

wraiths are to bloody expensive for the risk I cant justify it, theyre skirmishers and cant break ranks so you have to deal with combat resolution, and they cant march on their own.
 
Wraiths are good. I've been taking 4, never more than 5, and just sit them up against a unit without magic attacks & they stay put forever.
 
Forge said:
sure but how many attacks will those knights be doing? how many hits? how many wounds? they dont break ranks, so your opponent will just get his rank bonus and stead fast.

wraiths are to bloody expensive for the risk I cant justify it, theyre skirmishers and cant break ranks so you have to deal with combat resolution, and they cant march on their own.

The number of attacks your knights get depends on the number you take. THey do get supporting attacks so if you take 10 you get 10 attacks that will in fact break rank be at STR 6 with lances on the charge and have KB on top of that with a T4 and 2+ armour.

Im not sure what else you need to justify this... there is no magic bullet and no unit is nigh invulnerable or a sure win tactic, so I guess I dont know what else you would need this unit to do to make it worth using them. Eye beams? Laser guns? Deathray Moon Station?
 
Gladius Rex said:
Forge said:
sure but how many attacks will those knights be doing? how many hits? how many wounds? they dont break ranks, so your opponent will just get his rank bonus and stead fast.

wraiths are to bloody expensive for the risk I cant justify it, theyre skirmishers and cant break ranks so you have to deal with combat resolution, and they cant march on their own.

The number of attacks your knights get depends on the number you take. THey do get supporting attacks so if you take 10 you get 10 attacks that will in fact break rank be at STR 6 with lances on the charge and have KB on top of that with a T4 and 2+ armour.

Im not sure what else you need to justify this... there is no magic bullet and no unit is nigh invulnerable or a sure win tactic, so I guess I dont know what else you would need this unit to do to make it worth using them. Eye beams? Laser guns? Deathray Moon Station?

ya for like 280 points (with no standard, champion, musician, banner ect.) they become semi effective, but you kill one and your not breaking ranks anymore. for those points you can take a large block of grave guard ect that does the job even better.

You would need cavalry to be a viable choice these days, theyre to bloody expensive for what they do and are bound to get beat in combat. and if they dont, steadfast all day with BSB rerolls and generals leadership, then the next round they are WS 3 Strength 4 garbage.
 
I'd have to agree that for the cost of a Black Knight you can get 2 grave guard w. Great Weapons almost. Much easier to heal, more damage output and more staying power. Grave Guard are the superior choice this edition, by far. The only thing I can think of using them for is possibly for a delivery system for characters, but with Infantry not half as hampered as they were in 7th, this isn't as important anymore. Charging is way farther and way easier, with redirecting possible.

Wraiths were good in 7th and with less Static CR, I think they'd be even better this edition. Max static CR from round to round is only 4, so if they're near a BSB, they'll only need to deal 4 wounds a round to tie combat. A group of 5 puts out 15 attacks, hits on half usually, wounds on 2/3 or 5/6 of the time. 5 is all that would be needed to hold up/chop up a standard unit of RnF. You'd likely need more if you want to whittle the unit down enough to cause them to break. If I took Wraiths, I would take a large unit that would be difficult to wipe out. Probably around 10. Especially as they can fit into small spots and have supporting attacks, I would think this edition they'd be great. Haven't played yet, so I'd have to test it out. The banshee scream can also be effective, and it's scary enough to make people pause. One good roll can topple some of the beasties out there, or sufficiently wound them. Combined with VHD, they can dish out a LOT of pain.

You should try them out in a big unit Forge. Dance them in with VHD, and see the damage they'll do. March 12", VHD 8", quite the charge range.
 
you guys act like you think you should just be able to run knights in alone and just win. Warhammer fights are won via strategy and coordinated movements. Yes, a grave guard unit can hit a flank, sure, but a Black Knight can do it from further away and ignore terrain issues and deliver a very good set of wounds at STR 6 KB. It can likely do this the same around another infantry unit hits from the front if you are good in your deployment and movement phases.

the effectiveness of units are how they contribute to the army and the overall gameplan, not their own brute force necessarily. A group of Black Knights have a charge range of 7 + 2d6, that is an average of 13. Grave guard have a range of 4+2d6 for an average of 10, this makes it less likely that you have to utilize the fickle winds of magic power dice to make flank charges.

and dont act like STR 4, WS3 with Killing blow is horrible. Odds are, you are probably using a Lord with the helm of command anyways and you could make them WS 7 if you so desired. Truth of the matter is that you have a particular playstyle that you like and you refuse to break from it, which is fine, but then dont start a thread complaining about the units that you wont give a chance to do their thing so you can find the advantage of them.

noone is going to tell you that you are wrong for loving grave guard, i think we all love our grave guard, but that doesnt make the Black Knight useless
 
Gladius Rex said:
you guys act like you think you should just be able to run knights in alone and just win. Warhammer fights are won via strategy and coordinated movements. Yes, a grave guard unit can hit a flank, sure, but a Black Knight can do it from further away and ignore terrain issues and deliver a very good set of wounds at STR 6 KB. It can likely do this the same around another infantry unit hits from the front if you are good in your deployment and movement phases.

the effectiveness of units are how they contribute to the army and the overall gameplan, not their own brute force necessarily. A group of Black Knights have a charge range of 7 + 2d6, that is an average of 13. Grave guard have a range of 4+2d6 for an average of 10, this makes it less likely that you have to utilize the fickle winds of magic power dice to make flank charges.

and dont act like STR 4, WS3 with Killing blow is horrible. Odds are, you are probably using a Lord with the helm of command anyways and you could make them WS 7 if you so desired. Truth of the matter is that you have a particular playstyle that you like and you refuse to break from it, which is fine, but then dont start a thread complaining about the units that you wont give a chance to do their thing so you can find the advantage of them.

noone is going to tell you that you are wrong for loving grave guard, i think we all love our grave guard, but that doesnt make the Black Knight useless

Im just laying out the numbers here, Calvary are all but dead unless accompanied by a host of characters, ours cant even march without a vampire near by, which probably means hes in the unit which means ethereal doesn't mean jack. If they were much cheaper I would take them, but they are simply to expensive (not only a single model, but the amount you have to take to make them do anything) to field, blood knights are the same but twice as hard to field. this game is an infantry game now, the way it should be, but i dont think our calvary is even worth taking unless you plan to run it with a few characters in it, one with blood drinker especially.
 
THere are other ways to keep your ethereal black knights marching besides putting a vamp in there.

There is a banner that allows marching away from vamps, you can always put a black coach or Varghulf nearby to help usher them along, or even a caster Thrall on hellsteed or caster Lord on abyssal terror/dragon.

I agree with you to a degree, infantry is certainly better. I dont understand why cavalry wasnt erratta'd to get devastating charge special ability across the board or why they didnt allow only 5 to cause disruption, but cavalry still move quickly, they still carry lances, and they still overrun better than infantry.

are they a little pricey? Probably, but it doesnt mean they CANT do their job if you use them correctly
 
Gladius Rex said:
THere are other ways to keep your ethereal black knights marching besides putting a vamp in there.

There is a banner that allows marching away from vamps, you can always put a black coach or Varghulf nearby to help usher them along, or even a caster Thrall on hellsteed or caster Lord on abyssal terror/dragon.

I agree with you to a degree, infantry is certainly better. I dont understand why cavalry wasnt erratta'd to get devastating charge special ability across the board or why they didnt allow only 5 to cause disruption, but cavalry still move quickly, they still carry lances, and they still overrun better than infantry.

are they a little pricey? Probably, but it doesnt mean they CANT do their job if you use them correctly

what im saying is, because they are expensive, because you have to take 10+ of them, because charge distances are random now, because there is such a thing as stead fast, because magic is ridiculous, because cannons got hell of alot better along with the other guess range weapons among other reasons I would rather spend my 300+ points else where in my list 2 varghulfs, characters ect.
 
vodacce said:
The winners of the 2 most important italian tournament use Vampire counts.

The winner of the first tournament use skeletons
The winner of the 2 tournament use a deathstar blood knight unit.

Better late then never...

I have used the following set-up with great succes:
Caster Lord in Skellie Bunker, Regenhoff BSB King, back-Up VanHelse Necro, 2x Ghouls (min 24), 20ish Skellies (bunker), GG GW BOB horde (30), 4 Wraits, 1 Coach + x (x= Either Vargulf, Either more Ghouls or a Vampire hero).

I'm looking forward to change my playing style and I would like to try 'more skeletons' and 'Blood Knights', and therefor I quoted your response!

Could you share some more information on how these are used in Italy, evidently with great succes? Maybee have these guys give us some tactical advise?

Forge said:
Ohh no dont get me wrong!

I use zero ghouls all skeletons and my win loss ratio is in the 85% region and ive played over 50 games.

The same question for you Forge!
 
MalumMonachus the first armylist is The army list of Guidara one of the best italian players ( he wins 2 italian GT in 3 years) i don't know everything. I remember

lord with red Fury 50, hatred eternal 25, ghoul kin 25
magic objects: 5 2+t.S vs Fire, 15 Cuirass armor, 20 strength potion, 60 sword +3 att

Drakenhof BSB

Vampire with power scroll, Lycni, and Death lore (the runner combo)
vampire with beast lore and command Helm

2 units of ghoul
1 unit of skeletons (24) with fire banner 10 ( in this unit the lord and the Bsb go)
1 black chariot.
Other units but i Don't remember. The beast vampire use the beast spell +3 att +3 strength on the lord. The lord can do 20 att in one turn ;)

I don't know the 2 army list (Deathstar Blood knight) but I think that the lord is like the Guidara lord but on horse. the unit use 75 banner. Sorry for my bad english
 
vodacce said:
MalumMonachus the first armylist is The army list of Guidara one of the best italian players ( he wins 2 italian GT in 3 years) i don't know everything. I remember

lord with red Fury 50, hatred eternal 25, ghoul kin 25
magic objects: 5 2+t.S vs Fire, 15 Cuirass armor, 20 strength potion, 60 sword +3 att

Drakenhof BSB

Vampire with power scroll, Lycni, and Death lore (the runner combo)
vampire with beast lore and command Helm

2 units of ghoul
1 unit of skeletons (24) with fire banner 10 ( in this unit the lord and the Bsb go)
1 black chariot.
Other units but i Don't remember. The beast vampire use the beast spell +3 att +3 strength on the lord. The lord can do 20 att in one turn ;)

I don't know the 2 army list (Deathstar Blood knight) but I think that the lord is like the Guidara lord but on horse. the unit use 75 banner. Sorry for my bad english

sounds like every other competitive boring list that VC is subject too imo, im sure he had Grave guard and a wight king with regen banner you can count on it,

in response to the question I was asked, I take the minimum amount that I have to of core (all in skeletons, make them into the largest 2 units I can, and throw the largest one on one of my grave guards flanks, and the smaller one in the back and put my helm vamp in it. then heres the strategy part of it, I dont rely on my skeletons doing jack haha they sit there and look pretty and sit on my flanks being a nuisance and a tar pit, and soak up shots, they rarely are killed so I save 500- whatever amount of points.
 
Damn Forge, I just don't know man. I don't see how you can just write off taking whats good in an army as "boring" or whatever. I know that all the time & money I spend on making an army better be for something, and that I like to win. And, unless you're playing new players or children, its always a challenge to win. There is no automatic "win" button. You don't like Ghouls? You don't like the Regen banner? I just don't get it. It doesn't fit with the "story"? Shit, if we followed the story von Carstein vampires would have Empire troops, handgunners and cannons and whatever else. Everybody uses the same shit? Well that's why theres like 15 different teams or whatever. Tired of using magic? Play Dwarfs. Tired of having no shooting? Play Empire. Tired of winning? Play Wood Elves haha. Or whatever. That man that won that tournament in Italy probably spent a lot of effort on his list, and I bet he at least painted some of them if not all so I say thats whats up, not oh how boring. Good for him.
Me, I'm gonna keep taking Ghouls. Me, I'm gonna keep taking the Drakenhof Banner in 90% of my lists. I'm gonna keep trying to win. Hopefully my opponents have a different attitude than you, and they try to win too, so we can have a good competitive game and we can both get better at what we love to do. Which is play fight with plastic toys haha.........
 
So, I may be wrong, but the more I read the first half of the posts on this thread, the more it sounds like everyone used to just take a cookie cutter tournament army list in 7th edition and now they're pissed off that they can't anymore.
It also seems like the opposing side of the arguement is that people (or person, not sure exactly) are annoyed with the fact that they have to bring said cookie cutter list or there's no point playing even. This is so far from true especially in 8th edition. This is the reason GW made 8th the way it is. There were a couple of OP xeroxed army lists that could win any tournament and the game stopped being fun.
WoM, rolling for charges, attacking with Initiative value. These are all things they put in place to balance the game for us. Forget trying to build an "OP" list or a "balanced" list anymore. Every damned army list is balanced now because the rules force it to be. Your GG with great weapons and the drakenhoff banner? See how well that does against a lvl 4 fire mage. You'll be lucky if they even see combat.
And as far as "useless" units go that's the dumbest part I seem to be hearing most often in this post. That there are only a few units in the list that are even worth taking. Those units are there for a reason, and just because that 'ard boyz winning list you got from google doesn't include them doesn't make them "useless" or not cost effective.

I've been dying for some examples since I read how many things people find "useless"

Varghulf - Best warmachine/elite hunter in the game. A vampire with M9 and stats like that? Run them into the front of a RnF and they won't do much, they can't negate ranks either. Eat a cannon crew on turn 2-3 and don't think about the points you just won, think about the points that varg stopped the cannon from killing! My favorite Varg moment; hitting 5 Chaos knights in the flank, killing one and not taking any wounds in return from the one knight able to attack back. I win combat by 2 he fails post combat reform and stays facing the same way. I kill 2 more next turn and he runs and I run him down.

Ghouls - I run 2 units of 40 in horde formation in 2K, way over 25%. Tell me 40 poisoned attacks isn't a scary thing. These guys have taken out chaos warriors, saurus, most things really. Remember ghoul's I3 is pretty handy to have now. And never ever underestimate T4

Corpse Cart - one of my favorite units. Sure the bound spell has changed now, so what! cast it first with one dice. If you fail, you fail and the corpse cart can't cast anymo...oh wait it doesn't matter. If you pass it and it happens to be in between said 2 hordes of ghouls, that's a lot of ASF attacks. It's also one more thing that your opponent is going to have to throw likely 2 DD at. Even a lvl 4 has to roll at least a 3+ for the dispel to work, and a 2/3 chance to stop 80 ASF poisoned attacks isn't good enough not to justify tossing 2 dice at in my opinion anyway.

Spirit hosts/Cairn Wraiths - These guys can dominate games! Of course they can also die miserably as well. Wraiths first; bring 3-4! 150pts isn't really all that terrible when you're gambling on having them either be game changing in your favour or bait for some nasty magic attack that could be shooting/charging something else instead! And as far as Spirit hosts go, I don't bring them very often however I do almost always bring a Vamp with FL and the vamp lore. Just to make sure I get all the spells I want from it. Including but not limited to Wind of undeath! It's a great spell if your opponent happens to have lots of units. If not, you didn't waste anything because the extra points to guarantee VHD and SuH are worth it anyway. I played an empire player with 9+ units and only a single char capable of hurting ethereal. Free unkillable unit anyone?

Cavalry - I'll admit that wolves got nerfed at least a bit, but how many other armies can claim a unit that fast for so cheap? If you want them to negate ranks, bring 20! They still have M9 that part didn't change and even with that many it's not like they're really taking up that many points. And why is it that 5 Bloodknights can't be effective? Sure they don't have any ranks and such, but I only bring 4 by themselves and they're invaluable! Don't run them into RnF, it won't work. But I challenge anyone to tell me a better solution to staring down a Steg, or a hellcannon, or a Stank, or a hydra, or any other damned big ass thing that CAN do a lot of damage to your RnF. And as far as black knights go, please refer to someone's earlier post mentioning the 10 S6 KB attacks as that's a scary thought to ANY opponent. And sure, I suppose 10 GW GG are half the cost, but the whole point of cav is getting them where you want them to be! And ethereal movement is a hell of an advantage with that goal in mind. Those GG might as well be zombies or not even there for the sake of how much they're killing during the 4 turns they aren't in combat.

Wow, this is a lot longer than I intended but I guess I'm more upset at people bashing my beloved VC than I thought. I'll wrap up now I guess by saying TRY out the units in our book! Think outside the box! If you're tired of using a xeroxed army list, start thinking about how best to use a different one instead of complaining that the same list everyone uses is so boring. Stop nitpicking the old 7th edition powerhouse lists and start writing your very own brand spanking new 8th edition lists. You might surprise yourself.
 
Wow?! Well said!

Between Astorre and Fluffytemplar, I don't think I need to add anything lol

I for one hardly ever run the same army list more than 2 or 3 times in a row. After that I just get bored and need something else and VC has so many options available to it that we can chop and change like that (even though some may think thats not true ;) )

Anyway, like I said, Astorre and Fluffytemplar, thats the kind of mentality I think is needed. Well done!
 
Astorre said:
Damn Forge, I just don't know man. I don't see how you can just write off taking whats good in an army as "boring" or whatever. I know that all the time & money I spend on making an army better be for something, and that I like to win. And, unless you're playing new players or children, its always a challenge to win. There is no automatic "win" button. You don't like Ghouls? You don't like the Regen banner? I just don't get it. It doesn't fit with the "story"? Shit, if we followed the story von Carstein vampires would have Empire troops, handgunners and cannons and whatever else. Everybody uses the same shit? Well that's why theres like 15 different teams or whatever. Tired of using magic? Play Dwarfs. Tired of having no shooting? Play Empire. Tired of winning? Play Wood Elves haha. Or whatever. That man that won that tournament in Italy probably spent a lot of effort on his list, and I bet he at least painted some of them if not all so I say thats whats up, not oh how boring. Good for him.
Me, I'm gonna keep taking Ghouls. Me, I'm gonna keep taking the Drakenhof Banner in 90% of my lists. I'm gonna keep trying to win. Hopefully my opponents have a different attitude than you, and they try to win too, so we can have a good competitive game and we can both get better at what we love to do. Which is play fight with plastic toys haha.........

errrmmm wow.... here let me guess your list, and the rest of the communities at that (including my own to a certain degree)

General cookie cutter list for id say 90% of this forum and VC players alike
.....................................................................................................
Vampire Lord

Wight king with drakken hoff banner
(insert character here)
(insert character here)

X amount of Ghouls (in horde formation)
Ghast
X amount of Ghouls (in horde formation)
Ghast
X amount of Skeletons (5x?, bunker unit)
Standard Bearer(at least)

30+ Grave Guard
Great weapons
Banner of the Barrows

Black Coach/ 2 Varghulfs/ 3-5 wraiths

seeing the example of that italian players list is no different then the majority of the tactics and basic list composition you see in everyone elses, same boring tactic. ive done the blood knight deathstar, and its good, not the best, but good, you cant make it in any less then 2500 points tho.

..................................................................................................
as far as fluffytemplar's rant goes, the rules FAR from limit the fairness you can make your lists, look at my list in the legion of the damned section under "2800 points of pure suck it," as far as your "every unit is there for a reason" shpeal is non sense, our book was written in 7th edition, everything was useful last edition to a certain degree, i took everything, now its all to bloody expensive because their effects were nullified or units uses were nerfed, and the fact that you HAVE to spend 25% on core, and almost half of the buyable units in the core section dont count towards core. Lvl 4 fire wizard? i dont hear about anyone running one of those, if they do use your dispel dice wisely with the new magic system you have a good chance at a dispel. its all been mentioned before, Varghulfs are good but you should take 2, they arnt as good now that cannons will blow them to pieces easier and they cant break ranks, wraiths are still situational, NO ONE pays for spirit hosts, 95% percent im guesstimating doesnt use corpse carts because they are to bloody expensive and their bonuses all got nerfed, unholy lodestone isnt very good because of the less castings of IoN, balefire isnt very good because of high casting values, adding the wizard level, and being able to throw 6 dice at a spell with even a level 1 wizard, the bound spell sucks now too, yay ASF on skeletons, or strike at our amazing iniative 3 with great weapon grave guard. Wolves are bad, maybe 5 or 10 of them for fluff i guess but chances are they wont do anything. Now your last example is where I totally disagree, which makes me wonder how many games youve been playing 8th edition, 4 blood knights (with champion because you said challenge) is 240 points bare bones with a champion, and they will die pretty easily considering they have a 2+ armor save no ward, they will die.

im saying ghoul models are ugly, and dont make much sense to me fluff wise, and they dont carry banners. sure they are great in hand to hand, but again i dont like being forced into taking anything more then I have to, and taking 2 horde formations of ghouls seems rather gross to me, and cheesy. and to me a vampire count army should have a majority of skeletons.

and for the record, I love the drakkenhoff banner and never leave home without it, ghouls are a crutch imo if you are taking a majority of them. and if your taking alot your borderline cheeseball.

I take virtually the cookie cutter list above, but instead of ghouls i take skeletons, and only 2 units of them total and only minimum core.

as far as painting goes, my army is complete and show case worthy :vampire2:
 
Well said! the only reason i take grave guard is because i have little else to fill up my points in special currently (i am aiming at converting myself some fellbats and black knights.)

skeletons are too soft? take lore of metal on someone and then have a 40+ unit with the same armor as a chaos worrior and laugh as you res the damage they cause with a single IoN.

I also have had some wonders with spirit hosts/Winds of Undeath. to name one encounter, raised 3 wounds, placed them in front of a unit of bretonian archers serving as a level 4s bunker, vanhels'd it into the unit, caused 2 wounds, won the combat and charged them off the table. In the same game 2 bases held a unit of knights errant in place for 3 turns while i munched all the other units around.

my vargulf frequently devours significantly more than its own points (does a great job against monstrous infantry/cavalry i have found) as long as you arent a fool with it. And my unit of 5 blood knights (musician and standard) have slaughtered in my name on almost every occasion.

I have never taken the drakenhoff and never needed to, SuH will either restore the damage caused, or drain a ridiculous ammount of their dispell dice, which hands the rest of the magic phase over to you.

I have found in 8th edition, its far less about writing yourself a successful list and winning every game due to some mathhammer, and far more about adapting as the game goes and using successful strategy instead of just marching forward.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu