My philosophy: point to list comparison 8th edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
@Forge. I think we all have ran that list at some point. We may even go back to it now and then. I think what seperates VC players is whether or not they are willing to break from that list and do different things. And this isnt about owning the models, I understand if you dont own a particular unit, and where I play, it is acceptable to proxy in models for a unit before deciding to put in the effort to purchase and go into production for the unit. Now if you dont play in that sort of shop, that is a shame, maybe try to arrange a friendly game where you can explore some of the lesser used units and find ways to make them work in a list.

I regularly field the following units.

Lords
Mannfred
Vlad
(a TON of different combos for custom lords ranging from my solo "Scud Lord" to Mannfred wunnabe Lords)

BSBs
Hoff BSB KING (mounted and unmounted)
Blood Keep BSB KING
Hoff Thrall BSB (mounted and unmounted)

other Heroes
-Konrad
-Mannfred
Forbidden Lore Thralls
WKs who are not BSBs
Necros on Corpse Carts
necros not on Corpse Carts (often carrying that Staff of Damnation or a Dispell Scroll)
Thrall scouts (a whole thread about crap i have attempted to do with them)
Thralls on hellsteeds to hunt warmachines

Cores
Ghouls, ghouls, and more ghouls,
Skellie bunkers
skellie tar pits (HW&S)
zombies (groups of millions and by that i mean 50+)
corpse carts without necros

Specials
Graveguard GWs (burrows or strigos)
Graveguard HW&S (burrows or strigos)
Black Knights x5 (strigos or screaming)
Black Knights x10 (strigos or screaming)
Spirit Hosts x3 (typically)
Fel Bats x 3

Rares
blood knights x 5 (sometimes 6)
Varghulf (never ran two of em at the same time... maybe try that sometime soon)
Wights x 3 w/ Banshee (even ran two groups of 3 w/banshee)
Black Coach

So really, the only two units I can think of that i share your disdain for are the Dire Wolves and Bat Swarms. I didnt like the Dire Wolves that much when they were fast cav because they couldnt shoot, and they couldnt be used to bait opponent frenzied units in the same fashion that people tried baiting my Blood Knights. Neither of these units also count as core for points, so it is a bit harder to figure out how to use them when you are basically mandated to put x number of points of ghouls/skellies/zombies out there to start with. Short of those two units, I can safely say i have fielded everything else and found ways to win with them. It isnt always AS EASY as going with the cookie cutter list you presented, and from time to time to do use that list you presented, but I dont feel nearly as compelled to stick strictly to that list and because of it, my opponents cant anticpate and plan for what I may or may not do. That mind game i play has probably won me more battles than the units on the board. it screws with their battle strategy from terrain set up, deployment, and tactical movement.

If a tournament came up tomorrow, would i probably use that cookie cutter list... maybe with a few mods, because it is probably the "optimal" list, that i do agree, but i think saying anything outside of that list is "useless" is going a bit far.
 
Yeah, I don't understand what Bloodknights are going to do vs a Stank. I thought they were T10 now? Zombies are more effective; both autohit, both have the same chance of wounding (barring AS), both get wounded on a 2+ (although the bloodknights will have a 5+AS); you'll have a much bigger unit of zombies, and neither will likely wound or kill a Stank.

Well, hopefully the Warhammer Online game will be released to the general public and I can see how people are using these units I had stricken off the list.

Cavalry got a big time nerf. Direwolves could be useful, but only as a unit to place before committing other units IMO, or as a Dragontrap, even if they are less maneuverable.

All units are not useful. Batswarms sucked in 7th, and they still suck. Corpsecart took a huge hit, and while I don't think it's worth it, it's bound ability could be good on Vampires. Getting ASF on ghouls doesn't matter usually with the stepping up rule. If your opponent has an I value of less than 3 it'd help but other than that... on vamps, it'd basically give them all hatred, and help in challenges. Even for 75pts, might be worth it. I've been wanting to try it out in a list that has a Hybrid Lord with MotBA and a thrall with MotBA/Helm.

Anyways, I digress. In 7th, I found we had more options for interesting lists than 8th. Black Knights were great in 7th, direwolves were great, Skeletons and ghouls both had their place as Static CR was important, Corpse carts were useful... I don't see a useless unit in 7th that has been pushed into the useful realm in 8th. I only see the reverse.
 
holy cow... i better go smelt my pewter blood knights tonight for their inability to destory a steamtank. How dare they not destory a T10 model. They will charge in, annihilate, overrun and write the living wills of practically any other model from any other army but DAMN them for not doing in the steam tank.

i feel ripped off having purchased those metal models now. Why didnt i just convert up some Chaos Knights or slap a few extra GG shields that im not using to make some now useless black knights look like Blood Knights.

its like that time i bought that vacuum cleaner from the door to door salesman.

or maybe something like a steam tank (which is sort of Empires version of a dragon) is best left to rank n file troops like it always has been.

pretty sure that hasnt changed.

8th ed offers up alot of "chess like" balance that we didnt have before in 7th. Things like Dragons and Steamtanks are pretty tough cookies in Close Combat, but thats why they introduced the nasty vortex spells (I test or DIE Dragon!) Cavalry used to rule the roost and ride solo (i had a friend who filed an entire WoC army as cav, no foot models at all) and sure he couldnt run that list now, but it doesnt mean his Chaos Knights didnt hurt me a bit when he ran into the flank of my Graveguard who were busy fighting off some Mauraders.

8th edition is not mathhammer. There is alot more randomized rolls now. Winds of magic rolls helps keep the game from becomming Herohammer. Random charge ranges helps make infantry with faster models still have to have a bit of luck instead of being able to math out where to deploy to guarantee a charge for them. So its not Mathhammer anymore either.

What 8th edition has become for alot of armies is a test of your overall battle strategy. Like Lynks said earlier in the thread, its about adapting as the battle goes. Its about getting flank charges (forget disruption, if your flank charge with cavalry cant kill 4 dudes to make up that disruption, you are doing something wrong).

To win in 8th ed you need to fufill the following forumla.

1 - you need infantry models to create your battlelines and try to keep steadfast while removing steadfast from your enemy. VC is actually better at this than most armies. I include shooting here, because the biggest advantage of shooting is reducing enemy ranks prior to engaging in CC, so archer units/artillery help the infantry by giving them the Steadfast when battle first begins. (obviously for us, this is Skellies, Ghouls, Graveguard, and even Zombies)

2 - you need flank chargers to help swing that balance in your direction (more important for other armies than ours perhaps, but if a VC army gets to do this to an opponent who is already going to likely lose the Steadfast battle, its game over) (think Black Knights, Black Coach, Varghulfs, Blood Knights)

3 - You need swift models to successfully overrun or hunt down shooting/caster units. (Fel bats, Black Knights, varghulfs, even Dire Wolves possibly)

4 - Magic support - If you lack shooting (which we do) you can use offensive magic like i mentioned shooting above, thus to help get that steadfast when CC begins. You also can use magic to help counter big monsterous things like dragons, steamtanks and hellpit abominations with magical vortexes. If you got other units that can do this, your magic becomes a buff/debuff support or in our case, IoN and SuH to regrow troops.

So everything really falls into that battle scheme. If you approach your list from a mindset of "how am i going to fufill these roles in my army" you are giving yourself a chance to win no matter what you choose. After that, you need a good deployment and a little luck and a little somthing to keep your enemy on his toes (like a Staff of damnation or feedback scroll) to help turn the tide.
 
@Gladius: I was responding to Fluffy's post about using BloodKnights to down "Steg, or a hellcannon, or a Stank, or a hydra". Maybe you missed his post, or thought I was railing on Bloodknights for not destroying Stanks? I'm pointing out that against Stanks, use something else.
 
Gladius Rex said:
holy cow... i better go smelt my pewter blood knights tonight for their inability to destory a steamtank. How dare they not destory a T10 model. They will charge in, annihilate, overrun and write the living wills of practically any other model from any other army but DAMN them for not doing in the steam tank.

although I agree charging blood knights at a steam tank is a lost cause, I disagree a unit of 5 will run over a whole unit, maybe dent it, but then the blood knights will all die. even if you score all 15 of your attacks and all of them wound, he may kill a couple or none, he still has more ranks then you, and you cant break his ranks, yay steadfast generals leadership of 9 or so with a reroll from the BSB WIN.
 
See in your reply you still dont get it. I never run blood knights into ANYTHING alone. They are flank charger. You hit something with an infantry unit ( i dont care which, zombies even) then the same round or next round (depending on how good your deployment and luck is) you hit that unit in the side with your flank charging Blood Knights and its frickin over.

its synergy. There is a saying that "no man is an island" and in warhammer the saying should read "no unit is an army"

what is so hard to understand about that? There are still some units a blood knight unit can hit alone and be ok, but i think its well stated if you let your opponent have and keep his steadfast, you are going to lose I dont care what unit you are using.

If Blood Knights hit with all 16 attacks (cuz i never go anywhere without full command) and the horses even do half their hits, lets round down to 2 of the 5 and you wound on all of them, there isnt much of a unit left. Even a unit of 30 Chaos Warriors or Mauraders is going to be hurting if you hit them in the flank and they dont get their 5+ Tzneech parry save.

At the end of the day, you have to make your units work in unicen. You have to play as an army, not as a coalition of self sustaining units.

The game has evolved from Basketball, where one star can take over a game (that would be 7th ed) to Football, where your star running back doesnt go anywhere without a good offensive line in front of him and an adequate passing game to keep the defense honest.

its a team game now, every unit has to have a role and be able to perform it. Doesnt matter which army you are fielding, VC or otherwise.
 
Gladius Rex said:
See in your reply you still dont get it. I never run blood knights into ANYTHING alone. They are flank charger. You hit something with an infantry unit ( i dont care which, zombies even) then the same round or next round (depending on how good your deployment and luck is) you hit that unit in the side with your flank charging Blood Knights and its frickin over.

its synergy. There is a saying that "no man is an island" and in warhammer the saying should read "no unit is an army"

what is so hard to understand about that? There are still some units a blood knight unit can hit alone and be ok, but i think its well stated if you let your opponent have and keep his steadfast, you are going to lose I dont care what unit you are using.

If Blood Knights hit with all 16 attacks (cuz i never go anywhere without full command) and the horses even do half their hits, lets round down to 2 of the 5 and you wound on all of them, there isnt much of a unit left. Even a unit of 30 Chaos Warriors or Mauraders is going to be hurting if you hit them in the flank and they dont get their 5+ Tzneech parry save.

At the end of the day, you have to make your units work in unicen. You have to play as an army, not as a coalition of self sustaining units.

The game has evolved from Basketball, where one star can take over a game (that would be 7th ed) to Football, where your star running back doesnt go anywhere without a good offensive line in front of him and an adequate passing game to keep the defense honest.

its a team game now, every unit has to have a role and be able to perform it. Doesnt matter which army you are fielding, VC or otherwise.

sure, buts whats stopping your opponent or even coaxing him not to shoot/magic/blow up your 325 point + unit of blood knights that wont take more then a turn of cannon shots at them. you can get 25 Grave Guard with great weapons for the price of those blood knight and thats IF your not spending extra points on a magic banner. the grave guard will live to see another turn, arnt to much slower now because of random charge distances, have multiple ranks to break your opponents ranks, will have strength 6 in every round which is plenty, killing blow for killing characters ect. in the last edition more power to 5 man units of blood knights I ran them all the time because you could have screeners, cannons were guess range, magic wasnt rediculous, and blood knights if positioned right could function on their own.

blood knights are too many points and im sure most of the community will agree they leave them at home because we are forced to spend 25% on core, and because there are more important things to buy and or better things to buy.

Idk about you, but in all my games up to 2500 points, I would never be able to find the points to spare for a unit of 5 blood knights and my horde block of grave guard, at 2000 i have a hard time even getting the few characters I feel I need. for me I usually choose one or the other, and the grave guard always come on top because they live to see the end of the battle.
 
Forge said:
errrmmm wow.... here let me guess your list, and the rest of the communities at that (including my own to a certain degree)

General cookie cutter list for id say 90% of this forum and VC players alike
.....................................................................................................
Vampire Lord

Wight king with drakken hoff banner
(insert character here)
(insert character here)

X amount of Ghouls (in horde formation)
Ghast
X amount of Ghouls (in horde formation)
Ghast
X amount of Skeletons (5x?, bunker unit)
Standard Bearer(at least)

30+ Grave Guard
Great weapons
Banner of the Barrows

Black Coach/ 2 Varghulfs/ 3-5 wraiths

seeing the example of that italian players list is no different then the majority of the tactics and basic list composition you see in everyone elses, same boring tactic. ive done the blood knight deathstar, and its good, not the best, but good, you cant make it in any less then 2500 points tho.

No thats not my list haha.... In 3000 points I usually take very few characters, maybe a Lord, BSB, and Konrad, maybe one other magic user. I do take 2 Ghoul units & 1 Skeleton unit but its not a bunker (they take a 2nd flaming banner), as I've been using a hybrid lord with Light magic (So no Helm). Then I take 2 Grave Guard units because they're my favorite, then a Black Coach or no rares at all. Haha.... I've never used the same list twice either, I write them all in the same notebook with notes I take during/after the games and tweak things here & there. So I still don't get what your point is! I mean are we really on page 3 about why most everything in the VC book sucks & everybody plays the same list? I know this isn't commin from the guy that wrote a list with like 8 Wight Kings!!! Was that thinking outside the box? Haha... its crazy bro just have fun who cares I don't think anybody except Tomb Kings can really cry their book sucks you know cause its like 12 years old or whatever....
I don't know, maybe I'm just stupid I mean I've only been playin for bout 6 months now but damn I'm glad I found this shit out, it's a lotta fun & hopefully my "cookie cutter list" haha will wreak face this Saturday I'm goin to my 2nd tournament ever!!!!
 
Gladius Rex said:
See in your reply you still dont get it. I never run blood knights into ANYTHING alone. They are flank charger. You hit something with an infantry unit ( i dont care which, zombies even) then the same round or next round (depending on how good your deployment and luck is) you hit that unit in the side with your flank charging Blood Knights and its frickin over.

its synergy. There is a saying that "no man is an island" and in warhammer the saying should read "no unit is an army"

what is so hard to understand about that? There are still some units a blood knight unit can hit alone and be ok, but i think its well stated if you let your opponent have and keep his steadfast, you are going to lose I dont care what unit you are using.

If Blood Knights hit with all 16 attacks (cuz i never go anywhere without full command) and the horses even do half their hits, lets round down to 2 of the 5 and you wound on all of them, there isnt much of a unit left. Even a unit of 30 Chaos Warriors or Mauraders is going to be hurting if you hit them in the flank and they dont get their 5+ Tzneech parry save.

At the end of the day, you have to make your units work in unicen. You have to play as an army, not as a coalition of self sustaining units.

The game has evolved from Basketball, where one star can take over a game (that would be 7th ed) to Football, where your star running back doesnt go anywhere without a good offensive line in front of him and an adequate passing game to keep the defense honest.

its a team game now, every unit has to have a role and be able to perform it. Doesnt matter which army you are fielding, VC or otherwise.

Oh yes and I would NEVER charge blood knights into a Zombie combat they will crumble crumble.....
 
Astorre said:
Forge said:
errrmmm wow.... here let me guess your list, and the rest of the communities at that (including my own to a certain degree)

General cookie cutter list for id say 90% of this forum and VC players alike
.....................................................................................................
Vampire Lord

Wight king with drakken hoff banner
(insert character here)
(insert character here)

X amount of Ghouls (in horde formation)
Ghast
X amount of Ghouls (in horde formation)
Ghast
X amount of Skeletons (5x?, bunker unit)
Standard Bearer(at least)

30+ Grave Guard
Great weapons
Banner of the Barrows

Black Coach/ 2 Varghulfs/ 3-5 wraiths

seeing the example of that italian players list is no different then the majority of the tactics and basic list composition you see in everyone elses, same boring tactic. ive done the blood knight deathstar, and its good, not the best, but good, you cant make it in any less then 2500 points tho.

No thats not my list haha.... In 3000 points I usually take very few characters, maybe a Lord, BSB, and Konrad, maybe one other magic user. I do take 2 Ghoul units & 1 Skeleton unit but its not a bunker (they take a 2nd flaming banner), as I've been using a hybrid lord with Light magic (So no Helm). Then I take 2 Grave Guard units because they're my favorite, then a Black Coach or no rares at all. Haha.... I've never used the same list twice either, I write them all in the same notebook with notes I take during/after the games and tweak things here & there. So I still don't get what your point is! I mean are we really on page 3 about why most everything in the VC book sucks & everybody plays the same list? I know this isn't commin from the guy that wrote a list with like 8 Wight Kings!!! Was that thinking outside the box? Haha... its crazy bro just have fun who cares I don't think anybody except Tomb Kings can really cry their book sucks you know cause its like 12 years old or whatever....
I don't know, maybe I'm just stupid I mean I've only been playin for bout 6 months now but damn I'm glad I found this shit out, it's a lotta fun & hopefully my "cookie cutter list" haha will wreak face this Saturday I'm goin to my 2nd tournament ever!!!!

3000 points is a tottally different ball game, lists start changing around the 2500 mark. you will never see 2 grave guard units in 2000 points. ever. my list with 4 wight kings was a 2800 points game and i saw the opportunity to beef up my horrible skeletons, not taking the helm in even 2000 points let alone 3000 i think your handicapping your self as you take out a few grave guard and you can have it. but your list still doesnt seem that different to me then everyone elses, a couple horde units of ghouls, a smaller unit of skeletons, grave guard, wight king BSB with hoff banner, Vampire lord, and black coach. the only difference is you had the extra 500 or so points to splooge on another grave guard unit.

I never noticed the blood knights supporting zombies sentence, but boy oh boy is that the easiest way to kill your blood knights as you take 6 or 7 extra wounds due to unstable from 20 zombies dying. i would never try to support zombies, nor would i ever use them for support they are to easy to kill.
 
Zombies do die pretty quickly, that is true, but you are missing the forest because of the trees. I dont care what you are using to tar pit with, replace the word Zombie with Ghoul if you so please, thats not really the point I am making here.

If you want to say that Blood Knights are too expensive then dont run em, but then also stop complaining about not having options if you are going to "justify" yourself into that situation. I find Blood Knights to not be too expensive and i find them to laugh alot at cannons when they get a 4+ ward save due to their banner and typically a Thrall runs with them holding a Blood Drinker and I find they maintain pretty well while he is around.

Now if you want to doom and gloom yourself to only ever fielding grave gaurd, then so be it man. I just dont understand the purpose of complaining on the forums, getting responses from the community about other things you can try to mix it up, and then attempting to shoot every single one of them down - one by one - in some attempt to what? Get us to agree with you? Alot of us are fielding different stuff and telling you about it, tell you when and how it did work or how you can attempt to get them to work as intended and you just want to keep denying it all.

We didnt come to you, ask you for your list, and are complaining to you about it... you came to us.

I guess I dont understand what it is your on the forum seeking?

We are here to offer help and suggestions... why resist it?
 
Gladius Rex said:
Zombies do die pretty quickly, that is true, but you are missing the forest because of the trees. I dont care what you are using to tar pit with, replace the word Zombie with Ghoul if you so please, thats not really the point I am making here.

If you want to say that Blood Knights are too expensive then dont run em, but then also stop complaining about not having options if you are going to "justify" yourself into that situation. I find Blood Knights to not be too expensive and i find them to laugh alot at cannons when they get a 4+ ward save due to their banner and typically a Thrall runs with them holding a Blood Drinker and I find they maintain pretty well while he is around.

Now if you want to doom and gloom yourself to only ever fielding grave gaurd, then so be it man. I just dont understand the purpose of complaining on the forums, getting responses from the community about other things you can try to mix it up, and then attempting to shoot every single one of them down - one by one - in some attempt to what? Get us to agree with you? Alot of us are fielding different stuff and telling you about it, tell you when and how it did work or how you can attempt to get them to work as intended and you just want to keep denying it all.

We didnt come to you, ask you for your list, and are complaining to you about it... you came to us.

I guess I dont understand what it is your on the forum seeking?

We are here to offer help and suggestions... why resist it?

we are having a discussion about what works and what doesnt, and yes you most certainly did come to me, no one asked you to post in the topic, and by your words it feels like you are trying (key word trying) to speakon behalf of the entire community.

If you want to dump 600 points on a unit (5 Blood knights, ridiculous banners, vampire with dread knight, infinite hatred, blood drinker ect) that doesnt even offer look out sirs, and can be wiped by 2 cannons so be it.

how you come to a conclusion that this works idk, maybe you dont play against empire, dwarfs, high elfs, wood elfs, skaven, ect. sounds like a serious points dump for something so squishy, when you could have 40+ grave guard in their stead or allocate those huge point values over the rest of your army.

but hey what do I know right?
 
Mate, I play against Empire all the time and I have NEVER had a unit of Blood Knights wiped out by 2 cannon shots.......EVER!!!

And I have never taken 40+ GG, the most I have ever taken is 28 plus a Lord and a WK. Grow some balls and take something different for a change, I think thats all they're trying to say!

BTW do you need a tissue so you can go have a cry in the corner?
 
Darius the Insane said:
Mate, I play against Empire all the time and I have NEVER had a unit of Blood Knights wiped out by 2 cannon shots.......EVER!!!

And I have never taken 40+ GG, the most I have ever taken is 28 plus a Lord and a WK. Grow some balls and take something different for a change, I think thats all they're trying to say!

BTW do you need a tissue so you can go have a cry in the corner?

Hey, you can take all zombies for all I care, and you saying their good wont make them good, same case with 5 blood knights. one cannon shot on average if placed right will hit your character and a blood knight, if you think that 4+ ward will save you your sadly mistaken unless your very lucky.

I only take 29 grave guard and my BSB, you use the EXACT same crap as me, I CHALLENGE you to make a list with 600 point unit of blood knights and character and your grave guard in 2000-2500

or you can just take your 5 man blood knight unit and no grave guard and win either way i guess.

if your opponent wants to kill 5 blood knights in a turn, generally im sure that will happen, with all the rediculous spells, war machines ect.

tell me how you play differently! enlighten me please, im sure you take near minimum core (1-2 units of ghouls, 1 skeleton unit), grave guard, wight king bsb with hoff banner, VL combat or magic based doesnt matter, and your VL with helm of commandment or a thrall. i want to know what makes your list radically different. I want to know because your trying to flame me and tell me to be different when you use the exact same crap as everyone else, If anything im set apart I dont use any ghouls at all, all skeletons, but thats a matter of taste and doesnt really change the core values of what VC armies do now, one central unit, 99% of the time being grave guard in normal point values.
 
I'm sorry, once again..........do you need a tissue?

There's probably no point because it doesn't matter what is said to you, you are obviously to stubborn to actually hear and register what is trying to be said to you. But here goes............

Hey, you can take all zombies for all I care, and you saying their good wont make them good, same case with 5 blood knights. one cannon shot on average if placed right will hit your character and a blood knight, if you think that 4+ ward will save you your sadly mistaken unless your very lucky.

I never said zombies were good, I personally do not like them and do not rate them highly at all. EVERYTHING in this game has become situational, Blood Knights included. Also the vamp will get a look out sir and then bring the other 1 or 2 back with Blood Drinker lol I don't take the BK deathstar often but when I have it has always been there at the end of the game. Part strategy, part deployment and part luck. Same as anything.

tell me how you play differently! enlighten me please, im sure you take near minimum core, grave guard, wight king bsb with hoff banner, VL combat or magic based doesnt matter, and your VL with helm of commandment or a thrall. i want to know what makes your list radically different. I want to know because your trying to flame me and tell me to be different when you use the exact same crap as everyone else, If anything im set apart I dont use any ghouls at all, all skeletons.

I generally take 35% core, half and half, ghouls and skellies. 3 characters, sometimes WK BSB with Drakenhof, sometimes not, sometimes Konrad, sometimes custom vamp. Generally take a combat lord and I have NEVER taken the HoC, I believe in the fluff, that a Vampire should be in the midst of battle killing as many things as possible!

But regardless of all of this, thats not my point, my point is that I am not afraid to change things up and have a bit of fun with my army lists. That is, after all, what this game is meant to be all about. Like I said at the start of this thread, you and I have EXTREMELY different battle ethics and i can assure you, I DO NOT TAKE THE EXACT SAME CRAP AS EVERYBODY ELSE!!

Just my opinion.
 
Why wouldnt we take grave guard? xD It´s one of our best units and I dont care how boring it is, it works. I use ghouls, GG, hoff banner, casty lord and all that, but I´ve still had problems winning the games I play. Either im playing a better opponent or his crap is better than mine xD.

I´ve started to try out different lord builds, right now its a lord casting lore of death with plenty of protection so he can be where the fighting is thickest. I soon realised that I had to create an army around him, a thrall will the helm and those useful spells from our own lore that I need. I´ve been advocating less characters and more troops, but since it hasnt worked out for me I´ve changed my approach.

All our meta games are so different so while 5 blood knights can work for somebody it can be a total waste of points for another. No need to be hostile about that xD. I´ve seen lists that looked very out of place (small units, fell bats, wolves etc) and thought "that cant do any good", but it depends on your playstyle aswell, for the list creator it obviously worked great! Pick whatever units you will and be happy about it, as long as you enjoy playing the list. VC´s took a hit in this edition, but I have nothing against a more underdog role instead of hearing "you won because of a broken armies book".

Lighten up guys :).
 
@ Forge - You started this thread with a complaint - that is an open invitation for people to respond with options to help you out of your rut. I think that is all alot of people are trying to do here. I can totally understand if the metagame is different for you and I, that is all well and good, but at the end of the day... you arent going to adapt your playstyle to accomidate other units and frankly then... there is little anyone can do on here to help you with that.

The armies represented at my game shop are as follows Dwarves, Empire, Brettonia, High Elf, Dark Elf, Warriors of Chaos, Orcs N Goblins, Demons (Nurgle), and Skaven. Occasionally... the HE guy will proxy his models to be Wood Elves... but i havent seen that since 8th ed happened lol.

So its not like I dont see these things you speak of. I have never had more than 1 Blood Knight die from a particular cannon shot. I typically try not to give a cannon or a bolt thrower for that matter my flank so it can hit more than one. When one dies, i typically can get a SUH or ION off to regrow the 1 wound on the Hero or Knight needed to keep them going. Anything short of artillery typically doesnt touch them that much.

maybe I am just lucky - i dont know?

I dont think anyone is arguing that Grave Guard are not worth the point investment. We are all aware of how good you can make a grave guard unit and how much those units cost. Can you field a second unit of Graveguard for the Price of a unit of 10 Black Knights or 6 Blood Knights. Sure, noone is stopping you. Does the Graveguard have some advantages. Sure. Do the mounted Knights have some advantage? Sure. You can get Str 6 KB on both units, but the Graveguard end up 5+ armour whereas the Black Knights end up 2+ armour. Graveguard fielded 5x? get you 11 attacks. Black Knights in a block of 10 will get you 11 attacks plus the admittedly abysmal Skeletal Steed attacks (if they are really even worth bringing up). Knights can move through terrain, making them easier to get into the flank without the aid of PD and VdM. They also have a higher move value and can charge from further away. The Graveguard grant look out sir protection and gain more regrowth from an IoN spell.

So yeah, you can go back and forth. Ive had infantry attempt to get into the flank and fail where Black Knights or Blood Knights would have probably made it. Ive had terrain end up being an issue and wished i had that ethereal movement.

Noone is calling you crazy for liking Grave Guard. Noone is calling you crazy for liking Skeletons over ghouls. Skeletons are great against higher Str models (they do just fine for me when having to tar pit HE White Lions).

You just seem upset by the fact that you feel limited in choices. Maybe I am misreading your posts?
 
I find that building one particular kind of vampire is a good way to get killed. My 'caster' vampires tend to be Forbidden Lore (light) and Dark acolyte, with Infinite hatred. Insert random armor here, something to give him a good ward, and then some weapon, usually blood drinker though. Why waste points holding back? Your paying for a vampire who can tear most people apart with his bare hands, hes got the best stats for a lord other then a Chaos lord... Why not sink those into combat? Helm of command is good and all... And its great against small elite armies where you dont need to worry about being outnumbered or having something hit you. But that bunker dies easily to 13th spell or any other of the rediculous spells out there. The only real defense against the 'super spells' is to be in close combat. In the last 4-5 games ive played, i have never had my lord die, even up against the doom bull deathstar or horded Bloodletters with herald. Build him to last, and be careful, and let him go to town.

Secondly, Ghouls/skeletons depends entirely on who your playing against, and what their usual strength is. If you play against people with strength three or less, then ghouls are easily king, because they throw out alot of damage, and you will win combat. Now, but with deep skeleton formations against people, you will find that while you loose quite a few a turn, you do not go anywhere. Your static combat res will allow you to stand there, and just absorb casualties, whittling them down as you do it. Now what happens when they whiff the attacks they need? Alot of people go short and narrow to maximize combat efficiency, but eventually their dice give out, and they wont win a combat. 5-6 Res that they cant touch. that means, on average, with just a banner: 4 kills to TIE combat. Any kills you score by sheer luck increase that further. 50 Skeletons, 5x10 with a war banner, hw+s will tie up or stop almost anything... A tarpit that if you roll right, will WIN COMBAT.

As for playing differently to get the lesser used units to work, that is a given. You play differently if you run hordes of ghouls and GG then if you run any other list. Tactics change depending on the terrain and what you bring to a table. Skeleton blocks wont win a lot of combats, but skeleton blobs that a Coach just aided with a flank charge will win, and will break someone, easily. Your deeper then they can manage, and most opponents cant touch the coach, which makes it free combat res. Nearly any combination WILL work, if you plan to have it do that. I play to advance right into the teeth of my opponent, relying on numbers to get me there. Any of the light spells i get off either equalize the fight, or make me ahead. Speed of light, and suddenly skeletons or ghouls are BETTER then anything on the table, with most people needing 5s to hit, 6s if you get pha's protection off.

I guess what im trying to say is: Be creative... Cookie cutter lists make babies cry, we all know that. You can win with other combination then "OMG GG GHOUL SPAM CASTER LORD BUNKER.....". Notice all the people who win with VC dont do that anymore? if everyone spams 'the best build' then soon other people take that into account and know whats coming, then boom, youve lost because they know exactly how to stop your combos from working. Do things people dont expect, dont go 'oh, insta win combo...' Those NEVER WORK. a SMART opponent knows to see something coming. "Optimized' builds is BULLSHIT. We have a game, based entirely on randomization and PEOPLE. Two things that are IMPOSSIBLE to know for sure whats going to happen. Randomization only matters if your throwing 120+ dice at something, like Imperial Guard for 40k, in which case the statistics will eventually carry the day, due to numbers. Be prepared to wiff those attacks. Be prepared for your opponent to know your book better then you do. All the people in my gaming area KNOW the optimized builds, and take that into acount when they will be playing me. But they are allways wrong, because i bring weird or new things each time, and they are allways smiling and shaking their heads as my skeletons run down their minotaurs, or i charge vampires out of my units and at his skirmishers that he put in front of me, run them off, then run back into my unit next turn.

Be Original. Be creative. Dont turn this into Magic the gathering, where everyone plays 1/12 different types of decks, with practically no variation.
 
Darius the Insane said:
I'm sorry, once again..........do you need a tissue?

There's probably no point because it doesn't matter what is said to you, you are obviously to stubborn to actually hear and register what is trying to be said to you. But here goes............

Hey, you can take all zombies for all I care, and you saying their good wont make them good, same case with 5 blood knights. one cannon shot on average if placed right will hit your character and a blood knight, if you think that 4+ ward will save you your sadly mistaken unless your very lucky.

I never said zombies were good, I personally do not like them and do not rate them highly at all. EVERYTHING in this game has become situational, Blood Knights included. Also the vamp will get a look out sir and then bring the other 1 or 2 back with Blood Drinker lol I don't take the BK deathstar often but when I have it has always been there at the end of the game. Part strategy, part deployment and part luck. Same as anything.

tell me how you play differently! enlighten me please, im sure you take near minimum core, grave guard, wight king bsb with hoff banner, VL combat or magic based doesnt matter, and your VL with helm of commandment or a thrall. i want to know what makes your list radically different. I want to know because your trying to flame me and tell me to be different when you use the exact same crap as everyone else, If anything im set apart I dont use any ghouls at all, all skeletons.

I generally take 35% core, half and half, ghouls and skellies. 3 characters, sometimes WK BSB with Drakenhof, sometimes not, sometimes Konrad, sometimes custom vamp. Generally take a combat lord and I have NEVER taken the HoC, I believe in the fluff, that a Vampire should be in the midst of battle killing as many things as possible!

But regardless of all of this, thats not my point, my point is that I am not afraid to change things up and have a bit of fun with my army lists. That is, after all, what this game is meant to be all about. Like I said at the start of this thread, you and I have EXTREMELY different battle ethics and i can assure you, I DO NOT TAKE THE EXACT SAME CRAP AS EVERYBODY ELSE!!

Just my opinion.

No the vampire does not get look out sir, you have 2 rank and file models you need 5.

so you do not take grave guard? all skeletons ghouls and a 5 man unit of blood knights, no helm of commandment? interesting....
 
Forge said:
so you do not take grave guard? all skeletons ghouls and a 5 man unit of blood knights, no helm of commandment? interesting....

I normally run 10 blood knight plus vamp plus wk lol its the deathstar I mentioned. I don't always take that and I don't always take GG, sometimes I don't take either. Correct, no HoC, its not part of my fluff.

Regardless, my point is, much like everybody else's (especially Mortus, kudos on your post) you do not have to take the same old same old. Diversify, experiment, take an 'underdog' army, don't be afraid to change things up and know that if you can keep your 85% win margin intact (I think thats what you said?), then you will know that you are a better General than your opponent. Instead of the guy who can write OP, broken and BORING army lists.
 
I will NEVER run Grave Guard or Blood Knights. I don't run a special, I go core with max lordy thrall and Rare choices ignoring Special completely, I win a fair amount of my games. I know it's not necessary to win.
 
Blood knights are rare not special friend.

And a question for Mortus: how does a 5X10 unit move O.O? Just a slight wheel would eat up a good chunk of movement.
 
Darius the Insane said:
Instead of the guy who can write OP, broken and BORING army lists.

Though for some gamers that is a part of the fun. Churn out the maximum of a particular army.

Personally I am fine with either way as long as I know what kind of opponent I am facing. This isn't just when I show up with a fluff/experimental list but also for the sake of my opponent who might not appreciate at all facing this kind of lists(perhaps is trying out his lists for a tournament or so).

There's no right way to play this game. All you can do is gather up a collection of like-minded people and have a good time playing the game you all enjoy.
 
Dklyn said:
Blood knights are rare not special friend.

And a question for Mortus: how does a 5X10 unit move O.O? Just a slight wheel would eat up a good chunk of movement.


Oh I'm not running them not because they aren't rare, I'm not running them because i don't like how they looks :s All about flair!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu