My philosophy: point to list comparison 8th edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
@ Forge.

I guess the people I play with just suck... *shrug*... I mean, they dont get alot of choice in the angle, i determine that when i angle my anvil unit. They either gotta charge me, or set their angle and be charged. Unlike VC... they dont regrow troops so easily and are often not unbreakable... so they tend to like to get their charge in and when they "shut the door" the end up at the angle I want them.

since the people I play with are highly intelligent and have played alot longer than I have been and frequenly place well in the local tournaments, i will assume they are pretty good.
 
Gladius Rex said:
The feedback scroll doesnt dispel. The Wizard gets his spell of successfully, the Feedback Scroll just makes him roll every die he used to wound himself. Thats why it still works. Since the Feedback scroll states that the spell succeeds, i think it is still within the rules. Now a true dispel scroll, you are correct, I couldnt use.

nope, the FAQ over-rides all those scrolls due to the first paragraph of their rules;
"whan an enemy spell is cast, a wizard who has a (insert scroll) can read it instead of attempting to dispel the spell..."

an IF cancels out any kind of dispel attempt/s, thus those other scrolls are useless!

still, the feedback scroll is a nice little item to hang onto with say a necro since an opponent won't always get IF, even when they are throwing 6 dice at the attempt.
but it doesn't stop that silly power scroll sadly... although, it seems that most tournaments which incorperate a composition score are banning the power scroll outright!

cheers!
 
I guess that is an interesting point. Good catch. Will take that into mind when i next think about using one of those scrolls.
 
So i checked in on the FAQ and i see what you are talking about. When my game group read through the FAQ, we had not associated all the other various scrolls with this rules, just the Dispell scroll. Reason being that the other scrolls ilke Leeching and Feedback say "after the spell is resolved" thus we did not assume them as part of the dispell phase, but i see the distinction you are shooting for here. Will definitely pass this along to the other guys.

Makes me feel like the feedback scroll should cost less then... but oh well, probably still useful since nobody wants to just cast their purple sun one time lol.

thanks for the tip Anubis.
 
Dklyn said:
Mortus946736 said:
It doesnt eat up any more wheeling then any other 5 wide base... Exactly the same

Am I going crazy? I'm pretty sure it does... but it's been a while since I studied anything like that. My thinking: No model can move more than twice the movement and the models in the back I'm pretty sure will be moving more if in a longer unit for the same angle. When you wheel you "immobilize" one of the front corners (treating it as a spoke of a wheel) and the furthermost model is like the outside rim of the wheel right (which I think in units greater than 5x5 is the back corner)?

It's like comparing a car tire to a tricycle right? If they both rotate the same angle, the car tire will go further...?

Seeing as noone posted the correct response to this...

The maximum distance moved by any model while wheeling a unit which is 5x10 is exactly the same as if the unit was 10x5 (horde formation) and wheeled through the same angle. In both cases (actually in every case with a rectangular formation) it is the model diagonally opposite the pivot point which moves the furthest.
A quick-and-dirty bit of calculation for the 5x10 formation gives us the outside model moving around 12x it's base width for a wheel of 45 degrees.
 
Gladius Rex said:
@ Forge.

I guess the people I play with just suck... *shrug*... I mean, they dont get alot of choice in the angle, i determine that when i angle my anvil unit. They either gotta charge me, or set their angle and be charged. Unlike VC... they dont regrow troops so easily and are often not unbreakable... so they tend to like to get their charge in and when they "shut the door" the end up at the angle I want them.

since the people I play with are highly intelligent and have played alot longer than I have been and frequenly place well in the local tournaments, i will assume they are pretty good.

Id rather take a charge on my terms, leaving him open for a flank charge by one of my units on the flank, then charge my opponent and leave my flank wide open, you only get +1 combat resolution from charging now anyways no other bonuses its not a big deal, anyone who lets you charge their flank un contested by something that is known to obliterate his unit should rethink his strategy.
 
I agree forge, I do the same thing, but with VdM, my opponent knows that typically i am more maneuverable and even though they are going to have more shooting than I, they know if they want to defeat me they gotta get into close combat and they know that I am more than content with using magic to regrow lost troops from shooting and also to unleash a little offensive magic their way.

I mean, if you were WoC... would you really sit 8 inches away from a block of ghouls with your block of Tzneech Warriors or Khorne Mauraders who sole job it is to get into combat and just "wait it out" while your VC opponent launches magic missles at you and regrows whatever troops you are able to take out with the Hellcannon?

It is sort of deciding which is the lesser of evils.

I play a nurgle Demon player who presented me with the same problem as I presented him. We both ended up in a stand off, 4 whole rounds of toying and positioning, both trying to get the other to make a move. Rounds 5 and 6 we finally ended up with a daisy chain of charges ( i think both of us ended with flank charges) so then it turned into a two round brawl after a 4 round magic missle fest.

game ended in a draw, but it was his first time seeing VC and my first time seeing Nurgle Demons, so we were both treading lightly. Now that i know how they work, and when we have played each other since, I have to adjust my tactics against him, because like us, they are also unbreakable.

In a situation like that, I would gladly run my ghouls and my Blood Knights into the front of that enemy and make him face a blender of ghoul poison attacks and BK lances. The ghouls are easier to wound, so most likely he will attack at them when possible.

but aside from another unbreakable army who doesnt have to worry about steadfast, most armies cannot afford to sit back and wait forever like VC can.
 
@forge
Equip the 4 blood knights with the flag of blood keep, they're no longer a bulls eye for enemy missile fire and they provide better offensive power than your standard 400 point graveguard unit w/ banner of the burrows. They're not as susceptable to enemy return fire as you make them out to be, as 1. they can potentially destroy small, elite units in a single round of attacking and 2. their T4 and 2+ armour save makes it very hard for S3 enemies to hurt them. Basically it's a cheap way of doing lots of damage, you just have to choose your targets carefully.

Black knights are still useful, just not as a straight up combat unit. Use them to charge the watchtower first turn, thin out the garrison so that your infantry block can wipe it out in a single turn once it arrives. Use them as war machine hunters, character assassins, or monster hunters. You mentioned this already, but bodyguard for a mounted lord that wants to get into combat ASAP.

Wraiths are decent against all armies, even daemons. Against mundane weapons, use them as roadblocks or unit killers. Against magical weapons, pick small units, cast VHD and watch as no return attacks are made.

Fell bats = war machine hunters. A bit redundant given our other more versatile options, but they're there and they're effective.

Skeletons aren't inferior to ghouls. Ghouls may do twice as much damage, but skeletons are only doing 1 wound or so per turn so double damage doesn't mean much here. Skeletons get banners, useful in B&G, they also get musicians, which lets them see more combat, useful for a character escort. Best of all is the 6+ wardsave, they double as a tarpit should any high strength enemies come your way.

Zombies: useful for watchtower scenario, deploy 20 in watch tower, its cheap and they're unlikely to die in one turns combat. You can raise extras without Master powers and possibly hold until your better infantry reaches the tower.

Dire wolves are useful for extending your deployment options and delaying scary enemies for a turn.

Bat swarms and corpse cart: I agree they aren't worth taking.

As for all lists being the same... well you were shown that Italian players list earlier in the thread and his wasn't too generic. His lord was dealing 10 strength 8 attacks per turn, while not the most inspired strategy it's also not the most common. And just looking around this forum I see every unit utilized except for bat swarms. I wouldn't say your options are limited, it's just that your idea of strategy is narrow and extends no further than the list building phase; you're judging units by how well they'll clobber other units, and you disregard other most subtle advantages, so of course the superior tactical potential of black knights and fell bats will be lost on you.
 
holla: Good post, I agree with most of it(still don't like zombies). I especially agree on Skeletons, when picking ghouls I tend find myself struggling to mainting a solid number of banners. Ghouls were 'the choice' in 7th. Not so much in 8th(I've yet to be impressed by horde formation ghouls). One must not forget the access to magical banners either.

Your last point, I wholly agree.

Cheers, D.
 
holla holla get dolla said:
@forge
Equip the 4 blood knights with the flag of blood keep, they're no longer a bulls eye for enemy missile fire and they provide better offensive power than your standard 400 point graveguard unit w/ banner of the burrows. They're not as susceptable to enemy return fire as you make them out to be, as 1. they can potentially destroy small, elite units in a single round of attacking and 2. their T4 and 2+ armour save makes it very hard for S3 enemies to hurt them. Basically it's a cheap way of doing lots of damage, you just have to choose your targets carefully.

Black knights are still useful, just not as a straight up combat unit. Use them to charge the watchtower first turn, thin out the garrison so that your infantry block can wipe it out in a single turn once it arrives. Use them as war machine hunters, character assassins, or monster hunters. You mentioned this already, but bodyguard for a mounted lord that wants to get into combat ASAP.

Wraiths are decent against all armies, even daemons. Against mundane weapons, use them as roadblocks or unit killers. Against magical weapons, pick small units, cast VHD and watch as no return attacks are made.

Fell bats = war machine hunters. A bit redundant given our other more versatile options, but they're there and they're effective.

Skeletons aren't inferior to ghouls. Ghouls may do twice as much damage, but skeletons are only doing 1 wound or so per turn so double damage doesn't mean much here. Skeletons get banners, useful in B&G, they also get musicians, which lets them see more combat, useful for a character escort. Best of all is the 6+ wardsave, they double as a tarpit should any high strength enemies come your way.

Zombies: useful for watchtower scenario, deploy 20 in watch tower, its cheap and they're unlikely to die in one turns combat. You can raise extras without Master powers and possibly hold until your better infantry reaches the tower.

Dire wolves are useful for extending your deployment options and delaying scary enemies for a turn.

Bat swarms and corpse cart: I agree they aren't worth taking.

As for all lists being the same... well you were shown that Italian players list earlier in the thread and his wasn't too generic. His lord was dealing 10 strength 8 attacks per turn, while not the most inspired strategy it's also not the most common. And just looking around this forum I see every unit utilized except for bat swarms. I wouldn't say your options are limited, it's just that your idea of strategy is narrow and extends no further than the list building phase; you're judging units by how well they'll clobber other units, and you disregard other most subtle advantages, so of course the superior tactical potential of black knights and fell bats will be lost on you.

I disagree with your first paragraph, they are by no means cheaper, nor are they more efficient killing wise, and most certainly are not more survivable and easy to keep maintained

4 blood knights with just a standard and blood keep banner is 315 points

eww, ever heard of a strategy called "dice on target" that unit will most likely die out in one turn, if not you will be spending most of your magic phase if not all of it raising back a few of their dead.

I never said black knights weren't useful, but Id rather spend my points on something else, they are to expensive.

Disagree with your 3rd paragraph, wraiths are situational at best, and no they are not good against deamons...... at all LOL

Skeletons are inferior in the fact that there are more strength 5 attacks being thrown out these days, the added toughness of ghouls along with the weapon skill is much more favorable against MOST units you will encounter. Minded I still only use skeletons for fluff and aesthetics reasons.

As far as your last paragraph goes, you obviously didnt read the thread. Characters usually change, units do not, the italian players list is nothing different unit wise then everyone elses lists.

ive played with fell bats, and they never do anything, and most certainly never make their points back, if they were half the cost i would take them. Black knights need to be babied to work, and even then they lost what they once were, I used to always run them.
 
"I disagree with your first paragraph, they are by no means cheaper, nor are they more efficient killing wise, and most certainly are not more survivable and easy to keep maintained"

Oh but blood knights definately are cheaper, you say so yourself they're a mere 315 points where as your standard graveguard regiment is 400-625 depending on whether they have the drakenhoff banner. Killing wise, they have 12 strength 7 attacks and 4 strength 4 attacks - your standard graveguard unit has only 10-12 strength 6 attacks. These are facts not opinions, you can't argue with them :)

"eww, ever heard of a strategy called "dice on target" that unit will most likely die out in one turn, if not you will be spending most of your magic phase if not all of it raising back a few of their dead."

Their superior mobility allows them to choose targets more easily than graveguard, send them to attack strength 3 infantry they will only suffer 0.2475 wounds per turn - half that if they attack the flank and avoid supporting attacks :)

"Disagree with your 3rd paragraph, wraiths are situational at best, and no they are not good against deamons...... at all LOL"

What is bad about the 15 strength 5 attacks a 250 point wraith unit deals out? Again it's cheaper and better offensively than a graveguard unit. If they're vulnerable to magic, be creative *shrug*

"As far as your last paragraph goes, you obviously didnt read the thread. Characters usually change, units do not"

If this were true I wouldn't see different builds all over the army lists section of this forum ;)
 
the trouble with wraiths against daemons is they all have magical attacks and high initiative, while you have great weapons, toughness 3 and no armour. Your entire unit will be dead before they lift their blades.
 
holla holla get dolla said:
Hence why you should be creative ;)

i mean you can wave your hands in the air, make some paper mache, or say open seseme seed, and be as creative as you want, its not going to make wraiths any better, ESPECIALLY against deamons.

holla holla get dolla said:
"I disagree with your first paragraph, they are by no means cheaper, nor are they more efficient killing wise, and most certainly are not more survivable and easy to keep maintained"

Oh but blood knights definately are cheaper, you say so yourself they're a mere 315 points where as your standard graveguard regiment is 400-625 depending on whether they have the drakenhoff banner. Killing wise, they have 12 strength 7 attacks and 4 strength 4 attacks - your standard graveguard unit has only 10-12 strength 6 attacks. These are facts not opinions, you can't argue with them smile

first off i count 21 strength 6 return attacks hitting on 2's with killing blow, the ability to break ranks, the ability to face anything and not worry about high strength attacks, and actual static combat resolution, a unit that is able to take multiple templates, cannons, and magic damage and still be left standing, and a unit that responds fully to IoN rather then a 1 wound maximum. even without the drakkenhoff banner the grave guard still come out on top numbers wise (which is what your arguing with me about right?)

holla holla get dolla said:
What is bad about the 15 strength 5 attacks a 250 point wraith unit deals out? Again it's cheaper and better offensively than a graveguard unit. If they're vulnerable to magic, be creative *shrug*

thats where you start to confuse me when your trying to play math hammer and totally failing.

15 strength 5 attacks at WS3 (probably hitting on 4's) is no where as close to good as grave guard hitting with 21 attacks hitting on a minimum of 3+ (assuming WS6 and lower enemies) with strength 6 killing blow attacks.



holla holla get dolla said:
"As far as your last paragraph goes, you obviously didnt read the thread. Characters usually change, units do not"

If this were true I wouldn't see different builds all over the army lists section of this forum wink

VERY few of them are radically different,

ghouls and grave guard
 
i mean you can wave your hands in the air, make some paper mache, or say open seseme seed, and be as creative as you want, its not going to make wraiths any better, ESPECIALLY against deamons.

And you can state this without berating another member of the board for having a different opinion.

Could have just said, the high inititiave value and magic attacks of daemons makes Wraiths a sub-par choice, probably worse than that even. Even so, resorting to sarcastic remarks like above is just unnessecary and only serves to make these arguments personal which detracts from the actual discussion. That said, I think you are right. Wraiths are a bad choice against daemons but good versus almost every other army.

Most lists are infact built up on ghouls and grave guard. This isn't unique to VC. Gors and Bestigors are also popular core/special choices where ungors are being used in a similiar manner to our skeletons. 8th ed loves its infantry units.
 
"first off i count 21 strength 6 return attacks hitting on 2's with killing blow"

But that is not your standard grave guard unit ;) If you're running them as horde, you're probably using atleast 35 or so, and if they're hitting on 2's that means you're using both the crown of command and banner of the barrows. That unit costs 500 points, the vampire lending his weapon skill costs 135, the wight king with his drakenhoff is 225 and if you're still casting invocation of nehek even after all those buffs, I'd guess the magic being used to do that is worth another 25-50 points. In the end you're spending a huge amount of points on an unwieldy unit. That unit has it's merits, but it runs the risk of being nuked by purple sun, being tied up by skaven slaves, etc.. Fact is if you're looking for a strong offensive unit, our rare choices are more cost effective, and if you're looking for a defensive unit, why not give the drakenhoff banner to the 500 points of core that you dismiss as useless? If you put more than minimal effort into your core I'm sure you could find some use for them :)

"15 strength 5 attacks at WS3 (probably hitting on 4's) is no where as close to good as grave guard"

They're more cost efficient when it comes to points spent vs. wounds caused, is what I mean.

"VERY few of them are radically different,"

Out of the first 5 relevant lists in the army lists section I have found these ones were different from the standard list you describe:

https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-2000pt-Tournament-List-Heavy-Magic

This one includes dire wolves and uses skeletons instead of ghouls :)

https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-2500-point-strigoi-themed-armylist

This one makes use of dire wolves, bat swarms, fell bats, black knights, and completely forgoes grave guard ;)

https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-3-2k-Lahmian-theme-for-local-League

This one utilizes blood knights, fell bats, and uses skeletons instead of ghouls for core ;)

"Could have just said, the high inititiave value and magic attacks of daemons makes Wraiths a sub-par choice"

Actually what I was trying to say is that you can make the best of bad situations, not that wraiths were a good choice against Daemons. Even though wraiths are fragile against magically inclined armies, they can still pack a decent punch and perhaps make back 2/3rds of their points ;) I would not say they're worthless simply because they're sub-par against 2 or 3 out of 14 armies :)
 
holla holla get dolla said:
"first off i count 21 strength 6 return attacks hitting on 2's with killing blow"

But that is not your standard grave guard unit ;) If you're running them as horde, you're probably using atleast 35 or so, and if they're hitting on 2's that means you're using both the crown of command and banner of the barrows. That unit costs 500 points, the vampire lending his weapon skill costs 135, the wight king with his drakenhoff is 225 and if you're still casting invocation of nehek even after all those buffs, I'd guess the magic being used to do that is worth another 25-50 points. In the end you're spending a huge amount of points on an unwieldy unit. That unit has it's merits, but it runs the risk of being nuked by purple sun, being tied up by skaven slaves, etc.. Fact is if you're looking for a strong offensive unit, our rare choices are more cost effective, and if you're looking for a defensive unit, why not give the drakenhoff banner to the 500 points of core that you dismiss as useless? If you put more than minimal effort into your core I'm sure you could find some use for them :)

"15 strength 5 attacks at WS3 (probably hitting on 4's) is no where as close to good as grave guard"

They're more cost efficient when it comes to points spent vs. wounds caused, is what I mean.

"VERY few of them are radically different,"

Out of the first 5 relevant lists in the army lists section I have found these ones were different from the standard list you describe:

https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-2000pt-Tournament-List-Heavy-Magic

This one includes dire wolves and uses skeletons instead of ghouls :)

https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-2500-point-strigoi-themed-armylist

This one makes use of dire wolves, bat swarms, fell bats, black knights, and completely forgoes grave guard ;)

https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-3-2k-Lahmian-theme-for-local-League

This one utilizes blood knights, fell bats, and uses skeletons instead of ghouls for core ;)

"Could have just said, the high inititiave value and magic attacks of daemons makes Wraiths a sub-par choice"

Actually what I was trying to say is that you can make the best of bad situations, not that wraiths were a good choice against Daemons. Even though wraiths are fragile against magically inclined armies, they can still pack a decent punch and perhaps make back 2/3rds of their points ;) I would not say they're worthless simply because they're sub-par against 2 or 3 out of 14 armies :)


who runs grave guard in a normal formation..... very few.

all the lists you mentioned are either themed lists or such high point values that the extra points can be thrown around wherever they want, hence "point to list comparison" are those bat swarms ect. point effective? no, does it matter at that high of a point value? not really. and the first list is not radically different from anything, the only change is skeletons for ghouls, its nice he doesnt feel the need for the ghoul crutch, I do it too ive never used ghouls.

Yes Danseman, it was a little harsh, and I apologize. although I think filling the forums with wrong mathematical and strategical advice to be kind of irritating like "wraiths can work well against daemons if you play them right" when there really is nothing wraiths can do against any daemon unit as all of them even flamers would tear them to shreds in hand to hand.

99% of people on this forum take helm of commandment, you'd be quite silly not to, and to include those costs against the grave guards point/effectiveness ratio would be quite absurd, like I said earlier, without the regen banner your still more likely to survive with the grave guard then 4 blood knights, and throwing the regen banner in with your core i feel is a waste, they are cheap enough that with your minimum core achieved you have enough to where they dont need to rely on a magical banner, some people put them in ghouls but i dont see the point. most people are going to take drakkenhoff anyways for its versatility and adding survivability to models that need it INCLUDING characters, maybe we should theoretically subtract 45 points from the wight king BSB with drakkenhoff for each character that gains a 4++ save im sure he'd come out much cheaper.
 
"who runs grave guard in a normal formation..... very few."

I'd say the majority of people run them 5-7 wide, I can show examples from the army list section again? :)

"all the lists you mentioned are either themed lists or such high point values"

That's irrelevant, you claimed that "everyone" ran the same list with minor variations; my examples showed otherwise ;)

"Yes Danseman, it was a little harsh, and I apologize. although I think filling the forums with wrong mathematical and strategical advice to be kind of irritating like "wraiths can work well against daemons if you play them right""

I never said that... :frown:

"99% of people on this forum take helm of commandment"

Another exaggeration. It's a good item, and lots of people take it, but 99% is a bit much. I'd say around 50% of people take it :)

"you'd be quite silly not to"

Well this is off-topic, but the problem I see with the HoC is that it eats up point allowance on your lord and forces him to stay out of combat to use it. Now, for magic oriented lords who have points to spare it is indeed a nice addition, but for combat lords it doesn't work so well (and many people do play combat lords). The work-around is to include a vampire thrall and let him wear it, but that can be quite the investment as he ends up costing 135 points minimum and, like the lord, is unable to utilize his combat abilities. I'd say the HoC has it's uses, however it's not good enough to shoehorn into every list.

Ok, and for the rest of your post you ramble on a bit, and you seem to have missed what I was trying to say in my earlier posts. Basically what I'm saying is that blood knights are a relatively cheap, fast unit that deals out a lot of damage, and that grave guard are an expensive, resilient unit that deals out a moderate amount of damage. Both have their strengths and weaknesses, and both are viable. ;)
 
where do I begin?

holla holla get dolla said:
"who runs grave guard in a normal formation..... very few."

I'd say the majority of people run them 5-7 wide, I can show examples from the army list section again? :)

Idk where your getting your "majority" from, I know ive been here a very long time and am a very active poster and have been commenting on army lists which seem like forever.


holla holla get dolla said:
"all the lists you mentioned are either themed lists or such high point values"

That's irrelevant, you claimed that "everyone" ran the same list with minor variations; my examples showed otherwise ;)
No. I said VERY few are different

holla holla get dolla said:
"Yes Danseman, it was a little harsh, and I apologize. although I think filling the forums with wrong mathematical and strategical advice to be kind of irritating like "wraiths can work well against daemons if you play them right""

I never said that... :frown:

yes you (really hard to interpret otherwise) did

holla holla get dolla said:
"99% of people on this forum take helm of commandment"

Another exaggeration. It's a good item, and lots of people take it, but 99% is a bit much. I'd say around 50% of people take it :)

noooooo, your so very wrong, again, how long have you been here?

holla holla get dolla said:
"you'd be quite silly not to"

Well this is off-topic, but the problem I see with the HoC is that it eats up point allowance on your lord and forces him to stay out of combat to use it. Now, for magic oriented lords who have points to spare it is indeed a nice addition, but for combat lords it doesn't work so well (and many people do play combat lords). The work-around is to include a vampire thrall and let him wear it, but that can be quite the investment as he ends up costing 135 points minimum and, like the lord, is unable to utilize his combat abilities. I'd say the HoC has it's uses, however it's not good enough to shoehorn into every list.
130 points minimum.

I know many armies that would include a 130 point caster or 165 point caster with lore master that can bestow weapon skill 6 onto a target unit with no casting dice or threat of dispel needed, im actually sure everyone would take it, especially if your getting a 3-4 weapon skill boost, some armies pay about 1/3 of a standard models point costs to pay for elite units to gain even just 1 weapon skill

holla holla get dolla said:
Ok, and for the rest of your post you ramble on a bit, and you seem to have missed what I was trying to say in my earlier posts. Basically what I'm saying is that blood knights are a relatively cheap, fast unit that deals out a lot of damage, and that grave guard are an expensive, resilient unit that deals out a moderate amount of damage. Both have their strengths and weaknesses, and both are viable. ;)

I actually think its quite the opposite

i wouldnt consider a model that is worth 4.23 grave guard cheap that only has 1 wound. Infantry are faster now, and the benefits of cavalry have long since been jacked from them, artillery is stronger, magic is much more dangerous, and steadfast exists, and guess what?! grave guard get to choose who they want to charge, and whether or not they want to restrain a pursuit or not or retrain an overrun

Blood knight units ultimately end up being a more expensive unit if properly equipped and in numbers that will survive the battle.

no one runs 5 strong heavy cavalry anymore, they are unable to break ranks, steadfast is brutal, and there are so many ways to kill them now, its so much easier.

id rather take a 400 point mounted vampire lord and run him around solo then to take 4 blood knights, hes more likely to live.
 
"No. I said VERY few are different"

Actually you've said both, these arguements have gone around in circles for 7 pages and you've said many things, things which have some truth to them but are buried under hyperbole and stubborness.

The thing is that, yes, VC does have poor internal balancing and some units excel at a disproportionately large number of scenarios when compared to others. Grave guard, rare choices and characters are the prime offenders here - arguably ghouls too but I think their uses are somewhat exaggerated. If you had just stated this than I think most here would've agreed with you, but the thing is you went way too far in saying that everything asides from those aforementioned units are worthless. Black knights, blood knights, fell bats, skeletons, etc. may not be as good all purpose units as grave guard are, but there are areas in which they shine. I've mentioned those areas before so I won't repeat myself ;)

Another point of criticism I have to bring up is your stubborness. I've shown you the "math hammer" as you call it, and blood knights are undoubtedly the more efficient unit offensively compared to grave guard. You've refused to simply admit that and now we're on some ridiculous tangent and you're insisting that most people run their grave guards in horde formation. It's comical really, step back and see that :clown:

You're not going to convince anyone you're right when you present your ideas in a ludicrously exaggerated way, and then dismiss valid criticisms of those ideas. Keep an open mind, weigh what people say to you and don't be afraid to abandon former claims if you think you were wrong about them; just put your ideas out there and let people judge them for what they are ;)

Ok and one last thing I think I should reply to before I leave:

"noooooo, your so very wrong, again, how long have you been here?"

You may have posted more than me but I've lurked for quite some time, and anyways my time spent on this forum isn't really relevant since it only takes 10 minutes to check out the army builds in the army list section ;)
 
Most of the people playing to win, field their graveguard in horde as long as they are 20+, with great weapons and banner of barrows.

The most costeffective core unit is ghouls. Also very often fielded in Horde as they are often atleast 30 strong.

Most competitive players go for a caster lord which is either lvl 4 or lvl 3 with forbidden lore, Motba, HoC, Some kind of ward, and a arcane item.

Many people also field a WK bsb with Drakenhoff. Not anymore in ETC if they go with the gamewinning unit of GG mentioned at the top.

Rares are more diverse, all of them are seen.

Last comes the rest of the hero choices, magic support vamps and necros, flying vamps that hunt small units. This category changes from person to person.
 
I find, usually, that without relaible magical support, that horded ghouls and Graveguard are easy meat for multi charges.

You, even with 2+ to hit or rerolls, just dont dish out enough damage to win in combat going ultra wide, and then you start to crumble, requiring either more magic to balance out, or more troops into the equation. Those multi charges WILL happen, if you field hordes, because so many of points get locked into single blocks, and all it takes is wiffing one combat phase then POof, your super expensive unit evaporates to combat res.

Balance is the key. All ghouls is a great way to loose a fortitude mission, with a max of 2 Banners + bsb + general at 2500 points, meaning if you loose your general, or any two banners, you have lost if a fortitude mission is chosen.

What are you going to do if you get a watchtower? Your units are in big hordes, and wont fit into a tower without loosing heavy casualties, as there are ten men per level, most towers three levels high.

Hordes maximize frontage against smaller units, many of which can dish out infinitely more damage then ghouls can. Ghouls shine where they can poison monsters, or cut through rank and file people with no armor. THe problem is, most RnF either A, Hit before them, B, Are armored enough to shrug off enough poison to matter, or B, can just take the casualties, and smile.

Elves hit before you. Chaos hits before you. The only people who dont are Empire, who can take the casualites if its a front line unit, or can shrug it off, Lizards, which are as tough as you, heavier armored then you, and hit harder, or Dwarfs, who are as tough as you, heavier armored, and hit harder.

I dont rely on our core for anything other then killing single monsters with high toughness, like Hydras or Stegadons. Thats where they shine, no where else, really. Do they dish out more wounds then Skeletons? Yes, usually. But you field them for different reasons. Ghouls, if someone wants them dead, die alot easier then skeletons. Skeletons go deep, 5 wide, and with a war banner. 3 Ranks for a long time, 2 Combat res from banner. They hold a banner which is a plus over ghouls, and they have armor, and a parry save. Against strength 5+ INFANTRY, skeletons hold the line with parry saves, and deep ranks to hold on for infinitely longer then all those ghouls who are letting your opponent maximize his attacks into you, possibly with you not getting all yours in.

Now, each of our units has a place, but no unit is inherently useful on it's own, all need some support. Do i take more ghouls then Skeletons? Yes, three blocks of 25 Core. 2 blocks of 25 Ghouls, 1 of skeletons with a warbanner. I have ghoulkin for that march, and i send them up the flanks, one with a vampire, the other escorted by a coach, and they hold flanks nicely for that. My center is 1 or 2 units of graveguard and the skeleton, usually with a hybrid Lord with FB Light, to buff my better troops, all at once, while carving up rnf, using champions to hold out of challenges. Our units for the most part, lack in Initiative and weapon skill. Helm can help here, and sometimes i take one, depending on what im trying. Usually my list runs a varghulf, a Coach, and the core and grave guard listed above.

I think people will find that the 'optimized' build isnt quite what allways works. Play people who know vampire counts well, and they know what to expect. They hold a dice back to stop that book of arkhan, they throw killing blows at our general and BsB, or get a flaming attack in there to pound you when you have Drakenhoff. taking what everyone else takes puts you at a disadvantage, because people know what you will field, and what tricks to expect out of you, and can respond or plan for them accordingly, taking it into stride. Be unpredictable, i swear by that, and it doesnt let me down at all...

In addition: This is a game of DICE and PEOPLE. Two of the most unpredictable things in the world. Its foolish to say one thing is better over another when dice decide how well something works... Especially in 8th edition. 7th was a game of math, 8th is a game of randomization and dice rolling.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu