My philosophy: point to list comparison 8th edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
There are 3 kinds of lies in the world. Lies, Damned Lies... and Statistics.

you can look on paper and say X, Y, and Z about any given unit and make any claim you want, but the truth of the matter is that it is not likely going to pan out to those numbers. Maybe over the course of 50 games, but in the span of one game, it is unlikely that the stats will hold up. Call it luckhammer if you want, i will totally agree with you, it does take a bit of luck to win, even with a optimized list.

Last game against WoC (presented above) that unit of Chosen should have probably destoryed my Varghulf and overran, but they didnt, they failed. He rolled like crap, and I rolled like a champ and it held him up where he was pretty certain he would roll right on over my Varghulf and into my ghouls (though it would have needed a seriously good overrun roll - like a 9 or so to be my guess).

Game before that i played Dark Elf. For the first 3 rounds, the Winds of magic (for both of us) didnt yield more than 4 powerdice. Luckily for us, we both had ways to up those numbers, but it really hurt our ability to carry out our gameplans. I ended up wining the contest as well, as lower magic dice worked more to my favor than the DE.
I am sure he didnt plan on having such few dice when he was figuring up his list. Maybe he should never take sorcerors again because they didnt kill their cost and are unjustifiable?

Truth is that both of those players heavily rely on mathhammer to make their lists, choose their units, and even figure up where they want to start them based on estimated movements and wheeling distances so that they arrive exactly when scheduled.

Sadly the leaderboard at the gameshop doesnt reflect their preparation from month to month.
 
Gladius Rex said:
There are 3 kinds of lies in the world. Lies, Damned Lies... and Statistics.

you can look on paper and say X, Y, and Z about any given unit and make any claim you want, but the truth of the matter is that it is not likely going to pan out to those numbers. Maybe over the course of 50 games, but in the span of one game, it is unlikely that the stats will hold up. Call it luckhammer if you want, i will totally agree with you, it does take a bit of luck to win, even with a optimized list.

Last game against WoC (presented above) that unit of Chosen should have probably destoryed my Varghulf and overran, but they didnt, they failed. He rolled like crap, and I rolled like a champ and it held him up where he was pretty certain he would roll right on over my Varghulf and into my ghouls (though it would have needed a seriously good overrun roll - like a 9 or so to be my guess).

Game before that i played Dark Elf. For the first 3 rounds, the Winds of magic (for both of us) didnt yield more than 4 powerdice. Luckily for us, we both had ways to up those numbers, but it really hurt our ability to carry out our gameplans. I ended up wining the contest as well, as lower magic dice worked more to my favor than the DE.
I am sure he didnt plan on having such few dice when he was figuring up his list. Maybe he should never take sorcerors again because they didnt kill their cost and are unjustifiable?

Truth is that both of those players heavily rely on mathhammer to make their lists, choose their units, and even figure up where they want to start them based on estimated movements and wheeling distances so that they arrive exactly when scheduled.

Sadly the leaderboard at the gameshop doesnt reflect their preparation from month to month.

Mathhammer has done wonders for me ive won a vast majority of my games, losses being to relying on magic for about 80% of them the other 20% bad luck.


The game is math to a HIGH degree, if you do the math right it doesnt mean your going to win, but it does increase the percentage that the randomness factor will be a deciding factor as it gives you larger room for error/bad luck. You play mathhammer, you just dont know it, theres reasons you take grave guard instead of more ghouls, because they are better, you play mathhammer but you half ass it :vampire3:
 
@Forge
Your win percentage means nothing since we don't know the quality of your opponents. What we do know is that you employ a WAAC list and conventional strategy. A competant opponent could simply field their own WAAC list and strat, courtesy of the internet, and have a 50% win ratio against you ;) If anything your ~90% win ratio is proof that your opponents are bad, since even in skill-based games it's rare for a player to have a record that good, nevermind a game like WH that's largely influenced by luck.
 
Lets not start flaming eachother. Thats not this thread's purpose...

As to the ratios:

I find my lord to be 450 points on average, usually, or around there, and i a bit more then minimum core. Mostly GG, and usually a coach, sometimes with a Varg thrown in there.
 
Of course his win ratio matters, as does the general appearence of lists we see. It isn't for the lack of trying or that VC players are just extraordinarily unimaginative. 8th has quite radically changed the game we know and the game our current book was written for. One could argue this is the case for everyone but few armies felt the transition from 7th to 8th as keenly as VC.

However, his win ratio wasn't the crusial bit. It was the manner of lists that were successful, which lists were prone to losing. You can predict the probable outcome of a battle with mathhammer. If the mathhammer supports the empirical evidence, ie, the cause for a win or loss. Then it follows that those perdictions are infact accurate. Does this mean this is the only way, no but warhammer have never been a balanced game and certainly isn't now.

What you can do is argue for the fact(least from where I am sitting) that X and Y unit still is viable.

The less variables, the better. Especially with the extra randomness attached to the new game. On this basis, Forge is 100% correct. Mathhammer works. I prefer to use the less convential ways but even so one has to acknowledge that there are some units that have a definite place as the "the best choice". The primary example for this is our Grave Guard. There is no two-ways about it, this unit is amazing.
 
@Danceman
Mathhammer works, I agree, but I don't think it has enough potential uses to really be the deciding factor (or even major factor) as to whether or not a list is successful. GG are amazing and they're our best all-around combat unit, but you can easily see that without punching numbers into a calculator :P Likewise you can look at a fell bat's stats and go "hey this guy's perfect as a war machine hunter", or see a black knight and realise he's a multi-purpose unit not meant for going solo against infantry blocks. A lot of it's common sense really, and while mathhammer has it's places and will improve your list when applied correctly, I just don't find it coming up enough for me to win 90% of my games using it.

And I'd like to elaborate my scrutiny over Forge's win statistics...

@Forge
I think we can both agree that list building is one of the most important componants of competitive warhammer. Now, when I see a list like yours, I see the standard WAAC units you find anywhere else (and I'm not trying to use WAAC as a derogatory term, don't take this the wrong way :P) such as a power scroll vamp, GG death star, etc., and none of these units are really ahead of the curb in any way. It's because of this that I have to wonder how you're winning those 9 out of 10 games; if your opponents took similar lists, like Teclis, cupped hands, all the other (arguably) overpowered items, then how are you distinguishing yourself from them and beating them into the dust the vast majority of the time? I don't see how tactics could play such a role, since the tactics your list employs are fairly obvious from the onset of battle and your list doesn't allow for much deviation and creativity (your grave guard's going to want toughness 4, 4+ AS opponents, suicide thrall is going to use purple sun on low I infantry blocks, Fate of Bjuna as fallback plan, coach is going to assassinate, take out small units, etc.). It just seems like the standard tournament list, standard tactics, and nothing that should give you more than a 50% win rate over other "serious" players.

And another thing, I just don't see how your outlook on the game is worthy of discussion, so perhaps you could clear this up a bit :P. Essentially your arguement (from what I gather) is that the VC book has poor internal balancing, and I agree with you :) I think everyone agrees with that. But your method of translating that idea into words seems rather poor, as you use lots of hyperbole and really danced around the issue in your opening post. To me, as the reader, I am somewhat confused as to where you're trying to go with all this debating. Are you venting, are you literally saying it's imbalanced to the extent you portray it as (ie nearly everything being useless or a must have), or is there some other reason to this thread? It would make these arguements a lot more productive if we had a clear idea of what we're arguing about :)

And sorry if this was rambling, I try to keep things brief but I couldn't find a way to cut this down significantly :(
 
You're very quick to assume that just because you use mathhammer this somehow removes your ability to use your units well or employ any kind of tactics. Complex tactics adds more variables into the game. Having a clear battleplan with the least possible variables while still being complex enough to perform on a competitive level is the desireble effect.
 
He made the point that most 'optimized' lists run just like any others, with very specific units to be paired up to to be successful.

I think his point is entirely valid on this... Of course, maybe Forge is a god and DOES in fact now a secret optimizing thing that makes him win, in which case he shouldn't tell us, cause then everyone will know it and it wont work >.>
 
Are the graveguard a good unit? Sure! They can be Anvils or Hammers and that makes them a really cool special unit. They get Killing Blow, so they got a cool special ability that gives them even more utility. Noone is arguing that.

Where Forge tends to seperate from most who have posted in this thread at least, is that he is unwillingly to do anything else. Frankly noone is stopping him. I, like Holla, just do not get why he created a thread to complain about it if he wasnt looking for other viable options, which the community has tried to put forth to him, but he has stubbornly stuck to his guns that NO OTHER unit is a viable option.

We say to him "well, have you considered mixing things up with Black Knights"

he says to us "NOPE, they get shot up too easy and dont have enough wounds"

so we say... "Ok, how about the Blood Knights, they have a banner to help with the shooty shooty problem"

he says... "NOPE, they cost to much and still die too easily"

so we say to him, well have you considered Ethereal lists, maybe try wraiths, they are pretty good, or maybe using Spirit Hosts"

He replies, "Nope, they dont kill as good as a Horde of Graveguard"

So we say, "well sure, but they CAN get the needed job done, they CAN be viable if you use them properly"

he says, "NOPE, they can't"

The community has attempted to provide him with answers, examples, and solutions to the very problem he began this thread with, and it has turned now into an exercise in futility.

Let him field two units of graveguard in every list he runs and let him run ghouls as his core. Noone will argue with the list, i even think most of us has said it is the community approved "optimized" list.

thats fine with us, but then that brings us back to where we started and leaves us with the queston... what the heck is the purpose of the thread?

does misery love company? Was Forge trying to find others who feel the same way?

was he just wanting to vent and were we all suppose to see a frustrated fellow Count and just NOT respond with our different experiences and viewpoints?

is he playing Devil's advocate in hopes of stirring up a long winded debate (if so I applaud you sir, well done)

or was Forge actually looking for alternate viable units to field in his lists to break up his boredom of running the same ole list over and over.

I sure thought it was the last one, but now im left pondering nearly 161 posts later...

I mean, I am all out of other suggestions for you Forge. I guess its time to bite the bullet and buy a new army book and start collecting a whole new army of minis. Vampire Counts has little left to offer you man. We have no shooting. Id love to offer you a cool option for archers but it just isnt there unless you Dogs O War it up. Id love to pitch you some artillery, but we are lacking, as much as I want a Zombie Catapult that launches Zombies like stone throwers we are just not getting one anytime soon. Id even like to ease your mind with knowledge that the VC book for 8th ed is going to be full of new units and new items, and reduced costs, and improved Core stats.... but its not even in production yet to my knowledge and its not even near the top of the list for armies books to be completed.

So while I am sure I will be told (again) to try to keep my post relevant, I frankly have no idea what the relevant point to this entire thread is.
 
No, I win my games because my battle plans are almost flawless, I have a strategy. great warriors and strategists have been creating battle plans for almost forever, and have led to AMAZING battles that could not have been won without the forethought.


The thread was talking about point to list comparison, as points go up the choices do not keep up with the left over points, where as points should normally spill over into the core, special and rare choices they usually fall into characters as they were in 7th worth more points then the units normally.


as far as your rendition of me your wrong, Danseman has it figured out on the dot, its a game of variables and percentages. remove as many variables that you can and you have a more likely chance to succeed.

No one at my store has figured out a anyway to destroy my grave guard block yet (ya thats right, its never been destroyed in any of my games), they've thrown everything they got at it but its not enough.

Infantry has a HUGE upper hand on cavalry this edition, being as Grave Guard is our ONLY special/rare choice that is infantry and are at a VERY cheap price for what they do they are the obvious choice and in my opinion should be the only unit you can 100% count on, out expensive cavalry can be wiped by a unit with okkamas mind razor, great weapons, ect, they were good when there were only 5 or so attacks coming at you in hand to hand, now its 10 at least and charging doesnt give you strike first so you cant kill the initial 5 that could attack you, but now models step up, you cant deny attacks. cavalry are SOL because they are so expensive and you cant fully count on them you need a strong offensive/defensive unit like grave guard (the only real choice) you can count on, but not until like 3000 points will you have enough for both unless your skimping on your much needed characters.
 
Forge said:
No, I win my games because my battle plans are almost flawless, I have a strategy. great warriors and strategists have been creating battle plans for almost forever, and have led to AMAZING battles that could not have been won without the forethought.


The thread was talking about point to list comparison, as points go up the choices do not keep up with the left over points, where as points should normally spill over into the core, special and rare choices they usually fall into characters as they were in 7th worth more points then the units normally.


as far as your rendition of me your wrong, Danseman has it figured out on the dot, its a game of variables and percentages. remove as many variables that you can and you have a more likely chance to succeed.

No one at my store has figured out a anyway to destroy my grave guard block yet (ya thats right, its never been destroyed in any of my games), they've thrown everything they got at it but its not enough.

Infantry has a HUGE upper hand on cavalry this edition, being as Grave Guard is our ONLY special/rare choice that is infantry and are at a VERY cheap price for what they do they are the obvious choice and in my opinion should be the only unit you can 100% count on, out expensive cavalry can be wiped by a unit with okkamas mind razor, great weapons, ect, they were good when there were only 5 or so attacks coming at you in hand to hand, now its 10 at least and charging doesnt give you strike first so you cant kill the initial 5 that could attack you, but now models step up, you cant deny attacks. cavalry are SOL because they are so expensive and you cant fully count on them you need a strong offensive/defensive unit like grave guard (the only real choice) you can count on, but not until like 3000 points will you have enough for both unless your skimping on your much needed characters.

Dude... Im sorry... But you are honestly saying you inherently are so good that you win almost every game based entirely on tactics? This is flawed in so many ways, i wont even go into all of them.

One main one you should be aware of though is:

If you are that amazing with tactics and battle plans, you should be able to make all the other options work, as they are more conditional, and RELIANT on the tactics you seem so proud of, yet are yet to provide an example of.

Im sorry, but this thread was so promising at start, but i find my respect for your posts dropping off significantly.
 
Im not going to lie... i have typed and retyped about 10 different responses for you Forge.

But I think I am just going to walk away from this one.

Good luck with your Graveguard, I hope they continue to treat you kindly.

Sincerely,

Gladius Rex
 
If you are that amazing with tactics and battle plans, you should be able to make all the other options work, as they are more conditional, and RELIANT on the tactics you seem so proud of, yet are yet to provide an example of.

Why? It would be poor strategy to pick units that are unfit for the battleplan itself. Why would he be able to make every concievable unit and strategy work? He's found something that works and performs reliably for him. He obviously can use this(these) list(s) well.

It sounds almost as you've angry with Forge for not using the units you like. He's just playing with the unit choices he likes and that was the purpose of the thread. Just because you do not agree with this approach doesn't mean you have start using mock-conversations, tell him the thread is suddenly irrelevat and pointless and so on. Just admit you have a different philosophy on how to construct army lists and leave it at that. As long as we're having a good time everything else is secondary.

There is no point dragging this down to a personal level.

Cheers, D.
 
Danceman said:
If you are that amazing with tactics and battle plans, you should be able to make all the other options work, as they are more conditional, and RELIANT on the tactics you seem so proud of, yet are yet to provide an example of.

Why? It would be poor strategy to pick units that are unfit for the battleplan itself. Why would he be able to make every concievable unit and strategy work? He's found something that works and performs reliably for him. He obviously can use this(these) list(s) well.

It sounds almost as you've angry with Forge for not using the units you like. He's just playing with the unit choices he likes and that was the purpose of the thread. Just because you do not agree with this approach doesn't mean you have start using mock-conversations, tell him the thread is suddenly irrelevat and pointless and so on. Just admit you have a different philosophy on how to construct army lists and leave it at that. As long as we're having a good time everything else is secondary.

There is no point dragging this down to a personal level.

Cheers, D.

first point: This thread is devolving

Second point:

Now... How do you, someone i have never met or played, know what i play/dont play with or like or dont like?

My statement was based purely on the fact that he runs lists that apparently only the optimized lists, the exact same thing 90% of the people on here run, according to his own earlier post, and is doing well above average with them. And his only reason he gave for his stated win ratio with those kind of lists was a sort of vague 'Im just that good'

Of course, this entire path of discussion is going so far off topic...
 
. And his only reason he gave for his stated win ratio with those kind of lists was a sort of vague 'Im just that good'

Incorrect, he stated that his strategy and army list provides(through mathhammer and battleplan) a solid base on which he uses his units to the maximum of their effect. On the other side of the coin, why couldn't he be 'that good'? Just because he use lists similiar to other people doesn't mean we should expect the same results. He certainly had a lot of games which verifies his approach, indeed, have allowed him to really get to know lists based on these principles.
 
i coudl write in my signature right now that i have a 500-1 win ratio, and cite my use of something stupid, like zombies, and it would have the exact same evidence as him.

Im waiting to see what hes doing differently that allows him such an amazing ratio over EVERYONE ELSE i have seen here... Because i have never heard of vampire counts doing that good.
 
This thread seems to be straying from the original topic quite a bit, and some of the recent posts are borderline on things becoming too personal.

[mod]Please get back on topic, or this thread will be locked.[/mod]
 
"The thread was talking about point to list comparison, as points go up the choices do not keep up with the left over points"

That's true for all armies, and as far as I can tell it's due to two factors: magic not scaling up, and magical items being in limited supply.
 
Bishop - THis thread has no real point. It took me 160 posts to come to realize that. Noone is trying to tell Forge what he should play, we were just trying to give him options because we thought he was looking for other viable ways to win. Those of us who are using other things with success were trying to illistrate to him HOW we can still win using other units effectively. That just isn't his style. At this point... the thread is useless.

do us all a favor and lock it down.
 
I believe that the usefulness of this thread has run its course.

- Most of the recent posts contribute nothing of relevance

- Some of the recent posts are of a flaming, trolling, etc nature.

[mod] Locked [/mod]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu