Necromancer or Vampire?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Hell

Zombie
Feb 4, 2011
2
Zombies
2
Hi, fellow brothers and sisters of the night. I just started with Vampire counts and are new to this forum so please dont judge me to hard and impale me:grave: if this post already exist.
Im currently running a combat lord and WK BSB in my 1500p armie, but as the topic says,
im having a hard time figuring out wheater to use a necromancer or a vampire to cast spells.
With the vampire i get the free march move up to 6", he's harder to kill and can use vampiric powers.
With the necromancer i get free spell choice from the necromancer spells and since i want to get in combat
and most likely need to ressurect a lot i think IoN and VHD are ace. And i get 2 necromancers for the price of 1 vampire.
Any help, tips, tricks or dark insight from more experience generals will help alot.
 
Magic in 8th edition favors quality above quantity. It is better to have one high quality caster than many low level casters given they all draw from the same power pool. You already have a level 2 caster in your combat lord. He is a better caster out of the box than a necro will ever be. Vampire heroes can fight and carry an arcane item if you wish. You could give the vampire the book of arkan if you want to guarantee VHDM. Necromancers make good scroll cadies if you have points to burn for such things but in 1500 point games they may prove to be a liability.
 
Well as you need a vampire to lead your force he is a must.
I would however take a hero vamp in 1500 points.
With that you can have summon ghouls and a entire lore through the forbidden lore option and a 2+ armour save.
That will give you a 175 point hero.
In 1500 points you can have 375 points in hero etc.
So now you can take 2 necro's and make sure they have the spells you want.
With 3 casters you can cast on 1 dice and risk the fail as you have another 2 casters to pick up the slack.

Thats the choice I would make.
however if you want sure casting keep at least 1 necro, take a 2nd if you like but I would take a combat geared vamp instead as he will still be able to cast.
Now you can take a lord caster, Forbidden lore, master of BA, extra magic level and flayed hauberk. (if you don't use it on your hero)
So thats a level 3 caster with 2 extra power dice with a entire lore of your choice and a 2+ save all for only 365 points. :perv:
 
There are sort of two philosophies running about on this topic.

One side will tell you that Necros are a waste. Make your lord level 4 and just rely on him to push through SUH to regrow troops, basically forsaking IoN alltogether.

The other side will tell you that Necros are fine and dandy since they are dirt cheap, you can just take IoN and one die spam like we used to do in 7th ed and just go from Necro to Necro until you are out of dice or all 3 have failed the actual casting roll.

The problem with this debate is ussually (IMHO) a points related issue. At lower point games like you are talking about, it becomes a problem to properly kit out a lord fully. With only 375 points and the Lord costing 205 out of the box, you end up with 170 points between powers, magic, and mounts to toy with. That can become a tricky decision to make as 1/4 of your army does end up being tied to one single model and making him a good caster then really leaves him low on defenses and then requires more points in core to be set aside as a bunker to sit him in to protect him further.

Examples: Vamp Lord
+1 caster level
powers Master Black Arts
Dark Acolyte

That alone will cost you 335 of your 375 points. So you can slap a Flayed Hauberk on him or the Wristbands.

Then you need a Skellie bunker to sit him in. So a block of 20 Skeletons HW&S will run you 160, then if you want any command or at least a Standard Bearer so you can get the Lichebone Pennant and MR1 to stack with the Wristbands, you end up pretty close to 200 points there as well.

Now in your 1.5K army, you have 1/3 of your army that is a risk to move into combat if you go the the wristbands/pennant, or if you go Flayed Hauberk, you leave your expensive general exposed to Fate of Bjuna or other sniping type spells.

Since Lords are hard to really kit out on a budget lower than a 2K game, the Necro becomes a more viable option along with the tried and true WK for your Hero points.

at 375 points you can do the following.

Thrall (general) 175 pts
Dark Acolyte
Avatar of Death (HW&S+H.Armour)
Obsidian Amulet MR2 (5+ ward)
(4+ AS, 6+ Parry ward, 5+ ward vs magic) lvl 2 caster w. IoN and 2 other VC lore spells

WK (BSB) 125 pts
Barded Mount
Luckstone

2+ AS(one time rerollable) on a T5, 3W model with A3, at S4 Killing Blow and mount attacks (like they matter)

Necromancer w/ IoN 70 pts
Obsidian Trinket (MR 1 - 6+ ward vs magic)

With this set up, you have a nice blend of combat prowess with your Thrall and WK able to pony up and lead units into combat. Your Thrall as general will get targeted by magic as well as your Necro once the Thrall is in combat, so if your Necro sits in a small unit of Skellies (like 15 even) you can put the Lichebone Pennant on and give the Necro a 5+ ward vs magic as well. With this set up, you have two caster who can IoN up your army with minimal points sunk into a bunker to protect an expensive caster. This allows you more points of ghouls and graveguard to acatuall do the fighting for you. The WK should still be upgraded to a BSB, since your General in this case is only Ld 7, you will want the rerolls when you need them (though honestly pretty rare since you are unbreakable and ghouls wont be reforming due to no musician)

The only think you gotta fear in a list like this... is having the Blood and Glory scenario come up lol.
 
I have to agree with most of what I read but there is a use for necromancers two in fact.

If using a Vampier (lord or hero) with Forbidden Lore and not taking the Lore of Vampires your necromancers have the ability to store Vanhel's Dance Macbre for when you really need it.

If your still a little old school and wish to use only one die to cast Invokecation of Nehek. Then Necromancers can store ION just in case you roll a 1 or 2, thus ending your casting on the Vampire

Do not give them Items!!!!! having too many bound spells only compounds the issue of 2d6 casting dice.
 
I wouldnt say to NEVER give them items. A Necromancer with a Staff of Damnation can be quite useful in alot of situations especially if you combine it with Graveguard or Black Knights who get Killing Blow, because then you can effectively take out opponents characters in the magic phase before they get a chance to murderize you in close combat.

It is sort of like the sneak attack that your opponent should see coming, but rarely does.
 
I'm certainly in the camp that approves the use of Necromancers. In most of my armies I use a caster Lord, a Wight King Battle Standard Bearer, and 3 Necromancers with Book of Arkhan, Channelling Staff, and Black Periapt (or occasionally swapping this for the Staff of Damnation). Sometimes, or in higher point games I will add a Vampire Hero with the Sword of Swift Slaying, Flayed Hauberk, Dark Acolyte, and Master Power.

All my Necromancers run Invocation and Vanhel's Danse (yes, even the one with the Book). As I find redundancy the key to my Magic Phases. The Necromancy spells can be cast multiple times for a reason, and you can never get enough Danses xD .

I definitely agree with the Quality vs Quantity statement by King ChocoBoBo, but to that I say, "is it too much to ask for both?" (Sorry, I've been on an Iron Man kick recently).

I personally find the best balance to be a high level 3/4 caster surrounded by level 1's and the occasional 2. Again, the power of the Vampire Magic Phase is redundancy and overwhelming force. I have 4-5 Wizards to channel with, have the Staff for 5+ channels on one, the Periapt for another, and Master of the Black Arts for the Lord. I tend to offensively dominate the magic phases in my group even against Lizardmen and High Elves by beating them into submission with repeated castings until they finally succumb.

I feel the only real opponents that I would need to worry about are going to be Dwarves and Sigmarite Empire armies, since they can easily match the dice output even on poor rolls for the Winds of Magic. Though, I can't think of a magic-heavy army that wouldn't have problems with that sort of opposition.

So I suppose the essence of my case is that you should consider Necromancers with items meant to maximize your Power Dice and provide support/maintenance to the army.

Finally, I don't mean to call you out, but Gladius, I just wanted to point out that Magic Resistance does not stack. So the Lichebone Pennant would provide no additional benefit to your Necromancer with the Obsidian Trinket.
 
_Revan_ said:
I'm certainly in the camp that approves the use of Necromancers. In most of my armies I use a caster Lord, a Wight King Battle Standard Bearer, and 3 Necromancers with Book of Arkhan, Channelling Staff, and Black Periapt (or occasionally swapping this for the Staff of Damnation). Sometimes, or in higher point games I will add a Vampire Hero with the Sword of Swift Slaying, Flayed Hauberk, Dark Acolyte, and Master Power.

All my Necromancers run Invocation and Vanhel's Danse (yes, even the one with the Book). As I find redundancy the key to my Magic Phases. The Necromancy spells can be cast multiple times for a reason, and you can never get enough Danses xD .

I definitely agree with the Quality vs Quantity statement by King ChocoBoBo, but to that I say, "is it too much to ask for both?" (Sorry, I've been on an Iron Man kick recently).

I personally find the best balance to be a high level 3/4 caster surrounded by level 1's and the occasional 2. Again, the power of the Vampire Magic Phase is redundancy and overwhelming force. I have 4-5 Wizards to channel with, have the Staff for 5+ channels on one, the Periapt for another, and Master of the Black Arts for the Lord. I tend to offensively dominate the magic phases in my group even against Lizardmen and High Elves by beating them into submission with repeated castings until they finally succumb.

I feel the only real opponents that I would need to worry about are going to be Dwarves and Sigmarite Empire armies, since they can easily match the dice output even on poor rolls for the Winds of Magic. Though, I can't think of a magic-heavy army that wouldn't have problems with that sort of opposition.

So I suppose the essence of my case is that you should consider Necromancers with items meant to maximize your Power Dice and provide support/maintenance to the army.

Finally, I don't mean to call you out, but Gladius, I just wanted to point out that Magic Resistance does not stack. So the Lichebone Pennant would provide no additional benefit to your Necromancer with the Obsidian Trinket.

you should just take the book and a necro with van hels, the book can be used multiple times a turn even if you fail and its 4 levels easier to use and you cant miscast, the extra vanhels is if you get unlucky and roll a 1 on the book. 3 necros is pushing it in my opinion, MAYBE 1. but its up to you.
 
_Revan_ said:
Finally, I don't mean to call you out, but Gladius, I just wanted to point out that Magic Resistance does not stack. So the Lichebone Pennant would provide no additional benefit to your Necromancer with the Obsidian Trinket.

ACK, you are correct, i should have used the Protection Amulet. Same point cost, actually get the result i mentioned, I just glanced and took the wrong item. SHAME ON ME! Thanks for catching my error.

Forget the Obsidian Trinket, go with the Amulet of Protection. Same points, slightly better result lol.
 
Thanks for helpfull replys.
I'm going to run a combat lord for a few games and see how he compares to the caster lord. And since i dont want him to get blasted into oblivion because of bad/unlucky rolls, i will find a spot for some Necromancers. But im not sure i will run 3 Necros, feel that 2 (at the most) will do the job.
And i agree with not giving them items, or atleast not many/expensive. I however like the idea of using the book and a Necromancer with van hels.
So its time to create another armylist, paint up a Necromancer and give it a go.
 
Right, the Book can be used multiple times, but the reason he has Vanhel's Danse anyway is because I spread my Necromancers out so that they form a net of coverage acroos the army. That, and I typically burn out the book in 2 or 3 Magic Phases :thumbsdown: . Also, the key to my Magic is saturation of Power Dice, so I look for having those cheap channels as well as items to compensate for dice (I know I'm crazy but I've been pondering taking a 4th Necromancer with the Forbidden Rod too just to push through a critical Magic Phase where I just can't muster enough dice).

Oh well, nice thing about being crazy is that people don't see it coming.
 
It also depends on what is in your army. Are fielding Grave Guard. Are you reliant on skeletons or ghouls?

Think about what is in your army and what character best supports your army. How do you win battles and what character gives your army the best chance at it. It sounds like your army is geared to hand-to-hand combat, so have a vampire with Infinite Hatred, Avatar of Death, Enchanted Shield and the Ogre Blade as an example. He has a 3+ armor save, +2 to his strength and he re-rolls failed to hits in combat. He is also a 1st level wizard with IoN.

Good Luck and Happy Hunting!!!
 
Dark Lord Necrotis said:
. . . so have a vampire with Infinite Hatred, Avatar of Death, Enchanted Shield and the Ogre Blade as an example. He has a 3+ armor save, +2 to his strength and he re-rolls failed to hits in combat. He is also a 1st level wizard with IoN.

Good Luck and Happy Hunting!!!

Doesn't that put him over on his Magic Item allotment though? It looks lie it comes out to 55 points of gear. Unfortunately for us, we pay triple for the Enchanted Shield :thumbsdown: . Oh well, at least the War Banner is cheaper than the Rulebook.
 
I think you are right, i think he is over, but that is probably because he didnt notice the point descrepency on the Enchanted Shield. We do have to pay the higher price for now.

and I do agree with you on being crazy. If they don't know what you are about to do, they cant spend an entire week planning how to dissect and destory you.

my game shop plans its games out a week ahead of time, so being unpredictable is always a plus for me. 88% of the games are pitched battles, 99% are known foes and known point totals. Small pool of players, so I know what I am going to see, so i never let them get a good feel for what I might do.
 
Yep, I know the feeling, I definitely try to do the same, seeing as I have a very similar group situation. Even though there are some things I have a hard time not using (I love my Grave Guard horde of 50 once we get upwards of 3000 points xD [it was incredibly handy this past week when I ran into an Ushabti horde of 23 :| ), I usually try to make significant changes every few weeks, both to throw people off and to try new units.

Back on topic though: I feel like Vampires (Hero) tend to be more of a combative supplement to units whereas I find Necromancers to be magic support. Granted, Vampires can perform the same tasks, absolutely, but I like being able to pick the spells and know I'm going to have certain abilities duplicated across the army so I can Vanhel's where I need it. Barring Forbidden Lore, you'll have a single Vanhel's Danse, and a single Book of Arkhan.

Unless you plan on using the Arkayne Vampiric Powers, I don't really see too much advantage to the Vampire as a support caster when you factor in the cost. The best options are going to be either Forbidden Lore or Master of the Black Arts in my opinion, especially since Dark Acolyte will improve your casting, but you'll still run out of spells if you use a pair of them and a Lord versus 3-4 Necromancers.

I think Vampire Hero casters are best to either get the specific Lore or gain more dice to throw at Invocation while your Lord lays down the law. Necromancers have a similar utility (how I run them) to gain Power Dice, but I love guaranteeing that Vanhels.
 
I think you are right Reven and i think the trending amongst the counts sort of reflects that if you look at lists nowadays.

You see alot of thrall casters, but mostly to take the alternate lores.


Since IoN is the only spell we KNOW we are getting with a Thrall if we dont Forbidden Lore it up, then we have to assume that a Vamp is a IoN monkey and thus your MotBA is extra dice for extra attempts and that is quite handy.

I personally dont care for Dark Acolyte that much on a thrall. Being a level 2 caster just doesnt really cut it for me, i am likely to end up taking Raise Dead with one spell if I get Winds of Undeath or Gaze of Nagash, so i still typically end up with only one spell worth taking and most of the time, i end up hoping that i get vanhels with it, so at that point, id rather have a Necro for cheaper. Does the same job really, no more or less effecient.

The only other factor to take in, is marching, you need Vamps to march, so if you dont have rare choices like Varghulfs or Black Coaches to aid with this, you may want a Vamp caster just to allow for marching.

but its probably pretty rare that it will be much of an issue.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu