WHFB - 7th Necromancer's Spell Choices

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Draemock

Grave Guard
Mar 12, 2008
230
Dark Mists of Stockton-on-Tees
Zombies
93
Hi, yesterday i played a tester game at a GW store. And the Necromancer had Gaze of Nagash on its spell list according to the staff member who showed and played with me.

In the VC Book though it says Necro's know Necromancy spells and GoN has no such label?...Im confused lol
 
He lied to you, That was an Incorrect spell selection.

The necros may only have Invocation of Nehek, Raise Dead, and Vanhel's Danse Macabre.
 
Ahh.....luckily I was the one playing as Vampire Counts, though i only used it once and it failed the casting. Which im kind of glad at now as it would have been a cheat and i wouldnt have wanted to win like that....as it was i won the skirmish
 
Well, in my experiance GW staff have a tendency of doing that. Mainly cos for the teaser games they have utter shit armies XD But since it is just a teas they let you tweak a bit and such.
 
Similar to how in the Vampire vs High Elf battle report on the web site they said "Neither player had any idea going into the game how many points their opponents army was going to have - we both just went away and worked ourselves a legal (ish) army list for Warhammer using the contents of our chosen army box set."? lol


Another question about necromancer spell choices; when you write your army list, do you also have to write what spells/upgrades they have?
Or can you just write something like: Necromancer, Extra Spell. and then you have that choice of two at the start of a battle? If you just have a plain necromancer, do you need to write which spell he knows on your army list?

I'm mainly thinking in terms of tournaments etc where you need to submit an army list
 
I would say that you would have to specify which extra spell you have chosen to take.

All the army lists I have seen list what spells the Necromancer is taking when they have an extra spell upgrade.
 
But with forbiden lore you can choose at the start of every battle, right? Not really a necromancer question, but slightly related

And if you have to specify the extra spell, would you still be able to freely choose the 'original' spell?
 
I think you should be able to choose the spell / lore at the beginning of the game. It's a perk of having the snazzy ability.

I think there's a similar question about the timing of Banner of Sundering vs Lore choice https://www.vampirecounts.net/showthread.php?tid=2742&highlight=Sundering

Ha! Looking it up it was my thread. I thought the topic sounded familiar.

According to the rules quoted in this thread, the Necromancer spells are picked during army construction.
 
You pay fifteen points "per extra Necromancy spell" and know "one Necromancy spell" automatically, according to the army list entry. I'd say you pick them before deployment, at the same time as rolling for everyone else.

I pick mine in advance anyway because my Necromancers have a purpose in mind when they're bought.
 
Danceman said:
Under necromancers and then choosing spells ;
"choose these spells when picking your army".

I am sure one could interpret this sentence in different ways but to me this seem to strongly hit you pick the spell(s) when picking your necromancer and thus are bound to whatever spells you choose.

Not to get into some kind of flame war or anything, but I agree with Danceman. The wording strongly implies that you pick your spell when building your army.

Kaptain Von said:
I pick mine in advance anyway because my Necromancers have a purpose in mind when they're bought.

I also agree with Von here. Generally you have a purpose in mind for a particular Necro when putting together your list.

Of course, if you just want to cover all of your bases, spend the 30 points to have all 3 Necromancer spells. I think it'd be a waste of points, but it would be a legit way to keep your options open.
 
Basic Necromancers id think rolling to choose the spells brought into play at the start of the game is the way to go. think about it.

Lore wise your Necromancer might know all the spells available to him but only uses certain ones if he has the right tools or ingredients at his disposal.

Adding an extra spell just adds a large "reagents" pouch i think :P

For a character with Forbidden Lore and Count Manfred i think choosing the lore of magic you know would have to be done when creating your army. Other wise in a sense you would know EVERY school of magic, and end up just choosing which to bring to battle with you if you chose before each fight.

My thoughts anyway.
 
Draemock said:
Basic Necromancers id think rolling to choose the spells brought into play at the start of the game is the way to go. think about it.

Sorry, Draemock, but Necromancers do not roll their spells. See p38 of the Tome of Vampy Goodness.

As the necromancers do not roll their spells, I think their spells are fixed at army construction regardless of how many spells you buy them.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu