New Demons and updates in Next White Dwarf

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Ok, being a DoC player (ok, ok, enough w/ the booing and hissing), here are my thoughts on the travesty that is GW's "quick fix":

1) Soul grinder in fantasy!?!? Seriously!?!? Like others have said, why not just drop in some chaos space marines with the whole "traverse space and time" BS argument?? And who cares if it get's shooting. To make it any kind of worthwhile shooting you have to make it a 300pt war walker. Ummm...no thanks. Ooo! Ooo! Since it's a walker do I get a 6" scout move at the beginning of the game!? :happy: Oh, wait ... wrong system. And why is the worst shooting upgrade (bolt thrower type shot) the most expensive? o_o It's CC ability is mediocre at best as you cannot rely on the claw attack or Thunderstomp. If you ask me, the only way to make a good looking "Fantasy" soul grinder would be to take the arachnarok body and legs and to slap the soul grinder upper body on top of that - a huge drider if you will. Though, I'd have to also figure out how to get rid of that hideous "power claw". Maybe a keeper of secrets claw in its place.

2) Flamers are now useless. They got 4 downgrades: Warpfire instead of Flames of Tzeentch (yes, this is a down grade), increase in points, decrease in strength, and now they also suffer -1 for Multiple Shots. They are nothing but a short range, static fire base now. And they can't even do that well. If you compare what 240pts will get you for shooting from any other army, it's almost laughable. "But you get D6 shots!" I hear you say. Ooooooo. For 40pts/model I better be rolling a lot of 5s and 6s for that D6 roll. Any 1s, 2s, or 3s and you're behind on points. And needing 6s to hit is fine if you're cheap little skinks or night runners, but since daemons are an elite army, there better be some elite shooting.

4) The Slaaneshi chariots got weaker. The old chariot mounts for the heralds were S5 but now the Slaanesh chariot is S4 ... ??? o.o Even goblin chariots are S5.

4) The new models: The chariots look like s%#t and everything else is just ... alright. Nothing really to get excited about as far as looks go. And I don't know why they redid the flamer sculpt. The metal/finecast sculpts were much better.

What good came out of this?
1) All the plastic. Woo-hoo! Daemon players no longer have to pay $40 for 5 metal plaguebearers!

2) Screamers are FINALLY worth their points! Mark my words - everyone WILL turn all that old flamer hatred to screamers now. Mostly because all the rolls that flamers had before will now be filled by screamers. For a 10pt increase they got: +1S, +1T, +1W, and +2A. They lost the Flaming Attacks special rule (which really boggles the mind as EVERYTHING ELSE that is Tzeentch has that rule) and the slashing attack is a little weaker. Yeah, it's pretty much a no brainer. Screamers have more attacks, a better WS, the same S that flamers have, and can get to the enemy quicker since they can fly - all for the same points. WINNER!!! xD

This little fix was pretty much an epic fail. It did not address any of the real issues which is the cost of the core infantry (some being undercost and others being overcost), the wretched stats and cost of the daemon prince, and even the 100pt cost of a beast of Nurgle. Just think, in the VC book, we get a unit that is comparable for almost 1/3 the cost in crypt horrors.

[/rant]
 
1. Soulgrinders are T7 M8 and cheap as chips.
2. Flamers were bent out of shape anyway. They are now just standard instead of OP.
3. Tombking chariots are S4
 
1. Soulgrinders are T7 M8 and cheap as chips.
250pts is cheap? o.o
2. Flamers were bent out of shape anyway. They are now just standard instead of OP.
Yes, they were a little ridiculous before. Take any 2 of the 4 downgrades away and they'd be fine. Now they are a sub-standard unit that will be gathering dust on shelves.
3. Tombking chariots are S4
TK chariots have always been S4.
 
Well lets see here.

Arochs, Ghorgon, Shaggoth, Kitted HPA are all 250 points or over and I would rather have a Grinder than any of them. Toughness 7 and a Wardsave makes them just brutally tough.
 
Don't forget the 4+ armor save to boot. :tongue:

Sphinxes are T8 and you don't hear much in the way of how awesome they are. All you hear are the complaints that anything can wound high T monsters now that a 6 always wounds.

As far as the S and T of the SG go, the T will just help is stick around and you have to hit first before you get to use the S6. The SG is only WS3. And the whole "iron grabby fist of doom" rule, your opponent still has to fail their I test. And most things that you really want to use that special attack on are going to have a higher I. I suppose you could use the SG as a monster hunter since most monsters have lower WS and I as well. But the amount of points you have to spend to get a decent shooting attack (stone thrower or flame thrower) put the SG up to 300pts. 300pts for a stone thrower is nothing to write home about. All war machines are T7. I'll happily take 6 fiends instead of an upgrades soul grinder.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
1. Soulgrinders are T7 M8 and cheap as chips.
2. Flamers were bent out of shape anyway. They are now just standard instead of OP.
3. Tombking chariots are S4

Legion said:
2. Flamers were bent out of shape anyway. They are now just standard instead of OP.
Yes, they were a little ridiculous before. Take any 2 of the 4 downgrades away and they'd be fine. Now they are a sub-standard unit that will be gathering dust on shelves.

He's right Johnny. You'll never see flamers at a tournament again. You will see lots of Screamers which now perform the role the flamers use to have.
 
A sphinx has no save ... at all??? :O And I thought the Beastmen rares got the shaft (who are all GROSSLY overcosted!)

Well, as far as the SG goes, I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree. I'll never ever ever ever ever ever (I think that's enough evers :tongue: ) take a grinder unless I ever get around to modeling up one of my own (arachnagrinder for the win!). Which basically means I'll never field one as I'm about as creative as a log and couldn't convert my way out of a wet paper towel. :lol:

Anywho ... I guess I don't have to worry about to much for a few of reasons:
1) I don't get to play nearly enough games that I will really ever get to find out if a SG is worth it. Can't miss what you've never used.
2) If I don't buy the WD, hell, I don't have to worry about playing w/ the crappy "fix"! xD Though, I won't be able to use the "fix" for the screamers, which, really won't make much of a difference since it's either flamers using the book rules or screamers using the "fix".
3) I don't play competitively so I don't have to worry to much when I bring my one unit of 4 flamers.
 
The so-called 'Kitties' have a 5+ armor save and suffer one less wound from crumble than usual.

@Legion: Doesn't matter if -YOU- have the White Dwarf fix. I matters if your opponent is aware of it. You can't feign ignorance of new rules even in a friendly game.
 
Yorga said:
@Legion: Doesn't matter if -YOU- have the White Dwarf fix. I matters if your opponent is aware of it. You can't feign ignorance of new rules even in a friendly game.
Well, if an opponent is dead set on me using "the fix" then I will gladly let them buy me a copy.
 
Legion said:
Yorga said:
@Legion: Doesn't matter if -YOU- have the White Dwarf fix. I matters if your opponent is aware of it. You can't feign ignorance of new rules even in a friendly game.
Well, if an opponent is dead set on me using "the fix" then I will gladly let them buy me a copy.

What is more likely to happen, is that you won't get any games. White Dwarf updates are official no matter how badly they are written.

I play Demons and I would refuse to play another player who said he was going to ignore the update. If your playing circle is fine with that then have at it. My club would never accept that and would never play your list under the old rules.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
5+ armor is nothing for a big momster.
And that's why all the Beast rares (worst selection of rares - EVER), the shaggoth, giants, and the arach are all overcost compared to things like the a-bomb and hydra.

EDIT: Apologies for the double post - I should have edited this post w/ the following post. Sorry gents. :redface:
 
Yorga said:
Legion said:
Yorga said:
@Legion: Doesn't matter if -YOU- have the White Dwarf fix. I matters if your opponent is aware of it. You can't feign ignorance of new rules even in a friendly game.
Well, if an opponent is dead set on me using "the fix" then I will gladly let them buy me a copy.

What is more likely to happen, is that you won't get any games. White Dwarf updates are official no matter how badly they are written.

I play Demons and I would refuse to play another player who said he was going to ignore the update. If your playing circle is fine with that then have at it. My club would never accept that and would never play your list under the old rules.

Like I said, I'm not a competitive player. I only play in a small (and shrinking) circle of players who are for the most part friends. There is, unfortunately, no club of any kind in my area. If my friends insist that I use "the fix", then I will.

I think, though, that if GW really wants this "fix" to be the official rules, they should post it on their web site in the FAQ section and not force people to buy a glorified catalog in order to get said "fix".
 
Legion said:
I think, though, that if GW really wants this "fix" to be the official rules, they should post it on their web site in the FAQ section and not force people to buy a glorified catalog in order to get said "fix".

And miss out on that extra profit? o.o You do not know Games Workshop very well do you? You do know they are a public company (i.e.share holders) that trades on the London Stock Exchange, right?

Bottom line...don't expect any Freebies from them.
 
@Yorga - Yes, I know they are now a publicly traded company. Probably the worst thing that's ever happened to them.

@Mad'At - WD sales are dropping because it's nothing more than a glorified catalog now. The content is nothing like it used to be before GW went public. Sure, there's a batt rep here and there but otherwise it's all, "Here's a new book for Warhammer. Go buy it. And here's our new models for 40K. Go buy some of them too. Oh, and here's some more new models AND some new rules for The Lord of the Rings. Go buy some of them too." :thumbsdown: All the hobby tips are gone. All the cool studio campaigns are gone. I let my subscription drop shortly after 8th came out because there was no reason to get the mag any more.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu