Grish said:
..
Most wins involve static CR combined with a flank charge, or summoned troops.
Our troops are expensive for what you get, stat-wise. You pay for fear and the ability to raise them back from the dead.
...
Undead is an army filled with special rules. The way our general works, the battle standard bearer, an entire army immune to psychology, marching rules, suffering crumble, complete lack of shooting, lack of regular bait and flee tactics...
I really would get a feel of 'how' she likes to win; there's a big difference winning a combat by plowing some chosen knights of khorne or blood knights headlong into infantry, or winning a combat by a huge block of static CR skeletons that never get a kill, combined with a summoned zombie flank charge that never gets a kill, but the enemy runs away anyways. They give different levels of satisfaction.
I'm considering
VC as well, and I'd like to thank you for this synopsis because it really helped me understand what I was missing.
I would see all these Skellies/Zombies and wonder "So that's the tarpit to keep units busy as you kill other stuff", then I'd wonder "So, where's the stuff doing the killing? Where's the hammer in this army?" Sounds like it turns out that there isn't one, and the standard
VC army is to raise massive numbers and win with CR.
I then played a mini-battle with a friend the other day at GW. About 600 points each of
VC vs Orks. I liked watching his Chariot sit there because it was scared to attack and I thought I was doing well until turn 3 when I wound up getting my General killed. I then found out that I basically lost the game right there - the rule was worse than Necron "phase out" times 10 and you only have to lose 1 guy for it to happen! Now, I'm starting to see that this shouldn't happen if you hide him and that you can give him saves and such, but it still seems pretty harsh to have everything depend on one guy with 2 wounds who I assumed should be fighting in the front rank of my skeleton block. (if you're curious, I chased a running block of Black Orks and wound up fighting the Black Ork Boss who put all his attacks on my Vampire...dead vamp).
The other thing I noticed is that because we didn't get in depth figuring out magic, I couldn't do anything but use a spell to raise guys that had fallen...so my lines never grew from the 40 or so core I started with and his Orks were wasting me in CR. I assume/hope it wouldn't work that way in a real battle otherwise I'm not sure how I would win. But that got me to thinking...am I going to need about 150+ skeletons/ghouls/zombies to start playing
VC at a decent point level (let's say 1500)?
Can
VC run a different sort of list with any chance of winning? Say something that involves Vampires tossing all kinds of destructive magic around at the enemy and a few tarpits to hold units up until the vamps and other power units can blast them or hit their flanks. I guess this kind of describes how I play my shooty Nids, where the gaunt speed-bumps are there to hold up units long enough so I don't have to deal with everything at once as the power units (shooty Monsters and close combat Genestealers) take out the important targets first and then move on to whatever breaks free of the tar pits.
From reading message boards, it just seems like
VC is very one dimensional if you want to be competitive. I hope I'm missing something because I really like the look of the models.
Sorry, if I have derailed this thread, because that was not my intention. I just really found the
VC description given by Grish to be interesting/enlightening and I'm still trying to decide if that playstyle works for me and my first Fantasy army (kinda like the OP's friend).
I also really wish I could find a synopsis like this of some of the other armies that I've been considering (mainly WE, DE,
TK).
Thanks for listening to a noobie
