New VC - can't heal characters?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Raizi said:
Von said:
@ Raizi - I'd be wary about assuming a connection between discrete sentences. I want to agree with you but there's none of the punctuation that makes the meaning you're looking for explicit. See above paragraph - can't be bothered typing it out again.

I read the RFW wording again a few more times and I am beginning to see your point here. The thing that got me distracted was the mention of characters as 'targets' in the very beginning. This I interpreted (wrongly) to apply to IoN when it was just describing resurrecting powers and effects in general.

I will too refrain from using IoN to heal my characters and use the Lore Attribute for that instead. They still work very well together and the more I think about it, it will probably be for the better that way. Healing the units around you with a pulse and possibly restoring 2 wounds to a single character with a single casting is perhaps a tad overpowered. :)

@ Von - I'm sorry if I hit a nerve with my ranting. I personally like to play my games to the fullest but I never want to gain or benefit from a misinterpretation of rules nor actively pursue one.

Edit: hopefully we'll get that FAQ soon to clear things out.

You can tell when you've annoyed me, it's very easy - I stop talking to you. If we're still having some sort of conversation, we're good. xD

And yeah, I'm with you on both the 'play the game to the hilt' bit and the 'roll on the FAQ' bit. I'm not sure what their policy for Fantasy FAQs is (hopefully it's not 'nerf to drive sales of the next release').
 
@Wargamer Thats how I think it was intended but thats not what it says. Im looking at it now, and it does not say vampiric units can only gain one wound per casting, it says vampiric models can only gain one wound per casting.
I suspect an errata/faq will address it eventually. Not that I'll be taking advantage of it. I wont be using any vampiric units and even if I was I dont think its taking advantage of the wording of the rule a little too much.
 
Mach_5 said:
Zombieboy and others have it right.

Lone characters (those not in units) can be healed ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 1, sentence 2).

Characters in units cannot be healed by a spell or affect which targets the unit ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 3). So the spell Invocation will never heal a character that is inside a unit.

The Lore Attribute targets a Model within range, not a Unit, so a character within a unit can receive the benefit of the Lore Attribute.

I'm pretty sure you're right, this is the way I'd go with too.

- Cheers, Skarsnik.
 
Pietr Von Carstein said:
@Wargamer Thats how I think it was intended but thats not what it says. Im looking at it now, and it does not say vampiric units can only gain one wound per casting, it says vampiric models can only gain one wound per casting.
I suspect an errata/faq will address it eventually. Not that I'll be taking advantage of it. I wont be using any vampiric units and even if I was I dont think its taking advantage of the wording of the rule a little too much.

I'm with Pietr and his read of it. But it will never be an issue for me as even at the reduced price in points, I don't think Blood Knights are worth taking. Cavalry has little place in 8th edition due to Steadfast. The cav units were never intended to get bogged down in long fights. They were intended to smash and pursue. They do not function that way anymore. We'll see if the very cheap Black Knights can act as a Vampire delivery system.
 
So I finally got the book and I'm reading these rules properly. Von's got it right.

IoN doesn't specifically state that you can heal characters. Therefore, you can't heal characters. I think it's probably meant to, but it doesn't.

A power/spell/item doesn't need to specifically refer to RFW in order for it to be relevant. It's a general rule. IT is talking about THEM, not the other way around. As it stands, RFW leaves things open for a hypothetical item that will permit you to heal character. But IoN in its current wording does not.
 
Just been reading through all the comments and it seems Games Workshop have left a huge grey area with wording. Reading it, here’s my tuppence worth:

Resurrecting Fallen Warriors

'If a target consists of a single model, such as a lone character...' This doesn't, when taken with everything else that follows, suggest a lone character can be healed; this rule defines that they can't be healed more than their starting Wounds value.

'Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost Wounds cannot heal characters...' Without a clear, specifically stated exception, our Resurrecting Fallen Warriors Army rule states that we can't heal characters.

'If a character has joined a unit, only the unit will recover lost Wounds.' This covers that a character joining a unit becomes part of that unit, that they're not treated as a separate unit within the other; so this again stops them being healed.

Curse of Undeath

'...the Wizard (or another friendly model within 12") instantly recovers a single Wound lost earlier in the battle.' As the Wizard has to be a character this overrides our Resurrecting Fallen Warriors Army rule.

'...or another friendly model within 12"' A friendly model can be a character, but as it doesn't specifically state that it overrides our Resurrecting Fallen Warriors Army rule it can't be used to heal them, only other multi-Wound friendly models.

Invocation of Nehek

The spell targets a unit/units with 6", 12" or 18" and, although lone Characters count as a unit, as it doesn't specifically state it overrides our Resurrecting Fallen Warriors Army rule Characters can't be healed by it.

Summary

Our Characters can't be healed, unless they successfully cast a spell and use Curse of Undeath to heal themselves. This is the only time a character can be healed, except for Vampires with their Hunger special rule or Isabella with her Chalice.

But like everyone has said, roll on the FAQ, as it's hella confusing.
 
OK yeah so here's my take on this:

1) RFW specifically states two things in regard to characters: they cannot be taken above their starting wounds; they cannot be healed unless the spell or effect specifically says otherwise.

2) IoN specifically states that it targets ALL friendly undead units with X"

3) The BRB on page 5 specifically defines lone characters as units

IoN does give a very specific ability to heal lone characters with the undead trait since they are defined as units by the BRB. If the character is in a unit then he is no longer able to be specifically targeted as an "individual unit," and looses the ability to be healed. Additionally a character mounted on a monster could be healed as well, or his mount, since they together constitute a single unit. Though since the monster is a large target only one wound on either the rider OR the mount could be healed, as per IoN.

The only loophole I see is the lone necromancer. Technically he does indeed regain 1d6+level in wounds from IoN, even one cast by himself if he's out alone.

Pyre

p.s. Also by RAW IoN would heal 1+wizard level for Blood Knights since technically each model is only getting one wound. It would also heal one wound per wounded vargheist in a unit... which means one since its almost impossible to have wounds spread across multi-wpund models.
 
Excellent Logic Pyre, I believe that you're right on this one...But really we need the FAQ to know for sure, Hopefully before an upcoming Torny im playing in so i can get the right strategy going on...

Oh I agree, this REALLY needs an FAQ just to settle matters. Also don't get me wrong, I can see the logic of people saying it can't heal characters as well, I just think that healing characters out on their own and not in units is also the intent of the rule. It isn't broken to be able to heal vampires for one wound per casting is their out on their own, mainly because there are so many ways of killing them before the IoN ever comes into play now.

I did think of one other thing: technically wight kings on their own could be healed for d6+ level in wounds, but again I don't think that's exactly game breaking.


Pyre
 
Pyre said:
OK yeah so here's my take on this:

1) RFW specifically states two things in regard to characters: they cannot be taken above their starting wounds; they cannot be healed unless the spell or effect specifically says otherwise.

2) IoN specifically states that it targets ALL friendly undead units with X"

3) The BRB on page 5 specifically defines lone characters as units

IoN does give a very specific ability to heal lone characters with the undead trait since they are defined as units by the BRB. If the character is in a unit then he is no longer able to be specifically targeted as an "individual unit," and looses the ability to be healed. Additionally a character mounted on a monster could be healed as well, or his mount, since they together constitute a single unit. Though since the monster is a large target only one wound on either the rider OR the mount could be healed, as per IoN.

Pyre

Don't army book rules trump the main rulebook, such as High Elves interaction with ASF? So in this case, although lone characters are defined as units, because ION doesn't specifically state it heals characters then it can't?

I know it's just opinion, but I see it the other way, that Vampires received The Hunger special rule because they can't be healed, unless they successfully cast a spell and thereby benefit from Curse of Undeath; rewarding both Combat and Caster Vampires.
 
Don't army book rules trump the main rulebook, such as High Elves interaction with ASF? So in this case, although lone characters are defined as units, because ION doesn't specifically state it heals characters then it can't?

I know it's just opinion, but I see it the other way, that Vampires received The Hunger special rule because they can't be healed, unless they successfully cast a spell and thereby benefit from Curse of Undeath; rewarding both Combat and Caster Vampires.

But there's no contradiction. Nowhere in the VC book does it change the definition of solo characters, or say that they are not considered units. If anything the sentence quoted several times earlier about not going above starting wounds would support that RFW is specifically considering characters in the definition of units like chariots, monsters, etc. If the FAQ comes out and redefines something, then yes army book rules do override BRB rules, but there's nothing here to override. Individual characters are units, and IoN specifically targets all undead units.

Pyre
 
Pyre said:
Individual characters are units, and IoN specifically targets all undead units.

Pyre

That does make sense, but nowhere does ION specifically state it works on Characters. Everything in the game, whether units, lone Characters, characters in units, all count as units. As ION is a spell it's covered clearly how it interacts with characters, which are a type of unit, in the last paragraph of Resurrecting Fallen Warriors; it can't heal Characters unless it specifically states it can.

Saying that the spell targets units, Characters are units, so it can heal characters, ignores the fact it states Characters can't be healed; just because a lone Character is also a unit doesn't stop it being a Character.

Hopefully the FAQ will be clearer; I'd be happy either way, but believe what's intended is that our Characters are hard to heal now - The Hunger or Curse of Undeath, successfully casting a Lore of the Vampires spell healing 1 Wound of the casting Wizard, being the only way.

So for our characters:

Vampire characters - The Hunger or successfully casting LotV spell
Necromancer - successfully casting LotV spell
Wight King, Cain Wraith, Tomb Banshee - can't be healed
 
Mach_5 said:
Lone characters (those not in units) can be healed ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 1, sentence 2).

Characters in units cannot be healed by a spell or affect which targets the unit ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 3). So the spell Invocation will never heal a character that is inside a unit.

The Lore Attribute targets a Model within range, not a Unit, so a character within a unit can receive the benefit of the Lore Attribute.

Yep, you got it right mate. Thats how it goes:thumbsup:
 
horus1976 said:
Mach_5 said:
Lone characters (those not in units) can be healed ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 1, sentence 2).

Characters in units cannot be healed by a spell or affect which targets the unit ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 3). So the spell Invocation will never heal a character that is inside a unit.

The Lore Attribute targets a Model within range, not a Unit, so a character within a unit can receive the benefit of the Lore Attribute.

Yep, you got it right mate. Thats how it goes:thumbsup:

I completely agree with this also. I believe that is how the rules read and how I plan to play it....:thumbsup:
 
I like your logic, Pyre, and I DO believe that that's how it's meant to work, but in a purely rules lawyer sense I reckon ChildoftheNight's hit the nail on the head.

Even granting your logic (character=unit, targets all units), IoN says "targets all units" while RFW says "characters can't be healed" - as in, you can target them all you want, but it's not going to do anything.
 
This is a quote from White Dwarf Issue385. Which details some of the new stuff we get. Its in regards to a build for a vampire lord riding a Coven Throne

Her Talisman of Preservation ensures that both Character and Coven Throne will benifit from a 4_ ward save and, If things should ever go awry, >>both<<can also be healed with the Invocation of Nehek spell.

If this is anything to go by then IoN will heal characters as this Coven throne is classed as a Mount. Personaly I think they might have just copied and pasted the Tomb Kings ressurecting fallen warriors....at least Im hoping it has. The rules written for our RFW's makes no sense when combined with both our Lore Attribute and IoN. When combined with the quote from White Dwarf
 
theangels77 said:
I've noticed that they have pulled down the FAQ for VC from the Errata Section in the FAQ's on the GW website. Hopefully that means they are working on it now and we will have our answer shortly...:rolleyes:[/align]

Nah, they always remove FAQs of old books when they get new books. I'm betting it will be a few months before we see any FAQ for us.
 
Gonna suck majorly if it is a few months...Unless you have a decent opponent who will let you use Invocation of Nehek on characters or the lore attribute.....no chance other than Hunger for our Vampire characters to heal.....Wight Kings and Necromancers are screwed :(
 
Wargamer said:
theangels77 said:
I've noticed that they have pulled down the FAQ for VC from the Errata Section in the FAQ's on the GW website. Hopefully that means they are working on it now and we will have our answer shortly...:rolleyes:[/align]

Nah, they always remove FAQs of old books when they get new books. I'm betting it will be a few months before we see any FAQ for us.

Well they need to hurry up anyway, whether it's our discussion here or the fact I've got 3 opponents that refuse to play against my VC in our campaign till some rules (in their words) 'get fixed'.

On a side note: Top of their 'fixed' list is half our spells and the hexwraiths, which most of the local shops have made 'house rules' on already. Having to get the wraiths 1" from the enemy before you can run through them because you have to 'complete their movement 1" away from the the ran through one?' Zomething zounds fishy.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu