New VC - can't heal characters?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
The top line is nothing more than "water is wet" obviously you cannot take a character with 3 wounds on his profile and heal him to have 10. This had to be written somewhere. It doesn't say "YOU CAN HEAL CHARACTERS! (I can use caps too..) It says that when healing lone models such as..... you cannot take them above their starting value. (big surprise)

Such as what?

and it does not anywhere state that Characters can not be healed it says Unless specifically stated.

Name a spell or item that specifically states that a Character can be healed.

Oh and not just any spell, a spell that can resurrect models seeing that we are talking about the RFW rule.

The Hunger? No it's a special rule.

Carstein ring? No Vlad only.

Lore attribute? No, and it doesn't refer to the RFW rule so therefore is totally void of the FOOTNOTE at the bottom and CAN definitely heal Characters or mounts which are specifically models. What's more the Lore attribute says the "Wizard" who casts it gains one wound lost, it doesn't say Character, is the "wizard" not going to be a Character? Why doesn't it say the Character that cast the spell? Why doesn't it say the caster who can be a Character or the Character that cast the spell or another model (including Characters)?

Any other spells or items within our Army Book that I'm missing, how about the BRB?

IoN states ALL undead units within a range. ALL means ALL not all except Characters.
 
Abbysal said:
Do you not understand that the rules for RFW are the first paragraph only and that the 2seperate paragraphs are footnotes?

I can follow your logic that maybe it was intended to be a footnote. However as it is written, effects following RFW does not allow healing of characters.

Since this restriction will not likely been seen as offsetting the game balance, i cannot imagine it to result in an errata. At most just a FAQ that clarify that IoN cannot heal characters.
 
Abbysal said:
and it does not anywhere state that Characters can not be healed it says Unless specifically stated.

Page 26 paragraph 3: Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts. If a character joined a unit, only the unit regains wounds. Is your book missing half a page?

Name a spell or item that specifically states that a Character can be healed.

There are none, that is the whole point of paragraph 3

Oh and not just any spell, a spell that can resurrect models seeing that we are talking about the RFW rule.

You cannot heal characters by other means than the lore attribute, paragraph 3 makes it clear that spells/items do not heal them.

The Hunger? No it's a special rule.
That gives them permission to heal

Carstein ring? No Vlad only.
Gives him permission to heal

Lore attribute? No, and it doesn't refer to the RFW rule so therefore is totally void of the FOOTNOTE at the bottom and CAN definitely heal Characters or mounts which are specifically models. What's more the Lore attribute says the "Wizard" who casts it gains one wound lost, it doesn't say Character, is the "wizard" not going to be a Character? Why doesn't it say the Character that cast the spell? Why doesn't it say the caster who can be a Character or the Character that cast the spell or another model (including Characters)?

It says the wizard or one model, I use models to represent my characters, do you use potatoes? Lore attributes have nothing to do with anything written on your (half) page 26.

Any other spells or items within our Army Book that I'm missing, how about the BRB?

IoN states ALL undead units within a range. ALL means ALL not all except Characters.
It specifically states that it is all units except characters on the botton half of page 26, borrow an intact book from someone.

The last line is not a footnote, it is a rule.
 
Abbysal said:
The top line is nothing more than "water is wet" obviously you cannot take a character with 3 wounds on his profile and heal him to have 10. This had to be written somewhere. It doesn't say "YOU CAN HEAL CHARACTERS! (I can use caps too..) It says that when healing lone models such as..... you cannot take them above their starting value. (big surprise)

Such as what?

and it does not anywhere state that Characters can not be healed it says Unless specifically stated.

Name a spell or item that specifically states that a Character can be healed.

Oh and not just any spell, a spell that can resurrect models seeing that we are talking about the RFW rule.

The Hunger? No it's a special rule.

Carstein ring? No Vlad only.

Lore attribute? No, and it doesn't refer to the RFW rule so therefore is totally void of the FOOTNOTE at the bottom and CAN definitely heal Characters or mounts which are specifically models. What's more the Lore attribute says the "Wizard" who casts it gains one wound lost, it doesn't say Character, is the "wizard" not going to be a Character? Why doesn't it say the Character that cast the spell? Why doesn't it say the caster who can be a Character or the Character that cast the spell or another model (including Characters)?

Any other spells or items within our Army Book that I'm missing, how about the BRB?

IoN states ALL undead units within a range. ALL means ALL not all except Characters.

This is what has me leaning towards IoN can affect characters, and that the last sentencces should be read to only cover characters in units, where they cant be healed whereas they walk alone or mounted, they can be healed 1 point by IoN.
Had there been a single item/spell that did specifically stated 'THIS CAN BE USED TO HEAL A CHARACTER' in our book, I would have bought that IoN didnt affect characters. But since proabably ONLY the author knows what is the right interpretation of the rule, I'll just play with the interpretation that is worse for me, alas, no healing characters, until there is a faq saying otherwise
 
From what I understand, you can use a Spell from LoV, and give a model within 12 inches 1 wound back. Meaning you could effectivly give 2 wounds to a...say...Terrorgeist (IoN and the Lore Attribute.)
 
My two cents on interpreting RFW and IoN; I start with the sentence and bracket what it means/how I interpret it.

RFW:

1. “Some magic spells and items…” [VCs have the ability to restore wounds to units through spells and magic items]

2. “If the target consists of a single model…” [Single models can’t exceed their starting Wounds value]

3. “If the target is a unit of more than one model…” [What to do for units consisting of single-Wound models]

4. “In the case of multiple Wound models…” [What to do for units consisting of multiple-Wound models]

5. “Resurrected models are added to the front rank…” [How to position raised models]

6. (2nd paragraph) “Raise models may never displace…” [What to do if you don’t have room or anymore models]

7. (3rd paragraph) “A unit cannot usually be taken beyond its starting size…” [Like a single model (above), a unit cannot exceed its starting size (i.e. Wounds threshold). However, certain exceptions exist via specific rules]

8. “Unless specifically stated otherwise…” [Characters or their mounts may not be healed unless the rule provides an exception]

9. “If a character has joined a unit…” [Clarifies that characters in units do not regain wounds]

Points 2 and 7 are basically the same; they provide clarification that single models or units cannot exceed their starting Wound threshold unless a rule states otherwise.

IoN:

The spell restores wounds in a bubble per the RFW rule set described above. It does not make any of the following exceptions:

A. Allow a unit or model to be taken above its starting Wound threshold

B. Specify that a character or its mount may be healed

The lore attribute states that the wizard or another friendly model regains a wound lost earlier in the battle. Since lore attributes are Special Rules (p.491) and the attribute for the Lore of Vampires does not resurrect fallen warriors, this healing is not subject to the limitations of the RFW rule set (which only includes spells and magic items [Point 1 above]). Therefore, characters, their mounts, and other multi-wound models on the table within 12” may be healed.

In sum, IoN the spell cannot heal characters, but the lore attribute can.
 
arbogast said:
The lore attribute states that the wizard or another friendly model regains a wound lost earlier in the battle. Since lore attributes are Special Rules (p.491), this healing is not subject to the limitations of the RFW rule set (which only includes spells and magic items Point 1). Therefore, characters, their mounts, and other multi-wound models on the table within 12” may be healed.
I agree with your points, but I would say:

Since the lore attribute does not resurrect fallen warriors (p.491), this healing is not subject to the limitations of the RFW rule set.
 
2. “If the target consists of a single model…

People reading "you cannot do this!" as, you can heal all characters at will, seems to be the root cause of this problem.
A statement, is not a permission.
 
Smogg said:
arbogast said:
The lore attribute states that the wizard or another friendly model regains a wound lost earlier in the battle. Since lore attributes are Special Rules (p.491), this healing is not subject to the limitations of the RFW rule set (which only includes spells and magic items Point 1). Therefore, characters, their mounts, and other multi-wound models on the table within 12” may be healed.
I agree with your points, but I would say:

Since the lore attribute does not resurrect fallen warriors (p.491), this healing is not subject to the limitations of the RFW rule set.

:thumbsup:
 
Wow Yall must be drunk!:vampire3: page 26 says if hero joins a unit you can't just slap him with d6+ caster lvl heals! its saying same basic thing we all knew from last edition champion , then musician then rank and file. Pretty simple. just cause a hero joins a unit does not make him part of it and No he can not be resurrected In it!

Your taking very clear wording and jumbling crap out of it I am glad you guys are not translating the dead sea scrolls!!!

As for Signature spell heal any model within 12 inch or the caster gets 1 wound very clear.

As for ION its a bubble even says vamps , ethereal and large targets only get 1 wound when healed this way!!

You can argue and blah blah blah till cows come home if you want to be :thumbsdown: until your :grave: sure ! I am sure your opponents would be happy to face roll your non healing VC army!:O

I will Play it as it is intended. get any lawyer to read over all rules you mention and wording they will tell you exactly that!

I couldn't even read all comments some were so dumb!! From veteran's too! this thread is FAIL!
Call up writer and ask him to clarify it for you since you seem to need a FAQ for some basic wording you are misinterpreting !
 
Thanks Smogg for linking my post twice!! No trolling here just common sense and I can read and understand, what i am reading seems quite a few on here can not!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu