Sanai said:
I dont see how no bloodlines lacks character. My vampires are plenty characterful. My strigoi is a strigoi through and through
I don't mind no bloodlines either, but We're the exception here.
There's two different kinds of diversity going on here. One is the amount of diversity you can cram into a single army, and the other is the diversity of armies produced by a single book. A sublist/bloodline approach produces more shoehorned armies, but you can see and feel how your vamp counts army is different from someone else's. A non sublist/bloodline approach is more open, you can pick more units for your army, but it doesn't feel as unique from someone else's. Even if they didn't choose all the same options as you, they could have.
I'm a one-of-everything kind of player who usually goes for the vanilla options (vanilla marines, black legion chaos marines, undivided chaos warriors, von carsteins - adding emissaries from the other bloodlines after the new book let me do so), so my preference is pretty strongly one way, but I can understand those who prefer otherwise.
Still, though, most of the bloodlines are pretty well represented by the current rules. You want poor casting melee vamps in armor? you got it. Heavy casting vamps without armor? you got it. hybrid vamps? got that, too. Strigoi and Lahmian vamps, though, they aren't terribly well represented in the current book, since there's nothing to distinguish lahmian vamps from the von carsteinish hybrid vamps, and hybrid vamp set ups always end up feeling more voncarsteinish (heavily armored, etc).
Strigoi are even worse. Unarmed, unarmored melee vamps? How do you even pretend that's viable under the current book, especially in 8th edition? You end up going for serious wysiwig violations ("tough hide" counting as armor, "enchanted claws" counting as magic weapons, etc). The army list has the unit options to make a strigoi army, but the vampires are notably not there.
I expect to see the return of other bloodlines because of the terrorgheist model. Why would they bother creating a completely non-functional vampire model? Because that's what the ghoul king is. At the very least, they'll make unarmored melee vamps possible, I expect (a regen bloodline that prevents the bearer from wearing armor?).
More likely, to me at least, there will be exactly five vampyric powers, one for each bloodline, and every vampire in your army will need to take the same one. No statline modifications, no sublists, no unit restrictions - themed lists beyond that are up to the player. Bloodlines with the absolute minimum muss & fuss. Probably use USRs for it. Something like: Lahmia = Always Strike First,
VC=+1 combat res, Blood Dragons = heroic killing blow, Nechrarch = loremaster, Strigoi = I don't know, something to make them function without weapons & armor. Maybe a combo package of regen, poison, hatred, and 2x close combat weapons, but no options for other mundane or magical weapons or armor?
Anyway, that's how I'd do bloodlines myself.