But we're still addressing each others' points!
Uziel said:
-You are missing the point I am trying to get across. Two Vampires naturally belong to the same army, i.e the Vampire Counts army, and it would be natural for them to have a pecking order. The days are long gone when the Vampire Counts army was a general undead army. I don't mind a necromancer army at all, I just don't see the wisdom in building one based on the Vampire Counts list, on the grounds that I have stated numerous times.
And I don't see the wisdom in building it anywhere else given that every single unit would be the same, with the only expecption being that necromancer lords would
also be an option. Where else would the army be different? skeletons? check. Ghouls? check. Zombies? check. Wights? check. corpse carts? check. animal zombies - fell bats, bat swarms, & dire wolves? check. Wraiths & banshees? check. Maybe not blood knights, but honestly when 90% of the army list should be the same, it's easy to see that this book is where the 'necromancer' army, and it's
necro lord, belong.
-Not arguing against necromancers having been important story-wise in warhammer, but again, we are still talking about the Vampire Counts book, and not the Undead book of old.
There are two undead books. One for the Nehekharan undead, and one for the old world undead. We both apparently agree that necromancer armies should be an option - which of those books, then, do they go in? The answer is easy. The one with all the units that fit the necromancer army fluff. ie, the old world undead book, the Vamp Counts.
this is not really as much about right or wrong, as it is about preferense to be honest.
That's just it, though. All it takes is including the
necro lord as an option, and both our preferences are covered. I can field my
necro lord. You can stick with your vamp lord. Everyone wins.
-I would hope though,that the basis for a new Vampire counts army book has its focus after the Storm of Chaos. If one is supposed to drag along every piece of history into the current book, then you might as well bring Nagash back as well (in which case it shouldn't be Vampire Counts any longer).
Given that vamp counts armies have always had special characters from the past in them dating back to before there even was a vamp counts book, I don't think it's fair to throw out the historical perspective. Unless you would argue that Vlad and Konrad should also be dropped from any book going forward?
We use the stories of what happened with the named characters to inform the options within a book, including for generic versions of those characters, and named necromancer lords are a big part of the fluff for the old world undead armies that the vamp counts book represents.
For me it is about keeping a strong theme for the army, and making the Vampire Counts "keep with the times" as it were. If the next book retains its strong Von Carstein theme, I suspect that it may have some new units in store, based on the fact that Vardek Crom's horde was finally slaughtered in Sylvania, thus strengthening Mannfred.
Perhaps, but I think you'll find that many players want the bloodlines and the necromancers back, rather then be shoehorned not only into a single theme of von carsteins, but even a single subtheme of modern von carsteins under mannfred only.
The case I am making though, is that the army lists GW have made so far, ALWAYS represent current day armies, so Vampires would in fact have learned the lesson of Konrad.
The existence of Vlad as a special character in every vampire counts book since before there were vampire counts books shows this statement to be somewhat false. And again, while 'manfred' may have learned a lesson from konrad (not really, since he always valued the arcane over the physical, to such an extent that he was an aberration among his bloodline), there is nothing to say other bloodlines would have learned the same lesson. The lesson of Konrad to most vampires would be to not lose yourself to your bestial nature, rather then refusing to work with non-vampyric necromancers.
Sure, you can play special characters that might be dead at the moment (Vlad or Konrad), but that is the exception rahter than the rule.
# of dead or past special characters in current vamp book: 4. Number of current special characters in current vamp book: 1. The current character is the exception.
Didn't you claim earlier that it would be "natural" for Blood Dragons to seek out Necromancer Lords to raise their armies to conquer, much as the Von Carsteins do?
Don't recall that, but I might have. Von carsteins relying on necromancers for the bulk of their army would be an exception (although one that existed in Konrad), although von carsteins refusing to use necromancers at all is also an exception (present only in Manfred).
-Every army list creates a framework, based around a strong a theme as possible, thus naturally creating limitations which forces us players to make choices /i.e being forced to choose certain things). Even just something like "Dwarfs" is a limitation which help focus the theme of an army arter all.
The old world undead theme that the vampire counts had in their first two books, a theme that allowed for necromancer lords, is certainly focused enough to sustain an army. And in any event, a magic heavy
necro army with a mix of units will have a stronger thematic similarity to a magic heavy necrarch army or a diverse von carstein army then either would have to a bezzare monster/ghoul
horde led by a bestial strigoi. I happen to think there's room for all of them in the vamp counts book - I love the diversity of the army, and it's the reason I chose vamp counts over the all skeletons all the time tomb kings in the first place.
When I mean effective, I mean effective so that your Core units (and I suspect Ghouls will be seriously reduced so that they won't beome the typical core choice any longer btw) can stand up to the other Core units in the game, which also have characters among them in all likelyhood.
What are you talking about? Melee heroes are pretty meh in 8th edition. They net you, what, 2? 3 extra kills a round if they're good? When units are throwing out 40 or so attacks a round, those 3 mean very little, while a wizard tossing out a buff spell can serve as a force multiplier - less reliable due to the fickle nature of the magic phase, but far more explosive when they work. A melee hero likely just gets chopped down in a round or two these days, barring something like a reverse save dark elf.
The days when lousy undead troops could be brought up to par by peppering their front ranks with fighty heroes are just gone, and they won't be back this edition. Nowadays, you need to run good troops. That's why ghouls are better then skeletons right now. Ghouls have a chance of winning combat, or breaking even, or at least not losing so bad, with their almost respectable T4 and their many poison attacks. Skeletons could be half their current points, and ghouls would still be the better choice, because they'd be
capable of winning combat if you got off some magical support. But that's a conversation that has absolutely nothing to do with
necro lords, because most vamp players run bunkered caster vamp lords anyway, so there's no difference there, other then a
necro lord being theoretically a cheaper option, allowing for more troops and more fighty heroes to begin with.
If you're not going for extremly cheesy options such as a full front rank of Carn Wraiths etc, you are going to struggle to win combats, and you will crumble all to quickly. The hero options in a Necromancer army don't exactly kill a lot of enemy models in close combat each turn.
Neither do any fighty heroes. Vamp heroes certainly don't. And even armored up, they're going to get chopped down by enemy units. Fighty heroes are pretty meh in 8th edition. Again, though, people already bunker their vamp lords, so the idea that people might bunker a
necro lord doesn't make these units any more vulnerable then they already are, and it's not like I'm arguing that the melee vamp lord option be removed - far to the contrary, I'd rather see it greatly improved. I'd just also like to see a
necro lord option.
I do think the armies will get bigger, but that also means that the Core of the army can't really get that much better. The fact that fielding Skeletons and Zombies in a Horde formation is quite suicidal under the 8 ed rules, tells me that something needs to be done with the troops, and not the ability to raise them more rapidly by allowing a Necromancer Lord in a Vampire Counts army.
Who said a
necro lord would raise them more rapidly? I expect raising of units to get harder in any new book regardless, based purely on the treatment of the tomb kings book. The point is that no matter what happens, undead will in general be largely magic dependent - it's part of what makes undead in warhammer - and I'd like to see a cheaper option for supplying the baseline level of that magic, allowing players who want to to spend more points on troops and other heroes.
Putting a vamp lord in the front of your skeletons to punch things won't make them a good unit. It will just guarantee that your vamp lord will lose every round of combat. Fighty heroes don't make up for lousy units by personal killing power these days. That's a completely non-functional model. Only unit-wide buffs can make up for lousy units, be they magical or otherwise. The tomb kings MWBD is a good model, and one I'd like to see echoed in a vamp counts book. make vamp bloodline powers passive things that energize nearby undead through the creatures sheer unholy presence. Passive, reliable buffs based on bloodline that grant benefits worth paying the extra cost for, where the necromancer, while cheaper, needs to rely on the fickle magic phase to buff his troops up to reasonable competence.
But, again, I don't see this as an argument for or against the inclusion of
necro lords. No, the inherent problems with the suckiness of the undead ruleset in 8th edition aren't solved by the inclusion of a
necro lord. But they aren't solved by the exclusion of
necro lords, either, and they certainly aren't solved by requiring players to field expensive and vulnerable melee heroes.
I'm not suggesting the inclusion of
necro lords to solve the 'how are undead supposed to function in 8th' problem, I'm suggesting the inclusion of
necro lords to solve the 'why the hell can't I field a
necro lord' problem.
One aspect we haven't discussed btw, is what kind of a Necromancer Lord are you talking about rule-wise.
Just wanting them is really enough wishlisting for me, I've wasted way too much time on that activity over the years, but purely for the sake of example of how a
necro lord 'could' work (rather then necessarily how I think they 'should' or 'will'):
Human wizard lord statline, third level caster, can upgrade to 4th for the usual cost, standard undead special rules. Can use lore of Necromancy, or death, or shadow, but the army general must be the wizard with the highest leadership, and that wizard must use the lore of necromancy. Notably the
necro lord would have lower leadership then a vampire lord, and the vampire hero would be raised up to equal leadership.
Necro lord is not a vampire, and does not allow nearby troops to march just by his presence unless he is the army general, and even then only 6" range.
lore of necromancy: replaces lore of vampires. No special rules for necromancy spells. No picking spells. signature spell is invocation, restores d6 wounds to a nearby unit. heightened versions allow 2d6 split between two units, or 3d6 split between three units. no healing heroes, monsters can only heal one wound per casting, cavalry halve the number of wounds restored, rounding up.
Other spells a mix of utility, buff, hexe, and damage. Utility: create nearby zombie unit augment for more zombies. Buffs: movement spell, augment to allow charge; grant one target ASF, augment for re-rolls to hit. Hex: penalty on fear & terror tests, aug prevents use of general's leadership & bsb reroll for fear & terror tests. Damage: Magic missile that forces panic test, augment more damage & penalty on the test; Curse of years, aug prevents ward saves. I don't know. I'm not necessarily saying a more 'regular lore' is the direction I want the army to head in, it's just what I expect and what I'm planning around at this point, again based on looking at what happened to the tomb kings.
Lore attribute: if you successfully cast a spell from the necromancy lore and the opponent dispels it, roll a die. On a 4+, you may immediately attempt to cast the same spell with the same wizard again.
Aaand, that's it. In contrast vampire lords: they would allow marching just for being nearby, they would have a better stat line, they would start at a lower wizard level, but could be bought up to four if they so desired for the usual cost. Every vampire in the army would have the same bloodline attribute, a passive bonus in addition to the ability to march for nearby undead. Von carsteins reduce crumble wounds, necrarchs make undead easier to rez, strigoi confer hatred, blood dragons re-roll to wound, lahmia ... I don't know, something, I'm just tossing ideas out here. In addition, vampires would have access to unique special abilities that make them powerful but expensive, including as casters if they desire. For instance, a vampyric necrarch caster could be a loremaster, but that ability would be out of the reach of necromancers, or other vampires, for that matter.
As for your ideas, I don't see the current structure for magic staying. I think some of the concepts will stay, but the lore will look and act much more like a regular lore. That's just how they're doing magic these days - see ogre gut magic, which is now a regular lore, or tomb kings magic, now a regular lore. I see no reason to limit the necromancer's caster level to 3 or restrict their items allowance. For one it defeats the point of ditching the stupid 'necromancers suck, screw you if you like them' mentality of the current book, for another it's not necessary to make vampire's cool, they'll already have access to special powers and vampire-only items.
As a final point, I'd just like to come back to my key issues. First: Necromancers are a core part of undead fluff in warhammer, the current book does a terrible job of representing them, their army would be exactly the same as the vamp counts army, just with a
necro lord in it, so why not? Second: what does it cost you for me to have the option? Only one of us here is saying that the other person's fun is somehow badwrong.