New Vc wave could be incoming (Should rumourmongers be believed).

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I'm definately with Sanai here. Here is why:

-You can't use that it is possible in Storm of Magic to have them together as allies, as a good justification as to why they should be in the same army. By this reasoning, you could as well include a Razorgor Herd or a Zoat for that matter, as they can be bound as well in the Storm of Magic rules. The pacts in Storm of Magic are TEMPORARY at best, and even the rules support this (i.e. they use the rules for ALLIES in the rulebook).
-I you go by Storm of Magic, then just about EVERYONE can bind vampires., not just Necromancers. But again, this can be quite temporary, meaning that long-term control would be next to impossible (again, even Nagash failed). Vampires are much to dangerous to try to have as pets. I suggest you re-read the Von Carstein triology to get a deeper understanding as to the beast within that rule a vampire's existence. If they CAN kill you and take power, they WILL do so sooner or later (especially the Von Carsteins). It would simply be much to dangerous for a Necromancer to attempt to do so. At some point, he would be physically vunlerable, and then he'd be dead, and not in a good way. Vampires are not good at sharing power...
-A Necromancer Lord with a Vampire thrall serving him would never be able to trust him, and the vampire would surely kill him for his knowledge as soon as he was able to. He is but a mere mortal after all.

No, you don't have to bring along a Vampire Thrall, but this IS a Vampire Counts army, suggesting a Vampire Theme to our opponents. Kind of strange if you don't have to bring them along... This is one of many reasons why I think Necromancers would be better served with their own army book.

As to the idea that a Vampire would leave the running of his army to a necromancer lord; I suggest you take a closer look at the second Von Carstein Triology book again, the one about Konrad. Not truly being in charge of one's own army is a sign of weakness, something that Vampires can ill afford... The lesson of Kondrad would probably be known to most vampires, he was quite infamous after all...

I agree with you that I don't think the vampire lord will be improved so that it is a good idea to keep him in the front lines. But to keep the same crubling troops, with no real characters to keep them from loosing close combats, and then having two Lord level Necromancers (Necromancer lord and Vampire Lord) for summoning purposes, or having two or more pure Necromancer Lords in a pure Necromancer army, is NOt the way to fix things in my opinion. Making the army even more dependent on summoning troops is the wrong way to go. Wouldn't you rather have troops (other than special and reare choices)that could hold their own to a larger extent in close combat in the first place, instead of increasing dependency on the randomness of magic in 8 ed?
Actually rolling some dice for your troops, and seeing them kill something for a change is much more satisfying than again and again getting to re-raise the dead, just to see them massacred over and over again.
A typical game is only 6 turns, and NOT getting your units destroyed by saving them with spells, is certainly not the same as WINNING.. Just saying.. This particularly goes for Skeletons and Zombies, which I imagine would be a major part of a Necromancer led army...
 
Underlings plotting to murder and then doing away with their commanders is a pretty common thing in a number of Warhammer armies, like Skaven or Chaos or greenskins. Just because the situation is unstable or a bad idea doesn't mean that it won't happen. The games played would just be the battles fought before the vampire made his or her move.

A Lahmian vampire might be more than happy to manipulate the necromancer, essentially pursuing her own interests through the use of her Necromancer figurehead.

It should be noted that in our previous army book, the master necromancer was more powerful magically than any vampire save a Necrarch. Only Necrarchs and master necromancers could be level 4 wizards. So it's certainly possible that a master necromancer could use his superior magic to bind a lesser vampire to his will.

Alternatively, the necromancer might just have something the vampire wants. Magical knowledge. A means for revenge. An item the vampire is obsessed with.
 
Von Calyptra said:
Alternatively, the necromancer might just have something the vampire wants. Magical knowledge. A means for revenge. An item the vampire is obsessed with.

To which I say the Vampire wouldn't hesitate to kill him and take it. Why wait?

But, offcourse. One can always make up a story to support any given scenario, no matter how unlikely. What I'm arguing for is that there is precious little evidence that a vampire would be led by a Necromancer (and I don't consider Nagash just a Necromancer btw), and that both aspects (Vampires and Great Necromancers) would be best served with seperate army books. Cramming them both into the same list only serves to undermine their respective lores and the fluff surrounding them.

I know that we all don't share the same opinions on this, and that is fine. Just stating mine, and stating why I have my opinions in the first place. Not taht it matters much, as I guess none of us are working on the official 8 ed VC book anyway.
I just hope that when we first get a hard cover VC book, that it is a good one, buth fluff-wise and is more tactically flexible than the current one, for competitive play.
 
Tim said:
@Malisteen you make perfect sense to me, and I totally agree. Rate up!
[video=youtube]http://youtu.be/Ufuo1eeKY0c[/video]

Uziel said:
-You can't use that it is possible in Storm of Magic to have them together as allies, as a good justification as to why they should be in the same army.

Actually, a solid point, what is possible when the winds of magic blow may not be possible otherwise. I'll accept this point.

-A Necromancer Lord with a Vampire thrall serving him would never be able to trust him, and the vampire would surely kill him for his knowledge as soon as he was able to. He is but a mere mortal after all.

How is this any different between a necromancer and a vampire then between two vampires? By that basis, vampires shouldn't ever be an option in a vampire counts army, because no matter who the lord is its no guarantee that the thralls wouldn't turn on them. Sire's can't even control their progeny - Mannfred betrayed Vlad. Melkoir betrayed Wosoran, and was betrayed by Zacharias in turn.

It's part of the nature of playing an 'evil' army. And in any event, it's not like stable partnerships between Vampires and Necromancers haven't been formed in the past. Again, Ushoran and Kadon.

No, you don't have to bring along a Vampire Thrall, but this IS a Vampire Counts army, suggesting a Vampire Theme to our opponents. Kind of strange if you don't have to bring them along... This is one of many reasons why I think Necromancers would be better served with their own army book.

This is a better argument for changing the name then for banning necromancers. Again, Necromancers leading armies of the undead against the living is an archetypal story in the warhammer world, at least as archetypal as that of vampires doing the same, and lesser vampires have frequently served as lieutenants in these forces, willingly or not, dating all the way back to the armies of Nagash himself. This is an iconic concept that should exist in the game. What would that army look like? Exactly like the vampire counts army, only with lord level necros as an option. Since there's no way that could sustain its own book, since it's pathetically easy to represent in the current book, since there's no reason why vampires and necromancers couldn't work together in the fluff (and they have in the past), I see really no reason to oppose it. The only question then is whether the name of the army should be changed. Personally, I like the name, and the existence of another undead army precludes the obvious alternative, so I don't mind.

As to the idea that a Vampire would leave the running of his army to a necromancer lord; I suggest you take a closer look at the second Von Carstein Triology book again, the one about Konrad. Not truly being in charge of one's own army is a sign of weakness, something that Vampires can ill afford... The lesson of Kondrad would probably be known to most vampires, he was quite infamous after all...

The lesson of Konrad that you seem to be missing is that this was done in the past and is an iconic part of the vamp counts history and fluff. So it didn't work out for Konrad. So be it, the point is that it happened. Having apprentice vampires famously didn't work out for Wosoran or Melcoir, would you argue that Necrarch armies should be banned from including vampires other then the general? And the biases of a magically-focused Von Carstein likely wouldn't hold for, say, the Blood Dragons, who look down on the study of magic.

The fact that this worked poorly for Konrad is not an argument against allowing it. The fact that Konrad did this in the first place, however, is a very good argument for allowing it.

I agree with you that I don't think the vampire lord will be improved so that it is a good idea to keep him in the front lines. But to keep the same crubling troops, with no real characters to keep them from loosing close combats, and then having two Lord level Necromancers (Necromancer lord and Vampire Lord) for summoning purposes, or having two or more pure Necromancer Lords in a pure Necromancer army, is NOt the way to fix things in my opinion

It's about having the option, not forcing people into it. And besides, with wights, wraiths, and, yes, vampires, who's to say an army with a necromancer lord would have no effective characters to bolster their ranks with? And if cheap characters were available to fill the magic requirements of the army, the army itself could be bigger, making rezzing less of a requirement since there would be more troops, and indeed other fighty heroes, on the table in the first place.
 
Malisteen said:
Tim said:
@Malisteen you make perfect sense to me, and I totally agree. Rate up!
[video=youtube]http://youtu.be/Ufuo1eeKY0c[/video]

You have a coonvert. Congratulations. hehe :vampire3:

Uziel said:
-You can't use that it is possible in Storm of Magic to have them together as allies, as a good justification as to why they should be in the same army.

Actually, a solid point, what is possible when the winds of magic blow may not be possible otherwise. I'll accept this point.

-A Necromancer Lord with a Vampire thrall serving him would never be able to trust him, and the vampire would surely kill him for his knowledge as soon as he was able to. He is but a mere mortal after all.

How is this any different between a necromancer and a vampire then between two vampires? By that basis, vampires shouldn't ever be an option in a vampire counts army, because no matter who the lord is its no guarantee that the thralls wouldn't turn on them. Sire's can't even control their progeny - Mannfred betrayed Vlad. Melkoir betrayed Wosoran, and was betrayed by Zacharias in turn.

It's part of the nature of playing an 'evil' army. And in any event, it's not like stable partnerships between Vampires and Necromancers haven't been formed in the past. Again, Ushoran and Kadon.

-You are missing the point I am trying to get across. Two Vampires naturally belong to the same army, i.e the Vampire Counts army, and it would be natural for them to have a pecking order. The days are long gone when the Vampire Counts army was a general undead army. I don't mind a necromancer army at all, I just don't see the wisdom in building one based on the Vampire Counts list, on the grounds that I have stated numerous times.

No, you don't have to bring along a Vampire Thrall, but this IS a Vampire Counts army, suggesting a Vampire Theme to our opponents. Kind of strange if you don't have to bring them along... This is one of many reasons why I think Necromancers would be better served with their own army book.

This is a better argument for changing the name then for banning necromancers. Again, Necromancers leading armies of the undead against the living is an archetypal story in the warhammer world, at least as archetypal as that of vampires doing the same, and lesser vampires have frequently served as lieutenants in these forces, willingly or not, dating all the way back to the armies of Nagash himself. This is an iconic concept that should exist in the game. What would that army look like? Exactly like the vampire counts army, only with lord level necros as an option. Since there's no way that could sustain its own book, since it's pathetically easy to represent in the current book, since there's no reason why vampires and necromancers couldn't work together in the fluff (and they have in the past), I see really no reason to oppose it. The only question then is whether the name of the army should be changed. Personally, I like the name, and the existence of another undead army precludes the obvious alternative, so I don't mind.

-Not arguing against necromancers having been important story-wise in warhammer, but again, we are still talking about the Vampire Counts book, and not the Undead book of old.
Can't really recall any Vampire Thralls in Necromancer led armies though, and if one has to use Nagash as an exampe of a comparable Necromancer, then that is stretching the comparison more than a little bit. Can't remember the likes of Kemmler ever having dealings with Vampires, nor the Doomlord of Middenheim, etc...
But again, this is not really as much about right or wrong, as it is about preferense to be honest.

As to the idea that a Vampire would leave the running of his army to a necromancer lord; I suggest you take a closer look at the second Von Carstein Triology book again, the one about Konrad. Not truly being in charge of one's own army is a sign of weakness, something that Vampires can ill afford... The lesson of Kondrad would probably be known to most vampires, he was quite infamous after all...

The lesson of Konrad that you seem to be missing is that this was done in the past and is an iconic part of the vamp counts history and fluff. So it didn't work out for Konrad. So be it, the point is that it happened. Having apprentice vampires famously didn't work out for Wosoran or Melcoir, would you argue that Necrarch armies should be banned from including vampires other then the general? And the biases of a magically-focused Von Carstein likely wouldn't hold for, say, the Blood Dragons, who look down on the study of magic.

The fact that this worked poorly for Konrad is not an argument against allowing it. The fact that Konrad did this in the first place, however, is a very good argument for allowing it.

-I would hope though,that the basis for a new Vampire counts army book has its focus after the Storm of Chaos. If one is supposed to drag along every piece of history into the current book, then you might as well bring Nagash back as well (in which case it shouldn't be Vampire Counts any longer).
I certainly wouldn't bann other vampires than the general. Even though they know the risks, sooner or later nearly all vampires sire offstpring after all. Wouldn't like to see Wsoran or Melcoir again though as special characters though, as they are pretty irrelevant present time.
For me it is about keeping a strong theme for the army, and making the Vampire Counts "keep with the times" as it were. If the next book retains its strong Von Carstein theme, I suspect that it may have some new units in store, based on the fact that Vardek Crom's horde was finally slaughtered in Sylvania, thus strengthening Mannfred.
The case I am making though, is that the army lists GW have made so far, ALWAYS represent current day armies, so Vampires would in fact have learned the lesson of Konrad.
Sure, you can play special characters that might be dead at the moment (Vlad or Konrad), but that is the exception rahter than the rule.
Didn't you claim earlier that it would be "natural" for Blood Dragons to seek out Necromancer Lords to raise their armies to conquer, much as the Von Carsteins do?

I agree with you that I don't think the vampire lord will be improved so that it is a good idea to keep him in the front lines. But to keep the same crubling troops, with no real characters to keep them from loosing close combats, and then having two Lord level Necromancers (Necromancer lord and Vampire Lord) for summoning purposes, or having two or more pure Necromancer Lords in a pure Necromancer army, is NOt the way to fix things in my opinion

It's about having the option, not forcing people into it. And besides, with wights, wraiths, and, yes, vampires, who's to say an army with a necromancer lord would have no effective characters to bolster their ranks with? And if cheap characters were available to fill the magic requirements of the army, the army itself could be bigger, making rezzing less of a requirement since there would be more troops, and indeed other fighty heroes, on the table in the first place.

-Every army list creates a framework, based around a strong a theme as possible, thus naturally creating limitations which forces us players to make choices /i.e being forced to choose certain things). Even just something like "Dwarfs" is a limitation which help focus the theme of an army arter all.
When I mean effective, I mean effective so that your Core units (and I suspect Ghouls will be seriously reduced so that they won't beome the typical core choice any longer btw) can stand up to the other Core units in the game, which also have characters among them in all likelyhood. If you're not going for extremly cheesy options such as a full front rank of Carn Wraiths etc, you are going to struggle to win combats, and you will crumble all to quickly. The hero options in a Necromancer army don't exactly kill a lot of enemy models in close combat each turn. I do think the armies will get bigger, but that also means that the Core of the army can't really get that much better. The fact that fielding Skeletons and Zombies in a Horde formation is quite suicidal under the 8 ed rules, tells me that something needs to be done with the troops, and not the ability to raise them more rapidly by allowing a Necromancer Lord in a Vampire Counts army.
At best, I see Skeleton Warriors maybe being able to go toe-to-toe with the Spearmen of the Empire, but that is probably wishful thinking too. You still need the ability to occationally cause a Break Test once in a while, without the aid of Lords and Heroes.
With nearly every other Core choice being cheaper than ours, the removal of outnumbering, and a lot more models that get to fight, as well as the nerfing of fear, something needs to be done with the Core of our armies. This is not solved by bringing along a Necromancer Lord. I would much rather see that fixed, than to go back to trying to fix this issue by getting a cheap Necromancer Lord to raise more fallen warriors. I'm just guessing here, but I don't think we will be able to raise skeleton warriors/ghouls to beyond their starting number in 8 ed when the new book comes, in which case it will be even less of a viable tactic. With magic being the chance game it has become in 8 ed, we shouldn't hope that this is the way GW chooses to go. It would be a very poor fix at best, and also a step away from the strong Vampire theme itself.

-One aspect we haven't discussed btw, is what kind of a Necromancer Lord are you talking about rule-wise. I noticed that you avoided this subject earlier. How would you propose his lore and magic level should work? Should he have more than the current 3 Necromancy spells? Access to other Lores? Any new pure Necromancy spells perhaps? Just nice to know what you are arguing for including in the army vampire army list, or a pure necromancer led list for that matter.
My personal opinion, is that IF one is included, he should be lvl 3 only, with the Necromancy spells already chosen. Maybe you could buy a couple of new Necromancy spells (entirely new ones)for him at a set point cost or something similar in a pure Necromancer army (maybe he had a tome granting him a unique spell). I'd also limit him to 75 pts of magic items. No access to other spell lores (almost goes without saying in my mind). Bringing back anything resembling the Nagash "Jr's" from the old days (4.th and 5th ed) would certainly be a step in the wrong direction in my opinion.

-It is already clear that we don't agree on what we wish for in a new Vampire Counts/Undead (I for one am not really discussing an Undead book as such primarily)army book, so I don't really see this discussion going anywhere. Still, it is good that we all have different opinions, and as I've said earlier, it matters little what we think in the end, as GW will make the calls in any case. We can only hope that we do get what we respectivly want to see included in the lists.
 
I think it is time to agree to disagree and move on. You guys aren't going to convince each other. Just accept it and move on.

Power to the Necromancers!
 
But we're still addressing each others' points!

Uziel said:
-You are missing the point I am trying to get across. Two Vampires naturally belong to the same army, i.e the Vampire Counts army, and it would be natural for them to have a pecking order. The days are long gone when the Vampire Counts army was a general undead army. I don't mind a necromancer army at all, I just don't see the wisdom in building one based on the Vampire Counts list, on the grounds that I have stated numerous times.

And I don't see the wisdom in building it anywhere else given that every single unit would be the same, with the only expecption being that necromancer lords would also be an option. Where else would the army be different? skeletons? check. Ghouls? check. Zombies? check. Wights? check. corpse carts? check. animal zombies - fell bats, bat swarms, & dire wolves? check. Wraiths & banshees? check. Maybe not blood knights, but honestly when 90% of the army list should be the same, it's easy to see that this book is where the 'necromancer' army, and it's necro lord, belong.

-Not arguing against necromancers having been important story-wise in warhammer, but again, we are still talking about the Vampire Counts book, and not the Undead book of old.

There are two undead books. One for the Nehekharan undead, and one for the old world undead. We both apparently agree that necromancer armies should be an option - which of those books, then, do they go in? The answer is easy. The one with all the units that fit the necromancer army fluff. ie, the old world undead book, the Vamp Counts.


this is not really as much about right or wrong, as it is about preferense to be honest.

That's just it, though. All it takes is including the necro lord as an option, and both our preferences are covered. I can field my necro lord. You can stick with your vamp lord. Everyone wins.

-I would hope though,that the basis for a new Vampire counts army book has its focus after the Storm of Chaos. If one is supposed to drag along every piece of history into the current book, then you might as well bring Nagash back as well (in which case it shouldn't be Vampire Counts any longer).

Given that vamp counts armies have always had special characters from the past in them dating back to before there even was a vamp counts book, I don't think it's fair to throw out the historical perspective. Unless you would argue that Vlad and Konrad should also be dropped from any book going forward?

We use the stories of what happened with the named characters to inform the options within a book, including for generic versions of those characters, and named necromancer lords are a big part of the fluff for the old world undead armies that the vamp counts book represents.

For me it is about keeping a strong theme for the army, and making the Vampire Counts "keep with the times" as it were. If the next book retains its strong Von Carstein theme, I suspect that it may have some new units in store, based on the fact that Vardek Crom's horde was finally slaughtered in Sylvania, thus strengthening Mannfred.

Perhaps, but I think you'll find that many players want the bloodlines and the necromancers back, rather then be shoehorned not only into a single theme of von carsteins, but even a single subtheme of modern von carsteins under mannfred only.


The case I am making though, is that the army lists GW have made so far, ALWAYS represent current day armies, so Vampires would in fact have learned the lesson of Konrad.

The existence of Vlad as a special character in every vampire counts book since before there were vampire counts books shows this statement to be somewhat false. And again, while 'manfred' may have learned a lesson from konrad (not really, since he always valued the arcane over the physical, to such an extent that he was an aberration among his bloodline), there is nothing to say other bloodlines would have learned the same lesson. The lesson of Konrad to most vampires would be to not lose yourself to your bestial nature, rather then refusing to work with non-vampyric necromancers.

Sure, you can play special characters that might be dead at the moment (Vlad or Konrad), but that is the exception rahter than the rule.
# of dead or past special characters in current vamp book: 4. Number of current special characters in current vamp book: 1. The current character is the exception.

Didn't you claim earlier that it would be "natural" for Blood Dragons to seek out Necromancer Lords to raise their armies to conquer, much as the Von Carsteins do?

Don't recall that, but I might have. Von carsteins relying on necromancers for the bulk of their army would be an exception (although one that existed in Konrad), although von carsteins refusing to use necromancers at all is also an exception (present only in Manfred).

-Every army list creates a framework, based around a strong a theme as possible, thus naturally creating limitations which forces us players to make choices /i.e being forced to choose certain things). Even just something like "Dwarfs" is a limitation which help focus the theme of an army arter all.

The old world undead theme that the vampire counts had in their first two books, a theme that allowed for necromancer lords, is certainly focused enough to sustain an army. And in any event, a magic heavy necro army with a mix of units will have a stronger thematic similarity to a magic heavy necrarch army or a diverse von carstein army then either would have to a bezzare monster/ghoul horde led by a bestial strigoi. I happen to think there's room for all of them in the vamp counts book - I love the diversity of the army, and it's the reason I chose vamp counts over the all skeletons all the time tomb kings in the first place.

When I mean effective, I mean effective so that your Core units (and I suspect Ghouls will be seriously reduced so that they won't beome the typical core choice any longer btw) can stand up to the other Core units in the game, which also have characters among them in all likelyhood.

What are you talking about? Melee heroes are pretty meh in 8th edition. They net you, what, 2? 3 extra kills a round if they're good? When units are throwing out 40 or so attacks a round, those 3 mean very little, while a wizard tossing out a buff spell can serve as a force multiplier - less reliable due to the fickle nature of the magic phase, but far more explosive when they work. A melee hero likely just gets chopped down in a round or two these days, barring something like a reverse save dark elf.

The days when lousy undead troops could be brought up to par by peppering their front ranks with fighty heroes are just gone, and they won't be back this edition. Nowadays, you need to run good troops. That's why ghouls are better then skeletons right now. Ghouls have a chance of winning combat, or breaking even, or at least not losing so bad, with their almost respectable T4 and their many poison attacks. Skeletons could be half their current points, and ghouls would still be the better choice, because they'd be capable of winning combat if you got off some magical support. But that's a conversation that has absolutely nothing to do with necro lords, because most vamp players run bunkered caster vamp lords anyway, so there's no difference there, other then a necro lord being theoretically a cheaper option, allowing for more troops and more fighty heroes to begin with.


If you're not going for extremly cheesy options such as a full front rank of Carn Wraiths etc, you are going to struggle to win combats, and you will crumble all to quickly. The hero options in a Necromancer army don't exactly kill a lot of enemy models in close combat each turn.

Neither do any fighty heroes. Vamp heroes certainly don't. And even armored up, they're going to get chopped down by enemy units. Fighty heroes are pretty meh in 8th edition. Again, though, people already bunker their vamp lords, so the idea that people might bunker a necro lord doesn't make these units any more vulnerable then they already are, and it's not like I'm arguing that the melee vamp lord option be removed - far to the contrary, I'd rather see it greatly improved. I'd just also like to see a necro lord option.

I do think the armies will get bigger, but that also means that the Core of the army can't really get that much better. The fact that fielding Skeletons and Zombies in a Horde formation is quite suicidal under the 8 ed rules, tells me that something needs to be done with the troops, and not the ability to raise them more rapidly by allowing a Necromancer Lord in a Vampire Counts army.

Who said a necro lord would raise them more rapidly? I expect raising of units to get harder in any new book regardless, based purely on the treatment of the tomb kings book. The point is that no matter what happens, undead will in general be largely magic dependent - it's part of what makes undead in warhammer - and I'd like to see a cheaper option for supplying the baseline level of that magic, allowing players who want to to spend more points on troops and other heroes.

Putting a vamp lord in the front of your skeletons to punch things won't make them a good unit. It will just guarantee that your vamp lord will lose every round of combat. Fighty heroes don't make up for lousy units by personal killing power these days. That's a completely non-functional model. Only unit-wide buffs can make up for lousy units, be they magical or otherwise. The tomb kings MWBD is a good model, and one I'd like to see echoed in a vamp counts book. make vamp bloodline powers passive things that energize nearby undead through the creatures sheer unholy presence. Passive, reliable buffs based on bloodline that grant benefits worth paying the extra cost for, where the necromancer, while cheaper, needs to rely on the fickle magic phase to buff his troops up to reasonable competence.

But, again, I don't see this as an argument for or against the inclusion of necro lords. No, the inherent problems with the suckiness of the undead ruleset in 8th edition aren't solved by the inclusion of a necro lord. But they aren't solved by the exclusion of necro lords, either, and they certainly aren't solved by requiring players to field expensive and vulnerable melee heroes.

I'm not suggesting the inclusion of necro lords to solve the 'how are undead supposed to function in 8th' problem, I'm suggesting the inclusion of necro lords to solve the 'why the hell can't I field a necro lord' problem.

One aspect we haven't discussed btw, is what kind of a Necromancer Lord are you talking about rule-wise.

Just wanting them is really enough wishlisting for me, I've wasted way too much time on that activity over the years, but purely for the sake of example of how a necro lord 'could' work (rather then necessarily how I think they 'should' or 'will'):

Human wizard lord statline, third level caster, can upgrade to 4th for the usual cost, standard undead special rules. Can use lore of Necromancy, or death, or shadow, but the army general must be the wizard with the highest leadership, and that wizard must use the lore of necromancy. Notably the necro lord would have lower leadership then a vampire lord, and the vampire hero would be raised up to equal leadership. Necro lord is not a vampire, and does not allow nearby troops to march just by his presence unless he is the army general, and even then only 6" range.

lore of necromancy: replaces lore of vampires. No special rules for necromancy spells. No picking spells. signature spell is invocation, restores d6 wounds to a nearby unit. heightened versions allow 2d6 split between two units, or 3d6 split between three units. no healing heroes, monsters can only heal one wound per casting, cavalry halve the number of wounds restored, rounding up.

Other spells a mix of utility, buff, hexe, and damage. Utility: create nearby zombie unit augment for more zombies. Buffs: movement spell, augment to allow charge; grant one target ASF, augment for re-rolls to hit. Hex: penalty on fear & terror tests, aug prevents use of general's leadership & bsb reroll for fear & terror tests. Damage: Magic missile that forces panic test, augment more damage & penalty on the test; Curse of years, aug prevents ward saves. I don't know. I'm not necessarily saying a more 'regular lore' is the direction I want the army to head in, it's just what I expect and what I'm planning around at this point, again based on looking at what happened to the tomb kings.

Lore attribute: if you successfully cast a spell from the necromancy lore and the opponent dispels it, roll a die. On a 4+, you may immediately attempt to cast the same spell with the same wizard again.

Aaand, that's it. In contrast vampire lords: they would allow marching just for being nearby, they would have a better stat line, they would start at a lower wizard level, but could be bought up to four if they so desired for the usual cost. Every vampire in the army would have the same bloodline attribute, a passive bonus in addition to the ability to march for nearby undead. Von carsteins reduce crumble wounds, necrarchs make undead easier to rez, strigoi confer hatred, blood dragons re-roll to wound, lahmia ... I don't know, something, I'm just tossing ideas out here. In addition, vampires would have access to unique special abilities that make them powerful but expensive, including as casters if they desire. For instance, a vampyric necrarch caster could be a loremaster, but that ability would be out of the reach of necromancers, or other vampires, for that matter.

As for your ideas, I don't see the current structure for magic staying. I think some of the concepts will stay, but the lore will look and act much more like a regular lore. That's just how they're doing magic these days - see ogre gut magic, which is now a regular lore, or tomb kings magic, now a regular lore. I see no reason to limit the necromancer's caster level to 3 or restrict their items allowance. For one it defeats the point of ditching the stupid 'necromancers suck, screw you if you like them' mentality of the current book, for another it's not necessary to make vampire's cool, they'll already have access to special powers and vampire-only items.



As a final point, I'd just like to come back to my key issues. First: Necromancers are a core part of undead fluff in warhammer, the current book does a terrible job of representing them, their army would be exactly the same as the vamp counts army, just with a necro lord in it, so why not? Second: what does it cost you for me to have the option? Only one of us here is saying that the other person's fun is somehow badwrong.
 
I have to say I like Malisteen's idea of the bloodlines providing a unit-wide bonus much like the Tomb King's "my will be done" rule. It can be characterful and (importantly) reliable. I'd go with:

Von Carstein: Negate crumbling or bonus combat resolution
Lahmian: Always strike first, or bonus initiative if that's too powerful
Strigoi: Hatred or frenzy
Blood Dragon: Improved WS
Necrarch: Give the unit regeneration (to represent continuous reanimation)

You could even have lesser and greater versions for vampires and vampire lords.
 
Dan_Lee said:
I have to say I like Malisteen's idea of the bloodlines providing a unit-wide bonus much like the Tomb King's "my will be done" rule. It can be characterful and (importantly) reliable. I'd go with:

Von Carstein: Negate crumbling or bonus combat resolution
Lahmian: Always strike first, or bonus initiative if that's too powerful
Strigoi: Hatred or frenzy
Blood Dragon: Improved WS
Necrarch: Give the unit regeneration (to represent continuous reanimation)

You could even have lesser and greater versions for vampires and vampire lords.

I like the idea that the various Bloodlines influence the army as a whole as well, but this solution could be really hard to balance, and in some cases justify. Not saying it would be impossible though, just something that would have to be refined and game tested quite a lot, as it would have a major impact on the army as a whole.
 
Malisteen said:
As a final point, I'd just like to come back to my key issues. First: Necromancers are a core part of undead fluff in warhammer, the current book does a terrible job of representing them, their army would be exactly the same as the vamp counts army, just with a necro lord in it, so why not? Second: what does it cost you for me to have the option? Only one of us here is saying that the other person's fun is somehow badwrong.

-We can obviously argue til the next dark age comes around, but that's because we want totally different things for a Vampire Counts army book, theme-wise. You wish more of an Undead theme like we had in the 4 ed book, while I wish for a stronger Vampire theme like we had in 5th and 6th ed. Neither is right or wrong. Sure the current book does a terrible job of representing the more powerful necromancers (they're gone) as well as the strong Bloodline theme (also gone, althogh for the characters themselves, it is possible to make some pale imitations still).
-I'm not saying that you are wrong. I'm saying that I hope they don't go back to including powerful necromancers in the vampire counts army book, because it takes some of the focus away from the vampires themselves. I'd rather see more powerful Vampire Lords, and more vampire units, essentially building on the current theme, rather than including various options that don't really go that well with the Vampire setting.
-Necromancers by themselves are great, and I would love to have the ability to play a necromancer army. I just think that to do them justice, and not to weaken the vampires theme-wise at the same time, one has to build the army concept around them to a much larger extent, otherwisethey become too "plain", and they will easily become more background characters in a Vampire-focused army. That's why I'm arguing for letting them have their own list. There is a strong enough theme around them fluff-wise, that it can be pulled off in my opinion. Sure, many of the units would be the same as in a Vampire Counts army (Bloodline based), but I'm guessing that there will be some new units in 8 ed as well, that don't really fit them theme-wise.
One of the benefits of seperating the lists, would be that each Bloodline could influence how the army worked (by special rules for the vampires, seperate army special rules, etc), and a seperate Necromancer book could do the same for Necomancers, as well as including their own unique units to further strengthen their theme as well. There is, as you have said yourself, quite a lot of material fluff-wise regarding necromancers, and I think that it would be quite fantastic to buld upon this to make a strongly focused Necromancer army book.
Will GW ever make such a thing, sadly I don't think so. There is many a potential great army from the Old World, that will never see the light of day and Necromacers are not alone. I do think it would be great though, getting a Necromancer army with their own unique units, which one could base the army tactics around, rather than them being sort of a limited Vampire counts army tactically and theme-wise.
It will be exiting to see what GW does with the next book. I do hower think that to make both you and me happy, a much thicker book will be needed than the current one. :)
 
Uziel, as with any new rule, it would need balancing and playtesting. But it's not like it's unprecidented. The tomb kings can boost whole units WS with the presence of a tomb king or prince, then give the unit hatred by adding a necrotect. I see no reason why we couldn't have similar effects.
 
Dan_Lee said:
Uziel, as with any new rule, it would need balancing and playtesting. But it's not like it's unprecidented. The tomb kings can boost whole units WS with the presence of a tomb king or prince, then give the unit hatred by adding a necrotect. I see no reason why we couldn't have similar effects.

True. I'm just saying that with different effects for each bloodline (possibly affecting any unit in the army), it would requre more game testing than usual and that one would have to beware of a whole lot of more potentially devastating combinations across the army list(s).
 
In terms of fluff justification: vampires already energize nearby undead with their very presence, as they're (un)living foci of necromantic magic, even the ones who don't specifically pursue the arcane arts. That's already represented in their marching aura. I would just extend the same principle to let their auras grant other abilities based on bloodline as well. Actually, we could possibly even restrict marching to one bloodine (go to lahmia?), and grant some other way around it for other bloodlines (item? spell?). I like hatred for strigoi since it synergizes with ghouls (more rolls to hit = more poison), and re-rolls to wound for blood dragons since it synergizes with wights (more rolls to wound = more killing blows). I like that kind of dynamic - where the rules themselves suggest combinations endorsed by the fluff, rather then trying to impose some sort of arbitrary restriction. - although math-hammer would have to be done to make sure the extra rolls to wound granted from hitting more with hatred wouldn't provide more killing blows then the extra rolls to wound from re-rolling failed to wound rolls. If it did, the blood dragon ability might have to be something different. The point is to come up with abilities that naturally synergize with particular units or army builds in ways that organically produce fluffy armies.

For the record, I also want to see something more like the 5th and 6th ed Vampire Counts books - something where the army mechanics revolve around vampires (and I think the passive buff auras idea is a great way to do that, but this is why I don't like wishlisting - I become enamored of an idea and then get disappointed when the designers do something else), but where the option of a necromancer lord is still there for those who want it, whether as a matter of supplementing a more traditional vampyric army with some discount caster support or fielding an old world undead army without blood suckers, even if doing so leaves you at a disadvantage.

All in all, I don't think we're that far apart in the kinds of things we want to see or expect to see in a new book, and I've enjoyed discussing the issue here. Thanks Uziel, Sanai, and everyone else who's chimed in!

Actually, I so enjoyed the conversation that I completely forgot that this was an off topic tangent. Whoops, sorry! :redface:
 
I just want to add a few things here.

Firstly Sanai's description of Nagash was....horrific. A mere necromancer, who struggled to cast a basic spell?!!

Let's just correct that. Nagash invented Necromancy, it didn't exist before then. So he spent that time creating it, not struggling to learn from something else.

Secondly, the Supreme Lord of the Undeath was and still is the most powerful caster of Necromancy in the old world. At the height of his power the spell he cast raised an entire civilisation. One that had existed for thousands of years and numbered in the millions. So potent was the spell it had shockwaves the affected the dead around the world. There are still areas in the Old Word that the dead do not rest easy due to this.

In some fluff he was described as being almost Godlike at his peak. To give you some kind of comparison, this is what it took to kill him (according to the 4th edition fluff, which is the most indepth):

He had cast the Great Summoning, which drained him to the point where is was basically comatose.
Then a warrior king (reputedly to be one of the most powerful warriors of the time), armed with the deadliest blade in existence, protected by the entire Council's of Thirteen's magic attacked him.

Yes - A warrior with the Fellblade attacked someone in a coma. And still Nagash managed to cast a spell powerful enough that the backlash killed some of the Council of Thirteen protecting the warrior.. The warrior managed to kill him, but even with the power of the Fellblade Nagash managed to eventually resurrect himself.

The second time round it took Sigmar, basically a god, to kill him. This was said to be an equal fight, yet it was also said Nagash was pale shadow of his former self. So if a pale shadow was equal to Sigmar, it provokes some thoughts to how powerful Nagash was at his peak.

Soooo, enough of my fan-boy ranting.

But I fully agree with Malisteen. Firstly all the fluff bar the most recent states that Necromancers can become very very potent casters, more so than vampires in some cases. Some Necromancers do not manage to hold onto life, those that are weak become Wraiths, those that are strong become Liches (basically a dead Necro).

The only reason why Necros are classed as Undead is that GW simplified the rules, in previous editions they were alive.

In addition, there were said to be quite a few necromancers, which would make sense. After all it is the powerful lure of avoiding death which drives them. Of course only a few go on to become powerful necromancers, but certainly as many of not moreso than powerful vampires.

Personally I think the ratio at the moment is silly. Vampires, especially the potent ones, are meant to be rare and powerful creatures. They are not encountered often, but when you do it is something to be feared. However the recent editions have them popping up like daisies all over the place, which for me takes away from their mystery and charm.

Yes the book is called Vampire Counts. But I think there is more than enough room for potent Necromancers. Though it is not the most recent, there is much more fluff to show Necros can be potent casters in their own right, using hordes of undead to win their battles. This kind of theme should be an option for those who want to take it.

After all, if you don't like it, then you don't have to take it do you? Why take something away from someone else just because you don't want it?
 
Double post! :tongue:

I have created an offical rumour thread here: https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-Official-Rumour-Thread-New-Vampire-Counts-Book

Please update all rumours there, however feel free to keep discussing here if you like.
 
SoulSeeker said:
Let's have a little wager. I am betting that the VC book will be 2013 at the earliest and I am prepared to put up a handful of zombies as my stake (aaaargh, I said the s word :vampire3:). Anybody want to bet against me, that VC will be released before 2013. Any takers? xD
I'll take that bet. :D

All the best,
Harry
 
Count Von Sapponatime said:
SoulSeeker said:
Let's have a little wager. I am betting that the VC book will be 2013 at the earliest and I am prepared to put up a handful of zombies as my stake (aaaargh, I said the s word :vampire3:). Anybody want to bet against me, that VC will be released before 2013. Any takers? xD
I'll take that bet. :D

All the best,
Harry
That made me lol :)
 
N.I.B said:
Count Von Sapponatime said:
SoulSeeker said:
Let's have a little wager. I am betting that the VC book will be 2013 at the earliest and I am prepared to put up a handful of zombies as my stake (aaaargh, I said the s word :vampire3:). Anybody want to bet against me, that VC will be released before 2013. Any takers? xD
I'll take that bet. :D

All the best,
Harry
That made me lol :)

Commooon Harry! (though a november release would be quite poorly timed, right in the middle of my final examinations)
 
Here's a good question!!!

What other sort of lord choices do you think there will be? Excluding special characters of course. I mean I felt shafted when I was only able to field a "Vampire Lord" I mean: lots of options? Yes. Cool fluff hell yea. But to touch on the Necromancer argument. Wouldn't you people like a little variety on the field? Other than just "Vampire Lord" with A+B+C. Gets a tad bit stale which is one of the reasons I fell in love with the 6th ed. Book. Just my 2 cents of course.
 
Even before 6th the vc army was known as undead, for people remembering that, vampire lords as only lord choice makes them really sad. Where are the powerful liches and necromancers from before?
 
Tim said:
Even before 6th the vc army was known as undead, for people remembering that, vampire lords as only lord choice makes them really sad. Where are the powerful liches and necromancers from before?

They are still there but for some reason GW decided to make Army Book: Von Carstein this time around. Which incidently is what put me off VC. You could theme your army but in the end the theme was nothing more than a cosmetic and arbitrary aspect. In the end, it was just another VC list.

That said, if rumours are to be believed, GW are looking to redeem themselves on this point. For now though, my VC will remain shelved.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu