Newbie 1.5k Salamanders need help

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Sep 23, 2010
17
Zombies
17
Having played xenos for most of my 40k life, i've finally decided to pick up a marine army and get a taste of the 3+ armor save. I've chosen salamander marines mainly because the metagame at my play area is pretty competitive and also I like their chapter fluff where they would strive to retain their human ties long after becoming a marine.

Anyway, heres the list. See if theres anything that needs improving:

HQ
Vulcan Hestan

Elites
Dreadnought x1
MM, heavy flamer, extra armor

Th/ss Terminators x5

Troops
10 man tact squad x2
MM, meltagun, powerfist, combi flamer. Rhino transport.

10 man tact squad x1
MM, flamer, powerfist, combi melta. Rhino transport.


Heavy support
Land raider redeemer
MM, extra armor


1500pts
 
Welcome to the Space Marines! I hope you like the taste of 3+ armour, but by the looks of things you've got a lot of armour to much through first... xD

Ok, let's look at the list.


Vicious Whisper said:
HQ
Vulcan Hestan

Lovely choice. Has nice fluff, is rock-hard, and benefits this army like crazy. Keep him in there.


Elites
Dreadnought x1
MM, heavy flamer, extra armor

Nice, simple, anti-tank weapon with an anti-infantry capability as well. However, I'd drop the extra armour. It is draining your points somewhat, and if you save enough properly you could give this guy a drop pod...

Th/ss Terminators x5

Yes, a good, rock-hard unit to assault with. Can't die, practically. I'm guessing they'll be in the raider, with Vulkan He'stan? Can't fault them, they're uber, 'nuff said.

Troops
10 man tact squad x2
MM, meltagun, powerfist, combi flamer. Rhino transport.

Now, here's where I start to see cracks in an otherwise solid list. You've poured a lot of points into this. Unless you're using combat squads, they become very much obsolete. Firstly, I'd drop the combi-flamer; it's one upgrade too many. Secondly, having both the MM and the MG, whilst utilising Vulkan's Chapter Tactics rule, means the unit has 2 pulls. Sit and snipe with the MM? Or run forward, grab objectives etc. Now, seeing as you have a Rhino, I doubt you're going to need the multi-melta. You'll have to sit still for a turn (and get shot to pieces) whereas you can just disembark, pop the tank, and move on. If it doesn't die, why not take Melta Bombs instead for the sergeant? Cheaper than the mostly useless MM. I'd do this for both units.

10 man tact squad x1
MM, flamer, powerfist, combi melta. Rhino transport.

Mostly same as above; you could get rid of the MM and the combi-melta. You already have, what, 2 meltaguns, 2 MM, and possibly 2 sets of MB as well, not to mention 5 thunder hammers and a dreadnought power-fist... Then, you could keep the flamer.... I guess, but you do have two flamestorm cannons and an assault cannon with the raider. It's up to you, really; but the unnecessary upgrades should go.


Heavy support
Land raider redeemer
MM, extra armor

Very nice addition to the army, but the extra armour is redundant, really. You have armour 14 all round; this is going to survive most enemy attacks. The extra armour is just pouring more upgrades in...


1500pts

With all those lovely points you've saved (say yes and nod understandingly xD ) you can afford some new things. I'd say plump for a nice drop pod for your dreadnought, which will otherwise be left behind. Then, depending on what you have left, try and sneak in some scouts... keep them really cheap and cheerful, and you can probably sit them on your objective in objective games, or infiltrate them forward in KP games.

Just some pointers, I hope you take them into consideration, and good luck with your Salamanders!
 
Thanks for the advice Darvaleth! So basically after dropping the combi weapons from the tact squads together with the extra armor from dready, I could afford enough points to put him in a drop pod.

As for the MM, yeah I noticed that the heavy weapons tend to bog down the whole "in your face" theme, but its a free upgrade. So its either that or missiles and Vulcan would most likely frown on the latter xD

I do not own any scouts at the moment, I'll be putting them on hold until a couple more games later.
 
Oh yes, MM are free..... hmmm..... that alters things a lot. xD You'd have to split into combat squads, then, and have one squad sit still on one objective (perhaps half-way across board, or if there are only 2 objectives or it's KP, just somewhere in cover) then the rest run forward to attack the enemy side of the board.

The scouts are only really a cheap troop unit; if you happen to have 75 spare points, then you can get 5 of them. Otherwise, try to get cracking on an updated list... xD
 
Those squads are better off with a bolter than swapping it for a Multi Melta, as the bolter can fire on the move, and the MM will only be used if your squad does something silly like sit still and not be close enough to the enemy to fight.
 
I agree with the others. If you want to use the free upgrade and split into combat squads then go for a ML. Sure it's not a Melta weapon, but it has more variety and the range to ensure you can sit at the back and snipe with it. Or if you want to keep the Salamanders feel, drop the Heavy Weapon entirely and rush forward in your Rhino's. And yes, you need a drop pod for your dread, otherwise it's going be left behind with a fast list like this.
 
Yes, I understand where you guys are coming from, however heres my dilemma. If I were to keep the MM, 1 marine will technically not be shooting unless under special circumstances.

Were I to split them into combat squads Im afraid there wont be enough bodies to take the hit once they get engaged into cc, which is very likely for the close ranged build of the army.

So it boils down to 1 more rapidfire of a boltgun or a MM. What do you guys think?
 
Dont be blinded by Vulkans Special rules, take the Missile Launcher instead of the MM! Lets look at why...

Ok so the Missile Launcher is both move and fire and doesnt get any bonus from Vulkan, however it is the best all rounder Heavy Weapon available to the Tactical Marines. When you need range it has the highest, it has the same S as a MM with Krak and can blast template to clip bunched up infantry.

If you get to your objective then you will be stationary anyway and it doesnt always pay to charge headlong towards the enemy so to say you will never use it is a bit of a false statement.

The net loss if you decide to take the ML over a bolter is <drum roll>

A single bolt shell at 12". The reason why is because the marine has a pistol anyway, so if you are moving and firing you are only going to be shooting 12" and thats essentially only 2 bolt pistol shots.

If it comes down to MM or Bolter still take the MM, its a credible threat to any vehicle 12" away and a definite threat to any light vehicle 24" away. This creates a nice area denial bubble around the squad where a vehicle will not dare to tred. All for the cost of a single bolt shell, hey if you are staying put then just shoot the MM at whatever the bolters are shooting up.

Also dont get dissuaded from taking Extra Armour on your Raider (which should be a dedicated transport for the Terminators, subtle and seemingly unimportant however it should be listed as such), it may be AV14 but glance it and you might just find yourself stuck in the mud. Its more likely to survive being shot at which makes the Extra Armour that much more important, whereas say a Rhino is more likely to get killed through heavy weapons shooting at it so its less effective.

Also Drop Pod for a single Dread is just suiciding it. If you are seriously considering taking a single dread and you are worried it wont keep up the pace then dump 2 TL Autocannons on it and make it a Light Vehicle killer. Trust me when I say that the "Rifleman" TL Autocannon Dread is a great anti transport weapon. 4 TL S7 shots at 48" which can move 6" a turn, it all adds up.
 
After some trial rolls with the dice, I'd have to say Rifleman dreads are surprisingly consistent when it comes to popping armor 11 and I'm seriously considering packing him instead of a CC variant.

The army should be reaching me by the end of this week, I'll try to get a few battle reports from the various configurations suggested and see which one works best.

I'm glad to say that this forum's been the quickest so far when it comes to replying help posts, so cookies to you all!!xD
 
You tried Bolter and Chainsword? Its where I used to loiter until I got into Fantasy and essentially got promoted at work, now I dont have time to invest as much as I did.

Rifleman Dread falls on its face when there are no Vehicles AV12 or less, however in the current MEQ meta there generally are. Test its effectiveness at putting wounds on Monsterous Creatures, ok they get a save but just check those dice :)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu