Nightshroud, Beguile, Challenge and Krell!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Demian

Vampire Count
True Blood
Oct 28, 2011
1,245
Zombies
1,274
Greetings!

This came up the other night, while playing:

I had a Vampire lord wearing a Nightshroud, and he was next to the corner of a unit of skeletons. I also had a GW Wight King or Krell in the same Unit, and he was sitting in the middle of it (like a boss):

s V K s s
s s s s s

then comes an enemy and charges, and in combat, Krell issues a challenge and it's accepted by the enemy champion, and the final formation was like this:

e e e e e
e e E e e
s V K s s
s s s s s

(s= skeletons, V= Vampire Lord, K=Krell, e=enemies and E is their Champion. Red ones afected by Nightshroud/Beguile)


Question is:

is such an enemy affected by the Nightshroud, allowing Krell to strike at the same time? How about Beguile? can I chose to Beguile such an enemy with the Vampire Lord, even after he has been locked in a challenge?

I can only find a reference in the FAQ that Stomps and such cannot be directed at the Unit if you are in a challenge, always against the contender.
 
yay!

Ok now I have another question:

in the BRB says to "move in btb contact with each other (...) if you can't, just assume both are in btb, etc.

So, if I want my Krell challenger to be protected by both Nightshroud and Beguile, I would have to "force" my opponent to move, say in front of Krell, so that he ends up also btb with the Vampire Lord. Now, how does one resolve that? Roll-off and the winner/loser gets to move (physically)?
 
They aren't meant to, but loads of people do because it looks cool and there is a picture like that in the BRB. I'm not sure who moves though, I'd love to know too
 
I though that thing myself. I was under the impression that some rule explicitly said "models in a challenge are only considered to be in btb contact with each other for the purposes of any rules", however re-reading the Fighting a Challenge part in the BRB I believe it was just my imagination, as nothing there says that.

if there is no rule/FAQ that implies the above, then all these things I've asked are possible, and very powerful (you could protect your Seneschal in a challenge, and he may end up KBing another character, even if he dies himself... that would award juicy points for killing an enemy character in a challenge with a Champ :D!).


Ok, now in a totally unrelated question that just occurred to me:

Say a Vampire wearing the Nightshroud is affecting 3 enemy characters that do not use Great Weapons themselves. Then, as these characters are joined in a Unit, the supporting attacks kill your Vampire, disabling the Nightshroud at their turn to strike. What happens to those enemy characters? Since their Initiative has already passed, and they no longer have ASL, when do they get to strike? Are their attacks lost?
 
Demian said:
yay!

Ok now I have another question:

in the BRB says to "move in btb contact with each other (...) if you can't, just assume both are in btb, etc.

So, if I want my Krell challenger to be protected by both Nightshroud and Beguile, I would have to "force" my opponent to move, say in front of Krell, so that he ends up also btb with the Vampire Lord. Now, how does one resolve that? Roll-off and the winner/loser gets to move (physically)?

Your opponent could move his champ so he is only corner to corner with Krell and not touching the Vamp Lord at all and be within the wording of the rules.
 
Yorga said:
Demian said:
yay!

Ok now I have another question:

in the BRB says to "move in btb contact with each other (...) if you can't, just assume both are in btb, etc.

So, if I want my Krell challenger to be protected by both Nightshroud and Beguile, I would have to "force" my opponent to move, say in front of Krell, so that he ends up also btb with the Vampire Lord. Now, how does one resolve that? Roll-off and the winner/loser gets to move (physically)?

Your opponent could move his champ so he is only corner to corner with Krell and not touching the Vamp Lord at all and be within the wording of the rules.

My friends and I play it as such...

Challenges are issued.

The player who's turn it is moves his models into position. The player who's turn it isn't move his models (still complying to the rules of challenges, etc)

So it would be possible to get the Nightshroud into base contact.

The next turn if two models are still engaged in a challenge then they don't move.

Say your opponent challenges your Vampire Lord on his turn? In that case, you'd have to move your Vampire Lord since it wouldn't be your turn.

Again there could be a right way to do it...
 
Yeah, I guess as it isn't covered in the rules, one should implement a house rule on such things.

Anyway, try out the "nightshroud black hole" some day, it'll be an interesting discussion between you and your opponent, hehe (3 posts above).

Thanks for all the replies!

EDIT: Oh and btw, an opponent does not choose who to challenge. He issues a challenge (in general) and then you choose which one of your Characters / Champions rises to meet him.
 
This how me and actually everybody in my gaming group does it:

In a challenge only the challenger and the enemy champion/character are in bsb with each other.
In this case, with "Nightshroud" we would let a other enemy model of the unit be affected so that the challenge is
not affected by it and the vampire still gets the whole effect of standing there in the middel and affecting 3 models.
 
I guess from a fluff perspective the challenger would drop a gauntlet, and the challengee would move to accept it... not sure your opponent would like that argument if it meant "come to my Nightshroud" though!

EDIT: If you want to be really nasty, put Kemmler in the same unit and give Krell Heroic Killing Blow...!
 
Yeah, I'd rule it like:

The Player who's character declares a challenge gets to put the one who accepts it in any position that gets them btb contact. After all, the turn player gets priority when declaring challenges, and that means getting the charge off, planning and executing a strategy, etc.

Seems fair to me.


And about Kemmler, it's nice to have HKB while in challenges, however as I've read before, one cannot go monster hunting with the pair, since most monsters I'd like to slay in one blow, like Hydras, cannot enter challenges (even if the Black Axe is super sweet with D3 wounds and giving the Iron Man effect to the wounded enemy. The agony, not the cool brilliant genius).

That's why I decided to protect Krell with a Nightshroud, giving Krell the chance to eat any character's heart bit by bit or all at once. He can virtually kill anyone he wounds, even if they survive the D3 wounds.

The other idea I'm going to try is Konrad. he seems far more reliable than Krell, and costs even less. The only pain could be failing his stupidity test, since bsb aren't cheap these days.
 
Rules state " If a character accepts the challenge, move him into base contact with the challenger."

Then goes on to say " If, for whatever reason, this is not possible, assume the models are in B2B contact."

So if 2 units go head 2 head there should be no reason the challengee couldn't be moved to B2B with the challenger. I have used this tactic with my Vamp Lord on the end of a cav unit with a WK next to him with the nightshroud, thus negating any S bonuses against the Lord.

There may come up with weird set ups with maybe attacking a flank or rear of a unit. Then I would follow the 2nd part of the rule.
 
Correct. Nowhere in the rules does it say that just beause you are in a challenge you are not considered to be touching other models' bases. This is just a silly convention many players have adopted but it is not in the rule book. Therefore it is a very smart ploy to put nightshroud wearing WK next to you Vampire Lord.

But note: The character 'accepting' must be the one to move. So you won't always be able to stay next to the WK. One of the reasons I do not take Dread Knight on my Vampire Lord.
 
The player who's turn it is has the opportunity to issue challenges first. If that side chooses not to, then the other side can issue a challenge.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu