WHFB - 7th Not Vc, But still a Noodle Scratcher,

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Aegis

Varghulf
Jul 6, 2008
785
Chi town
Zombies
285
Ok. So i just finished playing a game a friends house and this cropped up. First the Units.


Slaan Mage Priest in a 20 man block of temple guard.

4+ Ward save (comes stock with it)
Disciplines,

Focus of Mystery (Know all spells from 1 lore of magic)
The Focused Rumination ("Free" Power dice for ever attempt to cast.)
Unfathomable Presence (MR3)


Versus


Level 2 Sorcerer of Nurgle.

Power Familiar.



Alrighty then.


This LvL 2 has Magnificent Buboes and Cloying Quagmire.

Question is for the quagmire.

For those sans the warriors of chaos book, the spell Verbatim.

"Cast on a 9+

This spell can be cast on an enemy unit in line of sight. If that unit is withing 24" then every model in the unit must pass an Initiative test, and those that fail the test must then take an armor save. If a model passes its armor save, its weight will drag it down into the rotting slurry- remove that model from play. This spell has not effect on units with the Fly, Amphibious or Ethereal special rules."


Quagmire goes off on the unit, damage worked out against saurus as they do not have any of those special rules. The Slaan, being Initive 2 shanks his test. Now what do we do?

A. Nothing as he has no armor (nor can he get any) and a floating spell flinging frog cant possibly drown in a puddle. :devil:

B.Take the ward in place of armor, meaning a passed ward = a dead frog. (Kind of weird, see as wards are supposed to save you, but then again so is armor.)

C. Passed ward = OK

D. anything you guys come up with that i did not think off.


As before when i've put forth oddities like this, i won't tell you guys what we used until i get a few posts back as i don't want to lead you guys on. I now bow out to the collective intellect thats floating around in here. (i know you are out there Disciple of Nagash and N.I.B ;))
 
I'd agree. The whole point of the spell is that it creates a quagmire and the weight of armour is the killer because it drags the wearer into the mud. I certainly don't think the ward here has any relevance.
I don't know anything about Slaan - there are very few Lizardmen armies around here at the moment. They look like frogs, though, so are they amphibious? Do they float/fly?
 
hehe, I'd have to agree he'll still be floating. The question is regarded to the armour, and since he has none... (although fat enough).

I have to say this is again one of the GW fails at wording their stuff correctly.
 
nope surprisingly not amphibious. altho they can be ethereal through one of their disciplines. We went with the ward save vs death but after the game i was thinking on the ride home that this just didn't make sense with the context of the spell. Even tho it would have helped immensely if he had died and stopped chucking 3-4 spells from the lore of metal at me a turn -.-
 
Hmm just seen this - I have to agree with the general consensus.No armour save so auto passes, plus as Vekarin said, the Slaan wouldn't be touching the ground anyway. According to the newest book they believe the ground is contaminated by chaos (correct in this case :)), and thus have never touched it since the first incursion.
 
I would also interpret it in this way - the heavier the armour you are wearing, the easier to pass an armour save, and the more likely you are to be dragged down into swampy death.

No armour = no save = auto survival = happy frog!!

This could throw a couple of anomilies into the ring, as it were, re the Lizardmen with the scaly skin saves and the aquatic rule - the Kroxigor for example has a save of 4+, but can treat marshes, rivers, lakes, etc as open ground. Any thoughts?
 
Probably wont come up since skinks are aquatic id rather give them curse of the leper twice and kill the whole unit XD (sans kroxigors of course)
 
When answering rule queries like this you have to try and ignore what "seems reasonable" until you have determined the rules do not fully cover the situation. After all Undead are affected by poison and Treemen don't get to ignore extra flaming damage when they are moving through a water feature etc.

It is very important to remember that units pay for the rules they get, treating Slann as though they can fly or are amphibious is giving them a benefit they haven't paid for.

- - -

In this case the answer seems to be very clear.

The spell causes models to take an initiative test, and if they fail they make an armour save which if failed causes them to die.

The Slann is hit by the spell as he doesn't have fly, amphibious or ethereal. However, as if the Slann has no armour save then he cannot 'pass' an armour save and so cannot be killed.

The only question I have is that I assume that models hit with this spell can still use ward saves to avoid dying (normally abilities that ignore ward saves say so).

- - -

I'd hate to have someone get this spell off on my Kholek Suneater! Initiative 1 and 2+ armour, it's nearly as deadly as Pit of Shades.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu