Opinions on the Magic Phase? Broken or Not?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I've been playing warhammer since 3rd edition. For 25 years. Players of 8th fall into three stages from what I can tell.

1) the game seems super random with 2d6 charges, nuke spells like people sun, dwellers etc and there is a lot of cross referencing when learning as the book has a lot of circumstantial rules. Some players try 8th, long for cavalry charges of 7th and declare 8th a mess without really giving it a fair shot.

2) the game then turns into death star units and uber spells. Players at this stage learn to over clock everything. They learn to maximize horde, step up, steadfast and nuke spells. They declare the game is all about these massive units and spells, they often get bored and quit or make others bored with the lack of tactics around the game.

3) then the game blossoms. The players realize the game is very elegant. The 2d6 charges creates a whole new level to movement and baiting your opponent, step up and steadfast has gotten rid of hero hammer and made infantry viable, the 2d6 for winds of magic keeps the magic phase balanced. The nuke spells are only overly powerful vs the stage 2 style of pay, this discouraging it. All of the unit types have a role. Its these reasons that you hear a lot of us veterans praise 8th edition. It's because it's the most balanced and tactical version of the game so far.

8th isn't perfect. Laser guide cannons, unmodified modified leadership, six dicing spells lacking consequences even though miscasts are nastiest they've been. Perhaps it's biggest flaw is its learning curve and that so many players had trouble getting to stage three. But I can tell you honestly, play well rounded, balanced armies with out deathstars and the game is really solid. Your group sound to me like they haven't reached that point yet. Because aside from the six dicing nukes that occasionally happens, the magic is fine.
Soory, had to give some props to this comment. Having been playing GW games for a long time now, I agree completely.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu