Phoenix Gaurd Troubles...

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Mullo

Zombie
Apr 27, 2008
10
Iowa
Zombies
6
Hey, everyone. My friend and I were playing a game today, and he fielded a rather large unit of phoenix guard (24+ Karadrion [sp?]). I had two good sized units of skeletons, one of them had WS 6 with the commandment helm. Plus I had a unit of black knights taking care of some archers, so they didn't really get involved in the fight.

My question is, how can I beat the phoenix guard? They cause fear, and so won't break automatically, the have always strike first with great weapon, and they have their ward save. So at best I'm getting a couple of attacks each turn, each one being saved with either their armor or their ward save. Each turn I would lose combat by five or more, so even with Invocation of Nehek, I couldn't keep up and all the skeletons were defeated.

The Black Knights did reach combat at turn six, at which time they were made quick work of the reformed phoenix guards always strike first great weapons.

I'm sure there's something I could have done to put up a fight, so if someone could enlighten me, it would be very useful in future battles.[/i]
 
i owned them with my blood knight unit. I had 8 Blood Knights with the Drakenhof banner, killed his unit of 25 phoenix guards and losing only 1 blood knight.

Phoenix guards > skellies, no doubt

Voltaire: Mind the language please!
 
First of all, Phoenix Guard don't have GW's, they have Halberds. As such, they shouldn't take out to heavily armoured troops. I'd combo charge them, and break them just as any other unit. Stick a Helm'd Skeleton unit in the front to fight them, replenishing them with IoN's, then charge a kitted Black Knight unit in their flank. Can even switch to Helm the BK unit here, and make sure they have either the Banner of the Barrows or the Royal Standard of Strigos to ensure more killyness.

That unit of his is hideously expensive if it's 24 Phoenix Guard + Caradryan. Kill it and you'll have earned yourself a -lot- of victory points.
 
don't forget the multitude of ASF we can field also. Cast one of the BK so they strike first on the charge, after that the phoenix guard will strike first anyway, but you will do the deed on the charge.
 
You can't really expect to beat his PG with 2 units of skeletons, as 15pts each means his unit with Caradryn is probably worth more than both the skeletons combined. The key is to get something in the flank, so that they have to rely upon dynamic CR to win the battle.
 
I don't know about that special charectar, but do his PG have more than 1 attack? If they don't, just feed them a big heaping platter of zombie goodness. They'll keep them out of the real action for as long as you pump PD into the unit.
 
What I do when faced with a unit like this is take my Vamp with Raise dead and Scepter, then just raise zombies on its flank to bog it down...then deal with the unit when u can...
 
They only have one attack, so are easy enough to bog down, but with ASF and the 4+ ward, there is no way you are going to be taking them by simply attacking the front. As has been said above, simply tarpit them until you can get a flank charge.

Also, watch out for Caradryn. He grants MR3 to the unit, so don't bother Wind of Undeath/Gaze of Nagash/Curse of Years on the model, as it will simply be a waste of your PD. The other problem is his special rules in CC. Don't ever let him engage your Varghulf/General/Dragon riding Lord/Corpse Cart. His halberd has flaming attacks, so no regen for the Varghulf/Corpse Cart. It also does D3 wounds at S5 against models of US3+, so even 1 successful wound roll can result in 3 non-regenerating wounds. Finally, if you happen to kill him, the model that killed him takes D6 wounds, no AS. This is called the Suicide Bomber, and if you see a high elf mage taking shadows and getting Steed of Shadows, you can often expect a 20" flying Suicide Bomber on your tooled up Vampire Lord who is also your General. Even if he fails to kill you with 3 S5 attacks, as he should, you face the prospect of D6 wounds with just a ward save if you slay him. Not nice on turn 1/2 of the game to lose your General in a massive ball of flame.
 
I hadn't really thought about Pheonix guard and how we would deal with them, Swordmasters being much more common round here, but it is a very good question.

Personally I think mashal, skillmatic and assimilation all suggested the best idea. Don't try and beat them, bog them down asap with a mass of Zombies. You'll be losing ~9 a turn, but thats only just more than one IoN to replenish. At 500 odd points your opponent needs this unit to be doing something useful, if you make him waste it hitting Zombies then you're doing well.

I don't think Pheonix guard have magic attacks so Wraiths could be deadly if you can get the flank/rear where Caradryn can't fight.
 
As mentioned unless these guys have magical attacks spirit hosts, wraiths into the flank away from the special character will hurt them. Or a charge from Blood Knights with ASF from Vanhels / CC with obliterate.
 
Meh, your strongest enemy unit? Get your Vampire Lord stuck in! Even a normal Lord is hitting on 3+ wounding on 2+, yes they have the 4+ save but that's still 1-2 killed a turn (more if you have hatred and fury), and they can't afford to lose a couple of members a turn. Eventually you'll win combat, and they'll break. They'll kill Skeletons, but you can bring them back.
 
It'll take some resources but it can be done. My idea was to charge a couple different units into it, enough to outnumber and flank them, and toss in a terror causing creature. Do everything to win CR and they auto break unless they roll insane courage. Problem solved.

Also, I think that a fully "juiced up" Black Coach could make mince meat out of just about any unit of Phoenix Guard just by itself....
 
Look the phoenix guard with upgrades is basically the anti-undead

having a look you take 24 phoenix guard with full upgrades you kit the champion out with amulet of light(gives unit magical attacks) and enchanted shield and throw in the standard of balance (makes unit immune to psychology) and with Caradryan you've got magic resist 3.

I don't know how to freaking beat that. If you manage to flank and rear charge them and manage to out number you have a chance to do freaking nothing because they're immune to psychology and will do more wounds to you than you do to them so you're screwed. Haha... scary stuff.
 
chris: 5 BKs flank charge, 5 Pheonix strike (0.33 kills), Blood Knights hit with 25 att (15 rider, 10 mount) should kill 5.8 Pheonix Guard.

CR:
Blood Knights (+5 Wounds, +1 Flank, +1 Banner) = 7
Phoenix Guard (0 WOunds, +1 Outnumber, +1 Banner) = 2
They lose and need 4 or less on 2D6 (assuming they can use Lords leadership).

I'm not saying setting up the flank would be easy, but theirs an obvious example of a way to beat them. Thats basic Blood Knights with no magic support, no Kastellan, no magic banner and no heroes.
 
Black Knights are decent too but they will need some support (hero/magic/helm). On the plus side they are cheaper and harder to bait.

Cairn Wraiths can do it too if your desperate. You will need a VHD on them to give them ASF and rerolls to hit so in that case it will be more risky. But it would do excellent damage too. The bonus with these guys is RBTs have no effect on them.

Blood Knights are beyond awesome in combat its getting them there thats the challenge.
 
N1AK said:
chris: 5 BKs flank charge, 5 Pheonix strike (0.33 kills), Blood Knights hit with 25 att (15 rider, 10 mount) should kill 5.8 Pheonix Guard.

CR:
Blood Knights (+5 Wounds, +1 Flank, +1 Banner) = 7
Phoenix Guard (0 WOunds, +1 Outnumber, +1 Banner) = 2
They lose and need 4 or less on 2D6 (assuming they can use Lords leadership).

I'm not saying setting up the flank would be easy, but theirs an obvious example of a way to beat them. Thats basic Blood Knights with no magic support, no Kastellan, no magic banner and no heroes.

Hell, assume you're assaulting them to the front, Phoenix Guard score 3 extra for ranks, Blood Knights one less for no flank. Score = 6 - 5 to the Blood Knights, and it's only going to get better in the second round of combat.
 
N1AK: If they're immune to psych they won't run and then one of your most expensive unit is stuck facing a bunch of bad asses for the rest of time. They also have ASF so they'll most likely win out in the end they won't be very strong by the end but they will win out. Remember the second you lose a combat with the Blood Knights you lose 5 attacks from frenzy from vamps and horses.

EvC: If you charge the front you'll have that Caradryan butthole to deal with on top of everything else.

I'm not saying they're invincible but if you have to take 5 blood knights to deal with one unit it's a pretty scary unit. Remember too that High Elves are a fast moving army so the chances of them charging you while you're bogged down with the phoenix guard are high. There are ways to beat it but they don't run in fear, they can hurt ethereals, there are 25 of them and trying to whittle down there numbers with magic is basically useless.

Obviously if you take a unit of 5 blood knights fully kitted out with the banner of the undead legion with a vamp BSB that has dread knight and walking death and drakenhof banner you will most likely take the unit out no sweat but less than that and you'll get bogged down and be vulnerable to whatever else he has in store for you.
 
Yeah, a massive, expensive enemy unit with a brutal special character will require a lot of effort and skill to take out. If not tooled-up Blood Knights with a character, then two infantry units, one in the flank/ rear will do it. Yes, you'll just have to outplay your opponent to take down a unit like this. Would you really want it any other way?
 
Thinking about this again if he takes Caradryan then take your own special character. Konrad with a Bear's Anger spell on him and some ASF support. Konrad with 6-7 str 7 attacks should do...okay.

For something a little more reliable (but much more expensive) a Lord with the Red Fury/Infinite Hatred combo should do good. Keep him on foot, give him a Talisman of Lycni and cast a Bear's anger spell on him. Konrad like damage with move 9 and no stupidity.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu