Question on Generating Spells

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Sanagu

Zombie
Jan 3, 2013
10
Zombies
13
This is just so I interpret the rules correctly..
Sorry if it was posted before, a quick search didn't find anything and I couldn't really find something explaining this in detail to me in the rulebook.

Scenario:
Having 2 Death Vampires, wanting to have DnD and sig spells in my army.

I know that a Wizard first generates his spells before the next but does he also exchange his spells before the next?

Say for instance I roll a 1 and 2 for the first Vamp, do I swap his spells for the sig first (if I so desire) and then have less chance to get a double, or can I wait with the swap til the 2nd Vamp rolls?

TL;DR: which scenario(s) is/are legal with 2 lv2 Death Vamps?
Scenario 1:
Vamp 1 generates spells: 1, 2
Vamp 2 generates spells: 1, 5
Vamp 1 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for DnD (4) because double, Caress (2) for sig
Vamp 2 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for sig

Scenario 2:
Vamp 1 generates spells: 1, 2
Vamp 1 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for sig
Vamp 2 generates spells: 1, 5
Vamp 2 cannot exchange Dreadknight (1) for another spell of choice since Vamp 1 exchanged it
Vamp 2 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for sig

Kinda important factor in knowing if I can get those spells!
 
Sanagu said:
This is just so I interpret the rules correctly..
Sorry if it was posted before, a quick search didn't find anything and I couldn't really find something explaining this in detail to me in the rulebook.

Scenario:
Having 2 Death Vampires, wanting to have DnD and sig spells in my army.

I know that a Wizard first generates his spells before the next but does he also exchange his spells before the next?

Say for instance I roll a 1 and 2 for the first Vamp, do I swap his spells for the sig first (if I so desire) and then have less chance to get a double, or can I wait with the swap til the 2nd Vamp rolls?

TL;DR: which scenario(s) is/are legal with 2 lv2 Death Vamps?
Scenario 1:
Vamp 1 generates spells: 1, 2
Vamp 2 generates spells: 1, 5
Vamp 1 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for DnD (4) because double, Caress (2) for sig
Vamp 2 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for sig

Scenario 2:
Vamp 1 generates spells: 1, 2
Vamp 1 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for sig
Vamp 2 generates spells: 1, 5
Vamp 2 cannot exchange Dreadknight (1) for another spell of choice since Vamp 1 exchanged it
Vamp 2 exchanges Dreadknight (1) for sig

Kinda important factor in knowing if I can get those spells!

Scenario 2 is correct. U must roll each caster separately and not cherry pick 2 wizards' rolls at once; that's illegal and people will call u out on it - something u don't want before the game even begins!

If you're REALLY wanting a certain spell, roll first with your lower level caster or the one that's less protected (least valued). Don't drop his spell(s) to the sig. THEN roll your more valued caster with a higher probability to get the golden spell or a double.
 
I really think it's scenario 2:

Reference of the BRB p.490:

"Ordinarily, each spell only be known once in the same army, The only exception are:

If a model has no choice over which spell it knows or If the army book or spell lore clearly states that a model can exchange another spell for the spell in question."

Both exception doesn't apply here.

Also:

"If you cannot (change a spell) because all the others spells have already been taken by another wizard, for exemple, then this extra spell slot is lost."
 
Since we are on the topic i have a question as well. When rolling to determine spells does one roll all the dice at once or separately.

Example:
A level 4 wizard rolls 4 dice. Now does he/she roll a dice, identify spell and if he/she wants to exchange for the signature. Or, does he/she roll 4 dice at once then determine which spell, if any, to exchange for the signature spell.

I always imagined it was the latter, but my group plays it as the former so i am wondering what you all think?
 
The latter is correct. Check page 490 of BSB, under Spell Generation, third paragraph. There it says the following:
The spells a wizard knows are determined by rolling dice and consulting the Lore of Magic in question.

Now, the word dice is the plural form, so when know the you must roll several dice (if yo have more than one spell at least). Though it doesn’t say anything about rolling the dice separately, nor does is say anything specifically about rolling them all at once. To me rolling dice separately is more uncommon, and as is usual in warhammer for something to work differently some the normal it has to be specifically said so. Therefore we can only assume that we roll them all at once.

However, the spell generation part isn't very clearly written, all in all more like guidelines than rules (just look at that part about having to write down you lore selection in the army list), so to all of this the answers aren't very clear. For all we know GW could have intended us to roll spells for all wizards at once.
 
Mad said:
For all we know GW could have intended us to roll spells for all wizards at once.

Guess if I have more than 2 wizards I'll need to learn to roll dice with my feet if I have to roll them all up at the same time.....:clown:
 
Here's a question while on the topic. Let's say I roll doubles with my wizard on a spell I'd rather not have. Could I choose another spell and then choose the signature spell for the one I don't want? Not like I'd try to be this cheesy, but is it legal?

Also I didn't know you could choose a new spell if another wizard in your army knows it. I was under the impression that you could choose only if you rolled doubles for that wizard.
 
Also Bloodbathmcgrath
brb pg 162. ordinarily EACH spell can only be known once in the same ARMY. The only exceptions are where a spell is not generated randomly, such as:....... (gives too examples).... Otherwise, if you ROLL a spell twice (whether for the same Wizard or for a different Wizard in the army)you must normally replace the dupilcate spell with another of your choice from the same Lore.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu