Quickblood and Great Weapons

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
if you have asf and get a greatweapon, giving you asl you are nullified in terms of asl/asf and you go in initiative order instead

greatweapon gives the special rules 'asl'
this can be negated by spells or qb and whatnot but only once, asl and asf from different sources dont stack, since you can only be affected by a specialrule once
 
How about High Elves with their great swords and ASF. Will they be able to re-roll failed hits against lower initiative models?

I have a friend that plays HE. And he swears that his great swords are allowed a re-roll versus lower initiative because of the High Elves rule.

Does anyone know a rule in the BRB or HE Armybook that would allow him to re-roll his great swords?
 
Melle said:
the old highelf book allowed this.
the new one dont.

high elves with great weapons strike in initiative order now, and are therefore not allowed rerolls due to higher Initiative.

Is there a BRB Page Number that I can point too to explain that High Elves with ASF and Great Weapons DO NOT get a re-roll?
 
Page 66 BRB states that if you have both ASL and ASF they cancel each other out and neither is applied.

On page 90 BRB it says that GW's confer the ASF special rule.

Not even if they have more than one application of ASF do they get to reroll with a GW: (from the FAQ):
Page 66 – Special Rules, What Special Rules Does It Have. Change “[...]the effects of multiple special rules[...]” to “[...]the effects of different special rules[...]”Add “However, unless otherwise stated, a model gains no additional benefit from having the same special rule multiple times.” to the end of the first paragraph

The rule your friend is using is the "speed of asuryan" that stated you had ASF even with a great weapon, they do not have this special rule in 8th edition and therefore need to use the rules as mentioned above.
 
Sigh! Yep, I understand perfectly. My buddy is being difficult. He reads as striking at initiative to still allow the re-roll against lower initiative models.

How do I explain that when ASF cancels ASL then the initiative bonus does not apply?
 
Not sure you can explain it any other way.

Having both rules cancel eachother out.
Seeing as asf grants the reroll, which he no longer has because its negated by asl, then you cannot benefit from the rerolls when they have cancelled each other out.

If he still doesnt get it, eat his models. :)
 
take the big book and smack some sense into him:)

seriously, if bullhax reference doesnt help i dont know what will.

the new speed of asuryan grants asf rule.
great weapons give asl rule.

these cancel eachother, you have none, and both ( cant be affected again by them from any source )

rerolls due to higher initiative only applies if you have asf. taking greatweapon you loose asf so no rerolls.

show your friend this thread.
if he doesnt accept this, he cheats, and i Suggest then you play against someone else
 
Melle said:
take the big book and smack some sense into him:)

seriously, if bullhax reference doesnt help i dont know what will.

the new speed of asuryan grants asf rule.
great weapons give asl rule.

these cancel eachother, you have none, and both ( cant be affected again by them from any source )

rerolls due to higher initiative only applies if you have asf. taking greatweapon you loose asf so no rerolls.

show your friend this thread.
if he doesnt accept this, he cheats, and i Suggest then you play against someone else

...or eat his models.
 
That's heavens is decent lore for HE nowadays... If he gets off the "reroll 1s" spell on his White Lions, they perform similarly to the 7th edition WhiteLions, as they hit most things on 3s, rerolling 1s... so against most things natural 2s don't grant a reroll.

In any case they can't reroll if the have GWs... even if they're Initiative 10 versus ASL Initiative 1 zombies.

GWs cancel out ASF, and you can't reroll hits if you aren't ASF.
 
It is the ASF special rule that gives him the re-roll.. That is canceled by the ASL..

If making him read facts and clear cut rules doesn't work tell him your combat lord has the "elf-killah-sword" if it wounds an elf his entire unit dies no saves of any kind allowed it costs 10 points.. It's not legal or in the book but neither is his homw made rules so why not?

alternatively you could give him a dictionary or hit him or give him a snickers..!

Oh how I loath people who cheat!

Sorry for the rant. Bull out!
 
Show him page 66 of the BRB and then say show me where in your army book it states that ASL dont cancel it out.

Should be that easy.
 
As a High Elf player I can also confirm your opponent is incorrect. In the last book (7th ed. armybook) High Elves had a special rule called 'Speed of Asuryan' that both gave them ASF and allowed them to ignore ASL from GWs. This rule has been changed now in 8th such that Elves only have ASF. They do not ignore ASL from GWs any more. Thus, as everyone has said, WLs, SMs, etc, etc all strike at initiative without rerolls when wielding a GW.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu