WHFB - 7th Raising fellbats

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Yann-Drak

Skeleton
Mar 8, 2008
84
Zombies
45
In the new rulebook fell bats are under the infantry section.

Does a lord with summon creatures of the night by casting invocation increases their nymbers by a d6 like with skeleteons and the other infantry units?

I hope that is not answered on another section
 
IoN will give you you d6 wounds back. And fell bats have 2 wounds. So at best you could get 3 bats back if you rolled a 6.
 
If you have summon creatures of the night, then you can increase the size of the unit by 1d6 wounds (remember than each fell bat has 2 wounds, so a roll of 4 gives 2 fell bats with its full 2 wounds each)
 
Some people will argue they aren't infantry. I believe they are infantry, as it makes most sense. However you should know in case someone brings it up.

Their arguments: the list at the back of the book is not detailing unit types as "Mounts" (I believe) are not a unit type. Therefore it's plausible that Infantry is not referring to a unit type either, its just coincidence. {this is the strongest argument I've seen}
Other weak arguments: They are on 40x40 bases, therefore they are not infantry. {counter argument; Ogres are on 40x40 bases and are definitely infantry}
They are fliers, infantry move on foot {counter argument; having the 'flight' ability does not change a units type. Black Coaches with flight are still Chariots, Dragons are still Monsters, Vampires with flight are still Characters. Also Fell Bats can move on foot, and begin and end their move on foot}

There could be some more arguments but those are the main ones I've seen brought up.
 
As its put into the infantry section at the back of the book I would say it heals D6, as grishnakh pointed out just because something can fly does not automatically change its unit type, To be honest I've not met anyone who would argue against it yet but there's always a few. Incidentally if you heal 5 wounds I assume I bring back 3 bats, one bat one with one wound or would other say that you only get the model back if you roll for its full quota of wounds?
 
@Disciple if you have the book on you, and I'm at work, check out the other Unit entries at the back of the book. Do they all match up with unit entries at the front of the MRB? I thought they had an extra one or two that did not.
 
Yes they do, funnily enough flyers do not have a description under the unit section meaning unless specified otherwise they all come under infantry, and its does states some infantry can be mounted on 40mm bases.
 
Fell Bats are not infantry. If you look at page 7 of the Warhammer rule book there is some discussion of what the different troops are. At the very top is says "Infantry includes all units of foot troops, be they Goblins, Men, Ogres, Trolls, or any other of the myriad Warhammer races fighting on foot."

Twice there are references to being foot troops. Fell bats are not foot troops, and therefore are not infantry.
 
Then what, exactly Sashu, are they?
There are 6 groups defined:
Infantry
Cavalry
Warmachine
Chariot
Character
Monster

These are all the categories. Some models fall into multiple categories (eg. Treeman Ancient, both a monster and a character). So which is the fell bat? Obviously not Cavalry, Warmachine, Chariot, Character. This only leaves infantry and monster. Monsters have specific rules that fell bats do not. None of the section on "Monsters" applies to Fell bats. Fell bats must belong to a category though. I do not think they are classified as 'none of the above'.

As much as it doesn't make a lot of sense, Infantry is the 'best fit' for fell bats. If it is the Fly rule that negates them as being Infantry, take a look at some other units that have fly. The Dogs of War birdmen have the Fly rule and they are definitely infantry. If for some reason the Fellbats couldn't fly all game and had to move on foot, would this then make them infantry? As much as it doesn't feel right... I don't see any other category that is a better fit. And there's a lot of evidence stacked up that they are, indeed, infantry (such as being listed as infantry in the Vampire book).

Fell bats CAN be foot troops. They don't have to fly. They can choose to run around on their feet.

My 0.02.
 
@Sashu
Can you please tell me what kind of troop the fell bats are?
And the harpies? and the furies? and the terradons?

And be aware than a "Flyer" is not a troop type. Indeed they are infantry.
 
Yep, they are foot troops, that is 100% certain. What is not certain is if Gav Thorpe actually knew this when he wrote the book!

"Infantry includes all units of foot troops, be they Goblins, Men, Ogres, Trolls, or any other of the myriad Warhammer races fighting on foot."

Fell Bats do fight on foot. Whenever they're in combat, they're fighting on foot. QED.
 
I'm very glad I read this topic, I had never considered that Fell Bats were infantry, even though I am fully convinced by the case made for this here.
The only question is whether it was intent, but in a case where the rules so clearly cover the situation this is no reason not to play it.

I will certainly be taking a unit of Fell bats now I know this.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu