rare choice against WE

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

ozzkoz

Zombie
Jun 23, 2009
14
Zombies
14
What would be a better rare choice against the wood elves, a vargulf or black coach? These are the two rare choice I have, no blood knights (too many points for me) and no wraiths.

Thanks for any input.
 
Vargulf's against any elf are so so so good, but if they are going Dryad heavy it will off set the effectiveness of them. Not a fan of the Black Coach here, and glade riders will carry your blood knights out of the game.
 
I'd actually rate the Varghulf and the Black Coach as the two better rare choices that we've got available when fighting Wood Elves. They're both tough, manouverable and adept at tackling smaller units on their own. The Black Coach in particular can be hard for the Woodies to deal with (short of a Treeman or Dragon, and you should be able to avoid the former) thanks to its T6 and multiple saves. A surprising move that you can pull on your opponent (thanks go out to Grish for tipping me off about this) is to charge something inside a wood or other terrain with your Black Coach. As a chariot it will suffer D6 S6 hits upon entering the terrain, yes, but if any chariot is tough enough to withstand such punishment without much trouble, it'll be the Black Coach. This can be a good way to root out those annoying little skirmishing units who'll either have to flee out of their cover or stand and face the Coach's impact hits. :)
 
Varghulf every time. He squishes Wardancers xD and doesn't need to fear their Killing Blow dance etc. Bestial Fury is nice too, as WEs love trying to flank things.

The Coach is hard for them to kill, true, but it also can't safely enter terrain (at least not until its starts getting bonuses) so isn't that effective in this case.
 
Ah, but it can! D6 S6 is nasty, but it aint killer. As in the battle report I put up on the forum last week, you can be quite confident that the Coach will survive the damage. If you're charging something that can flee, then you may not even get into the forest anyway or terror might send them running. And if you do take a round of hits- we have the luxury of being able to heal it anyway, whilst Wood Elves can barely hurt it.

Another good thing about the rules for chariots in difficult terrain is that you only take one round of terrain hits per turn- so if you charge something at the edge of the forest, take the hits and then wipe them out, when you pursue/overrun that turn, you won't take another bunch of hits. So if you can get out the forest, you're home free! And if you can go ethereal, then it's lol o'clock.
 
Bit of math hammer:

D6 S6 hits on the coach:
Avg hits: 3.5 Avg wounds: 1.75. AS 6+: 1.75*5/6 WS 4+: 0.73 wounds dealt to the coach for going through terrain.

So on average, it'll likely take no wounds or a single wound. Nothing to worry about. After it gets locked in combat, as long as it's not against a lot of static CR, the coach is probably better than the Varghulf. T6, AS 3+, WS 4+. Apart from static CR, it's not going to get hurt (except against Treekin or Treemen).

The only thing to be careful of is if he flees from the charge. Then you're stuck in the forest, and likely to take another 2 rounds of hits, plus your coach will be pulled out of the game for some time.

Another good thing about the rules for chariots in difficult terrain is that you only take one round of terrain hits per turn- so if you charge something at the edge of the forest, take the hits and then wipe them out, when you pursue/overrun that turn, you won't take another bunch of hits.
It's my understanding all pursuing/overrunning units ignore terrain, including chariots. Is my infallible understanding incorrect once again?
 
Grish said:
Another good thing about the rules for chariots in difficult terrain is that you only take one round of terrain hits per turn- so if you charge something at the edge of the forest, take the hits and then wipe them out, when you pursue/overrun that turn, you won't take another bunch of hits.
It's my understanding all pursuing/overrunning units ignore terrain, including chariots. Is my infallible understanding incorrect once again?

Check WFB p.64 under 'Flee and Pursuit', the chariot still takes damage.
 
As a woodie player, I'd recommend the varghulf and coach too. Blood Knights will be flanked or taken for a ride, and the wood elf army has too many magic attacks for the wraiths to be really useful :)
 
hmm ok I'll have to try them both out (not together, I don't like maxing my rare slots) I guess a they both sound lie solid choices. Thanks all!!
 
varghulf, definintely. the BC wil be bogges down in terrain for most of the game, or having it's movement dictated by staying far enough from terrain that the WE can't move it onto the coach. I do think wraiths are better, on the whole, as skirmishers.
 
(See, there you go- a perfect example of how the Black Coach might catch an opponent unaware, as many will assume they'll go nowhere near terrain, when you may know better!)
 
D6 S6 is nasty, but it aint killer.
Clearly, you've never seen me roll dice. If it can go bad, it will.

Admittedly it should survive one round of hits, but would you enter the woods when playing against WEs? I'm a bit paranoid about that kind of thing.
 
I've played quite often WE with my vampires and I've often found that the warghulf has a big drawback: unless it is supported it rarely wins a combat against dyads. I haven't worked out the mathhammer for this case, but I happened to me quite often (even charging). I think the BC is slightly better (and I've also crashed it into a forest without taking too much harm), but the varghulf does a great job luring glade riders and kurnous to the open and eats wardancers.

In my oppinion, if you are going magic heavy use the BC, but otherwise the varghulf is a good option, just try to avoid locking with in battles with dryads alone.
 
I've played quite often WE with my vampires and I've often found that the warghulf has a big drawback: unless it is supported it rarely wins a combat against dyads.
Clearly your Varghulf is neglecting his duties. Mine shows them how its done every time. Even with the mathhammer, it should be in the Varghulf's favour every time. 3s and 3s with 5+ saves (plus re-rolls first round), vs 4s and 5s with a 4+ save?
 
Johnny B said:
I've played quite often WE with my vampires and I've often found that the warghulf has a big drawback: unless it is supported it rarely wins a combat against dyads.
Clearly your Varghulf is neglecting his duties. Mine shows them how its done every time. Even with the mathhammer, it should be in the Varghulf's favour every time. 3s and 3s with 5+ saves (plus re-rolls first round), vs 4s and 5s with a 4+ save?

Well, probably he does not like chopping wood :frown:, but a bit of mathhammer can help here. As you said, 5A to 3+ with hate should be about 4H, then 3+ should be around 3 wounds, and 5+ ward should mean 2 dryads bitting the dust. Then two of them attack (there are four in base contact), 4A with 3+ and 5+ to wound (with regeneration), so we win by one because the unit strenght if we are lucky, a relatively easy check with L8.

Next round (WE's phase) is even worse: they attack first, so it is 8A, 4 hits on average, so 1-2 wounds and hope for regeneration, and now we have even worse chances to eliminate two dryads because hate is no longer on. To make it worse normaly the WE would join also another unit to the combat, so our chances of suviving become slim.

Definitely it is a dangerous business, noting that the varghulf is worth twice the dyad unit. I definitely try to avoid this combat if I can. However, it is not a desperate combat, as Johnny B has pointed out.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu