RaW on Banner of the World Dragon

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Bakedvampire

Zombie
May 7, 2014
23
Zombies
21
I play a lot against high elves and the player does some sketchy stuff with the banner. I can understand if it's against all magical attacks but he takes 2+ ward saves against miscasts. I don't think miscasts are spell dammage but i can't find a rule to prove him wrong. He has also has been taking magic resist on units for ward saves against miscasts.
I was under the impression that magic resist is only for direct dmg and magic missles but can't find that in the book either.
Would like the RaW for the banner if anyone has the book on them, and possibly a clarification on magic resist! Ty
 
The banner works on any form of magical damage. That is why it works on miscast damage. It was faqed to say miscast is magic damage otherwise kemmler would be immune with him being ethereal.

Magic resistance only works on direct magic damage. A miscast does not count as direct damage in the same way a terrorgheist death shriek is magical but does not trigger resistance.
 
If you're playing VCs and you're trying to destroy the unit with the BotWD, you're doing it wrong.

Grow a unit of 40 zombies to like 60-80 and tarpit it.

The miscast thing is correct and is just bad game design on GW's part, not your opponent's fault. My question is, why did the HEs NEED the banner? In play testing were they finding that the Elves just kept getting blown out? That army is so absurdly over-powered even without the banner, I just don't understand what they were thinking putting it in there.

Oh wait, Matt Ward wrote that book and he does this with all the armies he plays. He's a power gamer who got given the keys to the kingdom.
 
Ripper said:
If you're playing VCs and you're trying to destroy the unit with the BotWD, you're doing it wrong.

Grow a unit of 40 zombies to like 60-80 and tarpit it.

The miscast thing is correct and is just bad game design on GW's part, not your opponent's fault. My question is, why did the HEs NEED the banner? In play testing were they finding that the Elves just kept getting blown out? That army is so absurdly over-powered even without the banner, I just don't understand what they were thinking putting it in there.

Oh wait, Matt Ward wrote that book and he does this with all the armies he plays. He's a power gamer who got given the keys to the kingdom.
BotWD is really, really easy to counter. Don't take magic weapons, and it's useless. (You don't need them against elves anyway.

HE were much scarier with armywide ASF on GWs.

And people are way too scared of High Elves, they work exactly how Elves should. I much prefer Ward's style of "make stuff in the army exciting to play" to Kelly's "Make 3 pages broken and balance it by making everything else garbage."
 
RarerMonsters said:
BotWD is really, really easy to counter. Don't take magic weapons, and it's useless. (You don't need them against elves anyway.

OK. Now explain how to counter it in a tournament.

Here's an example of the kind of stuff tournament HE players bring.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cq79Acwix5o

I agree that you don't really need magic weapons against HEs, but you will need them against other armies in a tournament and they will stil be there when you come up against the elves. And a vampire lord is S4 once the frost phoenix gets in there. You could give him a great weapon but now the elves are going to possibly kill you before you get to swing.
 
VL, AHW, RF/QB, Potion of S, 4++ in GG

Handles high armor from other factions and works around BotWD, can kill Phoenixes when you need to (which are overpriced and likely to hand you a solid chunk of points)

I don't see how it's ultimately worse than any other cheesed out tourney build, with the exception that in VC cheese is the only option. In HE, you can at least build an even list if you want to.
 
@Rarermonsters agreed, I think VC can make the most broken, cheesey list out of all the armies. Two TG, BK bus with three vamps. Dire wolf and ethereal chaff. Depressing for both sides.
 
I normally deal with any unit carrying BOTWD with Black knights or GG, killing blow and high strength do the job but it depends on what build you take in your force.
For instance the Lord bus I use would have to fight it but the lord would be doing next to nothing as he can't really hurt them due to their 2+ ward. :P
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu