WHFB - 7th Red Fury Power + Dragon?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

tailzZz

Zombie
Dec 29, 2008
26
Zombies
28
Hi all,

I cannot find this answer anywhere, hence the posting!

Many people talk about "Infinite Hatred" and how it is superior to the dreadlance because it effects the ZD as well.


Does the ZD, or any mount chosen for the vampire with the certain power, benefit from the power as well?

In the rulebook it says that all characters and their mounts are considered one model.

So Red Fury = Red Fury ZD?

Thanks for your input.
 
No Red Fury does not apply, nor do other powers. When people speak of taking Infinite Hatred affecting the dragon, that is because Infinite Hatred gives the vampire Hatred and hatred specifically transfers to mounts per the BRB. However, the ZD only benefits from basic hatred from what I know, and will not keep hatred in each round of combat as the vampire does.
 
Sorry, Gabriel, I can't work out why you'd think that. The mount gains the benefits of anything like Hatred to which its rider is subject, as I understand it, so the ZD would gain Infinite Hatred. The ZD could only gain basic Hatred if the vampire had that, but the vampire doesn't.
 
It confers hatred, and in addition to this the vampire can re-roll to hits rolls every round. The rules of hatred apply to the dragon and that is all.
 
No, sorry, I'm really not reading the rule in that way. Whatever applies to the rider applies to the mount, be it frenzy, hatred, stupidity, whatever (and vice versa, so that a vampire on a ZD causes Terror). Thus, Infinite Hatred must apply to the ZD. Infinite Hatred is a variant on Hatred. If you want to argue that the wording of the power applies only to the vampire because it specifically states that the vampire (not mentioning his mount) has Hatred and gets to re-roll in every round of combat then I could see your point (although I wouldn't agree), but in that case there's no justification for giving the dragon standard Hatred.
Unless it's been FAQ-ed and I haven't remembered reading that bit. I hate FAQs. They're just an excuse for not adequately play-testing an army and properly editing the army book. But that's another thread altogether.
 
You are not reading the rules about what passes on to the mount clearly. It mentions which specific abilities pass on including Hatred, Frenzy, etc. It does not mention Infinite Hatred, which is a seperate ability, so it would not pass on to the mount. However, a part of Infinite Hatred grants the vampire Hatred as defined in the rules for that power, so Hatred transfers to the mount as defined in the BRB. Infinite Hatred does not. Additionally defining Infinite Hatred as a variant of the Hatred rule is your own interpretation and is not supported by the rules. It is a completely seperate ability.
 
Sorry Geraint, Gabriel is quite correct.

The Infinite Hatred rule:

..Vampire hates all enemies.....

As clearly stated the vampire gains the psychology effect Hatred, which effect is passed onto a mount if applicable as per the BRB.

Then an additional supplement

...may re-roll failed rolls to hit in every round....

The additional part does not get passed onto the mount. This was cleared up months ago just after VC first came out. It works in the same way that if DE or fighting HE, whilst they too may re-roll on every round of combat, their mounts cannot.
 
All right, fair point!
To be pedantic, though, Infinite Hatred, since it grants Hatred along with another ability, IS a variant on Hatred. If it was a completely separate ability then, as DoN has elegantly argued, then Hatred couldn't be passed on to a mount. But I am being pedantic!
 
It could be called "Mildy exaggrated hatred" or "awesome hatred" or "fluffy bunny syndrome of anger" and it wouldnt make any difference. The name of the power is irrelevant. What it gives you is;

1. Hatred. Not a variant of it, just hatred.
2. The vamp re-rolls to hits every round.
 
Hi There,

I am having this same discussion on a forum on wargamerau.com. The subject is "VC rule query" in the warhammer general discussion section if you wanna take a look.

I'm very interested in this comment:
"The additional part does not get passed onto the mount. This was cleared up months ago just after VC first came out. It works in the same way that if DE or fighting HE, whilst they too may re-roll on every round of combat, their mounts cannot."

In the FAQ it states that mounts do get the re-rolls in all combats (ie its the same as Hatred, except that re-rolling is not limited to the first round of combat), but you have stated the opposite.
For me personally, I think that because the rules are worded the same, minus a name change and some added fluff in the DE description, that these rules are the same thing, and therefore VC mounts should get the re-rolls in all combat rounds.

PS. Sorry to revieve this thread after over a week of inactivety, but I was only just put onto this thread today.
 
Except that FAQ you are referring to is an army specific FAQ for Dark Elves, and not a general FAQ.

Unfortunately, as similar as the two powers might be in wording, you can't take a FAQ answer for one army, and apply it to another army's power. It just doesn't work that way. It'd be like taking a FAQ answer for VC, and trying to argue that it would also apply to TK as they are both Undead and are similarly worded.
 
But you can take the precident from them - ie, the FAQ sets the precident. Like Hellcannons - when i was working on the Warrior FAQ i had many arguments with TO's that a hellcannon could charge 12 because its a monster with handlers (they would not accept it although its quite clear)... like the DE war hydra (which had recently been FAQ'd to take movement penalties on the charge)

So i think there is some relivance in cross comparission between the DE hatred and the VC one

Personally i think the mount benefits every round, i think its just semantics and gamey to argue it the other way
 
There's a reason the text says the VAMPIRE benefits every round. If you think arguing that "vampire = vampire" is semantics, then, well, that says it all really.
 
Death Stalker said:
But you can take the precident from them - ie, the FAQ sets the precident. Like Hellcannons - when i was working on the Warrior FAQ i had many arguments with TO's that a hellcannon could charge 12 because its a monster with handlers (they would not accept it although its quite clear)... like the DE war hydra (which had recently been FAQ'd to take movement penalties on the charge)

So i think there is some relivance in cross comparission between the DE hatred and the VC one

Personally i think the mount benefits every round, i think its just semantics and gamey to argue it the other way

Thank you! This is what I was trying to get at. I am in the process of getting in touch with the Dire Wolf FAQ council to submit my Q for an A.

EvC said:
There's a reason the text says the VAMPIRE benefits every round. If you think arguing that "vampire = vampire" is semantics, then, well, that says it all really.

Well most of the VC army book was badly worded (thanks Gav Thorpe and GW proof readers!:rolleyes: ). It took 5 pages worth of FAQ to clear it up, and even then it's still missing Q&A's!!:|
 
Yeah but you've got to admit that GW are reliable in making so many mistakes.
I really think the problem is that to look at every situation possible would take ages and GW don't want to do that.
As to the question, if it says hatred, IN ADDITION THE VAMPIRE... (can't remember exactly what it says) then it gives the normal rules for hatred and the benefit of the vampire having it in every round of cc.
 
Completely agree with EvC...

Until you can show me a VC FAQ or where in the BRB that states that Infinite Hatred is conferred onto the mount as well, then sorry but no dice.

The BRB states that psych like Hatred is conferred to the mount, but no mention of Infinite Hatred. And Infinite Hatred is made up of two parts. The Vampire hates all enemies, which is conferred to the mount as per the BRB, but as well, the Vampire gets to re-roll missed hits in all rounds of combat.

In the DE FAQ they were nice enough to clarify that with Eternal Hatred, the re-rolls are also passed onto the mounts. They didn't do that with the VC FAQ and Infinite Hatred though, did they?? You can talk to me all you want about precidents being set, and whatever else you want to. But until you can show me where it is stated in writing and officially that the re-roll ability is passed onto the mount with Infinite Hatred, then you don't have a leg to stand on.

Dark Elves and Vampire Counts are two seperate armies, and Eternal Hatred and Infinite Hatred are two seperate abilities/powers unique to each army. As much as you would love to have them work the same after the DE FAQ came out, nothing official from GW supports that assumption. The rules that are out there currently for the VC army do not support your view. That may change in the future, but until it does.. :tongue:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu