red fury vs quickblood

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Zully

Ghoul
Aug 14, 2013
183
Zombies
161
ive noticed that people take red fury as their primary vampire power, using my (i will admit woefully inaccurate) mathhammer, isn't quickblood a better point for point power? as the initial 33% "to miss" renders red fury less desirable, quickblood gives you the rerolls which means you are only missing "12%" which makes your overall % hit/wound much higher

running the numbers on a naked baby vamp vs an enemy with WS 5 or less, an average T of 3 and equal to or less than I of 6

Quickblood Kills 73% on every attack
Red Fury Kills 55% on every attack

combine the two for max carnage, but i think its debateable red fury>quickblood if its a one or the other, or am i missing something?
 
I'm on boat with you, I feel like 4 reliable attacks are a lot more important to me than a potential 8. Now on a lord then I run both, but yeah on a baby vamp its quickblood all day for me. Especially with it being 20 points cheaper!!
 
Corien Sumatris said:
I'm on boat with you, I feel like 4 reliable attacks are a lot more important to me than a potential 8. Now on a lord then I run both, but yeah on a baby vamp its quickblood all day for me. Especially with it being 20 points cheaper!!

I just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing something obvious that the old bloods are in the know about :)
 
I like Red Fury because of Van Hels. If you get a Van Hels off, quickblood offers very minimal benefit. On the other hand, Red Fury gives great benefit with Van Hels.

Essentially, there are other ways to get rerolls to hit (Van Hels). There are no other ways to get additional attacks from wounds.

Additionally, I typically get my baby vampire the Sword of Striking, so hitting occurs on a 2+. Rerolls to hit aren't as important when you hit on 2+.
 
datalink7 said:
I like Red Fury because of Van Hels. If you get a Van Hels off, quickblood offers very minimal benefit. On the other hand, Red Fury gives great benefit with Van Hels.

Essentially, there are other ways to get rerolls to hit (Van Hels). There are no other ways to get additional attacks from wounds.

Additionally, I typically get my baby vampire the Sword of Striking, so hitting occurs on a 2+. Rerolls to hit aren't as important when you hit on 2+.
That's a really good solution vs scaven and at 15 points a bargin! Thanks for the tip :)
 
Zully said:
datalink7 said:
I like Red Fury because of Van Hels. If you get a Van Hels off, quickblood offers very minimal benefit. On the other hand, Red Fury gives great benefit with Van Hels.

Essentially, there are other ways to get rerolls to hit (Van Hels). There are no other ways to get additional attacks from wounds.

Additionally, I typically get my baby vampire the Sword of Striking, so hitting occurs on a 2+. Rerolls to hit aren't as important when you hit on 2+.
That's a really good solution vs scaven and at 15 points a bargin! Thanks for the tip :)

Sword of striking, enchanted shield, and Talisman of Endurance is a really nice set up for 50 pts.

3+/5++ on foot or 1+/5++ mounted, hits most things on 2+ and wounds most things on 2-3+. Great to help assist Vamp Lord in clearing out regular troops.
 
I quite like the +1str sword, quickblood, dreadknight, shining armour, shield and 2+ flaming attack ward save combo (meaning that standard rank and file ws3 are hitting on 6's)

(I'm playing in a 1000pt campaign where we need to field all comers lists)

But I'm also toying with the idea of making my vamp a knight on barded knightmare with heavy armour, lance, quickblood, dreadknight, talisman of preservation and charmed shield, I'm likely to face a hell pit so having 2 4+ armour saves could prove vital against the stomps and auto hits
 
I'm with datalink7 (and I usually am, that's one vamp who knows his stuff). Take RF and Sword of Striking with the 5+ ward and shadow for miasma for a vamp hero.
 
Sen, you and I don't often disagree, but I'm sticking with quickblood for hero vamps. I've had great success with it and it s cheap. I see the awesome behind red fury, I just feel like its not as good as everyone's makes it out to be. Now on a vamp lord the mm its totally worth it, but I just dont see it on a hero
 
RF, Sword of ASF, lvl 1 Shadow, armour-ed pony, and all the armor/wards/MR/Flag of Blood Keep that goes with that. Obvs for a BK/BldK list. Best I seem to come up with.
 
You want your Hero to be a 1-turn Lord/Monster killer?

Get him: Red Fury, Sword of Swift Slaying/Striking (if you have Van hel's), Potion of Strength + as much Armour as you can. Pop the Potion in the important turn and watch him eat stuff!!

You want him as a support hammer, that works well against troops, but should not do any heavy lifting?

Just as above, but focus more on his protection, rather than his killing power. Most troops have enough with S5.


And finally, you need him to provide a stable CR because he is in a rather weak unit? (Skeletons, or Ghouls)
Then yeah, Sword of Might / Ogre Blade + Quickblood should do the trick (if you are not using the Ogre blade on a Lord)

I usually use a second blender on a Knight bus, because they tend to provide no CR on their own (no Ranks, and sometimes my Black Knights refuse to hit, even with Barrows!) So, yeah they are needed with Red Fury there. When he is sitting with Ghouls, I actually need him to wound heroes/chariots, so he goes with 4 solid attacks =)
 
Can always bust out the math as well.

Vamp with Sword of Striking and Red Fury vs. Vamp with Sword of Might & Quickblood

Vs. Toughness 3:

Red Fury Vamp does 4.69 wounds
Quickblood Vamp does 2.96 wounds

Vs. Toughness 4:

Red Fury Vamp does 3.45 wounds
Quickblood Vamp does 2.96

Vs. Toughness 5:

Red Fury Vamp does 2.36 wounds
Quickblood Vamp does 2.37 wounds

Vs. Toughness 6, Quickblood pulls ahead.

Note: this is also not taking into account any armor saves.

So it depends what you want. If you want to deal with Toughenss 6+, or high armor saves, quickblood vamp might be better. In my opinion, though, most of the time the baby vamp is there to help clear away basic troops. Bigger stuff the Vampire Lord can deal with.

Additionally, the above is with no magic buffs. If you get a van hels off, the Red Fury vamp does even better while the quick blood vamp doesn't change. If you get a hellish vigor off, it helps both but Red Fury vamp stays ahead below 6 toughness.
 
It's kinda down to your personal preference. Mathhammer might support one or the other in X circumstances, but as with army composition and tactics, it depends on you. Some people *hated* random winds of magic because it removed certainty from their game. The same people only take lores that have a signature spell that will *always* be useful.

Personally, I prefer to either succeed gloriously or crash and burn in a blaze of glory. So its Fusrodah Ghoul Kings or Red Fury Lords for me! (Alternatively, take *both* powers...!)
 
They are both very good vampiric powers (¿best ones?).

But the reason, IMHO, why red fury is better than quickblood is simple: ASF isn´t the only way our fighty characters can achieve reroll to hit their failed attacks, we also have the VANHEL´S danse macabre. And we can have it two times in the same magic phase: as a simple spell, and with the ever taken, the arkhan book.

So quickblood, wich is very good, isn´t as necessary as the maximum carnag...red fury, XDDD
 
Corien Sumatris said:
I'm on boat with you, I feel like 4 reliable attacks are a lot more important to me than a potential 8. Now on a lord then I run both, but yeah on a baby vamp its quickblood all day for me. Especially with it being 20 points cheaper!!

I'm the same. I prefer having more reliable attacks, rather than more potential attacks.

It also lets me buy Beguile (or Dread Knight), which can be useful if my hero vampire ends up against an enemy hero.
 
It really is a question of expected returns and variation. Cutting everything else out of the equation, against our stock standard WS3 T3 opponent (vamps ignore the stock standard 5+ armour save).

taking quickblood means you can expect to kill:
hit chance wound chance chance per attack
(1-(2/6 * 2/6)) * (1-1/6) = 74.07%

0.7407 * 4 = 2.96 wounds

wheras red fury will earn you:

(1-2/6) * (1-1/6) = 55.56%

0.5556 * 4 = 2.22 wounds

+ red fury means final wound count =

2.22 + (0.5556 * 2.22) = 3.46 wounds

For comparison's sake, against an enemy of equal toughness and weapon skill red fury does 1.25 wounds whilst quickblood does 1.5

Now it goes without saying that there is a great deal more variation in the wounds that red fury doesearns you compared to the wounds that quickblood earns you however you can expect red fury to give you a much better result in the long run against most foes.

Also, as people have said previously, there are many other ways of getting the benefits of quickblood (vanhels, corpse carts, scrying pool etc) while only one way of getting red fury.

Ignoring equipment, etc I would pick red fury as the returns are greater most of the time (and the returns are greater than the increase in cost too :P )
 
Vipoid said:
Corien Sumatris said:
I'm on boat with you, I feel like 4 reliable attacks are a lot more important to me than a potential 8. Now on a lord then I run both, but yeah on a baby vamp its quickblood all day for me. Especially with it being 20 points cheaper!!

I'm the same. I prefer having more reliable attacks, rather than more potential attacks.

It also lets me buy Beguile (or Dread Knight), which can be useful if my hero vampire ends up against an enemy hero.

But see, I think this is simply a false belief. It depends on what you want.

Against toughness 3 & 4, Red Fury is MORE reliable than quickblood. Against toughness 5, they are roughly similar, and toughness 6 and above quickblood is better.

This level of toughness is modified depending on the armor of the enemy, with quickblood becoming more reliable against better armor saves.

Quickblood doesn't automatically mean more reliable. Getting more attacks can mean more reliable average number of wounds. It depends on what you are facing and how you want to kit your hero.
 
datalink7 said:
Against toughness 3 & 4, Red Fury is MORE reliable than quickblood. Against toughness 5, they are roughly similar, and toughness 6 and above quickblood is better.

I think you're misunderstanding what I mean by 'reliable', and confusing it with which one inflicts the most wounds on average.

datalink7 said:
Quickblood doesn't automatically mean more reliable. Getting more attacks can mean more reliable average number of wounds.

But that's the thing - if your initial attacks miss, you'll get no extra ones from red fury. On the other hand, if you roll badly with quickblood, you have the rerolls to (hopefully) set things right. That's what I mean by reliable.
 
Vipoid said:
datalink7 said:
Against toughness 3 & 4, Red Fury is MORE reliable than quickblood. Against toughness 5, they are roughly similar, and toughness 6 and above quickblood is better.

I think you're misunderstanding what I mean by 'reliable', and confusing it with which one inflicts the most wounds on average.

datalink7 said:
Quickblood doesn't automatically mean more reliable. Getting more attacks can mean more reliable average number of wounds.

But that's the thing - if your initial attacks miss, you'll get no extra ones from red fury. On the other hand, if you roll badly with quickblood, you have the rerolls to (hopefully) set things right. That's what I mean by reliable.

But you have to factor in extra attacks into the reliability rating.

Reliability is all about what you will do on average. On average, with the setups mentioned in the post earlier, Red Fury will reliably inflict more wounds than Quickblood against toughness 3 and 4.

Now perhaps you want to say that there is less of a chance of a complete wiff, but I think the difference there is negligible.

I'm not good at math so maybe I'm messing this up, but:

Red Fury misses on 1's only = 1/6 * 1/6 * 1/6 * 1/6 = about a 0.06% chance of a complete wiff.

Quickblood misses on 1 or 2 with reroll = 1/3 * 1/3 * 1/3 * 1/3 * 1/3 * 1/3 * 1/3 * 1/3 = about a 0.01% chance of a complete wiff.

So you have a 5 hundredths of 1 percent difference between the two. I don't think that's a statistic that is particularly meaningful, which is why I believe it is better to use the average damage to decide which will provide you with a more reliable outcome.
 
As this debate somes up a lot, I have decided to build a versatile system of comparison between red fury, quickblood and red fury + quickblood. it is assumed that quickblood is giving you re-rolls in this calculation. Calculating it for every to hit and to wound combination would be tedious and result in unwieldy outputs, however you can modify the example. In this example there are 4 attacks, hitting on 3s and wounding on 2s.

http://anydice.com/program/2a98

(you may skip this if you can skip this paragraph if you don't want to know how it works)
Each wound is calculated as a die with it's distribution of results being either 0 or 1 dependent on the attacks, chance to hit and chance to wound.
As given, the initial value "4d" refers to 4 of these dice being rolled.
The next value, "[highest 1 of Wd6]>Y" is the probability of a hit. When there is a re-roll, W=2, otherwise W=1. Y refers to the dice score that you need to be above to hit (one less than the to hit value). In the example, Y is 2 meaning a 3+ to hit
The final value "d6>Z" is the probability of wounding where Z is the value needed to beat in order to hit (one less than the to hit value). In the example, Z=1


If you would like to calculate probabilities for different comparisons of weapon skills and toughnesses, insert the corresponding to hit or wound score into the given formulas then press "calculate" (please don't change anything other than the initial attacks and to hit/ to wound scores



Switching to the "at least" mode and running a few different calculations such as hitting and wounding on 4s and hitting and wounding on 6s shows that red fury, while having a greater variation in value, is actually more likely (or only very slightly less likely) to produce any particular value than it's quickblood counterpart
 
I find quickblood to be useful against elves due to both high and dark having asf across the board. Also having asf denies them getting re-rolls against you. If you only take red fury, you run the risk of being cut down before you can strike.

The re-rolls QB grants against other armies is always useful (how many times have you rolled your x attacks and missed completely?) but, denying elves the re-rolls is golden. I would prefer to take QB on a baby vamp and get some strength boosting gear over the SoSS against the majority of opponents although, that blade plus RF will make a baby blender at S5 which will do a number on poorly armoured, low toughness troops.
 
Ravenheart said:
I find quickblood to be useful against elves due to both high and dark having asf across the board. Also having asf denies them getting re-rolls against you. If you only take red fury, you run the risk of being cut down before you can strike.
ASF does not deny the enemy his rerolls. Only higher initiative does that. Read the rules for ASF again.
 
blekinge said:
ASF does not deny the enemy his rerolls. Only higher initiative does that. Read the rules for ASF again.

I think you're the one who needs to re-read the ASF rules.

If two models fighting each other both have ASF, they cancel out and neither get the rerolls.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu