refusing a challenge

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Oct 7, 2011
23
Zombies
27
My Vampires were taking on my son's Orc's. Vlad flank a unit already in close combat with my grave guard. I called out a challenge to his general in the unit. He refused the challenge. That round of combat the guard and Vlad took out a number of Orc big boys. That left vlad now base contact with the BSB. He was carrying some type of standard that nullified all magic items. Therefore, Vlad lost several advantages including the Carstein ring.

Next turn he calls make way and moves his general over to Vlad. Since Vlad is in contact with the magic banner he can't use magic. Bad rolls transpire and Vlad is lost no use of the ring.

Question: Since I issued a challenge the round before and the general refused it can he the next round of combat come back now and make attacks directly at Vlad. Seems if he was coward enough to deny the challenge why would he come back, unless it was the power of the magic standard that changed his mind

Thanks
 
pat@debrock.net said:
My Vampires were taking on my son's Orc's. Vlad flank a unit already in close combat with my grave guard. I called out a challenge to his general in the unit. He refused the challenge. That round of combat the guard and Vlad took out a number of Orc big boys. That left vlad now base contact with the BSB. He was carrying some type of standard that nullified all magic items. Therefore, Vlad lost several advantages including the Carstein ring.

Next turn he calls make way and moves his general over to Vlad. Since Vlad is in contact with the magic banner he can't use magic. Bad rolls transpire and Vlad is lost no use of the ring.

Question: Since I issued a challenge the round before and the general refused it can he the next round of combat come back now and make attacks directly at Vlad. Seems if he was coward enough to deny the challenge why would he come back, unless it was the power of the magic standard that changed his mind

Thanks

Thanks, one more question if I would have then issued a challenge. I would have base to base his general but my corner would be touching the magic BSB. Would the magic banner still affect me since I am in a challenge
 
I'm a little confused as to how the BSB was left in b2b with Vlad, he doesn't get to move if he is already in combat, the only reason he gets to move is if issue a challenge and he accepts.

How did a orc warboss even kill Vlad? he has to take a beguile test at -4 if he even wishes to hit him! Also the banner does not stop his ring from bringing him back to life, the moment you die you are no longer in b2b, the effect of the ring is not until you die, as such you get to roll to come back to life.

Next turn he calls make way and moves his general over to Vlad. Since Vlad is in contact with the magic banner he can't use magic. Bad rolls transpire and Vlad is lost no use of the ring.

Do you mean magic or magic items? if its magic it has no effect on that, I'm still confused how vlad even managed to get into b2b with two orc characters, he should be on the corner of the unit so at best he can get on or the other.
 
Well, I've never heard of the BSB Magical Banner in question, so I can't bring light to that matter

However, if the Orc unit was engaged in both the Front and the Flank, then there is only one explanation:

The Unit contained at least full command and 4 characters. Also, the Unit was formed 5-wide.

Why?

Because: Having the full command models fighting the Grave Guard, means only 2 characters were in B2B contact and thus cannot "Make Way" to the flank. One of them, was the General (maybe).

When Vlad issued the Challenge, none accepted it and the OP decided to send the General cowering away from that combat. That means another character had to step-up to fill the blank space the General just left. Being that the BSB suddenly ended up next to Vlad after killing a number of Orcs, means that the Unit shrank to only 2 Ranks, because the BSB Character had to move to the flank where Vlad was.

(I can't see why he couldn't just Make Way next to Vlad in the first place... but never mind, we move on)

If this was not so, then maybe there was an illegal (although unintended) step-up movement, that would not allow the General to come in contact with Vlad himself. Maybe if I had a little bit more information as how many enemy Characters were in that Orc unit, how many Ranks were left right before Vlad fell.

In regards to the question: Yes, any Character who's lucky enough his Unit didn't break the combat he cowers from can make a come back, but he must follow all the rules of placing: Always in the front rank, unless there is no room. Then he goes on the rank before (anywhere he wants) and, then he can Make way to get himself in b2b contact with an enemy, displacing Rank & File models only.
 
Its a 100pts banner which also gives you D6 magic resistance, as for the stepup move, the bits that sounds dodgy is how the BSB got into b2b with vlad, he's already engage in combat, as such he doesn't get to make a sideasmove. The only way I can see this working is if the unit was butchered down to to just being the 2 characters, even then it would have be a challenge which would then allow the orc warlord into b2b long side the b2b.

On the makeway move, he can make a makeway move if he is not in combat, if he went to the back, hid and them came to the front he would be engaged and unable to move into b2b with vlad
 
this is great!! First time I have actually asked questions on a board and it is fantastic thanks for the help

Here is the issue just before the battle I moved Vlad out of the unit of grave guard to run down his Shaman who was on the flank of the orcs. I took him out then charged the orcs by Vlad on flank and GG on front. The first round of CG I explained already. The key being both Vlad and GG did serious damage. The BSB was in the front row on the Vlad side of the unit at the start of the battle. The first round because there were enough ranks in line Vlad was not touching it. However, because of enough kills and he did not have to flee the Vlad was forced to moved up the ranks to touch the second rank of Orcs. His was now corner to corner with BSB so magic was impacted. Next round his general now in the opposite side of rank 2 makes way to come over face to face with Vlad. That is how I was touching BSB and also his general.

I don't understand the beguile test mentioned above, I thought that was only for leadership tests not for battles.

Also just to confirm the ring would still function because he would be dead no longer in impacted by the BSB.

This is really great and appreciate the assistance
 
Ok, in future this is what you do, you kill his BSB, be it with grave guard (you should be able to get 4 in b2b if the unit is wide enough), if he ends up in b2b with vlad then you simply use vlad to kill him, then when the warlord gets to attack you have your magic items back. If you do this enough times he will quickly learn that a BSB needs a wardsave, otherwise he will simply die.

Vlad has a vampire power called Beguile, after challenges have been issued you pick a model in b2b, its takes a leadership test at -3, if he fails he has to reroll all successful hits, as he also has aura of dark majesty he makes units with 6" a additional -1 leadership. If you pick a warlord, he must take a leadership test on leadership 5, if he fails the test he has to reroll all successful to hit rolls, it doesn't matter who they are aimed at either. Don't forget with vlad on his own he should be taking two fears at -1 leadership.

Yes he would still get his 2+ come back to life, the rules do not come into effect until he is removed from play, being removed from play removes him from b2b contact with the BSB.
 
I believe the reason the bsb got into base contact with vlad was because he had earlier declined a challenge, stepped back so that he is not in base contact witht he enemy, and then make way?
 
Either way, a character cannot make way if they are already fighting. if his general was engaged with the GG, he can't make way (rulebook specifically says "unegaged characters" may make way).

Once in base to base contact, the only way a character can move at all is through a) wiping out the unit he is in contact with or b) reforming after combat (however you can't combat reform when you are engaged on two sides, so this wouldn't have been possible).

EDIT: Just saw that you said his general was in the 2nd rank. How was the general in the 2nd rank? Did he have 3+ characters in the unit and a full command?
 
Demian said:
Then he goes on the rank before (anywhere he wants) and, then he can Make way to get himself in b2b contact with an enemy, displacing Rank & File models only.

Using "make way" you can displace R&F and command models.

Gatti said:
EDIT: Just saw that you said his general was in the 2nd rank. How was the general in the 2nd rank? Did he have 3+ characters in the unit and a full command?

I believe that is where he was placed after refusing the challenge.
 
Yeah, sorry, Make Way displaces R&F and Command Models =)

Anyway, just as logan said, kill the BSB first, if it is carrying a Magical Banner, the more reason to (every magical banner boosts the Unit that holds him, killing him ASAP disables the strategy!).

Also, yes I was wondering if the enemy Unit had (at least) 3 characters, because even if the enemy General was "placed" next to Vlad due to casualties (and Vlad moved a bit when the Unit "shrank"), when he refuses a Challenge he does not count as being B2B with anyone, not even if the entire Unit disappears that round. Then, when he comes back, he must be placed in the Unit with a legal formation.

Only by having an additional Character and Full Command can such character end up on the 2nd Rank, and then he can Make Way wherever he wants.

Oh, and as a reminder: Kill the BSB! Always! :D!
 
You can of course also challenge him with another character (if available) and prevent the lord fom hitting Vlad or alternatively move the BSB somewhere else.

Also in 7th it used to be the challenger who determined which enemy character that got moved to the back when the opponent refused a challenge. Has this changed? If not you can chose to move his BSB/General/champion or whoever to the back depending on who you want to kill by directing your attacks against him. Challenge or not you can still hit him.
 
You can still choose which character will be "Boo"ed

And sending the (most likely better equipped) General away was indeed a smart move, because the Unit should have broken in that combat...

but lucky snake eyes do happen.

Even if you send the BSB away, the Unit still benefits from every special rule that affects the Unit anyway. They just can't use their Ld.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu