Regeneration-lost to flaming attacks

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Mar 24, 2012
7
Zombies
7
Last night I played a game against an Ogre army. He had a Firebelly which struck at the same initiative step as the rest of his unit (I 2). I had a unit of Crypt Horrors in HtH combat with the Ogres and Firebelly. My question, Do I lose the regeneration save against the whole unit if he chooses to shoot the breath weapon first in the combat and wounds one of my Crypt Horrors? I played it that they lost the save just to avoid having to search through the rulebook, but figured I'd check the forums for a consensus answer.

Thanks,

Dave
 
Mad said:
In Sweden the common way to play it is that you get regen, but I'm pretty sure there is no definite answer. I guess it could fall under the sequencing rule, and thus you would (likely) lose regen in your opponents turn but keep it in yours.

Lolwhat?

"Sequencing" in combat doesn't necessarily apply (unless we're taking into account certain special powers and what have you). The order of attacks occurs, as described in the rule book, in initiative order. If flaming attacks hit at the same time as the rest of your unit you still get regen saves against everything but the flaming attacks. Your opponent can not argue against this. If he does he is flagrantly breaking the rules of the game for his own interests.
 
On the other hand a stupidly sneaky trick with a firebelly is its flaming impact hits and the wording on regen states that if a unit is wounded by a flaming attack it looses its regen. Very easy way for ogres to snipe characters with regen saves.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
On the other hand a stupidly sneaky trick with a firebelly is its flaming impact hits and the wording on regen states that if a unit is wounded by a flaming attack it looses its regen. Very easy way for ogres to snipe characters with regen saves.

And this is why Ogres are a pain in the ass. :vampire3:
 
TobiasRathein said:
Mad said:
In Sweden the common way to play it is that you get regen, but I'm pretty sure there is no definite answer. I guess it could fall under the sequencing rule, and thus you would (likely) lose regen in your opponents turn but keep it in yours.

Lolwhat?

"Sequencing" in combat doesn't necessarily apply (unless we're taking into account certain special powers and what have you). The order of attacks occurs, as described in the rule book, in initiative order. If flaming attacks hit at the same time as the rest of your unit you still get regen saves against everything but the flaming attacks. Your opponent can not argue against this. If he does he is flagrantly breaking the rules of the game for his own interests.

Whatever. All I know is that it has been under debate here in Sweden. But I'm not going to start arguing about it (more than I already have) since we had the same conclusion. An FaQ about it would still be nice I think...

EDIT: Also, remember that the stomp attacks would benefit from the regen loss.
 
The good news is you have a legitimate counter to that argument, Mad! Next time someone tries that on you tell him what we've gone over here.

If your opponent still doesn't believe you after that I'm not really sure what to say.
 
Stomp is ASL so it comes AFTER initiative 2 firebelly, so of course the regen is gone by then, this doesn't prove anything.

Also, impact hits won't be flaming, they wont get rid of regen. Unless otherwise stated regen gives you flaming shooting and close combat attacks, and as per the main FAQ special rules that inflict hits in close combat do not count as close combat attacks.
 
@Tobias: I've never had trouble with this on my own, I just know about the discussion through other forums. But as I said most people agree that it doesn’t remove regen. I just brought the thing up because I feel that the answer isn't written in stone (like so many GW rule issues) and that is something people should be aware of.

@Gojira: I didn't bring Stomp up as an argument, just as a reminder, so that no one will miss it.

I apologize for being unclear. It was never my intention to start a discussion about this.
 
No big deal, Mad 'At. You're right in that it's not as clear as it should be. It would only take a few sentences in the main FAQ to clear any issue up.
 
Gojira said:
Also, impact hits won't be flaming, they wont get rid of regen. Unless otherwise stated regen gives you flaming shooting and close combat attacks, and as per the main FAQ special rules that inflict hits in close combat do not count as close combat attacks.

I suggest you re-read the rules again, Pg#71 very bottom paragraph on resolving impact hits. Impact hits ARE CC attacks and with the flaming banner any wounds caused by them will remove regen.
 
Yea, it does say that but what are FAQs for? They tell us how they want us to play the game. Firstly we counted them as CC attacks, no problem there, then the faq comes along telling us that special rules that inflict hits in CC are not actually close combat attacks. Impact hits is most certainly a special rule. I would prefer to ignore this part of the faq but I can't really? It's pretty much a classic case of RAW says one thing FAQ says another.

The ideal situation would be to upgrade the lobotomised monkeys writing the faqs to ones with intact brains.
Edit: I should go on record as saying it was fine to begin with and in my opinion impact hits became caught in the crossfire aimed at something else. But there are people posting in this very thread who are advocates of playing it as is and by the faq rulings. We can't really have our cake and eat it.
 
Well every GT tourney I have been to in the NE and Canada has never played it that way and have counted impact hits with the banner as flaming. And truthfully I have never seen it stated any other way on any other forum. So I guess we'll just keep playing it that way and call it good.....:thumbsup:
 
I am with Gojira on this one. Yes, IH are considered cc attacks. But again, as Gojira states, in the brb faq it states special rules that inflict CC attacks do not benefit. It cites breath weapons and stomps, but IH is locates in the special rules section also. Kind of hard to argue with that.
 
midean said:
Well every GT tourney I have been to in the NE and Canada has never played it that way and have counted impact hits with the banner as flaming. And truthfully I have never seen it stated any other way on any other forum. So I guess we'll just keep playing it that way and call it good.....:thumbsup:

There is nothing wrong with a tourney modifying things to suit their own comp. I myself play mostly ETC comp, so I don't have a problem with this.

On the other hand, I wouldn't expect to go to an uncomped 'default' warhammer tourney and expect to be able to ignore an FAQ answer I don't like because it's silly or nonsensical.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu