A very similar thing happened with me, I was jaded and spent half my 20s away from all GW games, but remained on the periphery and got into Warmachine and Iron Kingdoms roleplay with DND 3.5. I saw Space Hulk come out in 2009 and I genuinely thought GW had turned a corner and it was time to come back; I bought into that game hard and I'm still building a crusading Terminator force, I just gotta have rival Space Hulk teams! I went Dark Angels and Imperial Fists at first, chopping up my first two Blood Angels squads, then I regretted losing the originals and got another intact Blood Angels squad, then after my mate lost/threw out his Space Wolf squad I decided to do them as well, I just love GW's recent Terminator sculpts! Then of course there's the unique Captains, command staff, new weapon options and the new Deathwing Terminators, making them useable for 40K... And expanding on the Stealers to build a Genestealer Cult... Aaaagh!!!
A lot of the mania came on in the past couple of years, but for about a year or I was happy with my Space Hulk, between modelling and playing occasionally. Then along came Island Of Blood and White Dwarf Issue 367; purely off the back of that awesome VC army with the unit fillers, modelled bases and unique colour scheme I threw myself back into the fantasy world with abandon, and I'll tell you something, I will never sell on my collection again! I'm now retracing my original footsteps in Fantasy from 15 years ago, collecting Undead and Elves and playing 8th Edition; Empire are on the horizon and I have a horde of Orcs and Goblins that I really don't need in my life!
This hobby's a cruel mistress, but I do love it! I think there's a lot to what people say, that although it's punishing on the wallet for us veterans it's madly prohibitive for the kids that are just starting up; for that reason alone I can understand and get behind Age Of Sigmar. Thanks for mentioning Spikedog, if his models are as inspirational as that WD army I reckon I'm in for a treat!