Rolling for spells - what order????

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Zanthor

Ghoul
Jun 22, 2010
162
Zombies
146
Ok, so I've got

Lvl 3 with MotBA and Forbidden Lore (Shadow)
Lvl 4 with MotBA with Lore of Vampires
a Necromancer with IoN and Vanhels Danse
a Lvl 1 Vampire with a Power stone.

Which vampire should I roll first to ensure that I get the spells that I want on my Lvl 4???
 
Hmm, you can't guarantee it in this situation. The Necro chooses his spells, so doesn't count and the vamp is only going to get one spell. So that leaves 5 for your Lvl 4 meaning you may not get the spell you actually want, for example you may not get Vanhels.
 
DoN is right its not a guranted thing but if you roll your hero first there will be 5 spells and your level 4 will know four so if you go that order you will have only 80% chance of getting what you want...I think :innocent:
 
I think I was looking at it from the wrong perspective. While I'd like to be able to arrange my spells as I please, and completely do away with Raise Dead, I don't think I can manage it.

So instead I should prioritize the spells that I want, which would be

Summon Undead Horde (4-5 dice for 5D6 is better than 2 dice for 1D6.)
VHDM (even though the Necromancer has it, casting it at +4 is better)
Curse of Years (nasty RiP to make them worry and/or use up power dice)
Gaze of Nagash (decent magic missile, but still...)
Curse of Years (when going against Daemons, against Empire it'll go up)
Raise Dead (no thanks!)

So, if I roll for the level 4, I've got a 90.47% chance of getting my top pick spell, with lower probabilities (due to doubles counting as my choice) for other spells.

If I roll for the Level 1 first, then I'll have a 16% chance of getting Summon on him (which would be bad) as well as a 16% chance of getting Raise Dead, which puts it at a 1/3 chance of the roll doing something I don't want. Not good at all.

So, definitely rolling for the Level 4 first is always going to be best.
 
Personally id go the other way around.

The big spells you want on the level 4 are Vanhels and Summon Undead Horde.

So roll for the level 1, if he gets Vanhels or SUH , suck it up and take raise dead instead.

Youre now chucking 4 dice for 5 spells and any doubles gets you whatever you want. Odds are youll end up with the spells you want on the level 4.
 
krisbot4000 said:
Personally id go the other way around.

The big spells you want on the level 4 are Vanhels and Summon Undead Horde.

So roll for the level 1, if he gets Vanhels or SUH , suck it up and take raise dead instead.

Youre now chucking 4 dice for 5 spells and any doubles gets you whatever you want. Odds are youll end up with the spells you want on the level 4.

Your logic escapes me. If I roll for the Level 1, I have 2 chances out of 6 for it to go wrong. But if I roll for the level 4 I get my top pick 90% of the time.

So no, the odds are not that I'll end up with the spells I want on the Level 4...
 
Im sick of people bashing Raise Dead, If used correctly in conjunction with Ion you can slam into an enemy and break them in combat. Then they flee into your zombies and you dont even need to pursue them to chase them down. Also the +2 to CR and removal of there rank bonus for a rear charge is incredibly strong. Also if your worried about your zombies getting cut down keep in mind that the enemy wont be getting supporting attacks as those only work for frontal attacks.

If used correctly Raise Dead can do many things from blocking LOS from enemy shooting, Redirecting groups, buying time and my ultimate favorite which is to bait the enemy. You can use zombies to cause your opponent to put themselves in comprimising situations, such as showing there flanks because of the way I positioned them. Raise Dead has plenty of uses in 8th edition and the spell should never be under-estimated. A character with the Sceptre de Noir can be quite annoying for the enemy to deal with if there a smart VC player that knows how to utilize Raise Dead.
 
Raise Dead is a very good spell, Forcing your oponent to show their flank is huge. If they dont take care of the unit then their most likely not moving very fast so that is buying you time to build up your line or buff it or lots of other things.
 
Yeah, yeah, well if I don't want the spell, I don't want it. The process is the most important, and like it or not, getting zombies into a combat is far from an automatic win, sometimes it can lose you the battle and the game. If they don't break and a hero gets into them, you could end up losing more than you gain, even more-so with the new reform after combat.
 
Zanthor said:
krisbot4000 said:
Personally id go the other way around.

The big spells you want on the level 4 are Vanhels and Summon Undead Horde.

So roll for the level 1, if he gets Vanhels or SUH , suck it up and take raise dead instead.

Youre now chucking 4 dice for 5 spells and any doubles gets you whatever you want. Odds are youll end up with the spells you want on the level 4.

Your logic escapes me. If I roll for the Level 1, I have 2 chances out of 6 for it to go wrong. But if I roll for the level 4 I get my top pick 90% of the time.

So no, the odds are not that I'll end up with the spells I want on the Level 4...


There are 2 spells in the lore that are important to get on your lord.
summon undead horde, and vanhels dance.

Aight? So we want these 2 spells on the lord. The rest are spiffy but realitively unimportant to the way VC's play.

Ok, you have 6 spells in the lore.

Roll for your level 1.
If he gets either Vanhels dance, or summon undead horde you can swap it for the raise dead spell, thus assuring the level 1 will NOT take either SUH or VHD.
If the level 1 rolls something usefull(outside of the 2 spells we want on the lord), Great. Stellar. If he doesnt.. who cares. He has invocation, and the level 4 is doing the heavy lifting in the casting phase anyway.

Now, we have 5 spells left in the lore.
Roll for your level 4.
If he rolls any doubles or the spell the level 1 has he gets to pick his spell for each dupe you rolled.

youre looking for 2 numbers out of 5 here, and youre getting 4 shots with dupes being wildcards.

I dont understand how you can think 2 out of 6 is better odds than 2 out of 5. The pool of numbers the lord is rolling on for the lords spells is smaller my way and therefore less likely to deviate from the results youre looking for. (ie SUH and VHD)

The only thing that matters here is getting VHD and SUH on your lord. Thats it.
Personally I take a level 1 melee thrall just to make sure my level 4 doesnt get raise dead, the thralls magic isnt terribly game impacting most the time, and with a melee build you arent depending on it and hes helping thin the lore out for your lord.

However If youre concerned with getting your lord the full goodie basket of vamp spells you might as well just take fobidden lore :vampires on a level 3 with motba and not waste points with the level 1.
 
I got one "question" to this topic, because it determines if krisbot4000s tactic of taking raise dead on the level 1 Thrall works.

If i recall correctly you can not have the same spell twice in an army (with the exception of spells bought from necros and bound spells etc.).

But it is said in the rulebook that you can have the signature spell more then once in an army. As all vamps can swap any spell for their 1st spell which is raise dead, doesnt that spell count as the "signature" spell and thus can be rolled more than once? I am not sure on this one but if it is true the tactic mentions by krisbot4000s wont work :(. Can someone with a rulebook etc at hand maybe give some insight to this topic.

@ Raise dead: If Zanthor does not want to have the spell, the main goal is to have a tactic which helps avoide getting this spell, even if some might find that spell usefull :)

@ Yanda: I am one of the guys who really dislikes Raise Dead in the newer version. You have to remember that fleeing into a unit of zombies is just difficult terrain and not an auto destroy. You also have to remember that units can now take a LD test, with reroll from the BSB and using the Generals LD, to ignore march blocking units. So both tactics are strongly nerfed. Additionaly the range of Raise dead is so low that you reeeeeeeeealy have to get close to pull a "raising zombies behind enemy lines" off, especiall since you have to have 1" space between your created zombie unit and all enemy units. Also what Zanthor said: Since autofear break is gone, having Zombies supporting one of your own units in combat can turn out to be a heavy liability in the 2nd or 3rd round of combat when other enemy units join and just make a mess out of the Zombies.
 
I prefer to roll for my l4 first. Vanhels, SUH, and maybe Curse of the years due to the big units that 8th ed. supports, are my choices. The rest I will take only if I must.
 
@ krisbot4000 I was about to tell you you're wrong, but looked up spell generation and realized that indeed you can still swap a spell for Raise Dead. I (and I'm guessing others) assumed that since there was no signature spell, it would no longer be an option, but it is.

This is great news for me indeed. It means that my Lvl 1 mage can pick the "don't want it" spell, while my Lvl 4 is practically guaranteed to get a good mix of spells.

It also means that I don't have to give any casting bonuses (like Power Stones) to the Lvl 1, and he can be my "scroll caddy".

It felt like a silly question, but now I'm really glad I asked! I think this subject will be useful for many players.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu