scream vs archaons armour of morkar

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Maybe I am not reading it right but I always thought the scream roll was not a to wound roll but rather a how many wounds roll. The number of wounds are then automatic no to wound roll normally required. Kinda like rolling a d3 for a multi wound weapon just to figure out how many wounds, just in this case the number could be 0 wounds.

Same would apply to spirit leech
That is correct. The argument is basically centered around "Does Armor of Morkar affect all wounds inflicted against Archaon? or just wounds that are generated from hits?" The difference between the multiple wound weapons and the scream is the weapons actually roll to wound. The Runefang has automatic wounds like poison attacks. I read it as protecting against poison, Runefang, High Strength attacks that could wound on 2, those two Death lore spells, and maybe even Hand of Dust (can't remember wording offhand), etc. I don't see the armor as protecting against things like TG/TB screams, Spirit Leech, or wounds caused by Attribute tests like those caused from Nehekharan Sphinx and others including spells.

The only reason I use the 2d6 as an example is because, in essence, you are rolling to wound. Not actually, just in essence. The only way to cause any wounds is to roll a 5+ unless Archaon's LD is modified, so to me, it meets the requirements set by the Armor if you read his armor as protecting against all wounds.
 
No takers on my 2/3 probability idea? Too bad.

I thankfully realised a mistake I made in that interpretaion. I read To Wound as to wound, ignoring the capitalization. Those capitalizations, along with the term 3+, actually makes it pretty clear when I think about it. The armour is directly refering to a To Wound roll and the To Wounds chart found on page 42 and 51. No attack against may ever roll To Wound on a better than a 3+.

Now to the real debate instead of my own personal confusion.

Archaons 3+ works on any to wound attempt, a wound and a to wound are two different things. Something that completes its to hit and the to wound wounds on a 1+ ignoring auto fail on one (automatic hit) still has a to wound, most just don't bother to roll it because it always succeeds. The scream does not have any to wound rolls, not even automatic ones, it skips the to hit and to wound and immediately moves to causing wounds.

This doesn’t make sense. Automatics wounds do not roll To Wound on a 1+, if they did the rolls of 1 would fail as per the BRB FAQ page 3. Just like the death shriek, automatic wounds do not roll To Wound.

The miscast table actually calls them hits, which is more indicative of an attack than a TG scream. Result 2-4=S10 hit, 4-5=S6 hit. Miscast already allows armor and ward saves, so why wouldn't Archaon's armor protect against the S10 hit?

How is calling it a hit more indicative of it being an attack than calling it a special attack? Other than that I'm a bit torn on how to interpret what is an attack. I think I'll just go with damage caused by the opponent, meaning miscast is not an attack.

I stand by the TG already having to roll a minimum of 5 in order to wound Archaon in the first place, so whether it's RAI or RAW is irrelevant. The only time it might be relevant is if Archaon's LD is 7 or below. Even then, there's a 1/36 chance you snake-eyes so it won't really matter anyways. It just doesn't make sense to roll for each wound caused by the scream. If you do, then what about Spirit Leech?? It follows the same dynamic. There are no hits, just wounds, again that don't allow armor. They aren't auto wounds, because you have to take a test. Now the S/T spells from Death Lore are different, and his armor should affect those because they specifically state they wound on a 2+.

Based on your logic, if Nagash were to cause a wound and multiplied to 3, would you have to roll 3 more dice and they only apply on a 3+? No, so why would it apply for a TG, TB, or Spirit Leech?

If the death shriek can get away with rolling 3+ on its "not To Wound" roll, what happens to the spirit leech? If both are Ld 10 and the WoC player rolls a 1 and you a 2, do you cause a wound or is it stopped since you didn't roll higher than 3?

Nagsah rolls To Wound just like any other dude. If his To Wound roll is successful and higher than 3 he causes a wound which is then multiplied into a D3 wounds.

The Death Shriek causes a fixed number of wounds (based on the 2D6 roll) and each of these has to roll To Wound one 3+ against Archaon.

That is correct. The argument is basically centered around "Does Armor of Morkar affect all wounds inflicted against Archaon? or just wounds that are generated from hits?" The difference between the multiple wound weapons and the scream is the weapons actually roll to wound. The Runefang has automatic wounds like poison attacks. I read it as protecting against poison, Runefang, High Strength attacks that could wound on 2, those two Death lore spells, and maybe even Hand of Dust (can't remember wording offhand), etc. I don't see the armor as protecting against things like TG/TB screams, Spirit Leech, or wounds caused by Attribute tests like those caused from Nehekharan Sphinx and others including spells.

The only reason I use the 2d6 as an example is because, in essence, you are rolling to wound. Not actually, just in essence. The only way to cause any wounds is to roll a 5+ unless Archaon's LD is modified, so to me, it meets the requirements set by the Armor if you read his armor as protecting against all wounds.

I really don't understand why you are bringing Hits into this. The Armour of Morkar makes no mention of hits, just attacks and To Wound.

Hand of Dust has the following wording: "If the To Hit roll is successful, the target suffers a wound with the Multiple Wounds (D6), with no armour save allowed. " So I guess you'd say the Armour of Morkar doesn't work against it since it is not an automatic wound.

I don't see any reason to make a difference between attacks causing automatic wounds and attacks simply causing wounds. Especially since the armour takes the automatic wounds as an example.
 
No takers on my 2/3 probability idea? Too bad.

I thankfully realised a mistake I made in that interpretaion. I read To Wound as to wound, ignoring the capitalization. Those capitalizations, along with the term 3+, actually makes it pretty clear when I think about it. The armour is directly refering to a To Wound roll and the To Wounds chart found on page 42 and 51. No attack against may ever roll To Wound on a better than a 3+.

Now to the real debate instead of my own personal confusion.



This doesn’t make sense. Automatics wounds do not roll To Wound on a 1+, if they did the rolls of 1 would fail as per the BRB FAQ page 3. Just like the death shriek, automatic wounds do not roll To Wound.



How is calling it a hit more indicative of it being an attack than calling it a special attack? Other than that I'm a bit torn on how to interpret what is an attack. I think I'll just go with damage caused by the opponent, meaning miscast is not an attack.



If the death shriek can get away with rolling 3+ on its "not To Wound" roll, what happens to the spirit leech? If both are Ld 10 and the WoC player rolls a 1 and you a 2, do you cause a wound or is it stopped since you didn't roll higher than 3?

Nagsah rolls To Wound just like any other dude. If his To Wound roll is successful and higher than 3 he causes a wound which is then multiplied into a D3 wounds.

The Death Shriek causes a fixed number of wounds (based on the 2D6 roll) and each of these has to roll To Wound one 3+ against Archaon.



I really don't understand why you are bringing Hits into this. The Armour of Morkar makes no mention of hits, just attacks and To Wound.

Hand of Dust has the following wording: "If the To Hit roll is successful, the target suffers a wound with the Multiple Wounds (D6), with no armour save allowed. " So I guess you'd say the Armour of Morkar doesn't work against it since it is not an automatic wound.

I don't see any reason to make a difference between attacks causing automatic wounds and attacks simply causing wounds. Especially since the armour takes the automatic wounds as an example.
So in your many thoughts what is your verdict in regards to a TG scream?
 
Thanks for all the replies guys, I'm kind of leaning towards the scream bypassing the armour rule looking at all the arguments to me the scream is more like a number of wounds caused my the multiple wounds rule and not a To Wound, so Armour wouldn't work against it.
 
So in your many thoughts what is your verdict in regards to a TG scream?

Sorry, guess I drifted off somewhat.

The VC player would have to roll To Wound on a 3+ for each wound caused by the Death Shriek. I see nothing that warrants treating explicit automatic wounds and simply 'caused wounds' differently.
 
This doesn’t make sense. Automatics wounds do not roll To Wound on a 1+, if they did the rolls of 1 would fail as per the BRB FAQ page 3. Just like the death shriek, automatic wounds do not roll To Wound.
Basically an attack goes

Attack: Roll to hit > number of hits > roll to wound > Number of wounds > take saves
Archaons armor: roll to hit him, number of hits > roll to wound (armor takes effect) > number of wounds > take saves
Automatic hit attack: Roll to hit > number of hits > roll to wound (auto success regardless of the roll, overriding the more general brb rule) > number of wounds > take saves
Scream: Number of wounds > take saves

Scream skips right past the part the armor is effecting is affecting.
 
And why would the automatic wound attack have the step "roll to wound (auto success regardless of the roll, overriding the more general brb rule)"?

Lets compare someone attacking with Ghal Maraz and someone attacking under the effect of Hand of Dust. Both roll to hit. Each hit wounds without rolling. Armour saves are ignored. Each wound is multiplied (into D3 and D6 respectively).

Why would one of them have a sequence for rolling to wound without caring about the result and not the other? Because of the word automatically? To me that word does not imply that. Had the wording been "clears the To Wound roll automatically" or "succeeds To Wound automatically", including the capitalized words referring to roll like the Armour of Morkar does, I would have agreed with you.

To me the sequence for both would be:
Roll To Hit > number of hits > number of wounds > take saves

The scream would be:
Roll attack dice > number of wounds > take saves

In all cases, no matter the word automatic or not, the Armour of Morkar would force its way in before the "number of wounds" step and make you roll To Wound, succeeding on 3+.

And again, since the 'automatic wounds' part of the armour is an example it is clear to me that all wounds caused by attacks are included.
 
Except you cant have number of wounds without the to wound roll. You dont determine the number of wounds and then roll to see if they actually are wounds. You roll to wound and use that to determine number of wounds.

Scream skips right to number of wounds because it doesnt have a number of hits to roll for wounds it wounds based on the value of a roll plus and minus modifiers.

Automatically wounding attacks dont skip the to wound step because they dont say you do and have hits that need to be turned into wounds. Just because you succeed regardless of roll doesnt say anywhere that the step is removed.
 
To me I think the scream is more like the multiple wounds special rule. So with hand of dust you role to hit, the armour forces the auto wound to only wound on a 3+, and then you role for d6 wounds (if you got a 3+), whereas there is no role to hit with the scream it jumps straight to the multiple wounds bit determining how many wounds. That's how I see it.
 
Treating The Hand of Dust and the Death Shriek differently sounds very strange to me. Both simply cause wounds without actually rolling To Wound. With both you can know how many dice you should roll on the forced To Wound roll because you know how many wounds it should have caused. On the scream based on the 2D6 and on with Hand of Dust depending on you hit not. Neither have a proper To Wound sequence but still has to roll for each wound it has caused.

How about result 11-12 Deafening Peals on the Screaming bell (which could damage Archaon if boosted with Nurgle magic)? It causes a D3 wounds. Would those have to roll To Wound? I'd say yes.
 
Anything with a to hit has a to wound as that is the sequence of an attack. The scream starts its sequence at the causing wounds bit while hand of dust still starts at the to hit, which means it has a to wound regardless of how trivial it makes the to wound.

The d3 wounds also shouldn't need to be rolled as they still start at already wounding.

Wounds caused are the hits that actually do damage to a target, if they have already been determined to have done damage (before saves obviously), why are you activating archaons armor when it is at the step where your trying to keep those to hits from actually wounding when, by the nature of being wounds caused, they have already wounded.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu