Screaming at the Bell

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Jan 26, 2012
5
Zombies
3
So I played a game recently and a banshee screamed at the Bell. My opponent insisted that he could target the Bell separately, due to the rule "Shooting at the Bell." However, everyone knows that screams are not shooting, so would this rule apply to them?
 
Screams are in no way a shooting attack. And because there's not even a Strength value on a scream, it should be pretty obvious the Shooting at the Bell stuff does not apply. Hopefully it didn't mess up your battle too much.
 
He's wrong. Tell him he's wrong and he should feel bad.

Also don't forget that Strength in Numbers doesn't apply to your Screams.
 
My rule book is out in the car, but I believe that you do target the "The Bell" or "The Unit". And then if it is the bell, distribute wounds as shooting. I will check in the morning as I don't feel like getting on pants to go grab my book.
 
Rizzo said:
My rule book is out in the car, but I believe that you do target the "The Bell" or "The Unit". And then if it is the bell, distribute wounds as shooting. I will check in the morning as I don't feel like getting on pants to go grab my book.

Right, my point is that the rules for targeting the Bell are under the heading "Shooting at the Bell," to quote the Skaven book. Screams are not shooting, as everyone on this forum knows, so there is no reason for the text under that section to apply to them.
 
OK. So how to you propose that the scream is handled then. You are now left with -
A: It kills some clan rats/storm vermin.
or
B: You get to snipe the Grey Seer.
C: You get to put wounds straight on The Bell.

The first line of Ghostly Howl states it "is a special attack used against a single enemy unit"... this lends to answer A.
The last line of Ghostly Howl states wounds are "distributed as if from shooting" this lends to my interpretation.
B and C seem to lack support, do you have an option D?
 
Nope you can not target the bell and here is a breakdwn of why

Step 1. The Scream targets a enemy unit
Step 2. The Bell is in a unit
Step 3. The Bell may be targeted seperatly by shooting.
Step 4. The Scream is not shooting
Step 5. Since the bell is in the unit the unit must be targeted as normal per the scream rules
 
Johnny-Crass said:
Nope you can not target the bell and here is a breakdwn of why

Step 1. The Scream targets a enemy unit
Step 2. The Bell is in a unit
Step 3. The Bell may be targeted seperatly by shooting.
Step 4. The Scream is not shooting
Step 5. Since the bell is in the unit the unit must be targeted as normal per the scream rules

Agreed, I vote "A" once The Scream is not shooting became a fact.
This is one I would clarify with tournament organizers or your opponent before even setting up the terrain personally.
 
I scream at bells and furnaces and my Skaven opponent (who's been using them for over a decade) has no problems with it.

Ill ask him to clarify why. Though he won't be taking bells too much anymore now that the FAQ nerfed them.

Besides, with all the MC out there, we're seeing more warlords on bonebreakers with fell blades and assassins with potions of strength with weeping blades.

The game's changing folks... Best adapt quickly :)
 
Don't forget the Plague Priest with a Blade of Nurglitch and potion of speed. Every wound drops toughness so that the plague monks with him get to strike at a lower T monster.
But I digress. I wont force an opponent to target my bell but, if they are willing to count as shooting for randomization, I don't grouse about them targeting the bell/rider. We discuss it before deployment, when talking about what terrain counts as, and other army clarifications.
 
I think you'll see less bells, but furnaces are still incredible for their points.

My Skaven buddy (I know, I'm actually friends with a Skaven player) has been running his Seer on foot. The points savings has been going on a combat rat lord with fell blade on a bone breaker.

Though its hit or miss, litterally.

Last night bone breaker charges out of a unit of SV into 3 CD renders with a Taurok. Taurok challenges for damage control, will be steadfast them the Khadia can flank charge it. But... The rat has 4 attacks, hitting on 3s... Rolls 1, 1, 2, 2.... No rerolls. I flip the f#^* out in celebration! The Taurok hits back, causing 3 wounds, but since the rat uses the bonebreakers wound characteristic it has 4 wounds. Anyway the bonebreaker couldn't get through the 1+ Taurok armor, got chased down.

Chaos Dwarfs 20 nilled Skaven.... I repeat, CD beat Skaven! That does not usually happen!

But yeah, Skaven got nerfed, but they're Skaven so f$@" em!!
 
Adam_Barrow said:
Seers take a separate S test against Dwellers/ect., Sunny. By by, Seer. : (

I know this thread is old but the question came up. Can someone please direct me to the relevant FAQ section/page?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu