My first ever model was the original 1990 Fire Dragon Exarch model for 40K. It still makes an appearance in some of my armies.
My first ever Fantasy model came a few years later when I started out by playing the Empire. I should say models really, since I purchased the Reiksguard Knights, Kislev Winged Lancers, and Kislev Horse Archers, all at the same time.
They were old metal sculpts in two halves with the 'cart horse' style steeds. The metal models were a pain to put together as well. They had to be pinned, and glued together with araldite (and before anyone wonders what I was doing pinning at such a young age, my dad assembled these particular figures).