Skaven Storm Banner and Death Shriek

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Miklos Vak Vados

Grave Guard
Oct 28, 2007
288
Zombies
153
My Skaven Opponent claims that the Storm Banner will prevent the Terrorghiest from using its Death Shriek unless I roll a 4+.

Is there something in a FAQ / Rule Book that explains why the DS is not a shooting attack that simply does not have to use a BS?
 
'Shooting attack' is one of the phrases in the rulebook that has no actual meaning or definition and as such, it is only relevant as a keyword to tie together attacks that suffer similar effects. Because of this, it only applies when it is explicitly mentioned. The terrorgheist entry states that it is a 'special attack that can be used against a single enemy unit in the shooting phase'. This means that it is not a shooting attack even though it takes place in the shooting phase because it is not explicitly stated that it is a shooting attack.

Beyond this statement above, there isn't anything hard and fast to convince them but if they refuse to accept the above statement then you should probably just find a new opponent.

A reasoning behind putting it in the shooting phase is that it resolves issues of order and prevents interspersing shrieks as a means to kill wizards off or make use of other advantages or disadvantages. Basically it just makes everything clearer and less convoluted.
 
Skaven are an army I run - and I use the storm banner - but I'd never even considered that it could be used to prevent the shriek. It doesn't matter how bad the storm is you can still scream! I agree with Lynks on this one - and I'd argue that whilst there is nothing that states exactly that the shriek is unaffected, common sense and what I think the rule as intended suggests that you are able to shriek without penalty. My feeling with the storm banner is that it is designed to prevent e.g. stormvermin, plague monks being shot to death from cannon, archers, handgunners etc before getting to combat. It makes sense - get a storm going on then missiles just are not going to be effective - but as I said before you can still shout! Also don't forget the death shriek rule was written after the skaven book was released, so its impact on the storm banner could not have been recognised within the skaven book. As for an FAQ answer to this - have you seen the Skaven FAQ? Last time I looked it was nearly as long as the original army book - and it in some people's opinions is still not finished. My gut feeling is that the reason why it hasn't been ruled on specifically is that a bit of fair play and common sense should sort it out - and they had bigger issues to fix. Their new army book when it lands will be very interesting indeed.

It leaves you in a bit of a tricky situation - depending on how well you get on with your skaven opponent. If its a good mate then is it worth the argument? If its someone you are not so close to then its your choice - personally I like Lynks wouldn't play them again. Its such a shame when situations like this arise!
 
Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on the Banshee’s Ghostly Howl? (p31)
A: No.


That banner is an item that effects missile fire.

If your opponent insists screams are shooting attacks (which they are NOT), show them this,
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu