Skaven Strength in Numbers and Death Shriek

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Miklos Vak Vados

Grave Guard
Oct 28, 2007
288
Zombies
153
My Skaven Opponent claims that the leadership bonus for Skaven Ranks Strength in Numbers adds to the leadership of the Unit when calculating DS.

The way I read the Skaven Army Book that SIN only applies to leadership tests.

Is there any way to explain the difference between the DS attack and leadership tests with SIN?
 
The skaven FAQ makes it a little clearer.

"Page 33 – Strength in Numbers.
Changethesecond sentence of thefirst paragraph to “Units
with the Strength in Numbersspecial ruleadd theircurrent
rank bonusto their Leadership valueforany Leadership test.”"


beyond saying that this is not a leadership test, it is only using your leadership value there is little you can do. You could reference the section on leadership tests in the main rules and highlight the difference i suppose.
 
This skaven player sounds awful. Nothing worse than playing against someone so desperate to win that it takes the fun away. But I guess being skaven kinda fits the army mentality
 
Possibly but there is another post from what i assume is the same game, relating to using the storm banner stops the shriek altogether. Just sounds to me like this player is trying to make it up as he goes along
 
Unfortunately it's typical GW squirelly language. According to them, you take the units current rank bonus and apply it to any LD test.

But what is a test? A terror test is definitely a test. It says so right on the label. But what about a Deathsnipe? You know, the one where you and the target both roll a D6 and add your leadership, and the difference is the number of wounds the target takes? That sure seems like a 'test' to me.

In the same vein, a ghostly howl or death shriek also seems like a test to me. You're using the LD stat to measure against something to see what the result will be. If that's not a test then I don't know what is.

Having said that, of course I understand what the rules mean. They refer specifically to psychology and break tests. But I can also see where a player would get confused, since there is no clear right and wrong here.
 
If im not mistaken a "leadership test" is clearly defined in the brb. Book not handy reference, but in any case, a ld test to me is rolling 2d6 and comparing it to the ld value of unit or model. It's not "squirrely", this is a clear case of extrapolation or rules bending.
 
well there are plenty of examples of what a leadership test is.

terror. fear. panic. crumble. daemonic instability to name but a few.
all do exactly the same. roll 2d6 and compare to your stat.

deathshriek or banshees howl does not test against a characteristic. it just uses it as part of a sum 2d6 - ld stat to give a wounds total caused.

litterally the leadership is used to indicate the resolve of the unit. if its low then they get scared to death easier. if its high then they either have a good leader or are not easily scared.

its simple. it is not a leadership test and that skaven player is trying to manipulate you to his will.
 
bigbadbat said:
If im not mistaken a "leadership test" is clearly defined in the brb. Book not handy reference, but in any case, a ld test to me is rolling 2d6 and comparing it to the ld value of unit or model. It's not "squirrely", this is a clear case of extrapolation or rules bending.

Page 10 clearly defines the leadership test and other characteristic tests. Italics for my emphasis.

"To take a leadership test, roll 2d6. If the result is equal to or less than the model's leadership value, then the test is passed. If the result is greater than the model's leadership value, a suitably dire consequence will occur, as detailed in the rule that called for the test."

and characteristic tests, the other tests included for completeness.
"To make a characteristic test, roll a d6 and compare the score to the relevant characteristic in the model's profile. If the score is equal to or less than the number in the profile, then the test is passed with no ill effect. If the score is greater than the number in the model's profile, the test has been failed and something nasty will occur, as detailed in the rule that called for the test."


As you can see, death shriek, ghostly howl and spirit leech are all very different to the format layed out above but most importantly, none of them call for a leadership test- only use the leadership value.
 
bigbadbat said:
If im not mistaken a "leadership test" is clearly defined in the brb. Book not handy reference, but in any case, a ld test to me is rolling 2d6 and comparing it to the ld value of unit or model. It's not "squirrely", this is a clear case of extrapolation or rules bending.

How would you, in one word, describe the act of measuring the LD value against another value to determine a result?

The only word that fits, is a test.

Now, you and I with years of experience know what the writers mean when they say "leadership test". But there then exists a whole other category of tests that utilise the leadership value that aren't designated as leadership tests. It's not surprising that some players are confused by this grey area, or that some players attempt to take advantage of it.
 
Storm Banner does not effect screams at all.

Strength in Numbers does not work for screams at all.

If some Scaven player says otherwise you can slap him into face.
 
Screams are not Leadership tests, they are attacks against the Leadership attribute, a VERY different thing. So no Strength in numbers, as it works for Leadership TESTS.
 
Oh?... Shrieks/Howls are leadership tests now?... Guess I'll be throwing 3d6 vs my lizardmen friend from now on... :clown:
 
Blutsauger said:
bigbadbat said:
If im not mistaken a "leadership test" is clearly defined in the brb. Book not handy reference, but in any case, a ld test to me is rolling 2d6 and comparing it to the ld value of unit or model. It's not "squirrely", this is a clear case of extrapolation or rules bending.

How would you, in one word, describe the act of measuring the LD value against another value to determine a result?

The only word that fits, is a test.

Now, you and I with years of experience know what the writers mean when they say "leadership test". But there then exists a whole other category of tests that utilise the leadership value that aren't designated as leadership tests. It's not surprising that some players are confused by this grey area, or that some players attempt to take advantage of it.

True. They do not however fall into the category of "leadership tests" defined in the brb as quoted above or usable by SiN as is clearly defined in the errata faq for Skaven.
Following this extrapolation, one could also argue that models equipped with gw would benefit from +2 strength when taking a strength test, which is obviously wrong as well.
As I stated earlier, the rules are clearly defined for when SiN is applicable. Unfortunately for skaven, the death shriek is not one of them.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu