Skeleton horde with spears??

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

jdaze78

Zombie
Feb 13, 2011
3
Zombies
3
Hi! I am just now getting back into the hobby, last time I played was 6th edition. I recently got the 8th ed. book and I read how all regiments can fight in two ranks, as supporting attacks. Also, If you are considered a "Horde" you get ANOTHER rank to attack. So my question is, if I had a skeleton horde with spears, could I fight in 4 ranks? Do these bounses stack? Thank you!!
 
Hi Mate welcome back to the game.

Yes you have it right

Any unit no matter how wide can fight in 2 ranks with as you say supporting attacks.

If you are in horde formation ie 10 or more wide then you fight in 3 ranks.

Add in spears and you get a horde that fights in 4 ranks, which is pretty good. Even crappy skellies (using their own stats) will be able to do something if pimped out in horde formation with spears. Imagine with WS 7 and okkrams out!!

But think about horde blocks of HE spearmen of say 50 models (expensive) but they have the additional HE rule that lets them fight in an extra rank so these will kick out (if against another horde) 50 attacks striking first with re-rolls.

Or

A massive block of the new orcs with spears. These are now classed as choppa spears and so are st 4 1st round of combat. Boom! Thats gonna hurt.
 
Thank you so much for clearing that up for me! Wow, so thats pretty good. I kinda regret giving all my skele models hand weapons & shields. Guess I better get some more =P
 
HW/shield have their merits. 6+ ward save will save quite a few with all the extra attacks flying around :)
 
I have been bringing 30 HW/S Skeletons for the past 5 games or so and have been fully satisfied with their performance. I don't expect them to do wounds, just be a roadblock.
 
For me, the Skeletons are HW&S. Their pitiful WS and puny S3 just doesnt warrant the extra 1 pt per for the upgrade and 5+ armour might as well be no armour, so the extra parry ward save is nice. My skellies typically are just a bunker for casters, though sometimes I may move them forward to tar pit really high str foes (like white lions)

I know you can Helm em to give em WS 6 or 7, and I know you can Shadow Lore enemies to make the S3 wound like its S5, but lets be honest... thats alot of work to make skeletons killy.

We got other units that are just as killy without the effort, so i leave the killing to them and use my skeletons to break the Steadfast of any foe dumb enough to charge my bunker, which means I need as many as I can get for the points i allow for this unit. Cheaper means more.
 
I've discovered that, with my terrible luck, I typically fluff as many rolls as is physically possible. However, the more dice I roll, the more the results seem to approach the statistical average. So, if my Spear Skeletons have only a 5+ armour save, I'm probably going to roll 4 or less on every single one. However, when I add the 6+ parry save, I get to roll another full set of dice. Almost always, I wind up parrying half of the inflicted wounds. :thumbsup:

All instances of freakish luck aside, I think it really comes down to personal preference. A horde of Skeletons with Spears will survive just as well as a horde of Ghouls, and they'll get the same number of attacks (although the Ghouls will have a slight advantage with their poison). IMO, the 1 extra point you pay for the spear isn't worth it, and, as I mentioned earlier, I like to make as many dice rolls as possible to balance out my luck a little bit. But that's just me. It's possible to field a Skeleton spearman horde and win games with it.
 
It is for HW&S, which is exactly what i was saying and what Bravo was commenting on. For us, going HW&S has been far more advantageous than applying spears to the skellies.

So you basically get the option of an extra rank of attacks at WS2, S3

OR

You get a 6+ Parry Ward save in CC

with only a 5+ armour save, i tend to side with the latter if for no other reason, its cheaper and thus i can get more models with that advantage.

If you could still get the parry bonus with a spear, then the extra +1 per model would be a real option for me. Frankly i just dont want to put dice into trying to make Skeletons do a job they are not real good at.
 
tex577 said:
Why do skellies with spears get a parry save?

I thought that was for hand weapon and shield only?

Sorry for the confusion, in my post I was referring to why I DON'T take spears on my Skeletons. If I stick with just the 5+ Armour Save, I usually fail my saves really hard. However, when I scrap the spears and take HW + S, my Skeletons seem to epically pass their parry saves.
 
i've found for me personally, the only time the extra pts for spears are worth it, is if you've a Lv3 or Lv4 lord with light magic supporting the skellies...

a Lv3 can throw just 2 dice and easily cast speed of light for WS/I10 on that spear hoard. sure your opponent will likely dispel it, which opens the door for a vanhel's danse or birona's timewarp on the unit!
now a Lv4 lord can go for the 12" effect of SoL and have a fairly reliable chance of not throwing double 6's! (i would never try this with the Lv3, unless it's the game on the line so to speak...)

light magic makes skeletons worthwhile because it has all the right buffs, and it couples beautifully with our own vanhel's danse, which necros get to spam for dirt cheap!
try combo'ing speed of light w/pha's protection and laugh as your spear will hit on 3's and only get hit on 5's in return! light can do some amazing things for skellies.

cheers!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu