Skeleton hw/s vs spears smackdown.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

miek

Zombie
Feb 14, 2012
5
Zombies
4
I have no idea how to model these lil' buggers :)
I can't decide on running the horde spears (50) or two blocks of 30 hw/s. Every time I think I got it figured out I can't decide.

I'm running mortis engine, and am kinda set on having a vampire with beasts (he can make himself quite the duelist) - so I really feel like I should get spears. But I just can't bring myself to model them yet, and I really want to get to painting them. I just have no idea what's "right" and don't want to regret having spears later on.

Not just my own problem, but I want this thread to be about really sorting out the issue in general.
 
ive been having this dilemma as well. ive come to the conclusion that if your running a mortis engine, then go spears. back them up with magic, have ur lord with them or both. a few people have been saying that they feel like their core is "just.. there.." as a requirement. putting ur lord in a big horde core unit and buffing them with spells turns ur core into something useful as well as being a characterful part of ur army.

curious about ur vamp with beasts: the model with the highest leadership has to be ur general, so that would be ur vamp lord. the vc book states that your general has to have the lore of vampires. do you have 2 vamp lords, or do u just use a vamp hero with beasts and hope u roll the spell ur after?

this shits me because i used to run lore of beasts on my vamp lord, and lore of fire before 8th so he could have the old flaming sword of ruin.
 
If you're running a mortis engine, I'd probably go with the spears. Be careful of the horde formation though. It luls you into a false sense of security without magic to back it up.
 
Hero vamp with beasts, its 25pts but if he gets any of the model buff spells he can't make himself insanely powerful, not to mention just +1s/t on his unit including himself.

To note, my greatest fear about the skeleton block is that mortis engine can die...
And I'm really scared of giving up way too much CR, and if I'm losing very large numbers of it I am uncomfortable with my vampire in it, but I know with just 1-2 spells it can turn around a round of combat very quickly, and is great at staying in it. Its just a big expensive unit (in both money and points) that I'm scared to support by hitting the enemy flank due to CR.
 
I know somebody said this already but her' it goes.

6+ parry save isn't worth the killing power you lose from spears.

Spears + horde formation (55+ skeles at least) = 'Nuff Said :smash:
 
I haven't the time this second to post the numbers, but Skeletons with spears in a horde is surprisingly durable and effective against other Core units. Because we don't need o worry about being steadfast we can go hordes with our Skeletons whereas lots of units like Goblins, Orcs, Men At Arms etc will go 5-6 wide and 7+ deep. With those additional attacks that we can bring to the fight due to that a unit of 50 Skeletons, with spears and in a horde formation, can win combats on their own.

If the enemy is 5 wide that means that we get 7 attacks x 4 ranks. Against a typical unit like Empire, Goblins and even Elves, that means that we will make 7 wounds, so call it 5 dead. Sure, that isn't a huge amount, but that is enough to have a solid chance of winning the combat (let's assume that our ranks and banners cancel theirs) at some point and it only takes a couple of bum rolls for the enemy unit to break.
 
TeflonTron said:
If the enemy is 5 wide that means that we get 7 attacks x 4 ranks. Against a typical unit like Empire, Goblins and even Elves, that means that we will make 7 wounds, so call it 5 dead. Sure, that isn't a huge amount,

Good point here, it's such a large unit that hits, well, hard enough, without support that it should be able to just tip the extra CR needed if just supported with a hero or even just one spell, or just one fear test failed.
Normally I wouldn't like to have to rely on such support, but really just one little push is needed, and with the screaming banner etc there's a few sources to get it from.

I'm getting fairly sold on running spears, might start the modelling tonight :)
 
TeflonTron said:
I haven't the time this second to post the numbers, but Skeletons with spears in a horde is surprisingly durable and effective against other Core units. Because we don't need o worry about being steadfast we can go hordes with our Skeletons whereas lots of units like Goblins, Orcs, Men At Arms etc will go 5-6 wide and 7+ deep. With those additional attacks that we can bring to the fight due to that a unit of 50 Skeletons, with spears and in a horde formation, can win combats on their own.

If the enemy is 5 wide that means that we get 7 attacks x 4 ranks. Against a typical unit like Empire, Goblins and even Elves, that means that we will make 7 wounds, so call it 5 dead. Sure, that isn't a huge amount, but that is enough to have a solid chance of winning the combat (let's assume that our ranks and banners cancel theirs) at some point and it only takes a couple of bum rolls for the enemy unit to break.

Well I suppose you've had better success than I have in this department. My skeletons never do anything in a horde formation besides get destroyed. If you are to even win that combat, you're talking about winning against someone that has something like 6 or 7 ranks, making them steadfast and most likely if you win they aren't going anywhere. I never count on my skeletons or zombies to put out even a single wound in a combat. In my opinion, I use them as anvils and slam a hammer unit into my opponent's flank after the initial combat round. But, if horde formation works for you, who am I to say it couldn't work for someone else?
 
Xander said:
Well I suppose you've had better success than I have in this department. My skeletons never do anything in a horde formation besides get destroyed. If you are to even win that combat, you're talking about winning against someone that has something like 6 or 7 ranks, making them steadfast and most likely if you win they aren't going anywhere. I never count on my skeletons or zombies to put out even a single wound in a combat. In my opinion, I use them as anvils and slam a hammer unit into my opponent's flank after the initial combat round. But, if horde formation works for you, who am I to say it couldn't work for someone else?

I'll go ahead and try it out ASAP; If it ends up working for me, it can't fail anyone :lol:
 
I think there are a few ways to run Skeletons with spears and effectively expect them to preform.

1) you need a mortis engine so you are at least getting that 6+ most of the time that you lost from parry. Two engines is even better.

2) You need to play the magic game. You have to make sure you are getting re roll hits on that unit and most importantly re roll wounds. The re roll hit aura will trigger ASF which brings me to my next point...

3) Corpse cart for ASF.

4) The bound item that gives you an extra attack. Every attack counts especially if you aren't in Horde. three ranks gives you still 29 attacks. Horde formation gives you assuming 7 are attacking 36 attacks.

5) I still recommend running them 7 wide by 5+ deep. So you aren't sinking in more points and not letting you opponent multi charge you! You do lose 7 attacks however by this method and this I guess depends on what you fight against on the regular. Horde formation won't come into play more often than not so why not just play the 7 you know you will be getting maybe 8 but still play them deep to negate stead fast by having the longer unit. This is preference and meta based.

6) One of the units should be the fear bomb unit with Aura of Dark on a vamp, and the screaming banner. Maybe even the power that makes your opponent re roll successful checks. And last but not least throw a wraith in the unit for challenges and terror so fear causers still have to check for fear.

If you skip a few steps and don't have a crazy magic phase you should still hopefully be striking first with 22-36 re rollable attacks. You can generate some serious combat rez from this. And the mortis engines help you Magic phase out tremendously if you take the +2 which is high risk high reward.
 
By having a longer unit to negate steadfast, you are assuming you will be winning combat. Horde form skeletons is for players that feel like they won't be winning combat very often and need all the attacks the can get to avoid instability casualties.

The day my undead units perform best is when they don't pop first turn.
 
drmooreflava said:
By having a longer unit to negate steadfast, you are assuming you will be winning combat. Horde form skeletons is for players that feel like they won't be winning combat very often and need all the attacks the can get to avoid instability casualties.

The day my undead units perform best is when they don't pop first turn.

I have a question (I guess for anyone); If they are horde with Spears, would you play them such that you are on the charge? Or accepting the charge so that you get the effect of the spears right away?

Also, with the Staff of Damnation, only the front models will actually benefit from the +1 attack, right? Since supporting attacks will always be regulated to 1 per model?
 
Tawg said:
drmooreflava said:
By having a longer unit to negate steadfast, you are assuming you will be winning combat. Horde form skeletons is for players that feel like they won't be winning combat very often and need all the attacks the can get to avoid instability casualties.

The day my undead units perform best is when they don't pop first turn.

I have a question (I guess for anyone); If they are horde with Spears, would you play them such that you are on the charge? Or accepting the charge so that you get the effect of the spears right away?

Also, with the Staff of Damnation, only the front models will actually benefit from the +1 attack, right? Since supporting attacks will always be regulated to 1 per model?

The staff would also work for the spear attack rank. It's not for supporting attacks though.
 
Xander said:
The staff would also work for the spear attack rank. It's not for supporting attacks though.

I'm afraid this isn't right. Fight in extra ranks rule specifies that the unit can make supporting attacks in an extra rank, so those spears are providing supporting attacks (BRB 69)

But to throw in my bit, I've been running a 50 strong unit of skellies with spears since the new book and have loved it (usually with screaming banner). IF you have a mortis engine to provide 6+ regen, then there's no downside to using spears.
 
Dklyn said:
Xander said:
The staff would also work for the spear attack rank. It's not for supporting attacks though.

I'm afraid this isn't right. Fight in extra ranks rule specifies that the unit can make supporting attacks in an extra rank, so those spears are providing supporting attacks (BRB 69)

But to throw in my bit, I've been running a 50 strong unit of skellies with spears since the new book and have loved it (usually with screaming banner). IF you have a mortis engine to provide 6+ regen, then there's no downside to using spears.

Ummm.... then I'm very curious as to why the lizardmen spearmen in the second rank get their two attacks (This has been stated by a very large tournament (Buckeye Battles and Ard Boyz) here in america. Unfortunately I don't have the book on me so I suppose I'll just have to take your word for it.
 
Dklyn said:
I'm afraid this isn't right. Fight in extra ranks rule specifies that the unit can make supporting attacks in an extra rank, so those spears are providing supporting attacks (BRB 69)

But to throw in my bit, I've been running a 50 strong unit of skellies with spears since the new book and have loved it (usually with screaming banner). IF you have a mortis engine to provide 6+ regen, then there's no downside to using spears.

Why couldn't they just say 'Fight in extra rank' as 'May make an extra rank of supporting attacks' instead of having to elaborate further in the book what they meant? Arrgggg G...W..!! (Say it like Animal House, because that's how I feel).
 
Something I thought of, with the mortis engine out, spear troops are only losing 1 armor value. Meaning that for every 6 troops that die, you are saving only one less, or giving just 1CR more. This is at the upswing of having 6-7 extra attacks (or even more if in horde formation) that are much easier augmented in this book than the units defenses. Another point for spears I think.
 
Xander said:
Ummm.... then I'm very curious as to why the lizardmen spearmen in the second rank get their two attacks (This has been stated by a very large tournament (Buckeye Battles and Ard Boyz) here in america. Unfortunately I don't have the book on me so I suppose I'll just have to take your word for it.


By way of explanation, there's no way, by the rules, for Saurus to get 2 attacks from the second rank. Spears grant the 'fight in extra rank' rule, which is specified as allowing 'supporting attacks' to be made in an extra rank. Supporting attacks for Infantry are limited to one per model, so if they've ruled that the Saurus in the 2nd rank get 2 attacks, they have done so against the actual rules. Saurus 5x5 with spears would get 20 attacks: 10 for the front rank, 5 for supporting attacks, and 5 for the spears' 'extra rank'.
 
Last time I ran 50 skeletons + a vampire in horde formation, they managed to kill 3!?(:O) dwarf quarrelers in a round of combat, when I threw 32 attacks + 4 vampire attacks into them...

I was a bit dissapointed to say the least :'(
 
One thing I am not seeing in this thread is how I use my Skellies. I run them a horde of spears with a Screaming banner, Banshee, and Combat Lord.

The kicker with this is the synergy i use with the cursed book. That random Debuff helps so much on many fronts.
1. Any of those debuffs are going to help your units survive or kill stuff big time. allowing for more CR with any of the spells generated.
2. Takes from the opponents DD while you lose 2 DD to his probably 3 DD. This allows you more dice to throw at other spells like raise spells or buff spells.
 
texhnology said:
Last time I ran 50 skeletons + a vampire in horde formation, they managed to kill 3!?(:O) dwarf quarrelers in a round of combat, when I threw 32 attacks + 4 vampire attacks into them...

I was a bit dissapointed to say the least :'(

With those attacks you should kill 6 on average, and take about 6 casualties back if they have great weapons. So it's not a bad set-up.
 
Some very interesting thoughts here. I had completely missed the fact that the Mortis Engine removes the Spears' downside as compared to HW+Shield. I'm also intrigued by the thoughts of Hording Skeletons - I would have thought that 5-wide and being in "lose as few guys as possible" mode would be the order of the day, but then again we don't have to worry about Steadfast. I'm considering adding a bit more beef to my Skellies to take advantage of Horde, then. That means that they could actually contribute in combat (le gasp!). :D
 
Tawg said:
drmooreflava said:
By having a longer unit to negate steadfast, you are assuming you will be winning combat. Horde form skeletons is for players that feel like they won't be winning combat very often and need all the attacks the can get to avoid instability casualties.

The day my undead units perform best is when they don't pop first turn.

I have a question (I guess for anyone); If they are horde with Spears, would you play them such that you are on the charge? Or accepting the charge so that you get the effect of the spears right away?

Also, with the Staff of Damnation, only the front models will actually benefit from the +1 attack, right? Since supporting attacks will always be regulated to 1 per model?

Since VC are unbreakable, I think charging is ok with spears. I wouldn't recommend it unless you have to do it to protect something else more valuable.
 
My arguement against using mortis engine is that Regen is becoming a liablilty vs many opponents. Using regen as a crutch for your army is so last book :tongue: Everyone has caught on to that 'one trick poney' as they say.

My arguement against using LD combo is that it is dependant upon your opponent and Absolutely worthless vs immune to psych. Banshee isn't worth he pts as a hero IMO. Even if your opponent fails his fear rolls, hes only hitting your skeletons of 4+ :rolleyes: Seems to me like screaming banner isn't worth taking on anything that isn't WS 3.

My advice on hero choices in combination with skeletons is: Take a wight bsb with enchanted sheild and a wraith for terror. This way you have the ethereal to take challenges or you have the killing blow WK if you think you can win a challenge. On rank and file you are getting +6 attacks and +1 combat res from the bsb and a -1 to instability casualties, because face it, we will lose combat more often than not.
Some say that Staff of damnation is good on them, I agree, however, I see that item nulified by your enemy the moment they find you that you have it. If I were to go with a bound item to help them out, I'd use rod of flaming death so that the opponent can't double charge me in the 10 wide front.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu