Skeleton Warrior Questions

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
May 13, 2014
360
AZ
Zombies
496
Should I make them with swords or spears?

I read they lose shields for spears but the Armybook just says "may take spears (for) free". The Rulebook just says those with spears may fight in an extra rank. I'm not sure what that means but it sounds like a win-win.

Also, a standard bearer seems key, given that he can be considered a magic standard bearer, but how important is it to take a musician?

:grave:
 
If you take spears you keep the shields, but lose the parry save. for this reason, most people will consider Spears a bad idea.

5 additional WS2 STR3 attacks are almost an irrelevance, but a 6++ Ward in combat can pay dividends.


Re banners etc. My advice is to take Full Command (Champion, Standard and Musician) for every combat block. That includes Skeletons.

The Standard isn't magical normally, but if you have one it can be upgraded. You have to pay the points to get a standard barer first, then pay more points to give him a Magic Standard.

A mundane standard is well worthwhile, though. Remember, a Standard is +2 Combat Resolution. If you loose combat twice in one game, the Standard has paid for itself. Three times or more and you've made a profit by bringing it.

Musicians are also worthwhile. We don't rally, of course, but swift reforms and the very occasional tied combat make it worth having.


I stand by what I said, in general, every combat unit gets Full Command.
 
Hand weapon & shield gives you a parry save, which is a 6+ ward save. With spears you do not get this but can instead fight in an extra rank, so three ranks of skeletons can fight rather than two (usually 15 instead of 10 attacks). What is best can be debated and depend on your army. If you have mortis engines I would advise on spears since you cannot use both a ward and a regeneration save. But more importantly, go with what you think is cool.

The musician adds one combat resolution if there is a draw. Seldom needed, especially for VC since it only mean that one skeleton dies due to crumble. What is also does, however, is to allow you to make swift reforms, where you get to make a normal move after a reform if you pass a Ld-check. Doesn’t sound like much but can be very useful in some situations. If you don't have one you might very well regret it. Although this ability only useful if you make sure the skeletons have access higher to Ld.

EDIT: Darn ninjas!
 
Mad said:
But more importantly, go with what you think is cool.

This is also true.

Myself, I have 50 Skittles with Hand Weapon & shield and 50 more with Spear & shield. Because I think both are cool.

Mechanically... In terms of pure usefulness, Hand Weapons are better, though. Which is why I advised against Spears earlier.

(As stated, spears are better with a Mortis Engine!)
 
15 attacks instead of 10 sounds cool. Might that be good with a Banner of Eternal Flame?

In order to understand the save more, how does a skeleton unit resolve a wound?

In regards to the coolness factor, I really like the look of a large regiment of skeletons with all of their spears raised straight in the air and bits of rags/flags blowing in the wind, so I'm going with that (:

What type of hero/lord works well in a skeleton unit? Other than the Mortis, anything else that a skeleton unit could benefit from?

I'm planning on assembling about 30 skeles and I also ordered:

-60 zombies (non GW legal)
-10 crypt ghouls
-1 ghoul lord/vampire lord
-1 vampire lord/Isabella
-5 black knights

And i am also about to order
-vampire lord on steed
-zombie dragon
-wight king/skeleton standard bearer

any build advice would be appreciated
 
EternallyUndying said:
15 attacks instead of 10 sounds cool.

Prepare to be disappointed.

EternallyUndying said:
In order to understand the save more, how does a skeleton unit resolve a wound?

They have WS2 and STR3. that means they will be hitting almost everything on 4 or worse and wounding almost everything on 4 or worse.

With Hand Weapons the best case is dealing around 2.5 wounds per round, with Spears the best case is dealing around 2.75 wounds per round. Both figures do not count enemy armour, the real figures will be lower.

Now, assuming the enemy are WS3+, STR4 - which covers the stats of almost everything you will be fighting (Human Halberds, Dwarf Warriors, Orc boys, Saurus Warriors, Chaos Warriors, Beast Banner Beastmen... Well, really any mainline infantry that's not Elves or Undead...).

The WS3+ STR4 bad guys with ten attacks will deal 3.63 wounds per round to Spear Skeletons, but only 3.03 wounds per round to Hand Weapon Skeletons.

The stronger or more numerous the enemy is, the better Hand Weapon Skeletons become compared to Skeletons.


And that counts for a lot because Crumble essentially doubles the wounds we take. Saving one skeleton with a Parry Save is functionally saving two counting combat resolution.


However, you should still build what you think is cooler. I just want to ensure it's an informed choice.

EternallyUndying said:
In regards to the coolness factor, I really like the look of a large regiment of skeletons with all of their spears raised straight in the air and bits of rags/flags blowing in the wind, so I'm going with that (:

What type of hero/lord works well in a skeleton unit? Other than the Mortis, anything else that a skeleton unit could benefit from?

As we've just seen, Skeletons cannot fight. Therefore, you must ask yourself what they are in your list to do?

They can be used to deny the enemy Steadfast while some other unit does the killing. Zombies cannot do that because they bleed CR very fast and Ghouls are too expensive.

Or they can be used to guard a Vampire. Skeletons cannot kill things, but a Vampire Lord can, with the right kit kill ten or more bad guys a turn fairly reliably while the skeletons cheer him on and soak wounds on the way in.

I find a Banshee is also a solid addition to a Skeleton unit.
 
The only case where I think most people would agree spear skellies are better than hand weapon skellies are when you have a couple of shadow casting vampires in the unit to buff them to strength 8 with mindrazor. Run in horde formation, that's a lot of high strength attacks. As you buff the skeletons in general (ie with rerolls to hit/wound with Vanhel's or Hellish Vigour) spear skeletons do get better, but by and large this is not worth the effort.

Though, as Minty and Mad 'At point out, if you think this is cool then go for it. I've run a horde of spear skeletons before, and loved it. Nothing's quite as satisfying as rolling that many dice...

But in general, hand weapons are better.
 
Thanks for all the cool info I appreciate the help.

I read something about needing a necro with skeletons?

Crumble is when the vampire lord dies right? So their parry save can help them even then? This wouldn't really be a big deal If i had a wight/ghoul/lord or even a necro+standard of discipline or maybe with a gleaming pennant.

If I wanted a vampire lord in the unit the crumble wouldn't be too bad. If the lord is my main then my skeles are most likely almost dead anyway when he dies. Or, if my main vampire was atop a zombie dragon, when he dies the whole game would be pretty bleak at that point regardless.

How about zombies vs skeletons? couldn't you have a lord killing with zombies which have more survivability?

Mindrazor sounds cool ill have to read more about it.
 
Crumble is what happens if you lose a round of combat. Example, a bunch of ogre cavalry charge your skeletons, they do 15 strenght 5 impact hits, you lose 12 guys, then they kill 5 more in normal attacks. You hit back, and do one unsaved wound (which means you got lucky). You have 3 ranks, a banner, they have 0 ranks, a banner, a charge, you lose combat by 15, so 15 more skeletons crumble and thus die.

Skeletons are 5 points, there are many things that can just cut through them like a knife through butter.
 
As a general rule, Zombies exist to die on the end of the bad guy's swords.

I wouldn't put any characters in a Zombie unit*.

In my normal lists I have two bricks of 50 zombies so that, at the start of the game I can think 'Hmmm... I don't fancy fighting that ultimate killing machine over there', and crash a zombie unit into it. The ultimate killing machine can then spend three rounds eating zombies and I'm happy. when it;s finished I'll charge another fifty in and it's spent the whole game chewing through worthless corpses instead of rampaging through my army murdering useful stuff.


Skeletons are the preferred delivery-unit for characters on foot. They have armour, they have a Parry Save (with Hand Weapon) and they can carry a magic Banner (Banner of Swiftness is a good one for infantry characters). They can also have a Unit Champion - which is essential if you have a combat character in the unit for reasons we can elaborate upon if you don't know.



*There is an exception. Zombies are cheap, so it is acceptable to use a minimum-size unit of Zeds as a 'bunker' for a Master Necromancer. In this scenario, you never want them in combat, they exist purely as ablative wounds for the Necromancer.
 
i personally make them with both,i belive is the best and more "BG" choose,they have been raised from the ground,in theory they could and should be of different rance and size actually. IMHO.
 
mournfang cavalry "are amongst the hardest hitting mounted troops in the known world" so i think that's one of the worst things that could be happening to your skeles. Wouldn't this be a good scenario for your zombies to tarpit them?

So if i receive 12 wounds, I would save it with their light armor/shield save of 5+ AND a +6 save afterward as its considered ward. Also given skeles 3T some strong attacks wound ignore the armor save but their ward save would still come into place (given its melee and from the front)

So, If I understand correctly swords are better because that ward save might save two skeles whereas their attacks are useless crap and 15 bags of crap is equally as worthwhile as 10 bags of crap.

If a Mortis Engines random aura happens to be within range then they basically get the same +6 save but I'm not planning on getting one, at least any time soon. Sounds like a ticking time bomb to me.

Given the fact that the swords look pretty cool, I'm sure I can come up with some really cool custom S&S poses, more compact units will be easier to transport, and spears are easily converted to swords for even more extra bits - I've decided to go with swords for my first regiment. I like the idea of hardier knightly skeletons.

Skeletons cannot regenerate like zombies but with a necromancer what happens? The can summon a new regiment of skeletons (2D6+3 on a 14+)?. How useful/common is this?

Can you take a necromancer and a vamp lord in one skele unit?
 
You can regenerate skeletons, only it's slower, D6+level skeletons vs. 2d6+level zombies. Summoning a new unit of 2d6+3 skeletons on a 14+ is a Raise Dead spell and any Lore of Vampires user can use it, should he roll in the beginning of the battle, be it a vampire or a necromancer. The only thing that makes vampires different from necromancers when ressurecting is that necro can take an 'Master of the Dead' upgrade that will allow him to raise more skeletons in a unit that were at the beginning of the game - normally you can do that only with zombies. I never had the occasion to use it, but I think it works best with multiple skeleton units.

As for the utility of 'Raise Dead' - don't expect to kill anyone with those, but you can screen yourself for a turn or two from ranged attacks, war machines, spells or intercept/redirect an enemy charge - it's quite useful, should you position it good.

And you can put any number of heroes in a single unit, not a problem. You can displace a whole front rank or even more if you are inclined so ;)
 
okay I read more about magic and lores.

Invo. of Nehek is a signature spell of Vampires. So I can guarantee it as a spell even in a level (1) vamp/Necro/Ghoul King, and every infantry unit within 6" will gain D6+(1) wounds healed aka dead units brought back to life. The champion and musician are always first (dead standard bearers are gone for good). Non-infantry units get 1+(1) wounds though some can only recover 1. AND the hero gets a wound recovered for casting a spell (if hes lost one). You can push it to 12" or 18" for a higher risk. The benefit to a necro over vamp/ghoul king is that you have a chance to turn your 30-skele unit into a 32-40 skele unit (provided you paid for a "Master of the Dead" upgrade for him).

That sounds sweet. Unfortunately, it can be dispelled or worse - you can roll two 6s in the attempt and, while you regen maybe 4 skeles, you then in turn wipe out the nearly the entire unit and banish your lord into the realm of chaos.

Is this correct?

Also, whats the rules for adding more models? Can you put in empty bases to represent the extra skeles or is it generally a rule that if you don't have the models, you can't add more units? Couldn't you make a few fillers to stick in to make up for this?
 
You know, spears + any buffs actually. More attacks generally always means more effectiveness. Even at ws2. Your not taking any VC core to be an anvil unit anyway. you take em to die, and raise them back up
 
The only thing about O. Mindrazor is you have to get it, which means you have to bring a L4 shadow caster and still there's only a 2/3 chance you'll get it right?

Then you have to pull it off, it has to not be dispelled and you have to not kill your entire unit while attempting it right? I think that if you do pull it off and you're about to shove 15 powerful attacks where they'll do a lot of hurt, your opponent is going to do everything they can to stop you and so this could serve as nothing but a distraction with a chance to obliterate the unit and caster.

But swords can also be used for this you just have less attacks. Swords bring reliability to save 17% of the skeletons you'd have lost in every head-on melee, buying you more time for your hero to dish out some more dmg and raise them back (while healing himself). Also the ability to even have a chance against powerful melee strikes that would simply erase spear-skeles. Skeles only really serve as guards so having better guarding ability seems wise.

My first undead servant has risen from the dead!

skeleton1.webp
 
EternallyUndying said:
That sounds sweet. Unfortunately, it can be dispelled or worse - you can roll two 6s in the attempt and, while you regen maybe 4 skeles, you then in turn wipe out the nearly the entire unit and banish your lord into the realm of chaos.

Is this correct?

Mmm, sort of.

First, since Invocation is a signature spell, every caster in your army can (and mostly should) have it. It's unlikely the bad guys can dispel over instance of the spell.

As for Miscasts. They hurt us a lot less than some armies. You aren't a real Bretonnian player until you've blown up an entire unit of knights with a single miscast due to bretonnian Wizard special rules...

As a general thing, Vampires don't care about any Miscast result other than 2-4, and even that only has a 50% chance of being truely bad.


EternallyUndying said:
Also, whats the rules for adding more models? Can you put in empty bases to represent the extra skeles or is it generally a rule that if you don't have the models, you can't add more units? Couldn't you make a few fillers to stick in to make up for this?

You can use empty bases. Sometimes I use dice. If I get, say, ten zombies and don't have spare models I just but two dice behind the unit, each showing a five.

It's only something you should do in friendly games, though. And only if it is not going to lead to footprint issues.

The letter of the law is that you must have models, but don't let the rules push you around.

EternallyUndying said:
The only thing about O. Mindrazor is you have to get it, which means you have to bring a L4 shadow caster and still there's only a 2/3 chance you'll get it right?

No. If your roll a spell, you get it, of course. But if you roll any doubles you can pick one spell of your choice. The maths is modestly complicated but the result is that a level 4 has a .908 probability of getting Okkam's Mindrazor - (or indeed, any one specific spell from any Lore).

EternallyUndying said:
Then you have to pull it off, it has to not be dispelled and you have to not kill your entire unit while attempting it right? I think that if you do pull it off and you're about to shove 15 powerful attacks where they'll do a lot of hurt, your opponent is going to do everything they can to stop you and so this could serve as nothing but a distraction with a chance to obliterate the unit and caster.
EternallyUndying said:
Correct. Personally, I consider betteing all your marbles on one super spell to be... dull.

It can be effective, and the super-spells are not bad for the game (though some say they are), but I find it to be a dull tactic to play with or against.

Throwing six dice and an almighty spell should be your emergency last resort, not your primary battle-plan.

Nevertheless - if it is your plan then you want a miscast! Having your spell dispelled is the worst case in this scenario. You want an irresistible cast and with six dice you have a .263 probability of miscasting.

That's another reason not to use this as your main plan. Your main plan should have better than one in four odds of working...

EternallyUndying said:
But swords can also be used for this you just have less attacks. Swords bring reliability to save 17% of the skeletons you'd have lost in every head-on melee, buying you more time for your hero to dish out some more dmg and raise them back (while healing himself). Also the ability to even have a chance against powerful melee strikes that would simply erase spear-skeles. Skeles only really serve as guards so having better guarding ability seems wise.

I agree with everything you said here.

But I also have and use 50 Spear Skittles because they're cool. so, uh... there's that.


Do you feel ready to start an army plog yet? It's always fun to watch an army grow from the start.
 
Given this helpful info I feel good about my sword skeles, and they came out good so far. I don't have plans for a Mortis but I'd like them to guard some heroes such as a master necro/vampire/banshee.

Yeah ill def start a blog. As of now i have a lot of units ordered and so I plan on making a lot

WAIT A MINUTE.....

How come nobody is talking about the speed of light? Mindrazor is cast on an 18+ and will basically give your skeles 10STR, but only with a vampire lord. The same vampire lord (or s. ghoul king) can take Forgotten Lore Vamp Powers for Lore of Light. With speed of light (8+), the skeles turn into S10 I10 killing machines. It doesn't even have to be the lord in the unit- any lord within 24" can cast this on the skeles. or, if there's a bunch of units within 12" he can cast it on all of the units.

You can still stick a master of dead necro in the unit for 185 points and hes guaranteed Nehek to add D6+1 skeles to your unit every turn on a 6+

This seems like the most optimal use of spear skeles. Now you're getting 15 S10/I10 attacks. But- it's the unit so that's 22 attacks w/ champ/Lord/Necro. This is also fun becasue they are likely to desperately dispel your SoL and leave you to easily cast Nehek and bolster your unit while your Lord is still getting his 5 s5 attacks every turn.
 
Really depends on what else you're running in your army, and how you intend to use your skellingtons.

60 Skellingtons with spears in a horde formation can actually kill stuff provided you get the Danse and/or Vigour off and provided you can get a couple of invocations off each phase to boost them back up. And it's only 320 points with standard and musician.

But if you're running your skeletons 5 wide in a deep block to hold people in place while your grave guard, etc run around killing everything, hand weapons and shields are the way to go.
 
I don't know who told you... any of that, but there are some misapprehensions there.

First, Speed of Light does not affect your Strength at all.

Second, your general MUST use the Lore of Vampires and the highest Leadership character in the army MUST be the general, so if you want a Vampire Lord to have the Lore of Light you would need to field two Vampire Lords and who has the points for that?

Third, putting a Necromancer in the unit is just asking for him to be gutted as soon as it gets into combat.


I'm not necessarily trying to piss on your cheerios, but I'm afraid life isn't quite that easy...
 
Speed of light affects your WS and I, not S and I. So even if you cast it, your skellies will attack first against everything but elves and a bunch of other things with ASF and will hit on 3+, rather than 4+/5+ - it's an improvement, but not very big one.

And to make things harder, to have Lore of Light with a level higher than 2 to ensure a particular spell, you have to take 2 vampire lords, so it's getting very expensive.

And slightly offtopic, sorry, BTW - it's bollocks that doubles when rolling for spells let you take any spell you want - at first they force randomness and then they put something like this. Before reading BRB carefully I thought one re-rolls a spell until there are no doubles :rolleyes:

EDIT: One minute too late... ninja'd ;)
 
Okay I see. Thanks for the corrections. Nobody told me that - I'm new and trying to interpret the rules.

Having an expensive lord seems like the way to go since hes the glue holding everything together. If the lord is on a throne or dragon, can it be targeted directly or is that good protection?

A plane jane vampire as a lvl 2 wizard with Forbidden Lore is only 165pts. Probably great for a lore with great signature but it might be disappointing if you're hoping for a particular spell.

Regardless it seems the safest bet is to have as many vampire lores going on as possible
-it's a pretty great lore with a great signature and attribute unique to VC
-you can spam nehek in hopes that some go off
-you can hand off the crown to prevent your army from crumbling every turn.

Given these facts, you would need a second lord in order to run a good mindrazor build, gimping your survivability if your vamp lore lord dies and staking a huge point cost. I think the most reasonable strategy would be to run a lvl 2 shadow vampire and hope for mindrazor. Then regardless of what happens, you still get 4 s5 (or better) attacks out of your unit no matter what for a pretty low point cost. Still, I'd prefer sword skellies for the durability and reliability every game. You still get 15 s7 attacks if you pull mindrazor off (4+2hero+5flank+4vamp). Would it be worth the risk?

If your master necro is not in the unit of skellies, how is he Nehek'n them back to life or staying alive? It seems like skellies job is to be the front line grunts, not avoiding combat.
 
Borgnine said:
And slightly offtopic, sorry, BTW - it's bollocks that doubles when rolling for spells let you take any spell you want - at first they force randomness and then they put something like this. Before reading BRB carefully I thought one re-rolls a spell until there are no doubles :rolleyes:

My gaming group acctually roll till theres no doubles. Makes the spells more random and we get some more variation, in a small gaming group you need that. I'm not happy about facing dwellers below every battle so it suits me :P
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu