Skeletons Bad?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Never Spears I would say. You are not expecting them to kill anything really. That's the job of the characters. Your skellies need to prevent giving up combat res as much as possible so parry is better.

I guess the way to think about it is many wounds 5 more attacks will give vs saves by parrying. Against standard troops you will average one more wound with spears. Less against better ones. You will save one parry per six wounds with sword and board. Seeing it like this if you take more than six wounds on the skellies (virtually always) sword and board gives better combat results.
 
excessiveswagger said:
Never Spears I would say. You are not expecting them to kill anything really. That's the job of the characters. Your skellies need to prevent giving up combat res as much as possible so parry is better.

I guess the way to think about it is many wounds 5 more attacks will give vs saves by parrying. Against standard troops you will average one more wound with spears. Less against better ones. You will save one parry per six wounds with sword and board. Seeing it like this if you take more than six wounds on the skellies (virtually always) sword and board gives better combat results.

what about in smaler point games or bus lists where your characters are somewhere else?
 
Well in such cases your skellies will be a tarpit (they won't win anything) so you are trying to minimise casualties so they will last longer. Thus sword and board is better in this situation too
 
Spears aren't significantly worse than swords, either, though. Not enough that you'll notice all that much. And since the primary reason to take skeletons at all is aesthetic rather than practical, then if you think spears look that much better than swords, you might as well use them. I prefer swords, for ease of transportation, but to each their own.

Also, if you plan on walling the front rank off with characters (I occasionally run a block of skellies with five wights or wraiths to seal off the front rank in melee, then you might as well use the spears, since you shouldn't be taking hits on skeletons to roll parries on anyway. Zombies do this job better as well, but skeletons can give the characters the 'flaming' rule with a banner in case you have to deal with abominations and the like.
 
Unfortunately, characters will not benefit from the flaming banner if they are using a magic weapon.

Skellies with Banner of Swiftness work well in concert with CH's and spirit hosts which are M6 so if you are an infantry player but enjoy a bit of speed, consider using them.
 
interesting point about using banshees or wraiths in the front rank to seal off the unit, might use that one
 
Seneschal said:
Unfortunately, characters will not benefit from the flaming banner if they are using a magic weapon.

If I'm taking enough heroes to wall off the front rank of a whole unit, I generally don't have the points lying around to give them much in the way of magic goodies, anyway.
 
I thought you had to keep the command group in the front rank? I guess if you're taking a wall of heroes you'd just leave the command group at home.
 
I love my skeletons. Almost all my games i have 2 blocks of skeletons 40 strong. Although it isn't popular here I use them with spears and in horde formation. I have several games where they have won the battle for me. A lot of my opponents really underestimate them and it costs them the game. I know its all about the dice rolling and maybe doubters would call me lucky however a lot of people don't seem to realize that skellies still hit most things on 4s. I love the look on my opponents faces when they think skellies cant kill anything and my 30 attacks cause 10 wounds. Or that magical time when they fail their fear test.
 
Seneschal said:
Unfortunately, characters will not benefit from the flaming banner if they are using a magic weapon.

Skellies with Banner of Swiftness work well in concert with CH's and spirit hosts which are M6 so if you are an infantry player but enjoy a bit of speed, consider using them.

Since this thread has been re-raised already I might as well ask, why wouldn't the character gain the banner bonus if they have a magic weapon?
 
Crystal said:
Seneschal said:
Unfortunately, characters will not benefit from the flaming banner if they are using a magic weapon.

Skellies with Banner of Swiftness work well in concert with CH's and spirit hosts which are M6 so if you are an infantry player but enjoy a bit of speed, consider using them.

Since this thread has been re-raised already I might as well ask, why wouldn't the character gain the banner bonus if they have a magic weapon?

Flaming attacks page in the rulebook, last paragraph. :tongue:
 
jonnoc said:
I love my skeletons. Almost all my games i have 2 blocks of skeletons 40 strong. Although it isn't popular here I use them with spears and in horde formation. I have several games where they have won the battle for me. A lot of my opponents really underestimate them and it costs them the game. I know its all about the dice rolling and maybe doubters would call me lucky however a lot of people don't seem to realize that skellies still hit most things on 4s. I love the look on my opponents faces when they think skellies cant kill anything and my 30 attacks cause 10 wounds. Or that magical time when they fail their fear test.

Feel free to post your armylist and your tactics :-)
 
Crystal said:
Since this thread has been re-raised already I might as well ask, why wouldn't the character gain the banner bonus if they have a magic weapon?

It's in the flaming rules - anyone with a magic weapon can't benefit from flaming attacks.

If you play strict RAW, this also applies to a lot of magic weapons that confer flaming attacks. ;)
 
Vipoid said:
Crystal said:
Since this thread has been re-raised already I might as well ask, why wouldn't the character gain the banner bonus if they have a magic weapon?

It's in the flaming rules - anyone with a magic weapon can't benefit from flaming attacks.

If you play strict RAW, this also applies to a lot of magic weapons that confer flaming attacks. ;)

What does RAW mean? And I can see how you could read it that way although it kind of defeats the spirit of the rules.
 
Crystal said:
What does RAW mean? And I can see how you could read it that way although it kind of defeats the spirit of the rules.

RAW = Rules As Written - i.e. the most literal interpretation of the rules.

(As opposed to RAI - Rules As Interpreted - what people think the designers actually meant).


I quite agree that that wouldn't be in the spirit of the rules - I just find it amusing. xD
 
Vipoid said:
RAW = Rules As Written - i.e. the most literal interpretation of the rules.

(As opposed to RAI - Rules As Interpreted - what people think the designers actually meant).


I quite agree that that wouldn't be in the spirit of the rules - I just find it amusing. xD

It is very amusing, imagine if tournaments were run on the RAW even in circumstances like this :O
 
Nagashizzar said:
jonnoc said:
I love my skeletons. Almost all my games i have 2 blocks of skeletons 40 strong. Although it isn't popular here I use them with spears and in horde formation. I have several games where they have won the battle for me. A lot of my opponents really underestimate them and it costs them the game. I know its all about the dice rolling and maybe doubters would call me lucky however a lot of people don't seem to realize that skellies still hit most things on 4s. I love the look on my opponents faces when they think skellies cant kill anything and my 30 attacks cause 10 wounds. Or that magical time when they fail their fear test.

Feel free to post your armylist and your tactics :-)

Ooh, and write battle reports, with pictures! or videos even!

No really, skeletons have been lackluster for me, but I'd love to actually see them in practice working out for someone else.
 
Malisteen said:
Ooh, and write battle reports, with pictures! or videos even!

There is good software for this:

http://www.battlechronicler.com/

If you're interested in doing a picture based battle report this is the best I've found for it, it can take a long time to make the report but once you get used to it, it can be an effective way to demonstrate what happened each turn without needing to go into detail about every movement and without the need to take several photos a turn of your match, it also gives a better idea of how every unit is positioned on both sides. Just program in the two army templates, set up the battlefield you had and try to replicate the battle turn by turn.

I found out about this on Ulthuan.net so here is a link to a random battle report using it just to give an example of how its used.


http://www.ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=48743
 
https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-Skeletons-With-Spears-Worth-It?page=3 check this thread thats also the page i started posting about my skellys with spears.

2 big horde blocks of 40 are my mainstay core hehe. Oh i messed up earlier its 40 attacks not 30 :p

I would say to classify our core infantry:

Zombs = tarpit
Skels = anvil
Ghouls = hammer


Haha if i get around to it maybe I'll make a thread on my skelly exploits :thumbsup:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu