Skeletons obsolete?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Swissdictator

Vampire Count
True Blood
Apr 16, 2008
1,546
Wisconsin
Zombies
907
The list I've been running is primarily focused on two units of GG, and a unit of Ghouls. I've had incredible success with them, including doing very well at a large tournament.

It seems that, now that GG and Ghouls can be healed, and Skeletons have the size cap (without the one power) that Grave Guard are such a better choice. Sure, they cost four more points. But compared to the old skeletons (from the 6th edition book) the GG are only 2 points more expensive... get magical attacks w/ kb, better WS, S, T, I, and LD. Plus better armor. Even with current skellie prices they're only 4 pts more expensive for all that! They are healed just as easily (setting aside the one power).

Opponents literally fear the two blocks. I run one hw/sh, and one with GW. The skeletons seem to give easy res as most opponents hit them on 3s, and wound fairly easily.

I am currently running two blocks of zombies for core slots, and a decent size Ghoul unit. If I changed up my powers I'd keep the one ghoul unit and swap the Zombie units for smaller ghoul units that I could expand with Summon Ghouls. Though Zombies are easily replenished... can park in a wood or building to hold... etc. That worked wonders at the recent tournament.

Plus 23 GG + Vamp + Wight King BSB is SOLID. Regen Banner and 3+ save in combat... they're almost as hard as Ironbreakers to kill. Maybe harder. My Vamp with Blood drinker makes it even nastier.

Skeletons just don't seem to be worth it to me at the moment. Sure, I could probably fit in another block if I did (three blocks of skellies)... but then I feel my Invocation is spread out pretty thin, harder to back up those units well, etc.

I still take some units of wolves so while the wolves don't count for min core, I still have 5 core slots. No Corpse Carts (not really impressed, but might add one as that apprently works with blooddrinker.. but still very hesitant to consider it).


It makes for a very fighty army that can hit like a ton of bricks. There is very little I would change... I might swap the Warbanner out for Banner of the Barrows.
 
What you seem to be forgetting is that with that one power you raise skeletons on a 3+ for 15pts and you don't loose extra's when you hit the cap.

Raising GG is a 4+ and means I'm loath to toss a dice at it repeatedly, 3+ is the good breaking point where I can be confident in enough IoN going off even after DD are taken into account, and the 3+ isn't to be underestimated, to be sure of not wasting DD opponents have to roll 2 to your 1 to dispel and that drains their pool well and quick given most of your castings are going off.

GG are superior Fighty blocks no question, but Skeletons with BotUL (warbanner is elsewhere) start at 7CR and with a Vamp (AoD, WDeath) are dead hard to dislodge at 8Cr and a fighty Character, even without the Vamp opponents have to kill a good few to win combat and you don't care because for 2 dice you can raise what you lost back.

Its not to be overlooked that having a decent percentage of your army in core is also helped by skeletons, you can get a decent holding block for relatively little expense which will keep your fighty characters alive and make your composition look less gamey.

GG make a great anchor or unit to start rolling that flank but they take special slots and eat points like maniacs when given them. Most importantly they compete with Black Knights and Fell Bats for slots.

GG come into their own when you want to spend ridiculous amounts of points on them, but Drakenhoff Banner will get you instant enmity and I'm still not sold on it given people will be predicting it and planning for it.
 
Thing is... I rely far less on magic this way. Plus Blood drinker helps with the healing.

The advantage with GG is I need to heal *less*. Sure, I have an upper limit, but I have that with skeletons unless I buy that power. Lord of Dead doesn't fit into my combos. Walking Death + Infinite Hatred + Red Fury is a great combo. I loathe to drop infinite hatred, and walking death is always useful.

One of my blocks has a BSB, Warbanner, Walking Death. Add the three ranks, banner, and out number (I go with about 25+) I'm going in with 7-8 combat res. I don't need four ranks to benefit as between Warbanenr or Walking Death I make up for not taking that banner.

Skeletons die easily, making the unit die that much faster from crumble. If I make it harder to gets wounds through, I win more often... and even if I don't I rarely need to heal as much. With or without regen banner.

The Regen banner is not that cheesey, considering the cost and I have to go with a BSB with no other equipment (usually a Wight King for the extra W, T, and free armor). Considering the other things out there (Annoyance of Netlings at 25 pts), 125 pts for a banner that gives a 50% chance to save for one unit is not that nasty. Though it'll be hard to counter, and if they do they're spending some points to do it. I don't depend on the banner, but it is a good tool.

I like having a fighty list as it reduces my dependence on magic. I won 4 of 5 games (barely losing the one) with only 7 pd and the Book of Arkhan. I rarely had to do healing. I don't mind throwing two dice, not at all. Plus, the blood drinker helps out big time too.

Two zombies units and a decent sized Ghoul unit still make my army look believable, it just looks like a Horde... much like a VC army should. I still have bats and a varghulf. Four characters too.

It's a tough list, but far from over the top. Isn't the point of the game to make tough lists? This is meant more for tournaments.
 
Swissdictator said:
Thing is... I rely far less on magic this way. Plus Blood drinker helps with the healing.

The advantage with GG is I need to heal *less*. Sure, I have an upper limit, but I have that with skeletons unless I buy that power. Lord of Dead doesn't fit into my combos. Walking Death + Infinite Hatred + Red Fury is a great combo. I loathe to drop infinite hatred, and walking death is always useful.

One of my blocks has a BSB, Warbanner, Walking Death. Add the three ranks, banner, and out number (I go with about 25+) I'm going in with 7-8 combat res. I don't need four ranks to benefit as between Warbanenr or Walking Death I make up for not taking that banner.

Skeletons die easily, making the unit die that much faster from crumble. If I make it harder to gets wounds through, I win more often... and even if I don't I rarely need to heal as much. With or without regen banner.

The Regen banner is not that cheesey, considering the cost and I have to go with a BSB with no other equipment (usually a Wight King for the extra W, T, and free armor). Considering the other things out there (Annoyance of Netlings at 25 pts), 125 pts for a banner that gives a 50% chance to save for one unit is not that nasty. Though it'll be hard to counter, and if they do they're spending some points to do it. I don't depend on the banner, but it is a good tool.

I like having a fighty list as it reduces my dependence on magic. I won 4 of 5 games (barely losing the one) with only 7 pd and the Book of Arkhan. I rarely had to do healing. I don't mind throwing two dice, not at all. Plus, the blood drinker helps out big time too.

Two zombies units and a decent sized Ghoul unit still make my army look believable, it just looks like a Horde... much like a VC army should. I still have bats and a varghulf. Four characters too.

It's a tough list, but far from over the top. Isn't the point of the game to make tough lists? This is meant more for tournaments.

Apparently the point is to make tough list that don't look tough.

Drakenhoff banner in the usual unit is an instant comp hit if the rest of the army isn't total tissue paper. (Netlings on a tree is too)

Token core units of 20 zombies also do NOT look good if you're obviously taking them to fill required core slots, decent ghouls are good though.

Fighty armies are all well and good, but a proper meta makes them vunerable. Copnsider the fact that a small magic phase gets stomped on easily, then its more logical to invest properly if you do. VC's pay for a small magic phase nomatter what so beefing it up is logical to maximise your return on investment.

Throwing two dice out of your pool to raise seems like such a waste, it minimises your return and makes it more worthwhile for the opponent to use two of his dice because you used enough dice for it that doing it again will cost you.

Relying on magic only becomes a problem when you allow it to be variable, or in other words when you don't bring enough dice to power through what you want or need to go through.

You mistook me, I referenced 4rankbanner because Warbanner goes in a unit thats there to actually win combats on its own, not just grind and hold. skeletons dropping quicker doesn't matter when two dice gets you two raises which your oppoent won't bother to dispel.

Taking into account Helm on the Casterlord you have a block opf skeletons that will bounce anything thats not your opponents MBT unit, and if he charges that into your center you do the victory Danse because you don't care about the skelletons then.

Me I prefer a Character build where you bunker the Casterlord and power out magic from him with and perhaps a herocaster depending on powers, hero-Vamps w/ AoD and WD lend combat punch and are only ~145pts so you don't overspend.
 
Seven Power dice seemed to do very well for me. The nice thing was most of the time I wasn't using it for healing either! I was casting Danse which got me moving really fast.

The problem with high magic is it is much more of a comp hit then having a heavy fighty build like I do. For example Dwarf armies with a few special blocks, and two shoot core units don't get knocked that bad usually... it is only when they have a lot of shooting. So two units of zombies to cover core slots doesn't seem to come across as that bad, particuarly since I have the block of Ghouls and a few units of wolves. Three small units of ghouls and summon ghouls might be nastier.... or 3 small units of skellies and Lord of Dead.

The other thing is, throwing one dice even with + 1 to cast I fail two... and the opponent can spread his dice out more easily too. Two dice almost assures success and usually gets me to get the opponent to either concede the healing OR throw three (and sometimes even four) dice to stop it.

Plus having a high magic army can easily misfire... one miscast can really hurt you... and if you're having an expansive magic phase it is that much more likely. In a 5 game tournament I only miscasted once.

We're sorta debating personal tastes here, and I hope I didn't come across like a jerk or anything... that is not my intention.

I might drop the Varghulf to replace the two Zomboid units with two decent size Ghoul blocks... I would not be against it... but I love the role the Varghulf plays... arrow magnet and sometimes useful.

Still, it then goes back to: Ghouls or Skellies. Personally I prefer Ghouls these days.

Again, I hope I came across well, but you do have me thinking. Maybe dropping the Varghulf to get a lot of ghouls might prove interesting.
 
Its 11PD before you get a comp hit, the rule of 10 is still good, and if anything, would be loosened for vamps.

1PD Casts dn't miscast, thats why 3+ casting is so good, 1PD casting means you can Danse and Raise aswell.

The problem I have with 2PD raises is that if he lets it go, and he should, its not worth the DD, he can then overpower your Danse which actually matters.

I agree on the personal tastes thing, but my point is really that in a tournament environment where a lot of the feild will have 6DD+scroll you either fight for the magic phase or you give it up.

I wouldn't like to comment on a list without seeing it, but without proper Raising in the army, ghouls with no save would need something special to make me take them, or be en masse with ghoulkin, might be an idea if you're playing fast and hitty, problem with fast and hitty in VC is you have a really fragile glass cannon.
 
I still casted the Invocation quite a bit with one dice, and that was when I was usually in combat and didn't need the Danse as much (I had the book). I'd heal and when I cast (which was average) I usually got my opponent to throw two dice.

The whole point I'm trying to make is the GG hit harder and are harder to kill... which also means less res for your opponent.




The list is:

Vampire
Red Fury, Inf. Hatred, Walking Death
Book of Arkhan, Blood Drinker, Flayed Hauberk

Wight King BSB
Regen Banner

Vampire
Dark Acolyte, Avatar of Death (Hw/Sh)
Helm of Commandant

Wight King
Sword of Kings


20 Zombies
20 Zombies
20 Ghouls w/ Champ
5 Wolves
5 Wolves

23 GG. Hw/Sh. Warbanner. Mu + Std

23 GG Greatweapons Hellfire banner Mu + Std

3 Felbats

Varghulf



The vampire general and her unit are hard to kill and her weapon can heal the small amount of casualties or wounds on herself.
 
I can see that it is a matter of opinion mainly but to go as far as to say that skeletons are obsolete is a little much, don't you think? In your army structure there's no way a skeleton is as effective as a grave guard because of your low PD count. However with more PD even a small-ish skeleton unit with Lord of the Dead makes for a scary unit most charging units are like RAWR charge! Then they just kinda like lose the enthusiasm about charging after the third round you have their fighty chargey thing in combat. It is a difference in styles and tactics but it doesn't mean that either unit has no place in an army. For me personally Grave Guard are useless. In your type of army though I'd imagine they can cause a lot of devastation.
 
I don't think the fact that Grave Guard are new and improved automatically makes Skeletons obsolete. Grave Guard are better for their points, and unlike Skeletons are actually capable of doing damage (rather than just taking it).
But Skeletons still make capable line infantry units, and their effectiveness should be compared to the other core options Ghouls and Zombies. This is where Skeletons don't shine.

Ghouls are tougher, with higher WS and I, and have two poisoned attacks. The added toughness virtually makes up for the lack of armour, and the combat buffs mean they are capable of defeating weaker infantry on their own (unlike Skellies).
I'm still taking some Skeletons, but I'm pretty much certain now that Ghoul heavy builds are the most cost effective.

- - -
I actually think Swissdictator has a very valid point regarding less magic focused VC lists. My current planned 2k VC list has 6DD, 2 Balefires and 2 Scrolls (plus periapt). It is basically an anti-Vampire (and HE / Daemon) list, because you're going to have to get within range of the 2 Balefires to cast anything useful, and then you need 6+ for IoN, 9+ for VHD.

Grave Guard with the Drakenhoff standard and Blood Drinker Vamp and basically a self sustaining unit, that doesn't require any magic to function.
- - -

Using 1 or 2 D6 for IoN

Which is best depends on a lot of factors to me, how much anti-magic your opponent has, whether it is your general casting it etc.

Using 1D6 with +1 to cast (LotD, Skull staff etc) will allow you to raise more models in total and negates mistcasting. (2 1/3 per dice).

Using 2D6 only gets you 1.7 models per dice, but should take slightly more dice for your opponent to stop.

Personally I am coming around to the 1D6 option I think it probably works out better (I just hate failing to cast).
 
I like the Skull Staff + Summon power combo.

While you still need a 3+ to cast, making the dispel roll 5-8 is huge. Basically means they have to use 2 DD to stop a 1 PD spell. Either you get half a dozen IoN off or they have to blow all their DD dice to try to stop you leaving your other spells unmolested.
 
Me too, the casterlord seems mandatory in magic heavy armies and surely is a monster in the magic phase. As far as skellies and ghouls go. I have found a new love for the ghouls, they are a capable fighting force. Still, I have a lot of skellie models. My border patrol and 1k lists are ghoul oriented, my 1.5k list is so good in it´s current form that I have a hard time getting ghouls in there along with the ghoulkin power.

In 2k I will probably go the ghoul route, supported with hero-level fighting characters and WS7 from my lord they will deadly :mrgreen:.
 
The sad thing is that Ghouls are so much better than Skeletons, there really is little point in taking Skeletons, unless you're one of those dying breeds that takes models becuase you like how they look, or you have a bony theme (rather than the current over-riding theme of a Necrarch leading a horde of Ghouls) to your army. The good thing is that the army is so strong that we can afford to take Skeletons rather than Ghouls, and still field an effective army.
 
Mikael.K said:
...or you have those odd 100+ skellie models lying around the house :mrgreen:.


Tell me about it! I also did A LOT of conversion work on both renditions of my VC. Undead Empire, and then a more extensive conversion project for Undead Chaos. Oi. I feel terrible letting them sit... I just love fielding Grave Guard though.
 
Skellys worthless? I prefer them to Ghouls myself, mainly because of the fact that you can magic banner them into being useful :) although ghouls can be useful...
 
Ghouls are more killy, totally, so are GG. Skeletons are different though.

GG take specials I'd rather use for Bats and Black Knight units (which are too good to overlook IMO) and are harder to raise aswell as having a cap and being more expensive.
GG are what they are, super skeletons. more expensive in more than one way, both have their uses.

Ghouls compete with Skeletons directly and are the same price relatively as tough as eachother given their defensive options, what you're weighing there is the extra killy of the ghouls for the extra Static CR of Skeletons.

Ghouls bring their kills, Skeletons bring CR.

Me I picked VC for reliability, relying on my ghouls to actually kill things and not get ASF'd or the myriad other BS that appears doesn't appeal to me as much as knowing I have XCR that can be depended on and the chance of some lucky dice giving me more but next to no chance of my dice flopping and me loosing the crucial combat that costs me the game.
 
well why not both? i view ghouls almost as my "elite" core troops. skellies get the brunt of attacks and hold the enemy down while ghouls flank them to negate ranks and get kills. that or insure that the enemy has to charge both my skellies and my ghouls. the well armored, high CR skellies go perfect with the killy ghouls.

and i love wights period. black knights are badass and i used to use them extensively because i loved calvary. but since invocation now heals GG D6 i'm definitely finding use for them. i converted a bunch of teutogen (however you spell it) guard to be GG w/GW and bought some normal GG for the hand weapon and shield combo. the gw wielding gg are my elite bodyguard for my general (who is commanded by a wight king with the drakenhof banner, everybody hates me for this unit). i'm still putting together the other GG but i can't wait until they're finished
 
I used to love black knights in 6th edition. So cheap for what you get. Now you pay 5 more points for the same thing and the ability to charge through forests (and a debatable extra 1" movement). With many of the units getting very expensive, I find it difficult to find a place for the black knights, especially since I need to field 3 units of infantry.

I find skeletons more effective against the opponents I play, and grave guard even more so. My opponents just love the heavily armoured troops, Chaos or Empire knights, and the higher WS of ghouls generally doesn't help as they're still getting hit on 3's, and can't get through the armour. The skeletons HW&S is just as good as the ghouls higher T I believe in most situations.

Given WS4, skeletons perform better against S3, S4, and nearly the same (a bit worse) against S5. Their killing power is good against lightly armoured troops, but I wouldn't count on either to generate more than a single CR through killing. Perhaps it is just the style of the group of people I play with.

So ghouls are better in most circumstances, but not all. I find having a concentrated amount of pressure in one area can be key and I think skeletons do a better job of generating it. You pay more, but its not a lot more. For an extra 37 pts (at starting unit size of 20), skeletons can have a Standard, Warbanner, and musician. That's +2 CR, and the potential to win a tied combat. +2 static CR for 37 pts I think is worth it. They are better at holding up armoured/elite troops.

I'm not saying that skeletons are better, because I think ghouls are, but I'm making the point that it's not in all cases. It depends how your army works as a whole. Also, I do not think the difference is so huge between skeletons and ghouls that we will stop seeing skeletons. I would need to do some more math hammer, but the extra pts for a standard/musician isnt' that much.
 
Personally I find Ghouls/Skeletons to be a wash. Skeletons can be made a little better at a higher cost.

The reason I went Ghouls is for one reason only: Ghoul Kin. There are times its worth its weight in gold.

If I could get a version of Ghoul Kin for Skeletons I would probably be Skeleton based.
 
10 skeletons with spears = 10 attacks, 5+ AS, War Banner, Mus
formation: 2x5
price: 127pts
starting combat resolution: +3

15 Ghouls = 11 attacks (maybe 13 or 15), Poison, T4
formation: 3x5 (2x6 + 3; 2x7 + 1)
price: 128pts
starting combat resolution: +2

Now take a small block of Swordsmen

17 Swordsmen = 6 attacks, full command
formation: 3x5 + 2
price: 127pts
starting combat resolution: +3

Skeleton VS Swordsmen
Swordsmen inflict 1 wound, Skeleton inflict 1 wound
Skeletons lose combat by 1

Ghouls VS Swordsmen
swordsmen inflict 1 wound, Duelist slays Crypt Ghast, Ghouls inflict 1 wound
Ghouls lose by 4

So as you can see Skeletons are much better when fighting light infantry, but when it comes to taking a charge from Imperial Knights - Ghouls are much better because of T4 (whilst Skeletons can't take AS)
 
So as you can see Skeletons are much better when fighting light infantry, but when it comes to taking a charge from Imperial Knights - Ghouls are much better because of T4 (whilst Skeletons can't take AS)

Correction: Skeletons are better when fighting Swordsmen.
 
The problem I have with mixing in your core is that you have to choose lord of the dead or ghoul-powers, the unit you don't support is going to underperform.

The problem I find with Grave Guard is that I really want some Black Knights even if its just to smoke out wood elves, at 125pts min fitting them and Grave guard in with a decent amount of characters and not having understrength core blocks vunerable to shooting is a real concern.

Then again I avoid the Drakenhoff banner like the comp-hit plague it is.
 
I don't take champs in my GG and if I'm facing woodies I switch up my characters placement. Instead of putting the support heroes in the Great Weapon GG I put them in the ghouls. My Great Weapon Grave Guard have the Hellfire banner. Watch those Treemen cringe!

It's also fun to see a Varhulf tear through fast cav. :lol:
 
Comparing a base skellie to a base ghoul the ghoul wins hands down, as mentioned an extra attack, T, I and poisoned attacks make if far superior, especially when you take into the account that many black powder weapons are armour piercing which doesn't make a difference to the ghouls. However you can kit a skellie unit to have more CR, the fact that it can take a SB with a magical standard does make this a viable unit but I think its going to end up being people will only choose skellies out of personal preference or fluff rather than any strong tactical choice. Personally I think ghouls should have been kept skirmishers, that way both choices would have different tactical advantages and therefore both be viable.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu