Skeletons + the Fear combo

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
drmooreflava said:
The fact remains. GG and Black Knights gain more of a benefit from the screaming banner than skeletons do. Ghouls gain more from it also, but can't take the banner without a bsb, making them the most costly choice IMO. Now keep in mind I am not advising the replacement of banner of the barrows with the screaming banner.

Of course, I just see the army being more viable the less each threatening unit costs on the battlefield.

My Skeleton + scary Vamp combo comes out to 557.
My 35 7x5 GG w/ Banner of Barrows is 500.
My stupid Lord and his Knight bunker is ~869.. with 538 being the Lord himself.

The more you spread out your numbers while maintaining a threat on its own is what makes a successful list imo. Basically the reverse of the GGstar mentality that is 7th Ed.
 
fjhamming said:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but if the general is not in the 6" aura, the unit can still use his unmodified leadership

Correct. And that fact will defeat the fear-bomb many times.
 
I believe you are wrong Yorga, the FaQ says:
Q: If a unit taking a Leadership test has a modifier to its
Leadership, will this modifier still apply if the unit uses the generals
Leadership, because of the Inspiring Presence special rule for
example? (p10)

A: Yes.

So I think the fear-bomb still works.
 
HERO said:
drmooreflava said:
The fact remains. GG and Black Knights gain more of a benefit from the screaming banner than skeletons do. Ghouls gain more from it also, but can't take the banner without a bsb, making them the most costly choice IMO. Now keep in mind I am not advising the replacement of banner of the barrows with the screaming banner.

Of course, I just see the army being more viable the less each threatening unit costs on the battlefield.

My Skeleton + scary Vamp combo comes out to 557.
My 35 7x5 GG w/ Banner of Barrows is 500.
My stupid Lord and his Knight bunker is ~869.. with 538 being the Lord himself.

The more you spread out your numbers while maintaining a threat on its own is what makes a successful list imo. Basically the reverse of the GGstar mentality that is 7th Ed.

Exactly, this is a running theme with VC. If you want to do something very effectively. You have to pay the points for it. Otherwise, you are half this and half that.

Hybrid lists are very fun in casual games. (the only kind I play)
However, it is very important to know the limits and short comings of your army book(often ossociated with competetive gaming), hence, our discussion. Right on for playing warhammer for the fun of it :thumbsup:
I find warhammer best companied by a few pints and laughs.
 
drmooreflava said:
The arguement vs giving skeletons the screaming banner is this. WS2 skeletons. The enemy hits on 4+ if they fail fear. Not as helpful campared to the enemy hitting on 5+ say if you gave it to GG or Black knights maybe even ghouls with a bsb could be acceptable.


The argument, for me at least, is not that the Skeletons now get hit on 4+ instead of 3+ but rather that they now hit on 3+ themselves. I'm quite aggressive in my play-style in that I try and get my units killing things rather than tarpitting. That is why I don't rely on magic or tactics that need 2-3 things working in my favour in order to work at all. Fifty Skeletons with spears, in a horde, can look after themselves very nicely against most units (obviously not elites etc) and even more so if they get to hit on 3+.
 
Mad said:
I believe you are wrong Yorga, the FaQ says:
Q: If a unit taking a Leadership test has a modifier to its
Leadership, will this modifier still apply if the unit uses the generals
Leadership, because of the Inspiring Presence special rule for
example? (p10)

A: Yes.

So I think the fear-bomb still works.

I stand corrected. :redface: I went to the FAQ and looked and you are right. Though it reads a bit different:

Q. If an enemy unit is affected by the Doom and Darkness spell,
and the unit is within the general’s Inspiring Presence radius, does
the Leadership value conferred by Inspiring Presence suffer the
modifier even if the General is not affected? (Reference)
A: Yes.
 
I did not find that one when I first looked it up, but they are both in the FaQ, mine on page 4 under General Principles and yours on page 10 under Lores of Magic. Strange that both are included as I think the one on page 4 also covers the specific application of Doom and Darkness. But I guess we shouldn't complain when the rules are extra clear, sometimes it is much, much worse.
 
Vortaine said:
how are the Lizards affected by the screaming banner? 3d6 take the lowest vs 3d6 take the highest? Would the two just cancel out?

I'm pretty sure you'd just roll 4 dice and take away the highest and the lowest of the 4. In a way, they cancel out, but they reduce the variance, so it'd be different. And quite fun see him roll those 4 :D
 
TheReckoning said:
Vortaine said:
how are the Lizards affected by the screaming banner? 3d6 take the lowest vs 3d6 take the highest? Would the two just cancel out?

I'm pretty sure you'd just roll 4 dice and take away the highest and the lowest of the 4. In a way, they cancel out, but they reduce the variance, so it'd be different. And quite fun see him roll those 4 :D

IIRC in the old FAQ where stated that both rules would cancel out, apparently the old FAQ isn't available (gw homepage) anymore to confirm it. Lizards will test on 2D6 without discarding any dice what so ever. I guess this will be stated in the new FAQ too.
 
Lizards extra dice for leadership is a bonus and from the screaming banner a disadvantage. So they cancel each other if the two cases exist and lizard player rolls 2d6.

My Vampire built i suggest is: heavy armor, enchanted shield, aura of dark majesty, fear incarnate, the terrifying mask of eee!, opal amulet.

He has a decent defense and gives the maximum potential for the banner.
Also, when you play skeletons or GG in horde formation, you don't need to put him in combat. A far corner of the unit is the best protection.
 
skario said:
Lizards extra dice for leadership is a bonus and from the screaming banner a disadvantage. So they cancel each other if the two cases exist and lizard player rolls 2d6.

My Vampire built i suggest is: heavy armor, enchanted shield, aura of dark majesty, fear incarnate, the terrifying mask of eee!, opal amulet.

He has a decent defense and gives the maximum potential for the banner.
Also, when you play skeletons or GG in horde formation, you don't need to put him in combat. A far corner of the unit is the best protection.

Hordes are large, and hard to manouver. Therefore my hordes end up being charged most of the time. (unless i play other hordes)
When being charged the opponent can choose to be in contact with your character.
 
fjhamming said:
skario said:
Lizards extra dice for leadership is a bonus and from the screaming banner a disadvantage. So they cancel each other if the two cases exist and lizard player rolls 2d6.

My Vampire built i suggest is: heavy armor, enchanted shield, aura of dark majesty, fear incarnate, the terrifying mask of eee!, opal amulet.

He has a decent defense and gives the maximum potential for the banner.
Also, when you play skeletons or GG in horde formation, you don't need to put him in combat. A far corner of the unit is the best protection.

Hordes are large, and hard to manouver. Therefore my hordes end up being charged most of the time. (unless i play other hordes)
When being charged the opponent can choose to be in contact with your character.

Yes. Nothing in the rules say you align dead center. Just have to maximize models touching. However charcaters on the end should only have two contacters instead of three if you maximize models touching.
 
fjhamming said:
skario said:
Lizards extra dice for leadership is a bonus and from the screaming banner a disadvantage. So they cancel each other if the two cases exist and lizard player rolls 2d6.

My Vampire built i suggest is: heavy armor, enchanted shield, aura of dark majesty, fear incarnate, the terrifying mask of eee!, opal amulet.

He has a decent defense and gives the maximum potential for the banner.
Also, when you play skeletons or GG in horde formation, you don't need to put him in combat. A far corner of the unit is the best protection.

Hordes are large, and hard to manouver. Therefore my hordes end up being charged most of the time. (unless i play other hordes)
When being charged the opponent can choose to be in contact with your character.

And what's wrong with being charged exactly?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu