Skeletons With Spears Worth It?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Andy2D6

Skeleton
Jun 11, 2012
52
Zombies
29
I already have a unit of 40 with hand weapons, so is it worth assembling my next 40 with spears?
 
No.

I really have yet to see decent reasoning behind using the spears over HW&S other than a wraith wall, which is a unit I think is too easily counter-able anyway

My opinion, if you're wanting all/mostly skeleton core for whatever reason, stick with HW&S
 
IMO... NO.

Skeletons are an anvil, by swapping spears for handweapons you lose the all important parry save.
They will not win combats, they are there to hold units in place for a long time.
You should be running your skellys 5 wide and deep, this limits somewhat the amount of damage they recieve.
One of my friends swears by skelly horde with spears. I've seen this formation disintegrate time and time again at a rapid rate. You're increasing your frontage, allowing more enemies to engage.

Even if run five wide with spears, your getting 5 extra attacks at ws2 str 3, whereas with sword and shield you are getting a 6+ parry against all wounds from the front.

The ONLY time this is feasible is if you're running a wraith wall, you could get extra attacks from another rank while being immune to damage as the wraiths shield your skeletons.
 
I would not say spears are worse in all occasions, pointcost same, only thing that differ in benefit of hw&s is the parrysave, if you are using mortis engine you get a 6+ regen, which does not stack with parrysave. Therefore the parrysave becomes almost redundat, not quite since a ward is better than regen (flaming, killing blow).

EDIT: forgot that parry are only for close combat to the front, and not vs stomp, and that killing blow, does not really matter unless multiwound and/or high armour save, thank you mortis engine-thread =)

Therefore if you run one, or even two mortis engine, a deep formation with spears are better than hw&s IMO.
 
emil_fh said:
I would not say spears are worse in all occasions, pointcost same, only thing that differ in benefit of hw&s is the parrysave, if you are using mortis engine you get a 6+ regen, which does not stack with parrysave. Therefore the parrysave becomes almost redundat, not quite since a ward is better than regen (flaming, killing blow).

EDIT: forgot that parry are only for close combat to the front, and not vs stomp, and that killing blow, does not really matter unless multiwound and/or high armour save, thank you mortis engine-thread =)

Therefore if you run one, or even two mortis engine, a deep formation with spears are better than hw&s IMO.

Exactly this, with a mortis engine i would always take spears. Also, im always surprised at how often a combat is marginally lost/won but still has a huge impact on the game. In that respect 5 att, even if ws 2 st 3, will make a difference.
 
I do plan to have a Mortis Engine, so maybe I'll make half of them up with spears.

If there's a particular game I really don't want spears, I can always just mix the units up and say they're both hand weapon & shield.
 
I will say "no" to this BUT if you built a list around them because you like the look of spears or just want to try something different....

Run two engines, 2 blocks of spears in horde supported by combat vamps with lore of beasts (wildform) and 2 units of 8-10 crypt horrors flanking the skellies. Double engine is slowly growing in popularity and I've seen some players do well with them. It might be tough fitting those 4 units in the general's bubble so you may have to mess around a bit with deployment but the double engines should give you a bit more survivability.
 
Mathematically, spear skeletons are worse in almost all instances. If you are going for whatever unit is the best, you shouldn't take them.

However, I intend to take them in my Teutonic Undead list. Teutonic infantry utilized spears, so they fit the theme. And they look great.
 
I'm doing one unit of each in our group tournament. Whichever one is left alive at the end is the winner, in my book. First one vs wood elves is this saturday.
 
ill just add my voice to the chorus then :cool:

if you have a mortis engine, sure use spears, but i personally stay away from skeletons alltogether. they are MUCH more expensive than zombies and they will get their ass handed to them by almost any unit anyway. better get 70 zombies than 40 skeletons. If you wanna fight, why not use ghouls instead? yes they are in turn much more expensive than the skeletons but as opposed to the skeletons, they CAN actually fight their way out of a whet paper bag. they arent great by no means, but our core is very weak as it is. better to use a horde of ghouls (for some hitting power) and then just buy zombies and wolf darts to fill out the core requirement (im talking ~2400p battles here)

the skeletons represents not the "golden mean" but rather the "bland gray mean". they are simply good at nothing and bad at almost anything.

just to avoid a flaming war i just want to say that there are ofc situations where skeletons are viable, and i do not think that all (just most :tongue: ) ppl who use skeletons do not know what they are doing. If you like the models and dont play just for winning then go ahead. use as many skeletons as you wish. just do not use them because "every one else does" or worse yet "because i saw them used in white dwarf". If something is used in a WD battle rep you can be fairly sure it is absolutely useless ;)
 
Aside from Mortis Engine argument I've found that spear skellies come out on top if you get a proper fear bomb to work.

My usual configuration:

Vampire (AoDM, Fear Incarnate, e.shield)
Leading 49 skeletons, with spears and screaming banner deployed as horde.

This unit admittedly cost around 500 pts, but are regularly giving any enemies not ItP a run for their money.

Once you start hitting on 3+, and the enemy only hitting you on 4+ then spears become a lot more attractive.

This ofc dont always work (the fear bomb doesnt), but even when it doesnt the difference between 6+ ward in CC and 10 extra attacks aint so great as that. And ofc if I do field this unit then Mortis Engine are more tempting than if i field sword'n board alone
 
Just to throw in my lot here...

I have 70 skeletons, 10 with spears, and the rest with hand weapons, so when I want to field a unit with the spears, I put them on the front, and then fill out the rest of the unit (up to usually 30-40) with the others, so I have had a good mix of experiences with using both...

Spears seem to take too much of an investment to make work in terms of getting them to kill stuff, e.g. Mortis Engine, augments etc. I've always found that I could have spent the points better elsewhere...
 
Vengeance Crusader said:
Just to throw in my lot here...

I have 70 skeletons, 10 with spears, and the rest with hand weapons, so when I want to field a unit with the spears, I put them on the front, and then fill out the rest of the unit (up to usually 30-40) with the others, so I have had a good mix of experiences with using both...

Spears seem to take too much of an investment to make work in terms of getting them to kill stuff, e.g. Mortis Engine, augments etc. I've always found that I could have spent the points better elsewhere...

But with the new book spears are no additional pointcost!
 
I'd say give them the spears by virtue of looking cooler. you can always mix up the units (which also look cool) and place the front ranks with a certain lot if you wish the units to represent one set up or the other. I've got all my skeletons with spears because I think it looks better and I play in an area where I can just clarify their equipment before the game start if all I'm doing is 'downgrading'.
 
emil_fh said:
Vengeance Crusader said:
Just to throw in my lot here...

I have 70 skeletons, 10 with spears, and the rest with hand weapons, so when I want to field a unit with the spears, I put them on the front, and then fill out the rest of the unit (up to usually 30-40) with the others, so I have had a good mix of experiences with using both...

Spears seem to take too much of an investment to make work in terms of getting them to kill stuff, e.g. Mortis Engine, augments etc. I've always found that I could have spent the points better elsewhere...

But with the new book spears are no additional pointcost!

Aye, you don't pay points, but you 'pay' with the loss of the parry ;)
 
Exactly, which is bloody expensive indeed!!! ( see my 'are they worth it' thread :grave: )

Why spend 220pts (240pts with upgrade) on a Mortis Engine just for the regen* when you could just either A: buy more skeletons, or B: just stick to the parry?

I agree though, that spear skeletons are cool, but like our other tar pits, it is a waste of time trying to do anything fancy with them!

*Think how many times the 6+ regen will pay off, and then consider how many skeletons you can get for a fraction of the cost of the Mortis Engine... With our chaff its all about quantity over quality...
 
I must point to my earlier pos..

If you dont do something fancy with them you're essentially wasting a quarter of your army.

Adding characters (one again fear-bomb is my favorite) and a shrewdly chosen banner, and you have a unit that can actually do kill stuff. Then it maybe worth having an extra fistful of attacks especially if you you ethereal characters who can limit the number of people striking back.

Not to mention how a lot of things negate or reduce parry/ward saves...
 
I use skeletons in horde formation with spears. they get an extra rank of attacks. they are easy to grind down in combat but that is the purpose to core. I have found a unit of them with the flaming banner can be very useful especially against regenerating units. I have a friend who avoids any contact with a unit like that when he brings his hell pit abomination. it never ends well for his skaven. Ultimately if you can find a way to do more damage use whatever works. Only once has arkhams mind razor worked really well on a unit like that.
 
A skeleton horde needs to be VERY large to take advantage of the spears. you need to have at least 40 models alive to fully utilize the bonus attacks. how often do you have that? and for how many rounds? sure you could start with 60 in a unit but thats a very expensive one indeed. I am guessing that a lot of the time you find yourself with less than 40 fighting models since they are already dead(er).
 
Skeletons with spears are worth it if you meet ALL the following prerequisites;

*ahem*

- You take 40+ of them.
- You run them with Screaming banner.
- The unit must contain a Vampire with Aura of Dark Majesty and Fear Incarnate powers.
- The unit must cause terror (contains a banshee / wraith or a second Vampire with Supernatural horror, or any character with the Terror Mask of EEE!).
- There is a Mortis engine nearby.
- The unit has been buffed by some kind of spell to make them better in combat.
- You are crazy. Because you just wasted power dice and spent over 500 points on trying to make Skeletons competent, when you could have gotten ~35 Grave Guard with Great Weapons and Banner of the Barrows instead for the same price or less.
 
grave guard are good but you need core. and ghouls have no chance of a save or full command. i personally like ghouls but without a regen save of some sort they fall as well. but that is the purpose of core. to die while you get you hammer units into the fray
 
Short answer. No. But I feel that way about skeletons in general. The limiting factor for our tarpits is wounds. 6+ parry very rarely factors highly in combat and WS 2 Str 3 attacks are next to useless. Zobies are bought far cheaper per wound and are only marginaly worse in combat. The only viable use for skeletons I have ever heard of is fear bombing.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu