emil_fh said:I would not say spears are worse in all occasions, pointcost same, only thing that differ in benefit of hw&s is the parrysave, if you are using mortis engine you get a 6+ regen, which does not stack with parrysave. Therefore the parrysave becomes almost redundat, not quite since a ward is better than regen (flaming, killing blow).
EDIT: forgot that parry are only for close combat to the front, and not vs stomp, and that killing blow, does not really matter unless multiwound and/or high armour save, thank you mortis engine-thread =)
Therefore if you run one, or even two mortis engine, a deep formation with spears are better than hw&s IMO.
Vengeance Crusader said:Just to throw in my lot here...
I have 70 skeletons, 10 with spears, and the rest with hand weapons, so when I want to field a unit with the spears, I put them on the front, and then fill out the rest of the unit (up to usually 30-40) with the others, so I have had a good mix of experiences with using both...
Spears seem to take too much of an investment to make work in terms of getting them to kill stuff, e.g. Mortis Engine, augments etc. I've always found that I could have spent the points better elsewhere...
emil_fh said:Vengeance Crusader said:Just to throw in my lot here...
I have 70 skeletons, 10 with spears, and the rest with hand weapons, so when I want to field a unit with the spears, I put them on the front, and then fill out the rest of the unit (up to usually 30-40) with the others, so I have had a good mix of experiences with using both...
Spears seem to take too much of an investment to make work in terms of getting them to kill stuff, e.g. Mortis Engine, augments etc. I've always found that I could have spent the points better elsewhere...
But with the new book spears are no additional pointcost!