Skeletons, Zombies, or Ghouls?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

What is your preferred infantry core choice?

  • Predominantly Skeletons

    Votes: 62 47.3%
  • Predominantly Zombies

    Votes: 6 4.6%
  • Predominantly Ghouls

    Votes: 36 27.5%
  • Predominantly a Mix

    Votes: 27 20.6%

  • Total voters
    131
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.

The Voice

Zombie
Nov 9, 2008
8
Zombies
28
I've personally always been a zombie man. I was just wondering what other people thought.

I figure that what I want from my core choices are "anchors". My army works on the basis of locking down their units in combats with my undying zombie hordes, whilst my knights and Varghulfs patiently position themselves to charge up along the flanks. Zombies are best for this because they're cheap, and easably raisable. They also have the extra bonus of being easier to make new units of, especially when I have the models already...

I've never liked the idea of skeletons because they seem to spend too much points on trying to be decent soldiers - which they'll never really be. Ghouls I haven't really tried out with the new edition. They're also double the points of zombies, which I think puts zombies ahead on the survivability front, even with a toughness increase of 2 to 4. A case could be made for Ghouls actually being decent in a fight, though.

So what do people think?
 
I would only ever pay points for Zombies if I needed to fill the compulsory Core slots cheaply. They don't stand up well as a tarpit (far too fragile) and they can't capitalise on auto-breaking enemies (pursuing and consuming an enemy unit and character is the demoralising thing about Fear and it's the demoralisation that wins me games). Skeletons are a more survivable source of static CR (it's the armour save and the slightly less insulting statline that does it) and Ghouls are better fighters by any measure.
 
I'm not convinced that skeletons are tougher than zombies. Though I admit it's close. +1 toughness and 4+ armour save, compared to half the cost, and easier to raise back. I think zombies are just ahead. Though half the cost and 4+ armour save should have the same effect (I think that works out on average but that might be flawed logic) in reality lots of stuff gets rid of armour, so it doesn't work out that way. Plus it's only a 5+ save against shooting. And you do get four extra zombies every time you raise compared to skellies...

I guess I come from a different perspective because I don't use my infantry to win combats. I just use them as basically what swarms used to be - tying stuff down so the flank charge can begin. Maybe skellies are better for their points at winning combats on their own than zombies are. But I still reckon zombies are ahead on durability for points.
 
The problem is with using zombies to anchor and enemy in place and then hit them with something nasty. Hitting an enemy while he has zombies to kill is a really really bad idea. You kill some and get a flank. He kills LOTS of zombies and wins combat thanks to slaughtering zombies.
 
Imagine if we had the ability to 'release' units from their raised state. The vampire raises his block of zombies, ensnaring the enemy in the grasping limbs. He charges in at the head of his knights, then simply lets the zombies drop dead in the magic phase, removing them before combat.

I prefer ghouls, as I tend to get lucky with 6s. My dice seem to roll a mix of 1s,2s and 6s. So I either miss anyway or don't have to wound. Also, I manage to get the charge often, as my opponents disregard the smaller ghoul blocks, and 12 attacks with poison can usually drop more than the banner and armour would save anyway.
 
The Voice said:
... Though I admit it's close. +1 toughness and 4+ armour save, compared to half the cost, and easier to raise back. I think zombies are just ahead. Though half the cost and 4+ armour save should have the same effect...

I always played skeletons with 5+ armour save (light armour and shield)?

I vote for the mix because I'm new to the game and still trying and learning :idea:
 
I tend to go out mostly with skeletons. True, every core choice has its uses. However, I find that when I need Zombies to tarpit something, I can as well raise them during the game - which I do anyway to block line of sight of enemy war machines.

Between ghouls and skeleton - tough choice. Both are pretty good. Skeletons can get a better static CR by 1 - 2 (Magic banner), which I like more than to rely on my dice. So on 1999- games, its almost skeletons only for me.
At 2k, I include one small goul unit, just in case I realy need killing power to bring something unbreakable down (like Slayers or Flaggelants, which are also bad fighters, against ghouls, that is).
 
The Voice said:
I'm not convinced that skeletons are tougher than zombies. Though I admit it's close. +1 toughness and 4+ armour save, compared to half the cost, and easier to raise back. I think zombies are just ahead. Though half the cost and 4+ armour save should have the same effect (I think that works out on average but that might be flawed logic) in reality lots of stuff gets rid of armour, so it doesn't work out that way. Plus it's only a 5+ save against shooting. And you do get four extra zombies every time you raise compared to skellies...

But if the supposed 'tarpit' has been wiped out on account of its inferior T and no save generating more wounds, thus more CR against them, and the unit that charged them has overrun into the unit I was trying to protect, it has completely failed in its duty.

They're easier to raise, but I hardly ever get to raise them back, because they're usually dead by the time my next magic phase rolls around.
 
dabber said:
The problem is with using zombies to anchor and enemy in place and then hit them with something nasty. Hitting an enemy while he has zombies to kill is a really really bad idea. You kill some and get a flank. He kills LOTS of zombies and wins combat thanks to slaughtering zombies.

That's a very good point. It would be a shame if my knights were to charge a unit and promptly explode if zombies were pinning them down. It's never lost me a game, but it has made me have to be careful...

Hmm, I may switch to ghouls. It suits my fluff, and they are a lot tougher... but still, I'll miss the +4 to raising... and I don't like the new ghoul models so much... though they have grown on me.

Hmm.
 
werner said:
The Voice said:
... Though I admit it's close. +1 toughness and 4+ armour save, compared to half the cost, and easier to raise back. I think zombies are just ahead. Though half the cost and 4+ armour save should have the same effect...

I always played skeletons with 5+ armour save (light armour and shield)?

I vote for the mix because I'm new to the game and still trying and learning :idea:

4+ armour save or 5+ armour save, I'm curious :|
 
Assuming they are not fighting with spears it is 4+. If the skeleton warriors use hand weapon and shield, this grants an additional +1 AS bonus against attacks from the front of the unit. Does not apply for flank/rear.

All models on foot with hand weapon & shield benefit from this, unless they have a magic weapon.
 
Yeah sorry, I should have made that clear.

I've sort of changed my mind about agreeing zombies aren't very good. :P And this is why:

1. An enemy unit is either powerful or it is not powerful.
2. If it is not powerful then even with zombies having lower statistics, the flank charge from your powerful flankers such as knights or varghulfs will still break them. Plus, with more zombies, even with them killing more, you are more likely to still have ranks and the golden outnumbering bonus (which may even cancel out how many zombies they kill)
3. If it is powerful then there's a good chance they'll kill swathes of your infantry whatever. The armour save of skeletons will be weakened considerably. In my case, I often play someone with chaos knights. They would need 3s then 2s against zombies and skeletons (ghouls have a slight advantage but not enough to justify double points). So the problem of them killing lots of zombies would be a problem for any infantry unit anyway.

Consequently, the problem of zombies contributing to your enemy's combat resolution is not overly serious, or something that would happen if you had any infantry block.
 
I just played against demons, and a unit (20 zombies w/ full command) tanked a skulltaker w/ juggernaught for 3 turns.. =) D6 +4 is nice.
 
I find that having a mixed bag of units is the best way to go. In 2k I run two ten man skelly units, one 10 man Ghoul unit and usually raise a unit of zombies. In the first couple turns I raise my units up to strength. People ussually let me get away with a lot of ION in turn 1 and 2 cause they are caving their DD for all the nasty offensive spells they think are coming. so my total core units only cost 288 points without any magic banners. I usually throw in the dead legion banner if I can. so I have plenty of points for the hard hitting stuff.
 
I think it's probably better to take Skellies and Ghouls in the army list proper. You can't make new units of skellies or ghouls, so I think a better idea would be to take what you need of those from the start, then raise zombie units as needed.

I use zombies for the main list only if I have to get up to my minimum amount of core units and I don't feel like taking a unit of 10 ghouls. For 80 points, I think 20 zombies can work better, even if ghouls do have 2 poisoned attacks.
 
Skellies ALL THE WAY !! :D
Seriously I have never liked the idea magic of depending on my magic to keep those unamored ghouls around. Skellies are a good mix of Armour and toughness though that WS can cause screaming fits. I have tried ghouls and they performed well. I killed a treeman with them !! :mrgreen:
I just have a problem rolling around with no save at all on my core units.
 
My personal favorite is skellies, though I find more and more ghouls are sneaking into my lists lately. My one beef with lil skellies is that while they can pin enemy units in combat like no tomorrow, they seldom win combat. I love tar-pitting, but I also like to take down enemies. Since my Vargulfs and Black Knights and whatnot are off being glory hogs and rampaging around the enemy deployment zone, I find ghouls make decent hammer units to the skellies' anvil. Having a full unit of Ghouls in the same combat also lets you slack on raising skellies for a bit as you'll get your rank and outnumber CR bonuses from the fresh ghoul unit- the skellies just have to keep that banner waving.

I don't think skellies would do well without someone to save them from inevitable loss, and ghouls really cannot take charges to well, so I'll vote for mix- the skellies in the center prancing about luring enemy units into charging them and being bogged down, and the ghouls on the flanks ready to catch the pinned enemy unit and eat them.
 
zombies ftw use always strike first from corpse cart and you should have two because one will always get dispelled and give them weapon skill 7 with the helm on a vampire lets see something try to kill a lot of zombies when they hit on 5's
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu