Skeletons, Zombies, or Ghouls?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

What is your preferred infantry core choice?

  • Predominantly Skeletons

    Votes: 62 47.3%
  • Predominantly Zombies

    Votes: 6 4.6%
  • Predominantly Ghouls

    Votes: 36 27.5%
  • Predominantly a Mix

    Votes: 27 20.6%

  • Total voters
    131
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.
Personally I always use Ghouls, I don’t bother with Skeletons. I only have zombies on the table when I raise them.

With two poison attacks and a great toughness they stick around. Those poisoned attacks tend to wear down an opponent. As you just raise more ghouls lost due to combat or CR causalities they can be used (and I have used them many times this way) as a tar pit as well.

Also on the plus side poison attacks are great against units with a high toughness, taking down large creatures in a snarling pack of tooth and claw.
 
Im a Ghoul boy. Not just because Have 80 ghoul models. I think the toughness 4 is what seals the deal for me. Since they have poison, and Corpse cart ASF to augment them, without the better CR skel's offer, its only a matter of time till ghouls win a CR, and hopfuly you out #, and auto break.
 
Skeletons all the way. It's true ghouls are overall better (with ghoulkin and a VDM you can charge in 2nd turn -1st if the enemy went first and advanced his troops!!) but I prefer the look of an all-boney army. To me its fluffier and looks better.
 
If I'm playing a IoN magic army I take either skelletons or ghouls. I prefer ghouls, but I'm still buying the units.

If I'm having less than 8 power dice I prefer to mix all three, skeletons for CR, a small detachment of ghouls for countercharge an a unit of zombies for tarpiting. However, I tend to play with 9-10 power dice, so my vote goes for the ghouls.
 
I also prefer the rules for ghouls, though I use the models for skeletons and a few grave guard to represent them in my ghost army.

Painted green, some cotton fog on the bases and voila! Ghosts! xD
 
Skeletons all the way :D

Personally I think making Ghouls r&f was a mistake... too viable, even though without options for standard or musician. Ghoulkin, T4, poison and 2 A's make up for that.
 
If you fight someone with Zombies to the front, and then flank charge the opposing unit, and you manage to break it, then it will flee away from your Zombies, which means that you won't get to pursue them, therefore not killing them and not being able to overrun into the next unit.
 
Correct me if I am wrong, for I am still learning, but I thought any unit got the option to pursue that was involved in the combat as long as they aren't in another combat as well?
 
Cromenon said:
Zombies don't pursue. They do a d6 worth of st2 hits for every full rank the unit has instead.

Sorry, I knew that part, its just when he said
then it will flee away from your Zombies, which means that you won't get to pursue them,

after he mentioned flanking them. I thought flanking units could pursue?
 
I bring a mix, as they each have their roles. Skellies have decent defence (with 4+ AS) and can add 2 more static CR (via magic banner).

Ghouls get the nice initiative grabbing ghoulkin march move, and the T4 is decent defence all by itself, and of course poison just does wonders against some troops.

I bring a block of zombies, too, as a) they are cheap, and b) it gives me a good sized tarpit block that I dont have to spend magic dice raising, and can easily increase in size. But this unit is usually just to distract some unit of the enemies, because as others have pointed out, they are too fragile to be a good tarpit that holds units in place for the flank charge. They give way too much combat res through dying.

So skellies for holding units up, ghouls for killing the right enemy units, and zombies just to give a meaty block for my opponent to waste his time/shots/spells on.
 
I tend to go for a mix. Take atleast 2 units of 20 zombies for sure, people say not to and just raise 'em during the game, but of course with magic there's always the dreadfull chance of it not going in your favor, so I take them for a "for sure" wall of meatshields.
Skeletons are a no brainer since you will probably need atleast some decent fighters.
I myself dread taking ghouls, they just dont fit into my ideal picture of my army, fluff-wise, yet I still take them for their tactical use, take them in units of no less than 20.
 
squigsinahole said:
zombies ftw use always strike first from corpse cart and you should have two because one will always get dispelled and give them weapon skill 7 with the helm on a vampire lets see something try to kill a lot of zombies when they hit on 5's

Even with the ASF rule the zombies still go last I believe. I don't have my rulebook on me but I recall reading that.

WS 7 zombies is always fun, but most non-core units are still hitting on 4s (improvement from 3s). You don't want to get zombies in contact with core units anyways.

I use a mix of 2 skele blocks and 1 zombie block in 2250s. Always aim the zombies for powerful low attack units like White Lions etc. (roommate loves their fluff).

One thing I did not realize or think of was that you can give your skele's spears and in the beginning of engaging in combat they get to chose 1 extra rank of attacks or +1 AS, neat!!:O
 
Personally I take small units of ghouls, and almost always take at least one vamp with Summon Ghouls and pump them on the way across the board.
 
Scjar said:
Correct me if I am wrong, for I am still learning, but I thought any unit got the option to pursue that was involved in the combat as long as they aren't in another combat as well?

I would like to have this answered as well. Can a flank charging unit pursue, if the enemy breaks and flees from one of your units, engaged with the enemy to the front?
 
Chobber said:
Scjar said:
Correct me if I am wrong, for I am still learning, but I thought any unit got the option to pursue that was involved in the combat as long as they aren't in another combat as well?

I would like to have this answered as well. Can a flank charging unit pursue, if the enemy breaks and flees from one of your units, engaged with the enemy to the front?

Not sure I understand the question. Units do not panic anymore once they are in combat (if subsequently charged in the flank/rear), so you must be talking about if a unit breaks while already engaed to the front and side/rear. Sure, both the front and side unit have the ability to pursue. Why would you think otherwise?
 
okay well normaly i would take only skeletons but I had to play against a VC player in the last tournament i played in and i saw how effective ghouls are so iam going to be taking them over the skeleton units they do coast a little more but they are nastywith a vampire hiding in them.

WOOT 800th post =)
 
Nice Josef

Chobber said:
I would like to have this answered as well. Can a flank charging unit pursue, if the enemy breaks and flees from one of your units, engaged with the enemy to the front?
Scjar said:
Correct me if I am wrong, for I am still learning, but I thought any unit got the option to pursue that was involved in the combat as long as they aren't in another combat as well?

Teehee! I foundz it. Look on page 44 of the BRB. It explains with a nice header that multiple pursuers are possible. In fact, you need to roll a Ld-test to restrain units if you want to.

I'm not sure if you can restrain with Undead - thought you always had to pursue (again, not sure on this). Though if it is, :lol:, good luck rolling a 2 with 2D6 and a Ld of 3 (skeletons for example).

Keep in mind that Zombies have the Shambling Horde special rule, meaning they'll never pursue (page 42 BRB)
 
Cromenon said:
We can restrain for pursuing, being ItP doesn't mean we cannot roll Ld-based tests! :lol:

BRB said:
(...)
Troops that are ItP automatically pass all their Panic, Fear and Terror tests and are not automatically broken if defeated in combat by outnumbering Fear-causing enemies, by take the Break test as normal.

Troops that are ItP may never flee as a charge reaction (...)

o_o

The rest is fluff reasoning. Page 53 of the BRB. It doesn't say they automatically pass all Ld-based rolls... just those three. I can remember the old book saying they pass all Ld-based tests, but apparantly not this edition.

So I still don't know... but it ain't under ItP.
 
Chobber said:
Scjar said:
Correct me if I am wrong, for I am still learning, but I thought any unit got the option to pursue that was involved in the combat as long as they aren't in another combat as well?

I would like to have this answered as well. Can a flank charging unit pursue, if the enemy breaks and flees from one of your units, engaged with the enemy to the front?
Not if the flank charging unit is Zombies. Otherwise, yes.
 
I like starting with one unit of zombies but only use them as a screen. One rank 20 to 40 wide depending on size of game. Screen advances being healed back by the magic users behind it. When you get close to the enemy reform the unit to open avenues for charge dance. I use skelatons as actual "fighty" units. Normally setup to win via CR with banners and a vamp. My normal core is one unit of zombie and 2 skelatons.

RicW
 
I am only new to VC and fantasy but to me it seems easier to have Ghouls the hardcore of the core units and just raise zombies, then you get them for free.
 
Correct they're free (for 50 victory pts) but if you've bad luck with magic or quickly killed so you hadn't the time to raise more...
 
Exactly, If you go to the battle reports section there is a great report on VC vs. wood elves. At 2500 points he starts with 2 lines of 40 zombies and the wood elves are decimating something like 38 models a turn just in their shooting phase. Nobody has that many powerdice. I would rather start with a unit of zombie and keep it healed then try to summon and replenish up to fighting size..
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu