Skellies vs Ghouls

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.

Lord Acheron

Zombie
Sep 12, 2009
8
Zombies
15
So, I'm quite new to the Vampires.

I've had a look-see and ghouls and skellies seem about even - points-wise they're identical, the ghouls have an extra attack and poison, skellies get armor.

So, which is better? Or, perhaps to poise the question better, which situation calls for what type? Do you field armies of just skellies, just ghouls or mixed? Should there be differences in the numbers/ranks?

If you could fill me in, that would be great.
 
I would go Ghouls every time, overall they are a tougher unit.

In my 2000 point lists, I usually have 3 units of 16/17 Ghouls, each with a hero.

It really depends how you want to play I guess, Skeletons get a full command group if you want it, with banners but banners tend to eat into the total points. If you run with skeletons in a 2k list, you generally have to raise a lot, Ghouls tend to hang on longer in battle.
 
i find its about even. ghouls are more offensive and skellies are more defensive.

personnally i play skeletons myself mostly for looks, i despise the plastic ghouls minis.

i take full command and hand weapon n shield combo, 6 wide. +4 combat res with 7 attacks (usually ASF with corpsecart locally) and usually outnumber by combat happens is generally all i need. if i don't break them first turn just raise a zombie unit on their flank or rear and they are gonners next turn. same applies to ghouls but your more likely to win combats through causing wounds than combat res. i find skellies to be a bit more survivable with 4+ save in combat, against mundane troops your still saving alot of wounds wheras ghouls just drop like flies IMO.
 
I'm guilty of sometimes deferring to Skellies because they rank up more easily than Ghouls. :rolleyes:

God, the new Ghouls are frustrating. Sweet looking but horribly impractical. I think in friendly games I'm just going to start fielding one front rank of models and then filling in the rear ranks with bases.
 
i go with skells because it fits more with my theme of a martial host of undead ghouls go better with strigois and nechs in my opinion
 
Question for the forum mods:

I notice that threadomancy is highly discouraged, but also that sometimes posters are directed towards old threads instead of rehashing past discussions. What's the deal?
 
With hundreds and hundreds of threads it becomes increasingly hard to navigate the forum. New threads push old ones back and while this is just fine (it's what the forum is for after all), new threads discussing the exact same topic is best if avoided.

Also it is better to gather all information about a specific topic in one place rather than spreading it out. Besides... Instead of having people asking the same questions for the umpteenth time, we want to direct them to a place they can get a proper answer without having to ask -When stuff comes for free you shouldn't have to pay for it if you know what I mean...

About the threadomancy: It should be OK to reply to an old thread if you have some relevant and new content that hasn't been said before (though this would rarely apply to the artistic parts of the forum (painting and writing)). Though in most cases you should just leave the thread alone.
 
At the risk of getting theis thread locked for both threadomancy and going off topic, I just wanted to thank Shadowfax for raising a very annoying problem with the site, one which I am sure that many of us have thought about but have never bothered to raise (including me). I am not satisfied by your answer Dark Sheep.

I have raised this matter in the Fresh Blood Member Suggestions thread where I think it is more appropriate.

cheers
 
Lofnazareth,

TDS's reply was as per the instructions I provided. However I can understand your point that perhaps it was unclear as it was not clarified in the forum rules.

The forum rules have been updated as per your post in the suggestion thread.

However for future reference if anyone does have an issue with a moderator decision or forum rules, please PM the moderator or myself.

If there anymore queries please PM me

Cheers

Disciple of Nagash
~Carpe Noctem Admin

NB: As this thread has gone off topic and we have two other threads as noted by TDS, this one will now be locked. DoN
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu