Dreadgrass said:
Okay so, I'm taking up your challenge.
I've got a mate who has the Tamurkhan book (Sourcebook containing the CD list in question) which I've borrowed off him this afternoon.
As I don't have the Dwarf book and have little experience with them, and as the new books haven't really released a similar army as yet, I'll compare the army to Warriors of Chaos.
Well, as I have the book... and my roommate has a full chaos dwarf army on which I face on a normal basis, I'll go ahead and take your challenge here. =P
SO, at first glance:
Prophet/ Socerer - more toughness and LD than a Sorcerer lord, but less magic potential and a built in miscast hit. Potentially more suited to being a warrior-mage. Handy utility in supporting warmachines, and daemonweapon, though their random nature can leave them a bit lack-lustre if you expect too much. Taurus are decent, probably on par with recent ridden gribblies.
I don't find anything wrong with the character itself. It's the magic lore that is stupid good. Have you read it? Out of the 7 spells they have, 3 of them are good, and 2 of them are the most overpowered thing I've ever seen. Ash storm and Flames of Azgorth are stupid. Ash storm is easily the single most broken spell in the game, and flames of azgorth is the strongest template spell to boot! I find the lore that these guys can take is stupid good, not the character itself.
Heroes - Daemonsmiths are pretty much in the same boat as Prophets, except without the Toughness boost. Castellans are good for coming with stubborn, so a BSB seems pretty much mandatory WoC Exalted have the advantage in pure combat stats save for the Castellans Toughness 5. A mounted Exalted also has the advantage in offense against the Bull centaur hero but he makes up for it somewhat with 4 wounds. His pricetag is similar to an exalted on daemonic mount though... Hobgoblin khans are... well... goblin heros. Best use I've heard mentioned is as re-directors/ annoyances or warmachine hunters.
You forgot the bull centaur character. The daemonsmiths have an ability that lets the warmachines reroll a single die in the shooting phase. This gets rid of half of the bad mishaps with the misfiring and I'd doubt you'd see him missfire a machine all game. The Castellen coming with stubborn is really quite good, but I do feel this guy is a few points over priced. The bull centaur character comes with 75 points of magic items instead of 50. You can really deck this guy out and throw him in the bull centaurs for some good damage.
Core - Infernal Guard - Pretty much considerably weaker Chaos warriors for a slightly lesser points cost. There missile options are interesting though with either a mass of Strength 3 shots with Blunderbusses or fireglaives, whish are essentially a halberd and handgun combined. Both shooting options raise the models points cost considerably.
The blunderbusses are worth the cost. Once you have a unit of 25 roll triple shots on you, and reroll their to wound and watch entire units evaporate I'm sure you'll see the same. You comparing these core guys to warriors isn't really the same. They're dwarfs and I know you said you don't have the dwarf book, but you should be comparing it to the dwarfs. An infernal guard has a point cost of a dwarf longbeard with a shield. What you're looking at differences stat wise are that longbeards don't panic, but infernal guard come inherently with a 3+ armour save (and a 5+ against fire, but meh). They're pretty much the exact same points cost for different bonuses. These guys are where they should be, not underpriced at all.
Hobgoblins - Well, they're goblins. I could compare them to Marauders (and they're similar in points too) but we all know how that'd end up. They can take bows though if you wanted more weight of strength 3 shooting...?
and thats it for core options. So no cheap re-directors or utility units to fill out your list.
True on the hobgoblins. They're just goblins. But this is something that dwarfs don't have the option of taking. It's half the points of the cheapest troop in the dwarf book, and these guys still have some uses.
Special - Ironsworn - Elite sword and board infantry. Strength 5 is nice coupled with a 3+ save but still only 1 attack each and Initiative 2.
These guys are priced fine, in my opinion. They're basically ironbreakers. Ironbreakers are 4 points less a model, but they don't have +1 strength and they also don't have magical attacks (which is a bigger deal than you would believe).
Bull Centaurs - 2 attacks 3+ save monstrous beasts with weapon options. Again, compared to a Chaos Knight the Centaur has more toughness/ wounds, the knight more killing power. Kind of a Dragon Ogre's little brother.
These guys are right where they should be points wise. They're tough sons of bitches to kill and I've seen them go up against chaos knights many a time and about 50% of the time come out on top. I wouldn't underestimate these guys at all.
Fireborn - More big tough beasties. This time Monstrous infantry. 2 attacks each but their flaming aura makes them better offensively then they look. I'd probably put them on a similar footing to equal points in trolls (slightly better, but also slightly more expensive) Oh, and they're essentially undead (Unbreakable/ crumble) and also have a crumble type effect that has them potentially take D3 wounds per turn.
You're discounting too much on these guys. A few things you have to look at here in terms of fighting them. -1 to wound if not magical attacks. This means that strength 3 needs 6s to even hurt it, strength 4 needs 5s, and so on. And if you do manage to get a wound through the entire unit has a 4+ ward save! I personally don't find anything wrong with the points for this as they are.
Magma Cannon - Strength 5, D3 wound flame template with 24" range. A good horde thinner and undoubtedly effective against trolls/ ogres.
I don't believe these are over priced either, they're hefty but preform well and can be given magical shots for pesky ethereals. Solid warmachine.
Deathshrieker - accurate Strength 3 template or single hit S8 D6 wounds shell.
This thing is a stupid cost for what it could do. Strength 3 LARGE round template, or a strength 8 shot that does D6 wounds. This thing is so multipurpose it's crazy. The first shot is amazing at wiping out troops and the big shot? Forget about any monsters you have. Try facing three of these. They're only the same points as a corpse cart and +10 more points chucked on!
Iron Daemon - Real hard to kill, Impact hits and Thunderstomp are about the extent of its combat potential (repeating chariot?) cannonade for a Strength 6 blunderbuss type attack or shell out the extra points to up its impact/ stomps to 2D6 for pure combat.
this thing is way overpriced. The one bad thing in the army. It can only charge in a straight line, this needs faq'd pretty badly.
Rare - Wolf riders - yep, if you want chaff/ redirectors you've got to pay out of your rare allowance for them! Good idea I thought to limit the mobility options for a dwarven army. Also means a max of 2 units...
These guys are much better than you would think. imo every player should have 2 units of 5. that's only 60 skaven slaves worth of points and well worth it. And like you said, it's something dwarfs have no option of doing.
Dreadquake Mortar - Very pricy, but powerful stone thrower. High strength (think Hell cannon/ Trebuchet) and makes units take dangerous terrain tests if they move after being shelled.
Pricy sure, but damned hard to kill. Give it an ogre, make it hellbound, and any warmachine hunters you had will get squashed. It's not bad to deal with though, and imo the points are actually a little high on this.
Destroyer - I think he's the whole reason the book gets a bad name tbh. I think it's a case of piling too much stuff onto a single model. He is incredibly pointsy though and an opponent with the right tools could earn some quick VP's with a little luck. Also, make sure your opponent takes those Toughness tests each turn! a 1/6 chance of taking D3 wounds without you lifting a finger is always worth the roll!
Alright... Here's where we have to talk. Lets look at this thing from the top. It's movement is 9. That's quite a charge range and you can sure as hell bet he's going to charge this thing into your best units. It's weaponskill 5, so he'll be hitting pretty most troops on a 3. Strength 7, this is pretty high for monsters. Any character you have or knights should probably hide as this will womp on them. Toughness 6 with 6 wounds is pretty standard for new monsters, but is still damn hard to take down. Here's one thing that really gets me... initiative 5. Are you kidding me? You mean I can't drop it in a pit? It has 6 attacks with a possibly of 9 after adding its frenzy. Large amount of attacks for this guy, more than most monsters. Everything that is touching him takes a strength 4 flaming hit at the beginning of the fight. that's at LEAST 5 hits against everything except for ogres because of how big this base is. It has a 4+ ward save. Seriously, a 4+ wardsave on this beast. All of this I could deal with if it wasn't for this little fact. -1 to wound if your attacks aren't magical. I can't believe this! Do you know what this means? Any unit that is strength 4 and under CANNOT WOUND IT! Strength 5 needs 6s to wound it! strength 6 needs 5s! this is crazy! This guy shouldn't exist at all, and I don't understand WHAT they were thinking when they made him (probably something like making money).
Hellcannon - as per WoC
SO on the whole compared to WoC I feel so far that CD's have less potential in the Movement, Magic and combat phases, but can compete well in the shooting phase. They're tough, and have some good units, but they're an small/ elite/ compact army.
The only unit in this army I would be unhappy to see hit the table is the Destroyer, I'd put him in the same boat as the skaven Abomb, possibly even a shade nastier depending on the opponent.
Please feel free to point out any other units you feel are unfair/ unbalanced. I'm trying to make a relatively unbiased comparison to give the OP an idea what to expect.
What you should be looking at is the fact that these are dwarfs. They can do all the same things as dwarfs except they're better at half of it. Not only that, but they're dwarfs with the 2 best spells in the game and the best monster in the game as well (not talking about storm of magic because... well that doesn't really see much tournament play). It's like GW decided to take dwarfs (which are already quite good in this edition) and give them magic and monsters!