So how is the new book Performing?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I'll do my best to derail this thread further.

Lore of Light = dirty tactics for TK? That's the dumbest thing I've read in a while. Is it legal? Yes. Then it's ok. TK need all help they can get. In my game at friday I faced a lvl 4 Hierophant, lvl 4 Lore of Light, lvl 2, Casket of Souls, Hierotitan. A pretty bad-ass magic phase in other words. But still not enough to win games.
I had a lvl 4, no scroll.

I'd rate them as the bottom of the 8th ed books, and that seems to be the majority opinion among competitive players too. http://warhammer.org.uk/phpBB/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=97951 In ETC, TK are allowed 200 extra points in their armies AND all victory points scored against TK are decreased by 10%. Think about that for a while...

TK lost their unique Incantations which were unstoppable due to sheer output and gave them a unique playstyle that took many off guard. The had the infamous 'The Phase' were they popped a few one-use items and burned through all magic defense to get a crucial magical charge off.
Now they play like everyone else *yawn*.
Catapults are heavily nerfed, they lost Icon of Rakaph, Scorpions are nerfed, can't heal characters, slow units, new monsters can't fight and pay premium for T8 when even S2 units can hurt them, Fear was nerfed in 8th ed and the list goes on. I think their magic lore lost the extra shots for catapults too.
Chariots were buffed. Tomb Guards are decent. The Curse is nerfed. Casket is nerfed (not an addition to your magic output anymore, instead it eats from your pool. Only affects one unit).

For me, playing against TK, the main thing is that they lost magical charges. It's not as bad for VC as we aren't short on fast, heavy hitters that can charge without Vanhels and we have better anvil units that can recieve a charge. Playing against TK before was always like a tough chess match, trying to predict were units would be and how things would work out in advance due to their Incantations. Now it feels like I can ease-mode against them. I feel sorry for a club mate who plays them, he's kind of bummed out and thinks about going back to WoC for tournaments.
 
Well that stinks for them, I have a friend that wants to play TK this us not good for him. I would be interested in how you do against other armies NIB
 
mate im not looking for a scrap so theres no need to insult me :) (and it is dirty tactics regardless of what you say , because that way it is not a balanced list, if u enter tournaments then u should know that u should have a balanced list and not pick the lore that u know ur going to win with because i know that if i was using my dwarfs that guy would not pick lore of light)
and that guy does throw 6 dice everytime but it kills like 3 graveguard a turn if that, and then it doesnt really kill anything else. Hes not bad, he just has really bad luck tbh, and he prefers augmenting his troops and not trying to kill mine as much. The guy has a hierotitan but that still doesnt help him much.
 
I still don't understand how choosing the lore of light is dirty... It's a lore in the main book, with good buffs for your units, useful in just about every circumstance. It isn't exactly my cup of tea, but there's nothing dirty about it.
 
It's because of the lore attribute being especially deadly to undead. Picking the lore of light specifically because he is going up against undead is often considered a dirty tactic. Similar to not taking any wizards against Dwarfs so they waste their magic defence, or only ever taking the lore of metal against WoC.

It depends on the culture of the gaming group. If they make lists specific to the army they will be playing or "all comers" lists.
 
Aramoro said:
morewar said:
-we can heal characters
-we can heal vampires, ethereals and large targets better than they can constructs(we can 1 wound per spell+attribute, they get 1 wound per phase)
-we can expand 2 of our units beyond their starting size
-our grave guard are better than tomb guard:
same price, we pay 1pts for +2 strengh, they pay 2 pts for +1 strengh. True we get ASL, but at I3, it makes no difference.
they get tomb kings to boost their WS, but we get +1 to hit for A LOT cheaper, which works better in combination with our fear banner.
-we have no shooting, but we are sooooo much faster: we can march+vanhel's
-we do better healing
-vanhel's is better than my will be done
-hellish vigour is better than the KB spell
-we have access to all the lores (exept life)+vampires, so we can fix most of our weakneses in our lists
-we have corpse carts
-crypt horrors are sooo much better than ushabti for sooo much cheaper
-crumble is the only problem that really carries over

Half the things you listed do not work against Tomb Kings or do not matter against them, which is why it's a hard match up. Yes Tomb Guard are only I3, but that's plenty fighting against Vampire Counts. They're immune to Fear, they have Lore of Light, Casket of Souls

I think you're overselling the Vampire Counts stuff badly, the books are pretty even generally with Tomb Kings having the advantage in the match up.

IF you had read my one of my replies earlier in this thread, you would have seen how as a TK player i give them the upper hand in this matchup. But its the only matchup where TK is dominant. The TK are clearly a testing draft for the VC and a try-out for a inexpirienced author :mad2: .
 
The Dead of Night said:
It's because of the lore attribute being especially deadly to undead. Picking the lore of light specifically because he is going up against undead is often considered a dirty tactic. Similar to not taking any wizards against Dwarfs so they waste their magic defence, or only ever taking the lore of metal against WoC.

It depends on the culture of the gaming group. If they make lists specific to the army they will be playing or "all comers" lists.

Thank You The Dead of Night, it is considered bad to be doing that, and in fact in our local store everyone are encouraged to use a balanced list and a balanced lore (like lore of fire for example, is a good all rounder) and most of the time u have to announce what lore u are using before u even know what army ur facing, that way it is balanced and no one can use "army specific" lores. its good training in a way if u think about it, because then u actually have to think about it, whether u want a really destructive lore or a charecter killer lore or u want to mess up the strength and toughness of enemy troops. And from that point onwards people find what lore they really like and then actually enjoy using it and not just use it because its good against that specific army.

And yes the lore is balanced, i didnt say it was overpowered, its not a dirty lore, its the tactic that people use , because they only pik it when they are facing undead, i could do the same thing tbh, take lore of light against tomb kings, but then that would just be boring and pointless game, me bacing my lore against tomb kings just so i can beat them.
 
I have won three and lost four. It's a little misleading though because those 7 matches have been with 4 significantly different lists. I've been trying things out to see what works and what doesn't. I don't think there has been a single unit that has made every game. I expect to see my ratio improve once I get a list I like and really start to get a hang of the strategies.

Overall I have to say I'm very happy despite losing more than I've won. I think that some things work very well and in general we have an answer for most units the game can throw at us, though it's hard to get all those answers in a single list (which I think is ideal, a perfect list means less strategy required).
 
Vampires and tomb kings are very different armies. They're both undead, so there's a little overlap, but really. As for the direct comparison, I'm not sure it's so straight forward.

morewar said:
-we can heal characters
-we can heal vampires, ethereals and large targets better than they can constructs(we can 1 wound per spell+attribute, they get 1 wound per phase)
-we can expand 2 of our units beyond their starting size
-we do better healing
Agree, our healing's just better in general.

-our grave guard are better than tomb guard:
same price, we pay 1pts for +2 strengh, they pay 2 pts for +1 strengh. True we get ASL, but at I3, it makes no difference.
they get tomb kings to boost their WS, but we get +1 to hit for A LOT cheaper, which works better in combination with our fear banner.
Remember that if you're using both banners, then you've added a character as well, and probably not a character as effective on their own as a tomb prince or tomb king, since a BSB with a magic banner can't take other magic items, while the TK royal grants MWBD by default.

Also, remember that MWBD is both an offensive and a defensive buff. Tomb Guard with a prince or a king hit more units on threes and in return are hit by more units on fours. Barrows is the better offensive upgrade, but it doesn't grant any defensive boost.

All that said, grave guard are still better, both for the heavy armor and the great weapon access, but not by much, and tomb guard are still mighty impressive, especially in an army that can significantly weaken the other side with shooting before melee starts.

-we have no shooting, but we are sooooo much faster: we can march+vanhel's
And they have core with 8" movement plus an extra move bubble from their signature spell that is easier to cast and heals units at the same time. We're faster, yes, but not by that much, and I wouldn't say that trumps our effective abandonment of an entire phase of the game, particularly one that the tomb kings can make pretty decent use of.

-vanhel's is better than my will be done
In what universe? Vanhel's is a spell. It can be dispelled, and it's not a signature spell, so you only get one try at it, maybe two if you're running a special character or the book of arkhan, and if you're playing in a smaller game where you can't take as many casters you may not have vanhel's at all if you don't roll it. MWBD is a passive ability that's always active. The only way to shut it off is to kill the character with it, and mummies are pretty darn tough to kill. Vanhel's is good, don't get me wrong, but it's not MWBD. It's a completely different thing, I'm confused why you're even trying to compare them.

-hellish vigour is better than the KB spell
For some targets, and against some enemies. They're different spells, though. This is a slightly more sensical comparison than the above, but still.

-we have access to all the lores (exept life)+vampires, so we can fix most of our weakneses in our lists
Our lore access is much more limited than you make out. Our general must use vampires, and is generally expensive enough that we're not taking multiple Lords in most game. Army crumble hits us much harder, and is more likely to happen in the first place, and we can mitigate it by having more vampire casters, so taking other lores is more of a cost. And our core is far more reliant on casters using our native lore then tomb kings core is reliant on theirs. Sure, we technically have access to more lores, but TK have a much easier time using any of the three they have access to, while we have a hard time getting away from our native lore.

-we have corpse carts
And they have warsphinxes, necroknights, heirotitans, and the casket. We're not the same army. And if you're using our vaunted speed to it's full effect, particularly if you're moving as fast as possible to try and outrun a shooty enemy, then the corpse cart will likely be out of range of your units for 1 or 2 key turns of the game.

-crypt horrors are sooo much better than ushabti for sooo much cheaper
I'm with you here, their book was written by cruddace, and he doesn't have the best head for rules or points values. As such, our book has much better internal balance, with far fewer dud units.


That said, tomb kings have:

- better leadership
- core that can be used effectively in roles other than just 'tar pit'. Chariots and archers in particular are better core than we've got.
- warsphinxes
- more passive buffs (not just MWBD, but also regen from the heirophant, Khalida for archers and Ramhotep for necroknights), where as we most of our buffs (apart from the admittedly fantastic mortis engine) rely on the fickle winds of magic.
- they have two rare choice options that buff their magic phase, neither of which comes with the significant disadvantage of dramatically increasing the chance of a disastrous miscast roll, and neither of which lock them into a particular lore choice.

And most importantly, structural variety. We pretty much have to go magic heavy. And we have to do all our heavy lifting in the close combat phase. And our core is pretty much melee infantry only. So most of the time, the enemy will know what to expect from a vamp counts army, even if they're not sure what exact units we'll be taking. Tomb Kings can go magic heavy or light. They've got melee infantry, ranged infantry, scouting fast cav archers, and units of chariots to fill out their core. They've got significant offensive potential in magic, shooting, or melee. They may have far fewer viable units, thanks to the uneven writing of their army book, but there's a lot greater range in the types of armies they can throw together using the units they have.

Not that I think we're worse of than tomb kings. But competitively, I'm not convinced we're better off, either, even if our book was better written and has fewer lousy units. I agree completely that the vamp book had a better writer, but I think it's silly to call the tomb king book a 'testing ground' for vamps. The vamp book didn't fix any of the overarching problems with the undead ruleset in 8th edition that bother tomb kings as well, and there so little overlap in the lists that the accusation is really just absurd. Where's the better version of entombed beneath the sand in the vamp book? Where's the rule in the vamp book that lets them deal with the problems of putting a character on a chariot? Seriously, now.

We're an army that does very few things. Magic and magic-supported melee, both reliant on strong characters. Is it that odd that an army as focused as ours is is better within that focus then a generalist army like tomb kings, that has tools to function in any phase of the game?
 
thats a nice argument!:happy: Probably frustration from tomb kings forum... Well you did forget the carrion in the good units;) the thing i cant really get over is NO HEALING CHARACTERS. And constucts. one thing i dont understand is why nerf the bone giant? or you give him high toughness so he can deal with elites, or you give him a high armour save so he can deal with cheap weak units, but he has none!
 
xxSLAYERxx said:
mate im not looking for a scrap so theres no need to insult me
My apologies, and I misunderstood you, thinking you meant that TK players who grabs Lore of Light use dirty tactics.

You can't tailor against other armies in a tournament. You pick lore when you create your roster. Many TK players use Lore of Light as second lore, as it's complements Nehekara nicely.

Yes, Tomb Kings can shoot. But not enough. The nerf to catapults was really tough on them.

To be fair I haven't played much 8th ed, and the TK book might have some kind of competitive MSU build still undiscovered, but...
My gut feeling says 'Tomb Kings are picking up the 8th ed soap'.
 
N.I.B said:
xxSLAYERxx said:
mate im not looking for a scrap so theres no need to insult me
My apologies, and I misunderstood you, thinking you meant that TK players who grabs Lore of Light use dirty tactics.

You can't tailor against other armies in a tournament. You pick lore when you create your roster. Many TK players use Lore of Light as second lore, as it's complements Nehekara nicely.

Yes, Tomb Kings can shoot. But not enough. The nerf to catapults was really tough on them.

To be fair I haven't played much 8th ed, and the TK book might have some kind of competitive MSU build still undiscovered, but...
My gut feeling says 'Tomb Kings are picking up the 8th ed soap'.

My aplologies for not making myself clear, tomb kings are good and they do need lore of light yes it makes them much better against us, tbh i might even suggest to my friend to use lore of light, although i dont think he will as he prefers to use the tomb kings lore, but they do have a few positive things like shooting and the really big monsters, they are a good army i just think that it takes a very skilled general to make a good tomb kings list
 
Lore of light is a good lore for the kings. Even apart from the specific benefits against other undead, it's got some good buffs and well compliments their list.

Don't get me wrong, my impression is also that kings are on the low end of the power scale for 8th edition, at least judged against other 8th edish books (whether you count that starting at skaven, beasts, or orcs). They're a bit below orcs, and noticeably below skaven and ogres in their ability to react to enemy lists and put units on the table that force the enemy to react to them. It's still far closer then the top and bottom end of books in 7th edition - kings are nothing like as bad as 7th ed ogres. And they do have at least a few competitive lists, most noticeably among them being Khalida in a giant unit of archers with catapult and casket and sphynx and caster support. From what I hear on the kings forum, more aggressive low magic lists built on sphinxes and chariots and necroknights are also doing pretty well.

The vamp counts book IS far better written then the tomb kings book. Far better internal balance, few dud choices. I can't think of a single unit in the vamp counts army that I would never run, with the possible exception of the coach, and maybe a couple of the special characters. The tomb kings book is far worse on this front, and it has a number of points costs out of line for 8th edition (spears on skeletons should be free, ushabti are way overpriced, halberds on tomb guard are overpriced, etc).

But what they have that works, works reasonably well, and gives them a fair bit of variety to work with in terms of their overall army composition and battle strategy. More than we've got, anyway.

And Vamp counts, for all that I think our book is awesome, aren't exactly a powerhouse out of the gate. We're a melee only army that, overall, is pretty bad at melee. That's not a great starting point, frankly. Our core is just bad at fighting, and we can't support it with our elites due to the instability issue - which really damages our potential synergy overall. The march bubble reduces our deployment options, our lore is decent - essential to the proper functioning of our core in the one role of 'tar pit' they are good at - but hardly fantastic. We're shoring up our weaknesses with magic when other armies are buffing their strengths or just blasting the enemy out of existence. And while we're strong in magic, we're hardly the powerhouse we used to be. Our heroes aren't innately better at magic than anyone else's, and the enhancements on offer are either modest and overpriced (MotBA, or come with significant added risks (Mortis Engine).

So in overall power - in between book balance? I'd say we're pretty much right where the Kings are, at the bottom of the 8th edition pile. Again, that's not nearly the handicap that being at the bottom of the 7th ed pile was, but there you have it. The vampire book looks better then the tomb kings book because it is better written, but it isn't stronger.
 
yh i think i would haver to agree with u on that, our book is not as strong as it used to be, dont get me wrong its awesome, and the new minis are great but now it is much harder to make a list that works, i keep finding it difficult to use skellies against ogres for example as they just get eaten away with the impact hits and stomp, i have a couple of things up my sleeve now that ive got with the grips of the new book, but it was much more difficult to face them with the new book, but im always up for a challenge so its all good :)
 
Malisteen said:
Special characters haven't been a part of the WFB tournament scene in Europe for a long time. There are exceptions of course, but in most cases they are banned. But hey, great that you can be competitive in your garage! ;)

Malisteen said:
So in overall power - in between book balance? I'd say we're pretty much right where the Kings are, at the bottom of the 8th edition pile.
We'll have to disagree here - I'd say VC have both good internal and external balance. I'd guess we'll turn out to be mid-high tier, the coming 6 months should give us a good picture.
Hear my prophecy - Tomb Kings will be planted on the bottom of the heap until they get a new book :grave:
 
I can't help it that europeans like to play house rules in their tournaments, giving some armies larger points pools and banning this or that option and so on. I'm talking about Warhammer here, the game produced by Games Workshop.

Maybe in Houserulehammer, the things the tomb kings book can do well just aren't allowed. Maybe in Houserulehammer, the pointed weaknesses of the vampire army can't be fielded, leaving the vamps free to rampage unchecked. But if you're concerned with the balance issues of Houserulehammer, then you can't blame Cruddace for that, as he's not responsible for it in the least. You should take it up with the writers of that game, instead. I'm confused how you think that a new Warhammer army book would fix the Kings' issues in Houserulehammer when there's no guarantee that anything in a new book would be allowed in your game, anyway.

I mean, there are tomb kings builds that are doing just fine in uncomped tournaments. If the tomb kings are failing in a comped environment, I'd blame the comp, not the kings.

edit: Again, not that I think kings are strong or anything, I still think they're on the low end for 8th edition. But that just doesn't mean as much as being on the low end of 7th edition meant. At least, not for regular warhammer.

edit2: Also, I didn't say I thought vamps had bad external balance, just that I think they're on the low end of the 8th ed books we've seen so far. Those books in general all have pretty good external balance, imo, such that even the stronger 8th ed books like ogres can have competitive games with the weaker 8th ed books like Tomb Kings. Provided you aren't arbitrarily restricting the kings' better options, like their special characters and sphinxes.
 
Ok I have game night tomorrow, married 5 kids I only get to go every other friday) Anyways I'm thinking this will probably be losses 6&7, yes I am pretty pessimistic at this point. I have settled in to this list and continue to tweak it to try and get something workable.
check out the current list here, https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-2-5k-competitive-if-we-can-any-of-our-lists-can-be-called-that-comments-needed

So after another fellow who had been playing vc online, battle net or something, suggested bringing my points into a smaller number of units, this ruins against the grain for me as I don't like death stars.
 
You said VC are at the bottom of the 8th ed pile. I'd call that bad external balance, and I think you're wrong. Time will tell who's right.

Malisteen said:
there are tomb kings builds that are doing just fine in uncomped tournaments. If the tomb kings are failing in a comped environment, I'd blame the comp, not the kings. I can't help it that europeans like to play house rules in their tournaments
:lol:

WFB is not balanced. Comp/restrictions has been part of the tournament scene for a LONG time, out of necessity, so don't act all indignant. There are still Purehammer tournaments, but they get increasingly more rare.
Did you bother to read the thread I linked to? The most vocal TK mourners on TWF are americans, among those at TWF "Larro" is a multiple GT winner. Did you notice that TK actually get handicap bonuses with ETC rules? If anything, TK should do better with ETC comp. After all, it can't get much worse than the last 12 months in the US: http://www.rankingshq.com/rankings/default.aspx?GameSystemId=2&RegionId=13 hmm what's that, the only armies worse than TK are Dogs of War and Chaos Dwarfs! :lol:
Btw, from what I gather the ETC comp is getting more popular in the US too.
Far from all tournaments in Europe use ETC comp (after all it's a team game and not completely suited to a single player event), but most ban SC's. It must really hurt TK players that Kalida is the only way to compete, it speaks volumes about the TK power level. But hey, great that TK are only doing badly in Europe, because in the US were SC's are allowed EVERYWHERE they are doing just fine! Or wait...

Maybe when the full round of 8th ed armies has been released, SC's like Kairos, Thorgrim, Skulltaker and Teclis will be gone or brought into line. If that happens, they will probably be welcomed back in tournaments. ETC is constantly evolving, and I wouldn't be surprised if Kalida was allowed for balance reasons.
 
hornywingythingy said:
My first thought was two engines giving each other 3+ regens, but you can't do that unfortunatly.

What are peoples thoughts on the cursed book, at first I thought it was brilliant, now I'm really not sure, d3 power dice for a spell at quite a low level, and you have to use it before you cast anything else. I actually think a powerstone I'd better.

Read over and check the spells again.(I re-checked, got my dice out, etc...) The only time the item isn't worth it is if you roll the 1st spell(shadow) and 5/6 on the D3. All the other spells, if you roll 5/6 on the D3, are still on par with their casting value.
Of course if your factoring in a level 4 casting its not, but a level 4 also doesn't have access to 3 lores. And the spells the item has are the cream of the crop.
Basically you just thorow this item on a level 1 castor(could have a necromancer or a vampire dread knight build), you give him lore of vamps for an extra invocation of nehek spell and backup general. You get these spells off with out worry of miscasts or a failed cast.
Obviously theres some dice luck to it. If your constantly rolling 5/6 for the D3 then your boned.

xxSLAYERxx said:
yh i think i would haver to agree with u on that, our book is not as strong as it used to be, dont get me wrong its awesome, and the new minis are great but now it is much harder to make a list that works, i keep finding it difficult to use skellies against ogres for example as they just get eaten away with the impact hits and stomp, i have a couple of things up my sleeve now that ive got with the grips of the new book, but it was much more difficult to face them with the new book, but im always up for a challenge so its all good :)

The old book only had like 1 or 2 power builds. Problem was that the book didn't even have any fun builds. Take X type of list or you loose. The new book just needs a bit of time for people to find the right type of combos.

And boy are there combos!!!! The old book had combos but so many were defunct.

The whole vamp book seems to have great synergy when playing all its parts together.
Theres a few obvious combos like zombies and corpse cart.
But there are others like:(sorry I don't have my book with me so I can't remember the names of everythign).
Curesed book, Black Coach, Master of Black Arts(ensures the winds of magic doesn't foil your army build, the coach powers up faster)

Dark Acolyte + Lore of Fire + Level 4 + Mortis Engine + Ring of (firebal)
- Cast the ring of fireball first, typically your opponent lets this low level magic missile spell go off cause its not too powerful. Then you get lore of fires D3 extra casting, dark acolytes D3 extra casting, base level 4, Mortis Engines +2. With all this extra you could almost thro 2 dice at any fire spell and it will go off.

Obviously mortis engine + regenerate units.

I've also Noticed that alot of vamp stuff stacks with many BRB items.
Wright King with +2/+3 attack sword
Mortis Engine + Seed of Regrowth(6+ regen)

Our Level 1 scroll caddies are more like level 1 Invok Neheck caddies. So we get the best of both worlds. 80-115pts for a Invok/scroll caddie isn't so bad.
AND backup general.

Everythign just stacks so much!




....still haven't played one game. Stupid best friend and his 'school work' and his stupid new addiction to Star Wars Online.
 
[edit: original reply deleted. too long. off topic. sorry]

Long Story Short: if tomb kings have even one competitive build outside of etc, but don't have any in etc, then that's etc's fault. As for vamps, you can't even give the book an honest review if you're introducing it to an already comped environment, so how it performs in etc events has no baring on the strengths or weaknesses of the book itself.
 
ok wow, so other than the etc comp issue. Any more victory/losses? I played the above list with a couple changes and managed to be a pretty competitive/cheesy HE list. It's funny he always runs a lvl 4 shadow mage but showed up with a lvl 4 beast and a lvl 2 light with seer staff, hr assured me that he hadn't tailored his list to fight me hymm.

Anyways pulled out a massacre, first real win with the new book.
 
I'm sitting at 4 wins and 4 losses. The new book has a lot of options, but ultimately I'm having a hard time winning as much as I did in the last edition. The last tournament I went to I placed 11th out of 120 competitors with the last book of vampires (using 8th edition rules). With the old book I was able to pull victories away quite often, and I suppose I simply need to get used to new tactics.
 
As was I in both 6th &7th eddition, with out the typical power junk ie helm bunkered lord, ghoul hords, Draken banner.

I just one my first real victory, the two others where against newbs my 5 year old could beat, out of 5. U believe that we will be able to win but only with a small number if build, 8th edd not this book, has killed us
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu